Talk:Will The Circle Be Unbroken?/@comment-7241299-20130227051030/@comment-12.190.158.7-20130228172643

OK first, you said that you think Marlene is going to make Toby a double agent. That's completely wrong. They've already said, a LOT of times, that Toby is NOT a good guy. He's NOT on the A team to protect Spence, and he DOES have evil intentions toward the girls.

Now, that being said, they've also hinted that Toby's feelings for Spencer may have actually grown to be real. That he has actually fallen in love with her, accidentally. I don't think Toby is dead because we haven't heard his story yet. We don't know yet why he's on the A team, or when he joined.

We know that some A existed, and was toturing Ali, in the flashback Halloween episode. That was Oct 2008 I believe. Then the Jenna thing happened on July 4th 2009. That's like 8 and a half months later (end of Oct to middle of July). Toby had no reason to be on the A team until after the Jenna thing. And, since Ali was able to visit him in Juvie, I bet Mona (or some other A team person) was too.

They've already told us there will be some sort of resolution for Toby and Spencer. I don't think that can happen without us learning how, why, and when he joined the A team, and seeing whether or not his feelings for Spencer are real. The A team stuff could be told through flashbacks, but his resolution with Spencer really couldn't.

And that is why I think Toby is still alive. lol