Talk:The Lady Killer/@comment-2.51.221.30-20120904063414

Theory: Toby killed Ali after all.

Remeber when Alison visited Hanna in the hospital? She said that the truth is reason she ended up dead (or something like that). And she also Hanna is better off with a really good lie. So Alison died because she said the truth to the wrong person at the wrong time.

My theory is, Maybe when Toby met with Alison in the day of her death, he told her he loved her and wanted to be with her. Alison, deciding to be truthful for once, told him she was seeing an older guy and could never feel that way about him. When Toby saw her getting into the car with Ian, he freaked and was super-jealous. And he killed her. Let's not forget Toby is very handy with a shovel and is strong enough to throw her into that hole in the backyard.