Talk:The Lady Killer/@comment-5271456-20120829223004

Toby makes A LOT of sense when it comes to being on the “A” Team. He definitely has the motive, but beyond that, there’s a lot of things that add up when you look back at the previous clues and things that happened that point to Toby.

For starters, he isn’t always around. So while he says he’s in another town working, he could easily just be working for the Big “A”. For instance, was he the one who caused the car accident in the case of Caleb’s mom?

Beyond that, Toby is/has …

- pretty eyes. - the one to massage Emily in the spa. - the one who out of the blue found Dr. Sullivan at the end of Season 2 - is likely the one to save Spencer from Ian in the Season 1 finale and was strong enough to move Ian’s body.

Remember when Spencer lost that flash drive of all the videos from the NAT Club in the Church in Season 1? And remember when Ashley’s pastor boyfriend found it? Now think back, remember when Toby went with Hanna to the church for that party? He probably planted the flash drive there! It would make sense he still had it if he was the one who saved Spencer in Season 1.

There are also clues, like when Spencer was tutoring Toby in French in Season 1. There was once a closing scene where “A” was listening to a French recording.

Then throughout Season 3 we have those closing scenes where “A” was looking for apartments and all that stuff. Obviously, that was Toby!

He's definitely been a part of the “A” Team from the start.