Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-6659210-20131101154015/@comment-24004040-20131101165207

Well, it's not like in real life mystery's get solved that easily? I personally always think it's stupid if everything really gets solved and explained, since in real life many mysterys aren't explained or solved. In TV series it's always coming out if somebody has an affair with another person, in real life there is the possibilty of that never to come out (I'm not meaning just PLL here, it's in every show).

So I personally like that there isn't everything explained after it happened, but how it makes sense. When Ali comes back and explains, THAT's when things are getting solved, because otherwise it makes no sense in my mind. Who should give them the answers if not -A or Alison herself? And till now it was not confirmed she was alive.

it was stupid for Emily to just let that CD openly there -yes. But she thought that at least at the police station she had to be safe with that. These girls are young, they are making mistakes, it's not like -A is something normal happening in every persons life. They shouldn't be all perfect and do everything right. They are teenagers and even should make naive mistakes like that. Otherwise you wouldn't watch the show, because there wouldn't be any surprises or suspense. (: