Talk:Alison's Attempted Killer/@comment-11633429-20140125224416


 * Romelo's PLL Theories*

1. Aria and Spencer are who Ali might be afraid of, hence the fact that she can't trust the Liars. I believe on the night of her disappearance, Spencer snuck out out of the barn, argued with Ali, then came back for Aria. Either Spencer hit Ali and Aria buried her, or they at least witnessed CeCe and Melissa do it. Every time someone goes missing, Aria's the first to wake up and Spencer's always gone. I feel as if that was all planned.

2. If you noticed, we pretty much met all of both the "A"-Team and "B"-Team members in the Pilot, with the exception of CeCe, Paige, and Shana. However, a spoiler recently surfaced about the fact that both CeCe and Paige's first appearances were in the Pilot. CeCe was the one who Spencer saw in Ali's room through her window, while Paige was seen at Ali's funeral. This could imply or allude to a possible CeCe/Maya connection. If Shana knew that Ali was alive since the events of "unmAsked," who's to say the same possibility couldn't apply to CeCe and Maya? Here's my thing: I think someone on the "A"-Team leaked false/planted information to Lyndon, thinking that Emily killed Maya, when we know she didn't. I understand the whole "if I can't love you, no one else can" bullshit, but why would you kill someone you're head over heels with? If not that's the case, then the only other theory I could think of is one that parallels the whole CeCe/Ali/Emily/Paige love triangle. Paige thought at one time (ep. #1.15) that Emily was involved with CeCe and Ali with the secret of Paige being infatuated with Emily. Maybe Lyndon thought Maya and Emily were in it to toy with his feelings?...

3. As to who's body's in Alison's grave, is one of three people:

-Ali is pulling a Miranda from Ravenswood, which would explain the Ali-sightings.

-it's CeCe's twin

-it's Marion Cavanaugh

4. If you notice, each Liar has their own "A." Hanna had Mona, which was a friend. Spencer had Toby, a significant other. The same for Aria and Ezra. Who does Ali and Emily have? I think Ali either has CeCe or Jenna. As for Emily, it's a mystery—Paige has been cleared, and Maya presumably could've had good intentions if she were to be "A," so I'm guessing Emily's "A" is a relative. More specifically, Pam Fields. Not saying she'd want to hurt her own daughter, but used her to find Ali by extension...maybe to get back at her for leading her daughter on? I think Pam knew Emily was gay pre-disappearance, but was shocked when Emily confirmed it, simply because she thought she'd grow out of her infatuation towards the same sex. Watch the 2012 Lifetime TV-movie "Sexting in Surburbia," and you'll see my reasoning.