Talk:Taking This One to the Grave/@comment-79.112.224.210-20140901131627/@comment-25175695-20140901135011

Maybe Marlene was talking about Mona when she said A was in the pilot? That wouldn't surprise me one bit, honestly.

I do think the Meredith theory is plausible as well as it is crappy. Because what would be her motive? She would have to be related to Bethany, maybe even be her twin sister. But Meredith is 25 and Bethany was 17 so that's not possible, so I've got no clue as to why she would torment the girls. Maybe she had a history with Ali, but I'd be so mad if that was also revealed when she's revealed as A.

How do you feel about Paige? She was also there from the beginning.