Talk:The Melody Lingers On/@comment-26006494-20150310194940/@comment-5742688-20150310205211

Here's what I think happened. Alison peeked through the Cavanugh's window and saw Toby and Jenna doing it. She had this knowledge but no proof. She used this fact into blackmailing Toby to take the blame for the Jenna thing or else she would tell everyone what was going on between Toby and Jenna. (Here's the conversation between Alison and Toby: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yEbi3-KrEd4 ) This would ruin Toby's repuation and once the truth came out, maybe Jenna would accuse him of raping her to save her face. When Alison found those videos, she had definite proof of what was going on between Jenna and Toby and used it blackmail Jenna.