Talk:Game On Charles/@comment-26131626-20150401173143

Afters seeing the picture of the horse in Spencer's room and the reddit analysis of Charlemagne, I'm convinced.

Theory: Apparently the Bethany and Charles storyline will be resolved together in s6, so there HAS to be a connection. The baby in the video is obviously not Alison, because the boy's aren't seven years old. Mrs. D. wanted Bethany to call her aunt - because she either her blood aunt or her aunt from Kenneth's side of family, which DOES have the surname "DiLaurentis". In the video she is holding her niece, Bethany. There are no twins. The litte boy with the longer hair, who patts the baby on the head is Jessicas son Jason. The boy, she asks to kiss his sister is her nephew Charles aka Wren. Bethany's murder is Charles motive for being A. Charles is said to hate and loves Alison at the same time: he despises Alison, because she lured Bethany to Rosewood, but at the same time he loves her and calls her his "favorite", because she resembles her cousin Bethany - his dead sister. Charles seems determined to protect her from something... from the four Liars.

We know the Liars were drugged by Alison with sleeping pills the night Bethany died. However they did not sleep the whole night. Ali claims that Spencer went to sleep again, after she sent her back to the barn. That was before she was hit. But in the pilot, Spencer is still wandering around outside AFTER Ali was hit. Also when Aria fells asleep, Pigtunia lies next to her, but when she awakes the puppet is suddenly gone. When Jason left the house that night she spots a red cup (identical to the ones the Liars drank from in the barn) on the porch and drinks from it. Soon after that, he passes out and remembers NOTHING later on. I think that was, because there were still sleeping pills inside the cup. One of the Liars left it, when wandering around outside. A prominent side effect for sleeping pills is MEMORY LOSS. I think the Liars have all done something to Bethany, that they don't remember anymore. Spencer once remembered chasing a blonde girl through the woods with the shovel and hitting her. Bethany was hit with a shovel, while Alison was hit with a rock. When under hypnosis, Emily sees herself hitting Alison with a shovel too - in the same spot Melissa later found Bethany unconcious! I also think that is the reason why A wanted Ali and the Liars in prison. He wanted them being locked up for his sisters murder, hence the bible verse about vengeance.

Someone found a great connection between Charles and Wren. "The great Charlemagne" was the name of the mysterious Mime in Ravenswood (4x12), who Marlene confirmed to be a big clue to Charles.