Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-5323601-20140103210020/@comment-24004040-20140103215405

Toby's mother died before the pilot aired. As you can see in The First Secret, Toby already moves into the house with Jenna.

You probably mean in the coffin, but if you ask me, whoever put that body there instead of Alison didn't really had a plan, it just happened. There wasn't a back up plan. And digging up a coffin with a body much older physically than Alison and not wearing the same clothes into that gazebo, that would take a lot of planning. Buying the same clothes that Ali wore (before even knowing one would kill her) and digging her up. Duh, I would just have pushed CeCe in, she wore the same clothes. That would be by far easier than digging up another grave. Toby's mum has any meaning to -A or Alison or the N.A.T Club, but I doubt she was seen as Ali's body. Especially since their deaths are years apart and it's clear Ali died THAT night, not another.

And you saw how frightened Mona was off opening the coffin from Wilden. She may have dug up Ali's body bag but she is not really used to seeing any dead body and seeing one so long in the ground? Don't think so. If the rest of the -A is also like that I really think that the body found that night DIED that night. (: