Talk:Songs of Innocence/@comment-3020315-20150604231407

A tiny theory.

What if Charles believed that Alison and Liars were in danger, therefore proceeded to kidnapped them to keep them safe. I know that ironic considering the torture he put the 4 liars for the last two years. But if Charles was locked up in Radley for most of his life, I'm going to assume losing all sense of control and his family made him power crazy and mentally unstable, therefore he stole the 'game' from Mona and enjoyed controlling their lives, and also did it lure Alison out. 'That Night', I think Charles dug up Alison's body after discovering she was really alive from a drugged up Mona. After awhile he grew attached to their liars, therefore getting rid of any who would 'hurt' them or reveal his identity (Mona, Jessica & Garret). After discovering another threat to the liars (BW?), who I think took control from S5, i.e. blowing up Toby's house, strangling Alison, he kidnapped them to protect them from this BW.

He seems to be Alison and Jason's brother. I think he misses his family, which is why is memories are so dear to him, but hates Jessica, Ken and Jason for disowning him. I think that he wanted Alison to know who he was but Jessica wouldn't let him, which caused his envy and obsession for Alison to begin. He tried to kidnap Alison on the night of her disappearance, intending to protect her, but Jessica witnessed it and assumed she was dead. Therefore he kidnapped the next best thing: Sara Harvey, who looked and acted exactly like her. I think he found out about her somehow through Bethany Young, who he developed a special bond with because of her resemblance to Alison.

I can just see him saying to them at the end of 6x10 "I was trying to protect you," or "don't say I didn't warn you".

Thoughts?