Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-4626911-20131227092709/@comment-24004040-20131227191929

@PLLFANATIC13

You can't be sure they aren't going down that road with Alison. Just because they don't follow the books 100%? Just because they said they wouldn't? (Of course they wouldn't, it takes every suprise). As season 1 aired they said Mona wouldn't be -A too and she was.

I mean, yes, I am a fan of the CeCe has the twin theory, especially because it seems plausible with CeCe/her twin wearing the same clothes and therefore Mrs. DiLaurentis only saw the yellow top and thought it was Alison and that now CeCe/her twin are harrassing the girls as to avenge it. But then I would be like, why? It's not like CeCe EVER was part of the group before Alison disappeared and only because she had a love/hate relationship to Alison doesn't make the other girls responisble for that. Yes, CeCe thought they were ALL at fault for her being kicked out and she was Red Coat. But for me, like in the books, if CeCe had the twin and the twin/Cece is alive than she HAS to be Uber A (or Black Widow as I presume is the endgame leader) which she definitetly isn't. She is a mere pawn who gets or not gets pushed around by Ezra. Like in the books Alison is the real big leader of the A-Team because she hated her sister Courtney (there we have the ever lasting connection with the girls). I hope people understand what I mean. I like the CeCe theory, but she hasn't that deep relationship with all the Liars that would make her twin be Uber A. For me, if they really go down the twin road, the person lying in Alisons' coffin has to have a twin which ultimately is Uber A/Black Widow. Otherwise the whole set up wouldn't make any sense for me. And since CeCe already was seen as being a Red Coat and a employee of Ezra AND maybe was even was paid (since the girls said she got a lot of money recently) for me there still is a high chance of really Alison having the twin.

You can't just rule that out because it happened it the books.