Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-12205443-20141004015134

2004 Lindsay Lohan would have been perfect for PLL. If they went with casting the liars to match the book's physcical appearance, then she could have played Emily, since Em was a redhead on the books. Amanda Seyfried could play Alison, Rachel McAdams could play Spencer, and the brunette one could be Hanna. Aria had jet black hair and blue eyes on the books, so Zooey Deschannel would be a good fit for her.