Talk:Fresh Meat/@comment-25584522-20150111165423

Okay...I just read some of the comments around here. I'll say it once because I've had many arguments over the issue, and frankly, I've had enough. It seems like no matter what, people are waaay over-reacting each time someone comes up with an AriA theory.

First, I apologize in advance for categorazing people into something they might not be.

I love the theory that Aria is A. I also love the theories about Hanna's twin or about Wren. I would die out of excitement if Mr. Clayton's theory about Ella will turn out to be the true theory Marlene have been talking about lately.

That being settled, I wanna say something, and I'm gonna say it once: Marlene and the other producers are lying like 80% of the time - whether it's about couples or A's identity. There is no freaking proof that Red Coat is the Black Widow. There is no freaking proof that  Black Widow  is Uber-A. To be completely honest with you, I think there are more proofs that  Black Widow  and  Red Coat  are two different people. Black Widow  was never confirmed to be Uber-A. Marlene, who've been known as a pathological liar, said that  Black Widow  is  involved  in PLL "Endgame". She never said The  Black Widow  is Uber-A.  Furthermore, when she was asked whether  Red Coat  and  Black Widow  is the same person,  she refused to give a straight answer.

Now, to answer your question about why Aria "can't" be Uber-A. Here is the thing: Have any of you tried for once be open minded about that? Have you been that arrogant to say you know better than other people? I'm not talking about some "hints" like the "shh" sign or the "A" mug. I'm talking about words, dialogs, the way she acts, the way she interacts with other people. Have you tried to observe those kind of things about her? I know I did. My mind was blown out of the window when I noticed how shady Aria is.

I read once an amazing theory about Hanna's twin. That theory was perfect. It literally had no flaws. Do you think I dismissed it because it didn't work with my assumption that Aria is A? No, I didn't. I found myself reading with the BEST PLL theory EVER. And I was happy, because I really enjoyed it. So I sent a message to the fan who came up with that theory and I congratulated him, and thanked him for that theory.

Have any of the anti-Aria-is-A fans bothered doing so? I doubt it. There are some people here who came up with amazing theories about Aria, and most of the time 'they got treated like crap.' You have a problem with the AriA theory? Move on, don't comment. Don't act like you're nice, because in reality you all are acting almighty like you know better than anyone. Hypocrisy knows no boundries, and everyone can see it.