Talk:Close Encounters/@comment-24150985-20140122043837/@comment-5.158.133.238-20140122053007

What if it was a trap by A? What if A showed up, not Ali and abducted (or worse) Emily? Then you would probably be like "Stupid Spence. Why didn't you see this coming? You could have rescued Em".

I can fully understand that Spencer showed up. Alison visited each liar once, so why does she suddenly only trust Emily and only wants to meet her? In the liars POV Shana is working with Jenna and Mona (who aren't in good terms with the liars), so why should Spencer trust her? How is Spencer supposed to know that Shana isn't A or A's helper and wants to lure Emily into a trap?

And C'mon, we all know that Alison wouldn't have given any answers. She didn't give any answers when she visited the liars (only some crytic messages, which are more confusing than helping), why start now?