Talk:UnmAsked/@comment-69.14.39.177-20120318170525

I think the best way to determine who "A" is would be to break down who Alison was already "torturing" in the Halloween episode to spark her getting the first threats from "A". It wouldn't be Jenna because she had just moved to town and met Alison; Ali hadn't really done anything to her yet. She wasn't torturing Toby because him and Jenna hadn't even started their "relationship" yet. It seems as though Ali and Ian were on the verge of having a relationship, but I don't think they were together yet in the episode. Although I'm sure it pissed Melissa off that she was flirty with Ian, I don't think she would have sent her a voodoo doll and smashed a pumpkin on her porch etc. Wren, Caleb and Maya hadn't even moved to Rosewood yet. We have no indication that she even knew Ezra, so unless we find out about their secret ties to each other in the finale (which I personally think would be way too random) then he's out too. It also seems like Ali and Noel were still on good terms in the episode. I also don't know what grounds Detective Wilden or Garrett would have to torture Ali, unless we find that out in the finale.

People who would've wanted to "torture" Ali would be - Lucas, Mona, possibly Jason or one of the four liars. The people that Ali outwardly torments in the episode are Hanna (she makes fat jokes at her expense), Aria (about her dad having an affair), Lucas (calls him "Hermie"), & Mona (teases her and runs away from her with Aria). She really isn't shown fighting with Jason; just having a snarky conversation with him.

So under this logic, it would make sense if it was Lucas, Mona, Hanna or Aria. Mona is probably out because they keep saying it will be different than the books. I don't think Hanna would take it so far to get run over by a car, so she's out too. That leaves Lucas, Jason or Aria. Based on other clues, I don't really know if it's any of them, but it would make sense based on the Halloween episode.