Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-34924658-20141102001524/@comment-25348587-20141102025014

Marlene wanted us to think this basically:

5x01: OMG Shana was A! I can't believe it! The girls are safe with Ali now! Yay happy ending in rosewood!

5x05: OMG Shana wasn't A?! A is still out there? OMG Marlene had us fooled.

If Shana was A or a helper, it would've been revealed just like with Toby. Uber A had no affiliations with her and trust me, if Shana was a part of the A plan, Marlene did a terrible job at making that apparent bcuz most fans agree that Shana is dead and just wanted revenge for Jenna lol