Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-24.205.88.161-20111025002103/@comment-4697769-20120105153324

Emily and Toby went to homecoming together, and like in the show the four liars got convinced that Toby was the one who killed Ali, so Emily ran away, Toby chased her, but unlike in the show, Emily didn't trip and ended up in the hospital... She managed to get home and lock the doors, Toby was outside knocking and wanting to talk to Emily, Emily just screamed something like "I know what you did to her" to him, and Toby got devastated, because he thought that Emily was talking about knowing that Toby was molesting Jenna, when what Emily meant was that she thought he killed Ali, and because of this misunderstanding Toby left, and because he couldn't live with everybody knowing what he did to Jenna he commited suicide. So basically he killed himself over a misunderstanding.