Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-174.54.207.20-20131014013110

Maybe I'm missing something... But if he's the " pretty eyes" from season 2, doesn't that mean he was A well before he told spencer that he would find out what was going on for himself? So... Maybe it's not a case of all is forgiven? Also, I think a lot of the arguments I've read for not liking Toby, or the actor playing him... I think that those are actually reasons why hes a great choice for the role. It's a character that keeps you guessing. From episode to episode I find him to be charming or creepy, suspicious or endearing, ridiculously attractive or like someone I'd run away from. I say, well cast. If it was a different actor, I'd have probably given up on the show in season 2.