Talk:Oh, What Hard Luck Stories They All Hand Me/@comment-26059809-20150201181056/@comment-25937133-20150201201650

I'm pretty sure Holbrook is good and they are just making him look bad.

Remember back in season 3 where CeCe theoretically told him who killed "that girl?" (who we now know is Bethany). CeCe probably named someone other than Alison. Holbrook knows Ali didn't kill Bethany and thus believed her if she told him she was framed for Mona's murder as well. The liars only see him as the bad guy because he is helping Ali and they think she is the murderer. Once they realize their mistake, we will be seeing Holbrook in a good light I bet.

My guess is that he isn't being so nice to the liars because he knows they are way off base in regards to Ali. Plus, based on the Christmas episode we can see he has some sort of romantic attraction toward her. Thus he comes off as mean and a creep to the liars. Just my thoughts :P

If they actually make him Wilden 2.0 I will be mad. Not only because I liked him; but because it is inconsistant with his character and poor/lazy writing.