Talk:Season 3/@comment-190.53.21.32-20130104180800/@comment-68.200.112.145-20130111145238

As for why he's a member of the A Team, Toby is still angry with the liars for allowing him to take the blame for blinding Jenna. Spencer knew about him being blackmailed into taking the blame and she was the one who handed Alison the lighter to light the firework, so he likely hates her the most. Not only that, but it seems like Alison tried to force Toby into a relationship with her. When she visits him in juvie, she accuses him of being A and he denies it and says he wishes he knew who A was so he could help him/her. He also mentions that Alison's posse deserves far worse than a few nasty letters.