Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-119.95.232.194-20131025111132/@comment-5224716-20131025165019

I personally think/want Spencer to have hidden memories, just like in the books. Maybe they had a huge fight after Ali left and Spencer followed them and things got dirty. Spence pushed her, she collapsed but she didn't die. Spencer came back to her barn and maybe she didn't remember it anymore because her mind didn't want her to or maybe it was because of alcohol.

And Spencer deep inside has this feeling that she might've killed her, she doesn't know why. Or maybe she remembers that she pushed her, but didn't ever mention it because everyone would think that she killed her, and it would ruin her future as perfect daughter she always wanted to be. Or she was scared of herself, that she lost control and after she pushed her, she also finished her off. And that's why Spence is the detective of the group, because she wants to know the truth and finish this case.

And maybe perhaps that's why she cried in season 3A (I think?) when she got a text from "A", "Surprise Spence, he isn't their killer" and she started crying. Maybe for a short second she started thinking about it again and was scared that A will tell everyone. Maybe that's why she joined A-Team? Maybe Alison coming back triggers it again, like she mentiones that fight?

And it could lead to Spencer taking drugs.