Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-93.221.77.16-20130328203333/@comment-91.37.94.14-20130331210017

Firstly, it wasn't Marlene but Goldstick who confirmed that Toby was honest about this explanation and secondly, that doesn't mean anything. Just because they say it, doesn't mean it's true, because obviously they wouldn't say "no he lied." since that would spoil everything for season 4 since we get the answers there.

Marlene and the others always say things to confuse us, so there is no way to just believe them.

It's like with the thing of Alison being Red Coat, just because the girls saw her, doesn't mean it was her. Cece looks a lot like her and they could just have mistaken Ali for Cece when they were still kinda blurry from the fire and it was dark when Spencer went after Red Coat and just could have mistaken her, still all people think it's Ali (I do too, but nonetheless it's still not a FACT that it's her.)