Talk:Songs of Innocence/@comment-26010475-20150607214842

What if Charles is simply obsessed with Alison? (He is still the bad guy)

I mean what if Bethany was the one who tried to kill Alison and Charles witnessed it, so he went after Beth and killed her to take revange for his sister ( or who knows what)?

He was a psyco, that's for sure cause around that time, he already had his dollhouse and he wanted to put Ali inside. He wanted company, his siter, but Bethany ruined everything for him. He was very lonely. As always. The next day, he saw Sara Harvey at the park and for a few seconds, mistook her with Ali as Mrs. D did. He kidnapped her to fill the hole that Alison left in his heart when she "died". (Poor girl. I'm pretty sure she had the hardest 2-3 years ever)

What do you think?