Talk:Season 5/@comment-93.186.16.212-20141220182812/@comment-93.186.16.211-20141220182855

With everything we know about A, I could only come to one conclusion. This is my A-theory: I think that Jenna is Big A. My arguments for this theory:

1. In the season 2 finale, I think that Jenna actually met Mona in the park (although many people say that she was meeting Shana) and at the end, Mona told Jenna that she did everything she asked her to do.

2. I don't think it's a coincidence that Jenna was wearing a red coat and black gloves the night "Ali's" grave was dug up. 3. The Jenna Thing: Need I say more?

4. If A's motive really is love, it could be that she became A because she is still in love with Toby.

5. Marlene said we will be on A's side in the end. IF she is telling the truth, Jenna is really the only person whose motives I will understand (because of the Jenna Thing).

6. Remember the burn mark on Jenna's hand in 4x01? It is said that A rescued the liars (sans Hanna) from the lodge fire, this would explain how she got that burn. 7. In season 5, A returned in the same episode that Jenna returned.

8. Remember the group known as "The Alliance" (Melissa, Shana and Jenna)? They said the members were helping the Liars.. But: Shana turned on them! Was Jenna ever really on their side?

9. The masks that A wears always has one solid eye (one can argue that she is half-blind when she wears them). I think this is like a metaphor for Jenna's blindness.

I know however that there are also some signs that Jenna is not A:

1. She is blind. BUT: Remember the end of 1x02? I won't elaborate but that proved that Jenna does not need to see to send messages. And not to be mean, but is it possible that she could fake being blind now? (That's a tough one, though)

2. The Black Widow (aka Uber-A) and Jenna were both at Wilden's funeral. BUT: Isn't it odd that, out of all the seats in the church, the Black Widow chose to sit behind Jenna? I think that person was a decoy.

3. A blew up the Cavanaugh house. BUT: I'm not sure if this was stated explicitly, but Jenna was not in the house when it blew up, or they would have made a bigger deal about it in 5x06. This could have been her way to try and hurt Toby, because he thought she was in the house and it exploded again when he ran to look for her.

So that's my theory and to be honest, if this turns out to be true, I will totally support Jenna as A. Feel free to share your thoughts!