Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-3575890-20120829233229

I'm seeing a lot of comments from people saying things like, "dumb Spoby shippers" and I have to ask, is it SO wrong that we'd prefer a ship that has been beautifully developed over three seasons to not be TOTALLY ruined? You can call this good writing, but I call it complete retconning. The fact is, Toby being a legitimate A just makes NO sense. Why would he have sabotaged himself to fall from a scaffolding? I know the A's are insane, but that is potential suicide. He could have easily killed himself, and it's not like he was a suspect to any of the girls at that time either to need to prove himself. Why would he disable his own brakes? Why would he have Spencer break up with himself? Sure, it broke her heart which is what his goal would have been if he had been A all this time, but it also would have been very stupid of him. If he's been playing Spencer all of this time, getting close to her so he can keep tabs on her, what was the sense in separating himself from her? Toby at least has to be a new recruit. But if he's a bad guy, why did he warn Emily to get out of the house? Also, it's obvious he was the one who lured the girls to the cemetery, where nothing bad happened to them there. He was trying to protect ALL of them. There are many reasons he could have, but I'm convinced his intentions are pure. Keegan said Toby will go above and beyond to help Spencer; this is clearly what he was talking about. He also said Toby will remain the moral compass of the show - LOL don't see how that's possible if he's straight up evil. So go ahead and call us delusional, but him pulling a Snape is the only theory that makes actual sense.