Talk:Through a Glass, Darkly/@comment-25547603-20141223105453/@comment-25584522-20141223113942

^ Apparently she confused that memory with the night Bethany's corpse was dug up by her and Toby.

I doubt it, though. I think Emily did hit Bethany, but she thought it was Alison. She was drunk and sedated, but there is always the possibility she never was and dshe faked drinking from the glass.

Imagine the horror on the faces of Emison fans if that would turn out to be true. XD