Talk:Oh, What Hard Luck Stories They All Hand Me/@comment-25132765-20150128235740/@comment-26044580-20150129044742

I actually agree with Little Boy Liar and Jarialover, as Toby breaking those confidentiality laws would tamper with cases (thereby possibly allowing the REAL muderer to get off, claiming false evidence - presumably Toby would understand this!), but I can understand how Toby might look selfish and hypocritical, given his past. I actually think that Tanner and the Rosewood PD is being a class A d-bag by putting Toby in this situation though - in real life, he would have nothing to do with this case, seeing as his girlfriend was a murder suspect and now the person is custody is personally known to him... Reality is being stretched here for maximum drama in my opinion. Unless it's been done on purpose by someone being sketchy!

I also wondered if Toby might have another motive... like being A or still involved in the A team, but more likely that he is worried that liars would implicate themselves more (and Toby as well) if he gives them info and helps them destroy any evidence. Imagine what that would look like for the PLLs! "Teen girls commits murder, frame ex-best-friend, uses cop boyfriend to cover tracks". I wouldn't be surprised if that's what A has in mind, tbh, as her plan to get all the liars and Ali in jail together.