Talk:Game On, Charles/@comment-25556607-20150603180421/@comment-4393153-20150603181244

I think Charles wanted Bethany to be the first Alison substitute, she had a connection to the Dilaurentis family (and if Charles was locked up in Radley at some point, they might have known each other) but then something went wrong, and Bethany wound up dead.

Sara disappeared the day after Alison did, so Charles probably went after her next because of her similar personality to Alison.

I don't know about Cece, beyond her and Alison pretending to be one another.