Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-14539762-20131117131511

What do you think: Who tried to kill Ali?

I think there are two people involved. One hitting Ali with a showel, one burying her.

A) Ian hit Ali. She went unconscious. Melissa saw this and thought that she is dead.  Melissa buried Ali to help Ian.

B) Melissa hit Ali. Spencer saw this and thought she was dead. She wanted to help her sister and buried Ali. This was so aweful that she forgot it though. In 4B she will take study drugs and as a side affect remember this. Now that Ali is alive, Spencer is scared that she will tell anyone that she or her sister were her attempted killer. That's why Spencer will do horrible things to find Ali.

C) Other way round. Spencer hit Ali and forgot it.  Melissa helped her by burying Ali's body. That's why Melissa protected Spencer before it all happened.

D) The same just with CeCe and Wilden.

B and C would be the most interesting ones imo.