Talk:A is for Answers/@comment-14.201.142.246-20140315092253

So Alison disappeared on the 1st of September, 2009. The First Secret Episode takes place the Halloween before Ali disappeared October 31st, 2008. In the episode Toby tells Emily his mum has been dead for a year, so Marion Cavanaugh died in 2007. A flashback in 4x01 A is for A-L-I-V-E shows Alison and Toby when Tobys mother was alive, meaning Alison was only 13.Also, according to Dr. Palmer, Marion was his patient at the same time that Alison and CeCe were playing their tricks at Radley. A 13 year old playing tricks with  a girl much older then her. WOW.