Talk:Deadly/@comment-172.250.5.128-20130929003331

omigod would the book just come out already I'm dying. I hate to think about it, but why would A leave Noel alive, especially if he saw his attacker? It might be a possibility, if A had not led them to the body, which meant she was already done with him and had nothing to lose. Which only means that he had to be dead, which would kill me, because Noel is my favorite character.

I just keep wondering who is A. Rereading the last arc, I think it's Kate, and then I think it's Wilden, and then I think it's Melissa, but then I remember that Melissa was kidnapped and Kate wasn't on the Ecocruise, and Wilden had Ali arrested or something and didn't try to help her, and then I think it's Naomi, but Naomi hated Ali for ditching her, so why would they team up? Maybe it's Riley, but she's too small a character. I can't stop thinking about it.

Anyone have any good suggestions or reasoning?

I'm leaning towards Naomi, because she has a connection to Princeton and she was at Gayle Rigg's funeral, and in the beginning of Burned it says that someone who was linked to Madison knew what they did and would become their new A. Who else could be connected to Madison and be A and be 'right in front of them'? Even though she 'saved' them at the end of the book, it was probably fake, just how the real Ali fake-friended the girls and convinced them to go to Poconos. After all, Naomi has practice with fake friending, according to the first couple books. And she's blonde and probably giggles and was in the play so she is a decent actress. But what worries me is that I just don't think she's that psycho. And if she and Kate had a fight where she may have told Kate that she was going to become A, and if Kate was really on Hannah's side, wouldn't Kate tell Hannah about it? Or maybe Naomi is blackmailing Kate.... whoa, this is way too complicated.