Talk:Red Coat/@comment-98.188.150.2-20130320194022/@comment-24021432-20130320225001

I believe those times the girls saw Alison were real, because she left something behind every single time she visited them:

Hanna - cup with the lipstick stain.

Spencer - the opened pill bottles.

Emily - a kiss.

Aria - the doll left by her door.

It would just make sense.