Talk:EscApe From New York/@comment-99.71.209.164-20140609162552

Was The Roof Scene PLANNED? theory

The more I think about it the more that scene seems planned. I mean 1. Noel just disappeared. I mean if that happened and I heard commotion, I would check it out or call 911 SOMETHING!! I mean even while they were talking he vanished and then came back.... fishy. 2. A had numerous times to shoot EVERYONE on the roof. I remember once he/she, I think was directly in front of Alison. It would've hit her uncoordinated shooter or not. And there was once when Hanna could've gotten shot too. So maybe Noel WAS the person in the mask. Just an idea. 3. A was shooting uncoordinated shots, as is they DID NOT want to hit the girls. They weren't running, and they were standing still. If A wanted to hurt anyone, somebody other than Ezra would've gotten shot, not kidding.

Ok you get it. Gist is if A wanted them dead they would've dead. It's like they wouldn't have ran if A had the gun pointed at them anyway. Plus even though you said this, Hanna could've shot A SO MANY TIMES IT IS CRAZY!! My guess if Noel was in the mask and Ali is Black widow/and dealing with A. A shot and missed each Liar on purpose. No sense. And also a good blog for PLL is prettylittlepossibilites on tumblr