Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-5773183-20130927203523/@comment-76.17.206.121-20140204223239

^ No. He never made Spencer lie. he simply told her to not to tell what he was doing. She never lied. She simply said" I can't tell you". Heck you can make up an entire story all by yourself and pretend Toby is an evil vampire if you want. But they made it obvious that he was on the A team to be a double agent from the very start. Its what they call a red herring. They may sometimes not tell fans what will happen in the future. But if they confirm what they MEANT for us to see, then its a done deal. Besides, there really is no other good reason for him to have suddenly joined the A team for a short stretch. he didn't let Spencer think he was dead. He didn't know what Mona did with the fake body. But even if he did, closing down A is so important that almost any short term emotional pain would be worth it for Spencer to finally be free from A. Being upset for a little while is easily worth it.