Talk:'A' is for A-l-i-v-e/@comment-77.69.238.18-20130502134801

I think that Cece, Melissa, Jenna, Shana, Wilden, and Wren are all connected with Garret and Ian being past members. They're all about the same age and all (minus Wren and Shana) had motive to hate Alison and want to hurt her.

I think that it was Wilden in the Queen of Hearts costume on the Halloween train. Shana hit Toby on the head in the S3 finale when he saw Jenna in the woods, and Melissa probably set fire to the lodge. I'm also suspicious of Cece because Jason thinks he saw her with Melissa the night Alison died, and she was dressed like Ali so I definitely think something was going on.