Talk:Cat's Cradle/@comment-5232449-20130627210713

Lately I've been thinking about this. I don't know why, but this is the first theory I have ever come up with that actually has sense. I believe both Alison and her twin (Courtney, or whatever her name is) are alive. I don't think a body has ever been found, for the reasons you might already know, or maybe it was someone else's body, who knows? One of the twin is red coat, who is trying her best to ruin the liars' lifes, by tormenting them, scaring them, making their life a total nightmare. The other one is actually helping the girls, she's one who pushed Ian, she's the one who pulled the girls out of the fire, she's the one who visits them. Alison is really sweet to the girls when the girls "sees her". She told Emily she was her favorite, told Hanna that "A was getting on her nerves" and that she was afraid she had been seriously injuried by -A, told Spencer that she missed her. Before dissapearing, Alison has never been kind to them, actually she was a bitch. In season three finale, one of them (the one who is trying to help them) put on a red coat and pretended to be her twin (the evil one) to deceive the other -A team members that were there (like the brunette girl or that guy/girl who hit Toby) to save the girls. When she did it, she dissapeared and throw the coat in the fire, that was found one day later by the fireman.

What do you think? It has no sense, right? Too messed up?