Talk:To Plea or Not to Plea/@comment-25547603-20150227181259/@comment-25977749-20150227192842

Clay, I think I understand in which direction your thoughts are going, (not one direction this time lol) So A feels as if he is in a relationship with Ali/ or pretending to be in one with her(Mr and Ms Varjack). That would explain why A is Ali's stalker and does the stuff A does. And it leads to the clue about beach hottie, who, may or may not, have had fathered Ali with a child. (A possible abortion could be the trigger that made beach hottie become psycho A.) Your theory highly suggests A to be a he. (Plus Daisy-Kraken spoilers about "Charles".)

But why would this A then want to torture the liars? They practically never met and they have little to do with Ali's various secret reletionships. A MUST be someone who knows about the liars and who thinks that they are equally guilty of what has been done to them and wants Ali AND the liars equally to suffer the same fate.

Plus how does this tie in with Bethany's murder?