Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-95.86.115.246-20140917185407

I always thought that Uber A is Byron Montgomery, and black widow is someone who is working for him. And I'm pretty sure it either Ashley Marin or Meredith.

And the connection? Ashley and Byron had a secret affair 2-3 years prior to the liars births, thus giving birth to Bethany, who was placed for adoption. Tom Marin knew nothing about that. Years later, after being sent to Radley under fake name ("Young") for unknown reasons, both Alison and Meredith -at different times of course- discovered this. While Meredith was threatened to work for him as part of the A team, (and that was the reason why Mona tried to set her on fire in season 3,episode 14, to keep her at line) Alison was a LOT more stubborn than Meredith, and she fought back. Byron was the anonimous person who threatened Alison around the time she got messages from Mona (the so-called "original A"... yeah right :P).

Because of that, Byron hit her with that rock the night she went missing. Mrs. D repeatedly said "what have you done" to Byron because she also had an affair with him (Bethany talked about it to her therapist in 5X12 in the recording. She knew Byron was her real father, yet she refferred to him as Mr. Young).

Bethany lured by Ali to wear Alison's clothes, was injured by both Alison and CeCe to fake her own death, and buried by Melissa, who thought Spencer was responsible. However, Byron, who was still wandering the area after speaking with Alison, saw the murder and hit her as a revenge for hitting his daughter (Bethany). DESPITE what Alison claims and what we believe, Bethany was buried Before Ali, not after her.

Both Meredith and Ashley knows the story, and one of them is Black Widow. Ashley, for obvious reasons (Bethany is her secret daughter) and Meredith, because she's afraid of Byron and his threats (i.e. He knows some dirty secrets of her, or maybe because she's having mental problems it's making him easier to control her with medication or something...)

Mrs D. didn't say anything about that, scared that she might be labeled as..um...well you know the word... And you would think that she will tell !! After all, it WAS her daughter she buried alive. Then why she didn't? Maybe because of Toby's mom, who probably was pushed to her death by Bethany/Alison/CeCe/Merdeith? Was she scared she would sent to jail for covering a murder?

I really don't know...Maybe Melissa holds the answers to the mystery...After all, that gal knows a LOT, and she always appears at the most ominous times. So who knows...she even might be BW... ;)

And of course,   PLL has so many confusing clues and hints that direct us to different theories that  I might be wrong. XD

 But if this is true, then Byron is one hell of a nutjob... :D