Talk:To Plea or Not to Plea/@comment-25282217-20150226232540

My theroy is this on the night Bethany disappeared Aria saw Ali with her father and thought they were talking about Merideth so Aria killed Bethany thinking she was Ali to protect her family. Brian realized what happened and place Aria in a mental institution where she meet Eddie lamb and patients who later transferred to Radely. Ella and Mike thought she had a breakdown over Bethany's death but Bryon knew she killed Bethany to protect him and the two of them are trying to keep it covered up.