Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-79.115.88.141-20140101190034/@comment-24004040-20140101210307

Again, I don't really ship that idea myself so I can only speak like third person and imagine what people that ship that idea might think.

If you think about it, Uber A can't be every girl, it's someone who probably is equally close to all the four liars because that's just how the show work. Uber A has to be someone all are connected with and probably ALL are deeply hurt to find out is Uber A because in my eyes it would be "unfair" if one person get's - even if it sounds strange in that context - preferred of hurting more in the show's all over finale. I know that sounds total strange but if Uber A gets to be revealed to be Melissa we all knew that Spencer would hurt the most because the others didn't really had a deep relationship with her and it would give her a harder time than the other girls. We all know that every liar has his own A-Team member. Mona for Hanna, Toby for Spencer (even though there could be another one, since Toby wasn't really a member even though Mona still is, but Melissa for example sometimes was blackmailed into doing something or again that protection number as she in S4), Ezra for Aria and for Emily it's still unknown. So my dream solution even though it probably won't happen still is that Alison gets to be revealed as Uber A. That would hurt the girls all equally hard while still giving Emily her own -A because she loved Alison out of all the most (I don't know how many seasons there are too come though, if there are more than 5 or 6 than Emily's -A could be revealed as someone else, because I doubt it's Paige).

That's why not everyone can be -A. For me therefore it doesn't make sense anyone of the Liars is -A, especially since we explored that with Spencer and I doubt it's so easy to be Uber A and Liar at the same time, no matter how many members you have. Uber A leads the whole Team and the Liars are pracitally together 24/7, but maybe that's excatly why some think it's possible. Since one of the liars really would be a huge suprise and hurt the others liars all equally the same. (: Only my theory though, maybe it's completely different xD