Talk:Close Encounters/@comment-24004040-20140122181720/@comment-24004040-20140123200442

1) That's not what I mean. I get that she's afraid because she was threatened and buried alive and all, but it's the fact that she was all whiny. She visited the girls before, all the girls. There she was good old bitchy Alison. Why is she all whiny now? Where is her tough being that we saw before when she visited the liars?

2) Again that's not what I mean. If Alison had so much trust issues, she wouldn't talk to them, espeically because as you point out she was buried alive and was harrassed. Than I would especially stay a hell of a lot away from anyone I'd even suspected. Friend or not. I. Would. Fucking. Stay. Away. And it's not about checking on Hanna, it's about the fact that she came totally near to them all, even though she doesn't trust them. And she didn't "leave" anything because she was searching for something. She took Spencers pills, and she wasn't searching for anything when being with Hanna. She only searched something while being with Aria, and it was even in Ali's own doll. Otherwise she only left hints that she was really there.  But that doesn't make sense. She screams at every sounds she hears but walked around Rosewood before like she was still alive even being all the good old Alison. She doesn't trust them? Then she wouldn't visited them before. Friends or not. It doesn't matter.

3) She came out of hiding because she made a sound (accidentaly) and Alison already suspected of someone being there. She had no other choice than to come out. And then she came closer because she thought that at the moment where Ali told Emily that she didn't trust the Liars, only Em, Spencer probably confirmed herself that Alison really is fishy and wants to divide the girls.

And of course I can understand too that Toby wants to leave it behind, but just think about it. Something that happened to Marion eerily has something to do with Mrs Di and some patient she wanted to protect. Spencer probably saw and important hint at what happened to Ali or who A is. I wouldn't want to just leave it at that too if it meant finally solving everything.

4) They even said Toby wouldn't be good, but he clearly is. And they wouldn't spoilt it because it would clearly destroy the excitement. Of course they say they won't and things like "Maybe someone else", because they want to distract us and it clearly works. Only a few people still believe in the Ali has a twin thing and therefore think of other options because Sasha hinted at that. That woud be the ultimately good plan as to make it really happen. I don't believe anything they'll say till I saw the whole series.

5) So true. Still believeing Wren is board shorts here and not Ezra -lol-