Talk:The Silence of E. Lamb/@comment-107.215.4.78-20140718213512/@comment-16754824-20140719002502

I think Shay is better than Lucy in some ways. They both aren't bad or anything, but Shay made my heart hurt when she was crying when her mom said they think they found Maya's body. She can deliver well. But Lucy's crying scene about Ezra being A was DEFINITELY laughable (agreeing with Jarialover). It was so hilarious (the faces she made), and I didn't feel bad for her whatsoever. She didn't send chills, she didn't make me feel any emotion except laughter about how stupid it looked. I know it sounds harsh, but honestly, that was one of the least heartbreaking crying scenes on the show. I would say it's because I don't give a crap about Ezria, but I don't give a crap about Emaya, and I actually felt horrible for Emily when Maya died. Lucy's scene was just... Not emotional and was fake looking. She's has good scenes, but I don't understand why she keeps getting nominated for awards when Troian's crying scenes are so much better. Even if you dislike spoby, you know her crying scene in 3x16 was just so sad. I felt so bad for Spencer! I AM NOT SAYING LUCY IS BAD, I just think she is mediocre at crying scenes and is definitely not the best actress on the show. Ashley is pretty good (her Hefty Hanna scenes are so sad!!), Troian is amazing (the best of the 4 imo), Shay is alright, and Lucy is alright.