Talk:Over a Barrel/@comment-4947372-20150118191608

Since people are talking about 3x18 when Emily had a memory of hitting Alison, it might be real to some extent though. Alison did say that all of the girls need to piece together "that night". We've gotten Spencer's part on that night, we might have half of Emily's part too. Now there's Aria and Hanna's parts on that night.

Spencer: Tried to hit Alison, but failed. Went back to the barn.

Emily: Possibly thought of hitting someone or did actually hit someone that night.

Aria: Connecting to my theory @ http://ultimateplltheories.tumblr.com/post/106240268520/ultimate-a-theory, it's quite possible that Aria helped Bethany out of Radley because they are cousins and she wanted Bethany to be free for the night. So, when Bethany ended up missing on that night, Aria and her family hijacked it to Iceland to get away from the Bethany and Alison drama.

Hanna: She's the one who's really confusing me. She has a part in that night just like the others. But what could it be? Anyone have ideas?