Talk:Songs of Innocence/@comment-26237951-20150605150248/@comment-5660329-20150605152442

Not necessarily. If Charles is KENNETH's son, then the only way he'd be related to Melissa and Spencer would be his sibling's (Alison or Jason's) sister. That wouldn't necessarily make them siblings because they wouldn't share a parent in that case.

Also, do you know what incest means? It's having sex or a relationship with anyone in your immediate family. I doubt Charles is wren; he hasn't been seen in too long and Julian said on his fb page a year ago that he had no plans to return to PLL but he'd like to. That being said, if Charles isn't wren.. Actually no matter who he is: he never had a relationship (sexual or romantic) with Spencer or Melissa, unless of course it was Toby but that's impossible.