Talk:'A' is for A-l-i-v-e/@comment-6344415-20130612154210/@comment-107.3.238.79-20130613014901

She also said she recruited Toby when he was away to find answers around 3x08 but the waitress called him pretty eyes and she also called a member of the A team pretty eyes in season 2. Then again she could call multiple people that... and if he were A in season 2 then that would mean that he was the one who sent Dr. Sullivan away, but he was the one who brought her back. And I think Dr. Sullivan would have told the girls unless she was also in on it. His entire story line is messing with me. Also, if he knew about A because Alison confronted him when he was in juvie, wouldn't he have recognized it in the hotel room with Spencer in 1x19? I honestly believe he loves Spencer, but I'm not so sure about when he joined. Of course this all could be because the writers may be changing their minds about whether or not he is evil. Keegan actually thought he was evil and was coming up with all of these theories and then they told him that he had actually joined to protect Spencer...

Mona could have lied about Lucas... I think she also lied about when red coat gained control. At the end of unmasked, she was sent to Radley and someone visited her. She told the person that she did everything the person asked her to. So she was taking orders before she told the girls she met red coat...? I'm confused but I have been doing my best to keep up and remember those little details that the writers hope you will forget.