Talk:Alison DiLaurentis/@comment-6307089-20130205160510

People keep saying like 'In the books this happened so this must be what's going to happen on the show' blabla, havent you seen that loads of things are different in the show than the books? It does SERIOUSLY look like theyre doing the twin theory, it would be hard for them not to now, with all the clues they've left.. But the twin theory as we know it is that Courtney was the Ali they knew, while the real Ali was away in a mental institute, so the real Ali killed Courtney, then tortured the girls as A because they're the 'losers her sister befriended' or something.. But it really doesn't look like they're doing it that way, because the REAL Ali from the books who was torturing the girls hated them right? But in every appearance Ali in the show has made to them she's so nice, remember when she said to Hanna that she was 'so scared Hanna was guna die she had to come back no matter how dangerous it was'? Well, this Ali genuinely cares about the girls. Why would she fake it and just be nice to them fakely, what would she get from it? And she does seem like she is in on all the -A stuff, but I really don't think she's a part of it. I think -A is blackmailing her, holding her hostage or something.. Because when she speaks of -A she speaks like sympathetically about it all, and she was asking Emily to come with her or something? Yeah I'm confused. What I think MAY have happened is that either.. The Ali they knew was Courtney, then Ali escaped, buried Courtney alive and went away, then the hand coming out the ground was Courtney escaping, so Courtney got out and killed the real Ali. That would explain everything about the death situation really, because the 'Ali' they knew would be the alive one who is appearing to them and being nice to them, i.e she's not the one who hates them. If that makes sense. Another theory I have is that the Ali they knew was the real Ali, and she had previously set Courtney up to look insane when she wasn't so she got sent away, then Courtney escaped, buried Ali alive and went away, Ali escaped and buried Courtney alive.. Then -A knew what Ali had done and blackmailed her that she must 'join them' or they will expose the fact she murdered her sister and she's still alive.. So Ali's gone along with it but is secretly like a double agent, she's not really on the A-Team by choice, she's actually going behind the A-Team's backs and protecting the girls. (Does that make sense?) I think these are the only two ways it would all make sense really!