Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-36429429-20180826225424/@comment-24173435-20180827020140

Alison threatened to blame "The Jenna Thing" on Toby. Because of her parents' wealth and rank, he believed that she could do it. She was also blackmailing him with the affair and peeping in on her and her friends. Because she was popular and beautiful, everyone believed her and not the strange shy kid.