Talk:Oh, What Hard Luck Stories They All Hand Me/@comment-25584522-20150129141337

I don't believe that Keegan Allen was telling the truth about knowing who Uber-A is just from watching the first season. I bet this is all just a bunch of BS.

But let's pretend that he is telling the truth. Let's pretend that Mona was the original A and someone we knew from the beginning stole it from her. Let's pretend that Mona was telling the truth about Red Coat. Let's assume that she is not someone's twin, and go realistic. In addition to that, let's pretend Red Coat is none of the Liars, Alison, or Mona; And finally, let's assume that Red Coat is Uber-A, and also The Black Widow. Here are the facts:

1) She was from the beginning.

2) She had motive to hurt The Liars, The N.A.T. Club, Jenna, Melissa, CeCe, Mona and Lucas; What bugs me in this that we still haven't been told the motive. Or maybe we have, and we just missed it.

3) She might have a connection to Wilden and Bethany, given the fact that she attended both's funerals as The BW.

4) She might be blonde.

5) She's a master at lying, deceiving, blackmailing, extorting, and manipulating. On top of that she's insanely murderous, bloodthirsty and probably a psychopath.

6) And most importantly, she suffered from burns in her past, hence the burnt mask in 4X01.

So who do we know that is a crazy and might be blonde? Who do we know that suffered from burns? Who do we know that is manipulative and violent?

The only person that I can think of is Meredith. But other than Aria and Alison, I can't see why she would go after Spencer, Hanna and Emily. Unless she saw them as collateral damage. She probably was the one who killed Mona; She might be targeting Lucas next for her bruises from episode 3X14.

I can't see why she would hunt down the NAT Club, Melissa and CeCe. I can't connect her to neither Bethany nor Wilden. Unless she used to be friends with bethany in Radley and a lover(?) to Wilden, hence why going after Melissa and CeCe, and by extension, the NAT Club as well.

What do you think? Could Meredith be Uber-A after all?