Talk:Into the Deep/@comment-166.137.88.40-20130806172506/@comment-67.180.234.251-20130806180806

For all we know, Garrett could have been lying.

And maybe Jenna still thinks she knows who killed Ali. Maybe she thinks Garrett killed Ali, and she still believes it's true. Maybe Spencer's just forgetting that Garrett said Jenna only thinks he killed Ali.

For all we know, Garrett could have actually been Ali's killer, but I doubt that.