Talk:Season 3/@comment-93.37.136.162-20121223180917

I didn't read the books, but I know what happened, so I'm gonna tell you what I think about Alison and her twin, Courtney. As a lot of fan think (and so have I for a long time), Marlene and the authours are going to introduce the twin's story in the series too. There were a lot of clues: the picture with two Alison, the french quotes who talks about twins (both in Alison's room), the story Ali told to that kid, etc. I mean, I'm not going to tell you all of them because everyone here knows what they are. But, in my head, a crazy idea just turned up: what if in the series there was a twin, but that twin is not Alison's? What if Spencer would have a twin sister? This is such a crazy theory, but I'm gonna explain. It's still unclear what Spencer really did the night of Alison's death. So: her twin wants to kill Spencer, but she accidentally kills Alison in the woods, thinking that it is actually Spencer. Spencer sees everything, buries Alison with her sister and then promises her that she will never tell the truth. Spencer's family are still the most messed up family in the show: they have a lot of secrets, and they are rich, very rich. They can do anything, even hide a psycho daughter because she is too dangerous for them and their prestigious work. Ian knew the truth (he has been married with Melissa for a while and he has been dating her during high school), that's why he was killed.

Ok, I know this is a very messed up theory, and not everything fits perfectly, but I think it would be a possibility. Marlene always posts a lot of twins' photo on her twitter, and I think, if Alison had really a twin, she would have already told us the truth. I think she is kinda trying to mislead us.