Talk:Game Over, Charles/@comment-26842002-20150805195757/@comment-24004040-20150805221652

Keegan once said that -A's motives were romantic. Various pictures of Bethany show a young boy and a girl (one being the boy taken away by a monster and the girl running after). Charles and Bethany were romantic. They had a relationship or crush's on each other. That is why Jessica cared so much about her. She manipulated her and gave her gifts because she was a friend of Charles. She probably saw Charles push down Marion from that window and that's why Jessica tried to keep her quiet with gifts and all, so nobody would find out about Charles.

Bethany would visit Alison officially on labor day (she had permission as far as I understood), but she ESCAPED with Charles the night before labor day. They probably made a plan to kill or hurt Alison (or just escaped because they wanted to be together freely). My theory is actually that Charles hit Bethany thinking she was Alison (and Alison probably dressed up Bethany as her because she wanted to find out who -A was) and therefore Charles projected his guilt and anger on Alison and hit her also with a stone.

No matter how or what, the fact remains for me that Charles and Bethany were in love.