Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-14539762-20131230215446/@comment-24004040-20131231124317

That's a good theory but I doubt they are going with the "how the Liars imagine it" thing. When flashbacks happen they are happening from the person who initiated it. Meaning that for example when Garrett told Spencer that he fake hit Ali with that hockey stick, the flashback was from his view. Or when Hanna flashed back to the moment Mona and her saw Ali on her porch it was from Hanna's view. It's always initiated. So when Grundwald said she pulled Ali out the flashback was from her view, so what she was was what she really saw. Meaning that she really pulled Alison out, not CeCe. I can't remember if Mrs Grunwald ever saw Alison before she pulled her out but there is no real reason that she would lie, especially since Alison really is alive. I know the producers could complicate things further with making her lie, but that would only complicate the plot and I think they have a hard time always switiching from Ravenswood to Rosewood since the sets are far away from another (can't remember, but I think so). I just doubt it. I'm pretty sure that Mrs. Grunwald saw Ali before or even saw her in Ravenswood when the girls where there. And she never talked to anybody else. So why should she come back sensing Ali was in danger and than pull CeCe out who clearly isn't Ali. Because she DID talk to Ali on the phone and not CeCe.

I mean your theory makes sense and my points aren't really valid, but it just doesn't really come up for me. Ali was buried alive and she was pulled out by Mrs. Grunwald, got into hiding and now is back. Making that CeCe who was pulled out would just complicate things too much if you ask me. That's just my opinion though, but I'm 99,9% it's still Alison who was pulled out of that grave.