Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-95.86.70.230-20140920191608/@comment-6084473-20140921071542

It means Alisons version of that night doesn't quite make sense with Melissas..

Melissa saw Spencer walking away dragging the shovel, which was seconds after Ali found out about the pills according to Ali, and according to Melissa she saw "dead" bethany seconds after that.. and Ali says she talked to Byron after Spencer.. And Byron remembers Melissa coming out of her house after that...

Either Ali or Melissa was lying... or the writers dont care.