Talk:Welcome to the Dollhouse/@comment-4995975-20150219225151/@comment-5660329-20150220200752

That scene was a little suspicious and, again, I'm well aware of him being a doctor and having money and the hints that he could be A. But I don't think he is. Regarding the picture of "Red Coat", there was a theory that it wasn't really Red Coat and it was just a picture of him and Melissa and what their life would've been like if they had gotten married. Of course he was referred to as "Dr."; he's a doctor. Spencer even called him "Doctor Wren" in season 1. Regarding Mona pointing out that he couldn't spell "diagnosis", sometimes people misspell things if they're tired or stressed. Just because he spelled it wrong then, it didn't mean he doesn't know how to spell it right normally.

I take it you did research on people eating butterscotch candy when you just stopped smoking? People who don't even smoke could eat that candy. We don't need to see Wren smoking all the time to know that he does; we just needed to see the one time. If that's your logic ("the fact that we don't know that much about him and he's been there since day 1 is very suspicious), then Jenna could be A too. She's been there since the beginning and we don't know much about her either.  "Marlene said".  I'm sick of people saying "Marlene said *insert fact here*", because MARLENE LIES.  I personally asked Julian on his facebook page if he would return to PLL and he said there were no plans to.

Ali said she could get drugs from a doctor she knew. Hey, is Wren the only doctor in Rosewood? No. Was it ever even established as to whether the Doctor knew was male or female? But let's pretend for a minute that your theory is correct and Wren is helping to get revenge. Why would he get revenge on the girls? They didn't do anything. I honestly don't believe that Alison had anything to do with Bethany being killed; I have a theory that they were friends and Cece was the one who pretended to be Alison (without Ali's knowledge) and meet with Bethany where she hit her. If anything, if your theory is true and he's helping to get revenge, he should be torturing Melissa.