Talk:Season 3/@comment-66.233.62.156-20120727133309

LOVE THIS THEORY EXACT FOR THE KILLING PART, I DON'T THINK SHE'S DEAD The NAT club were filming girls yes? Well Jason said that some girls would get paid to set their friends up. What if Ali set her friends up? (That could explain the $15,000 she had or however much it was) on the night of 'The Jenna Thing' & then, Jason stopped joining in somewhere along the lines so he had no idea of Ali's involvement with the club. Spencer's dad was one of the guys who paid to watch the videos. Ali found out, maybe blackmailed him (another potential money point) or confronted him & he panicked & killed her. Maya then may have found something in the house that Ali left that connected Spencer's dad to the crime & killed her too.

This may also explain why Garrett & Jenna had some sort of involvement in that night, Spencer's dad could've threatened to expose the NAT club if they didn't help him & I'm guessing either Mona or the new '-A' was watching & saw the whole thing.

I never understood why Spencer's dad flipped out over that hockey stick that Toby found & burned it, it made it seem like that was the murder weapon & then it came out that it was that shovel & then never mentioned that again.