Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-79.112.228.18-20141212203229/@comment-71.178.134.101-20141212234749

The show was very much implying that the second dress was for Bethany (since we know Mrs. D visited her a lot and gave her presents etc). The thing is that we don't know that Bethany is the twin - in fact the info about her birthdate indicates the opposite.

If this is true, then it's very possible that Hanna has the twin. Since many of the twin references revolve around her and sometimes Ashley Marin. I'm not sure why Ashley would have seen the twin from Ali's story on Halloween if she and Hanna were not connected somehow. It wouldn't make much sense for Ashley to see Ali's twin...I don't know what the point would be. Unless the writers initially wanted Hanna to have the twin and then changed their minds between "Grave New World" (the last Hanna twin reference) and now.

It's a bit tough to know because I feel like they have made several twin refences with both Ali and Hanna and I'm not sure how the show plans to reconcile this.