Talk:The Gloves Are On/@comment-26325450-20160127135647

What if Melissa is actually Bethany Young? Maybe she was talking to her twin that night, not CeCe. And then Bethany, who we think is Melissa, killed the real Melissa. That would be fun. I don't know if they ever explained the parts where Mrs D. Said: "you can never turn your back on a Hastings". Mrs. D did take Bethany to the stables where bethany had a fit, maybe she referred to that?. And Peter Hastings was always so shady when it came to Mrs. D and radley, even after the whole Jason reveal. What was the reason for this again? In the season 4 finale, Peter says: "I did everything I could to protect her", then Melissa (who I think is actually Bethany) said: "oh my gosh, dad...you think Spencer killed that girl", then Peter looks suspicious about the situation, as if he and Melissa (Bethany) were talking about two different things. I think Peter realized in that ep that it was actually Bethany in the grave, and he was secretly upset about that. I don't know, maybe the twin thing is pushing it, as usual, but that tape of Bethany did sound like she could be related to Melissa. Please, feel free to challenge this theory, cause I'm not too sure of my facts anymore! 😜 we never did see an older Bethany, so there may be a reason for that. Maybe I'm just stuck in PLL past and want the older characters to be part of the big bad crew. :p