Talk:The Lady Killer/@comment-174.57.46.165-20120830011735

I think Toby's on the A team because he's protecting the girls. Remember right before he left he told Spencer that he was going to "find out for himself" what was going on? I think he did. Then, he joined the A team in hopes of protecting the girls. I'm almost positive he's the one that's using the creepy voice. I'm thinking it was Toby that called Emily while she was in the lighthouse inn, telling her she had one minute to get out (in only one minute, Nate/Lyndon came back.) I can't believe that Toby would ever be A. He was harassed by A in season one. Maybe he's being blackmailed into being part of the A team? Maybe he had the choice (like Spencer in the season two finale) to either be killed or join the A team? Maybe he is protecting the girls? Who knows. I just don't think they'd make Toby be evil like that. There's always something more, something deeper.