Talk:Songs of Innocence/@comment-26208095-20150606074631

I think Bethany and Charles are related or he is just connected to her and wants revenge for her dead. I think the liars did something really bad (maybe just hit bethany) the night when they were all drugged and they can't remember. I think charles had a video or something like that in their rooms and showed them that as a "surprise" and the girls where shocked about seeing this or seeing Charles maybe hurting andrew or somebody else....? Just a thought :)