Talk:Surfing the Aftershocks/@comment-25102591-20140625024947

my theories so far:

a) mr hastings hit alison with the rock because of he was drunk. i say this because in this episode there was a bottle of alcohol on the table while he spoke to spencer in the kitchen and remember when ms d. said "never turn your back on a hastings" and in season 4 when ali got hit by the rock she turned her back to her mom in the window and that's when she got hit.

b) ms d. was a twin and her sister gave birth to a disturbed child who is alisons cousin aka "courtney" (if the writers wanna go that route) and wishes to be ali. therefore she goes to crazy lengths to get rid of her and her friends.