Talk:Now You See Me, Now You Don't/@comment-5224716-20130822145007/@comment-5224716-20130822150809

Why isn't this possible? Maybe this gun thing happened before the Jenna Thing but Alison told Emily about this after the Jenna Thing. And remember in season 1 police said Alison had Toby's hoodie/jacket (dont remember) and he gave it to her because it was cold? I think Toby was into Alison.