Talk:Oh, What Hard Luck Stories They All Hand Me/@comment-25584522-20150128232326

Okay please don't be mad at me but I have this crazy theory:

Returning to the Pilot, I noticed something weird about Emily and Aria, when they were talking about Alison's disappearance. And that is what they said:

Aria: "We kinda lost touch, remember?"

Emily: "That's what kinda had to do."

And then Emily said that "Alison is dead". (Before they even found the body)

Remember the scene with the girls in episode 4X01?

"It's not fair Aria, it was Emily's idea."

If the memory that Emily dug up during her hypnonsis session was real, then it means that Emily tried to kill Alison, and ended up hitting Bethany instead.

The question is, did Aria and Mona stole the A-game from Emily? Is it possible that the original tormentor was never Mona, but Emily? And when Aria returned, Mona took it from her under Aria's orders?