Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-6659210-20131101194153/@comment-24004040-20131101200309

Ian did now the person and was surprised to see him/her. But not as surprised as if that person being Alison, because than Ian would have reacted different, he still thought he killed her or at least that she was dead.

What I don't get is that Mona said she doesn't know who killed Ian, BUT she was the only -A in Season 1 and midseason 2, and -A did put his body in that barn or what it was and put the fake suicide letter there. Didn't they get even A-messages concering that matter?

So how come Mona doesn't know about it, if she was the only -A and we cleary saw a black hooded person pushing Ian and only mere minutes after his body was gone and -A set everything up?

That doesn't fit with what Mona says OR with what the producers want to do.