Talk:Pretty isn't the Point/@comment-9290937-20150211180558/@comment-25977749-20150211190550

I understand your point. The problem is, this show is full of red herrings and we all are paranoid, jump fast to conlusion, 'cause we want to find an answer that makes sense with all the clues hanging arround.

Besides from the twin theories and Alison being A, the AriA theory is by far the one which works out for the majority of the fans AND is one of the few plot twists, that hardly anyone would be pissed off of, too.

As for your argument about why would Aria harm herself/ put herself in danger, you answered it yourself – if she has mpd, it's entirely possible, that she doesn't remember what her A persona planned for her and the liars, which might even include risking something dangerous to keep her secret identity. And if you just don't want to hear about the mpd argument, don't forget how abnormaly crazy A is, equally to Batman's Joker: Joker as a criminal mastermind, put's himself in harmfull risky situations for his goals very often, too. Never underestimate a psycho criminal!!!

For more mpd stuff, I suggest watch the movie Fight Club and you will understand the dynamics of mpd as a plot element way better!

Nonetheless A = Aria does not necessarily has to be the real and only conlusion, and that is something every fan of the theory is aware of. So just relax ;-)

PS:

BW does not has to be Uber A btw!!! Or a female at all. We really don't know anything about her, so just her appearance here and there is no argument against or for the AriA theory, sorry.

Another argument of me is, that for A to know soooo much about the liars secrets/ lives/ wishes and fears, A has to be someone very close to them. So the suspects are one of the liars, Ali and her besty CeCe (and of course Mona) and the liars bed buddies, siblings (and the possible twins.) Someone out of the blue wouldn't make sense (cough Charlie cough).