Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-11585596-20120829234629/@comment-3575890-20120830003909

^ Motive is the only thing that does make sense. Nothing else matches up. It doesn't coincide with excerpts from interviews ("Toby will remain the moral compass of the show; Toby will go above and beyond to help Spencer") or pieces of history from the show. Toby would at least have to be a new recruit, because I find it extremely hard to swallow that he would frame himself for murder (how would that even make him look innocent?) and nearly kill himself just to make himself look innocent. That is not diabolical genius. That is just plain stupidity. And if he was pure evil, he wouldn't have warned Emily. If he's not doing this to protect the girls (and already, he's protected one), then there has to be a medium here.