Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-24004040-20140103152258/@comment-24004040-20140103174945

But Spencer was on meds to when Ali came into her house. And Emily was unconcious because of the smoke in that barn and Aria had those sleeping pills mixed into her tea and Hanna was in the hospital, full of meds, when all saw Ali.

It was always the purpose to let Ali appear when we couldn't decipher if it was a hallucination or real. And Ali met Hanna in the hospital, that means the other "hallucinations" were real. I think Marlene even said that somewhere (can't remember though). And we know that they weren't hallucinations because the girls were always there where Alison led them or left hints that she was there. Emily was lying outside, where Alison saved her. The puppet Ali had in her hand was on the table she had left it when Aria woke up. The lipstick on Hanna's drinking cup where Ali drank from. The open pill box from which Ali took all the pills.

And since Ali said something memorable like "You didn't even know me when you knew me" which gave more clues and the fact that she found that horse where CeCe and Mona hid those things kinda shows that she was there. Spencer heard her singing that song and only because of that walked into that room. It could have been a hallucination, yes, and even if it was, the hallucinations still always give clues about anything.

Maybe Spencer deep down remembers something related to that (twin thing) and her hallucination spoke it in a cryptic way.

But after what Ali said to Hanna in 4x13 I strongly believe every hallucination that we thought was one, wasn't. (: