Maya St. Germain

Maya moved into the house next door to Emily's, Alison's old house. She and Emily bond. They soon begin to develop romantic feelings for each other. They kiss at a party, but Emily starts to push Maya away and reconnects with Toby Cavanaugh. After homecoming, Emily realizes that she wants to have a relationship with Maya, despite what others think. The girls later believe her to be "A." Emily's parents think she is the reason why Emily all of a sudden comes out to them and tells them she is a lesbian.