Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-9290937-20141024135356/@comment-25547603-20141024145244

Anon: It was Shana on the roof, I think they pointed out that in 5x01. I agree with the Wren part, he's hiding something.

Mr Puppets: I actually liked the red herrings about A, it kept suspence high. I didn't like the Grunwald thing, c'mon it's not believable that she had the feeling that something bad was going to happen. If she wanted to do the Ravenswood series, she should have just let Caleb go away from the show forever and not let the supernatural come into PLL. (Mrs. Grunwald or Ravenswood or the whole 4x13 with Ravenswood and Miranda).

(But I would never want Caleb to go, I love Haleb, so I think she could avoid doing that show)