Talk:Through a Glass, Darkly/@comment-97.125.231.240-20141228235646

For all you Alison haters:

"Emily feels betrayed by Alison"

Okay, so I am a little confused right now.

Yes, I understand that after everything that they've been through that Emily would be scared to have her heart broken again... But what has Alison honestly done that is THAT bad?

Think about the situation Ali was in, she had the police on her back and had to identify Cyrus (not to mention if she did not identify him the police would question her and she would have to tell the truth about New York, meaing Aria would go to JAIL.) She was in a difficult postion and and clearly had a plan.

When she took the polygragh test, she didnt want to say anything that incriminated the girls and Emily even pointed that out. Alison risked her own life several times to be there for the girls, they would be dead if it weren't for her.

"Betrayed"?

She literally would have risked everything for them and they forgot that they woudnt even be alive without her. It was almost like Spencer was waiting for her to do one little thing wrong so she could turn the girls against her, gaining back her leadership in the group.

So yeah she identified Cyrus- but how is that so bad? Compared to how Paige betrayed all the girls in season 4, that was literally nothing. Paige didn't have the police on her back, someone's life on the line(Aria would have gone to jail if Alison had told the truth), and she wasn't being questioned 24/7. She had no reason to do what she did.

After Emily asked her repeatedly to not say anything about Alison being alive, she did it anyway. Emily told her about -A, she told Paige that Alison could be killed if her wherabouts were known- but Paige went against Emilys wishes and gave the police, -A, and Shana access to Alison. Does Emily realize that it is because of PAIGE that they were all nearly killed in New York? Does Emily realize that it's because of PAIGE that the police were onto them because SHE told them that Alison was alive.

Want to talk about betrayal? There is betrayal!!

What Paige did was out of selfishness and for herself, because she didn't want to lose Emily to Alison, she would've even had Alison killed if it menant she would win.

So how is Ali identifying Cyrus a bigger betrayal than Paige's? Look whose betrayal has cost more.

If after Alison risked everything for the girls and saved all their lives, and Emily could cut her off for such a minor thing... That in what sense and logic would Emily forgive Paige for betraying all them on a far greater level? It seriously makes zero sense and is just palin ridiculous.