Talk:The Bin of Sin/@comment-12205443-20150122024039/@comment-26211734-20150122032030

I'm pretty sure Tanner gave the butterscotch to Ashley or something like that. And if she's the one in that pic, then it would make sense why she's in Holbrook's office, and is setting the girls up, but making it look like Tanner. She would also have easy access to poor Ali.