Talk:No Stone Unturned/@comment-26520042-20150706031938/@comment-25337712-20150706062112

That was Alison's hand. Alison was wearing the bracelet that night too. I don't think Red Coat was the one doing the pulling either because we didn't see the person, just the arm. I think those flashbacks were used to tease that fact that Alison was alive and that it was showing Mrs Grunwald pulling her out.

It is very, very unlikely that the body could have been wrongly identified twice, even for Rosewood PD. So Bethany is probably dead.