Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-84.100.1.85-20141208015525

That night I dreamed of a revelation of A. When I woke up I was shocked by this story. Marlene says we may like A at the end. I've never forgiven Mona for being A, but I never wanted her to end in prison or die. If A is responsible for the murders, he must be condemned, whatever his motives. That's why I wonder if the liars would have two enemies after all. With twists in this series, I think there is a possibility that the person sending the messages to the girls since season 3, was not necessarily the one who committed all the murders. For example A the psychopathic stalker and Black Widow the murderer. In my dream, Jason reveals to Emily that someone was hiding in his house during Season 2. What if Jason protected a member of NAT club? The writers had not yet begun the plot of Big A at that time. The idea would be that Jason's friend was a paranoid person, and a kind of victim. So at the beginning this character wasn't planned to be the new A, just someone who needed Jason's help. It's not my favorite theory, but it might work: That night, someone (black widow) tried to kill Alison to retrieve the videos. If Ali has actually lured Bethany to Rosewood, I don't think she desired her death. Bethany's death was a accident. Not having these videos, Black Widow decided to destroy the NAT club (I think each members were present that night). One of them began to take this matter seriously and tried to find out who has the most interest to see them dead. This is the first move of Big A, suspecting the liars at the end of season 2 after discovering the Mona's informations. In Miss me x100, Jenna, Sydney and Mona meet a stranger in a park. My assumption is that they are allied to that A, to protect themselves from the liars (in particular Ali). Maybe A think that somehow they (and their secrets) are responsible for all the murders. In the 5x12, Mona would have been killed by black widow, perhaps about the informations the girls find in Radley. What do you think ?