Talk:Game On, Charles/@comment-24407719-20150602222748

Guys I have a theory, basically it revolves around Alfred Hitchcocks masterpiece Vertigo (!958) so I'm studyin thefilm for film class, and I believe that Marlene may have made a connection (We know she loves Htchcock). Okay so in the film the character Gavin maks an actress called Judy impersonate his wife, to try and convice the protaganist Scottie that she is possesed and wants to kill herself. BUT Gavin really just wants to kill his wife and makes it look like suicide. So what does this have to do with PLL... Well I think I know.

Okay so in the film Judy is transformed into the wfe "Madaline" two times. First by Gavin and the second time by Scottie who is obsessed with the idea of Madaline. Many critics and theorist refer to Judt as a "Doll" and it got e thinking of something. So if Charles may or may not be Ali's  brother but he is obssessed with her. So what if he met Bethany at Radley and transfromed her into Alisn just like he did with Mona. They planned on killing Alsion and taking her life, and now that it's failed he's turned Mona into Ali.

Pll already payed homage to Vertigo with Ian's death, and has paye homage to Psycho and Rear Window so it could be a possiblity that the transforming into Ali is all apart of Charle's obsession. After all the main quote is "Did he train you? Reherse You? Tell you exactly what to say"