Talk:Game Over, Charles/@comment-26079077-20150809183407/@comment-24004040-20150809194235

Reasons to believe Charles and Bethany were romantic: They escaped Radley together ; Bethany drew pictures of a young boy being taken away from a girl (symbols for her and Charles) ; Mrs. DiLaurentis gave her gifts because she was friends with Charles and she wanted to protect Charles which indicates she saw (and drew) how Charles pushed Marion off the roof. ; Keegan said A's motives were romantic.

So my guesses are either: Alison pranked Bethany (she knew Bethany would come to Rosewood) and something went wrong, so Charles tried to kill her and avenge her. ; Alison dressed up Bethany as her (we know Alison wanted to give her a yellow shirt), because she wanted to find out who -A was. Charles thought Bethany was Alison and hit her and ultimately projects his guilt on Alison and makes her responsible. ; CeCe and Bethany are twins and the one Melissa talked too was not CeCe, but Bethany (she wore the yellow top, didn't she?). But this would indicated Alison new CeCe had a twin (she knows both of them), so it is more unlikely but, CeCe makes Alison responsible for her twins death and is Red Coat.