Talk:A Dark Ali/@comment-82.147.251.165-20140811031506/@comment-5660329-20140811033544

^^ I think Troian should have won. I'm not saying that Lucy or Shay are bad actresses; I just don't think they're THAT great. & OK, but what about all of the other emotional scenes that she's had when she WASN'T sick? Personally, the only scenes of Lucy's that I liked were when she trashed Ezra's apartment and when she was crying in her car ... Shay, IMO, is better than Lucy because I cried when: Emily heard that Maya's body was in her yard, Emily cried while watching Maya's videos.. Basically every scene that Emily cries, I cry. Also, when Emily bitched out Sydney, I was like "YOU GO GURL!!!"; I was really impressed.

Lucy's scenes (besides the two I listed), on the other hand, don't move me as much as the other girls'...

For example, with Hanna: when she cried when Caleb was going to Montecito, when Caleb got shot and she saw him being loaded into the ambulance , when she finds out caleb used her ]... again, basically any time Hanna cries..

I've cried at Troian's scenes when Spencer cried on her mom's shoulder after Toby was A, when she and Toby broke up in season 2, this scene, when Spencer looked at pictures of her and Toby after he was A, etc.