Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-79.112.234.100-20140912132331/@comment-173.209.212.228-20140912195326

Then why did Mrs. D know that Alison was alive (I'm pretty sure she did.) Why did Mrs. D almost send an email "I can't protect you anymore."? IMO, telling the WHOLE truth will get everyone is trouble. The Liars, Ezra, Toby, Caleb, Melissa, maybe even the parents. I think she is a changed person because you're seeing this in Emily's, Spencer's, Aria's, and Hanna's prospective, not Alison's. Alison cried, couldn't speak, and didn't want to do anything when her mom died. Alison is weak. She needs someone. She cried when no one was therr for her. She cried and wore something of her mom's. Alison lies, yes, but my theory, is that she doesn't know who to trust. (Shana betrayed her.)