Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-14539762-20131117131511/@comment-24004040-20131118221921

I agree with someone hitting Ali and burying her are two different people. And I agree with that being Ian (who hit Alison).

But I doubt that Spencer really directly hit Alison and/or buried her. I think Alison's vision is something to go buy and she was really pushed into the gazebo and than buried. I doubt she got hit twice, because obviously after Ian hit her, she woke up again (seen as in the video). Because Alison only had one wound on her head.

In my opinion Spencer's secret doesn't really have anything to do with what happened to Alison, but it's really something from her past, her family and Alison knew about it. After their fight in the night she disappeared, Spencer was afraid Alison would reveal everything and followed her to question her and then it follows the books as in Spencer pushing Alison, thinking she killed her and than forgot (still there would be the question of only one wound, but who knows in Rosewood) and than Melissa really could have had the opportunity to bury her to protect Spencer. It seems likely since they are neighbours and Melissa seeing it wouldn't be a total surprise.

The only thing for me unlogical is that I really believe -A at least HAS something to do with the whole Ali killer thing. He/She knows so much and after Mona continued to harrass the girls and Alison. Uber A is not Ezra and therefore there has to be another reason which I think kinda is connected to why Alison was buried alive. I doubt it'll be Melissa who is Uber A (Black Widow in my mind) since it's kinda to obvious for me. They were building that Melissa is suspicious thing for to long and I really think Uber A will be somene totally unexpected but still someone who was there from the beginning.