Talk:The Jenna Thing (situation)/@comment-72.68.150.79-20131011043942

It either took place sometime after Halloween 2008 (because Jenna just moved to Rosewood that week and could obviously still see) or early 2009 (because Toby said that he was in juvie for almost a year and he was released on September 1, 2009, which was when Alison went missing) and if it happened on July 4, 2009, then Toby would have been in juvie for only about two months, which doesn't make any sense.