Talk:Oh, What Hard Luck Stories They All Hand Me/@comment-25199803-20150131133710

So I have a theory about the Thanksgiving episode (about AriA). I don't know if someone already had this or a similar theory before, so I'm sorry if this is just a repetition lol.

It was always weird how Mona out of all the liars decided to call Aria when she allegedly had "proof" that Ali was A. Here's what I think about this:

Mona never actually suspected Ali as A, she just made that up to distract from the fact that she knew all along that Aria is A. Like, she didn't want Aria to suspect that she suspected her.

On that Thanksgiving day she planned to expose Aria as A and thus wanted to lure her with that "Ali is A, I have proof" call to her house, which is the reason why she didn't call Hanna for example.

Before she did that, she told Mike about her plan, because she trusted him that he wouldn't get in the way and betray her. But she didn't reckon that Mike wanted to protect his sister and in order to do that he had to kill Mona.

Also in 4x06 there was a scene between Mike and Aria where he said something like "I'll always protect you and watch out for you". And in hindsight I think that scene could've been very important.

Do you think that could be possible? Or did I miss something?