Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-25547603-20141025210131/@comment-25547603-20141026034908

^ He knew who Aria was but when he saw her he forgot about everything and went by heart... He couldn't tell her about Ali because she would have dumped him. Who is his  "lacrosse friend"? I don't remember, tell me!

Jackie, Maggie, etc. well I think he didn't tell that to Aria because that belonged to the past.

"He writes down "Aria doesn't suspect a thing"."  Well ok, that isn't nice but I can understand. It's like "She doesn't suspect I'm investigating".

"He knew all along that someone was after Ali and the girls and didn't tell Aria; he didn't let them know that he knew and he didn't do anything to help them figure out who it was." I think he knew that by telling her what he was doing and what was his plan in the beginning, he would have ruined their relationship and I think he was helping them...stalking them. To find out who A is. If that makes sense.

But what left me shocked is this:  ''He was still doing his research after he met her because, if I remember correctly, he knew that Ali and the girls blinded Jenna. He knew that Caleb was working with Jenna to get information from the girls. He knew that Mona wasn't A."''

REALLY? When did they say this? Fuck. I didn't realize this. Fuck. I'm so... Fuck. I can't believe it! I thought he was unaware of this, I thought he stopped in the pilot and began again when he broke up with her. This changes everything... If this is true, really... I thought he stopped when he started his relationship. I kinda feel betrayed now. Seriosly he knew things the girls didn't know and he didn't tell them? And Aria forgave him? Ok. No really I have to metabolize this.....