Talk:Close Encounters/@comment-67.180.234.251-20140118184606/@comment-14539762-20140118194819

^ Spencer doesn't tell her friends everything that involves A (e.g. Toby giving back the RV), because they give a crap about this. Just look at the episode where Spencer and Emily went to Cicero. Spencer tried and tried to figure out who Ali called the summer she went missing, but Emily acted like she doesn't care at all. The whole episode (in school and in Cicero) Spencer was running after Emily, telling her about her suspicion and what she found out. However, Emily was more interested in befriending some sorority girls. Why waste your time telling people something they don't want to know about in the first place?

And you guys are exaggerating this "Spencer didn't tell her friends about Toby being A" thing. She found out in 3x16 and told her friends in 3x19/20. Since time is passing very sloooowly in Rosewood, it was probably just 2-3 days. Spencer doesn't hide that many things... not more than the other liars.

About Spencer's big secret in 4B: Who says that she remembers her secret? In the books she "forgot" (or rather her mind blocked) that she pushed Courtney. Maybe she doesn't remember her secret in the show as well, but the side effects of the drugs will make her remember it.

Spencer is not too judgemental. She is just sceptical and wants to protect her friends. Just think about this situation: They find the place Ali was staying at, there was obviously a fight and they know that A was there. Then Shana (who isn't really in good terms with the liars) tells Emily that Ali wants to meet her alone. It is not far fetched to believe that A (who might be working with Shana) wants to lure Emily into a trap, abduct her and then tell Ali "We have Emily. If don't come to x place at y o'clock, we will kill her".