Talk:Uber A/@comment-25826236-20141207002311

My (somewhat) crazy theory is that Big A is Mrs. D's twin sister. They've said that Alison doesn't have a twin (like the books) but there is still a LOT of "twin" stuff that they've put in her bedroom--what if it is all from her mom's childhood? I'm guessing that Mrs. D's twin (I use the nickname TwinD) had to be put in Radley a long time ago, and that's why Mrs. D was on the board of directors (to make sure that TwinD was well taken care of, etc). The night Ali disappeared TwinD got out, which is why Mrs D was so upset. I'm guessing that TwinD has some MAJOR resentment towards Mrs D and/or Ali. A twin sister is just about the only person I can think Mrs D would go to so much trouble protecting, especially if it's Mrs D's fault that TwinD was put in Radley for (presumably) her entire life, too. I bet that TwinD had something to do with Toby's mom's death, being in Radley at the same time. I've had this theory for a while, and I keep adding to it when I watch the episodes. I want to rewatch them to look for more clues, but just don't have time! When Marlene recently said that only one fan has guessed Big A's identity, it made me even more sure that this insane theory could be correct--it's not one I've seen online before. I'd love it if anyone else has clues that support it, or make it impossible (so I can finally stop thinking about it so much!!! hah!). Oh--another thing that might fit....I bet that Spencer is the one Mrs. Grinwold is talking about having been touched by Big A, because she spent so much time in Radley.