Talk:'A' is for A-l-i-v-e/@comment-5660329-20130617221716

"Ok seriously ,how the hell do u guys think ? I'm sorry but ,i clearly said there was three of them "that night" ,and if you're talking about the scene when Toby gets hit, there was two of them ,if u saw it then u should know. Jenna was the one who hit him ,and the one he was watching was either Melissa or Shana."

Okay, I'm talking about the scene when Toby was hit. I thought Melissa or Shana hit him and the person he was looking at was Jenna. If you look at this video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7atBH4bYalc) and pause at 2:50, the person's side profile looks exactly like Jenna. Melissa has short hair from what we last saw and the person he was looking at has long hair   -_-

and what do you mean "that night"? the night emily was drugged?