Talk:The Bin of Sin/@comment-6659210-20150126223058

When you first started watching the show, doesn't matter when, what was your first theory? My first theory ever, was that Alison is still alive and she was just vacationing in Paris. Obviously I was correct (probably not the Paris thing lol) because throughout the show they threw little hints that she was still out there, first time when she visited Hanna at the hospital and then pushed Ian from the bell tower, we all thought that was A. And when I re-watched the episodes of when the girls "halluncinate" I'm like "Wow that was so obvious," but we really didn't know at the time. And I think the 8th book came out when the Pilot aired, so we were just learning about the twin thing from the books. At that time I really wanted Ali to be alive and Courtney to be alive as well too because it'll be interesting to see how that plays out. Now, not so much. What do you think?