Talk:Game On Charles/@comment-25547603-20150330161521

Are we sure that the events in the dollhouse happened while the boys were looking for the van? It looks like the girls went to bed a few times and woke up in the morning, while all the events in Rosewood happened that same night of the girls disappearance.

Remember when many people theorized that the events in New York and in Rosewood happened in different days? (4x24) I think the writers read those theories and decided to do that now, in the Season 5 finale.

It's the perfect way to make us rule out many people (Toby, Caleb, Andrew, Ezra) while they could still be Charles.

Just think about this: the girls get in the dollhouse, wake up after they were drugged, meet Mona, play the game of the mystery date and then go to bed. In the middle of the night Mona wakes up the girls, talk to them and then they go back to sleep. All of this while the boys look for and find the van. This is when the Rosewood storyline ends.

Then the girls wake up THE NEXT morning (we see the scene), when they find out that "A" wants them to recreate the prom. In the evening, there's the prom and Charles is there. So Charles wasn't in two places in the same time, he may have been with the boys the night of the kidnapping and with the girls the following night.

One more thing is that Tanner finds the video of Hanna yelling at Mona "You're not Alison, you're Mona", but - how strange - there's no video of the girls preparing the stuff for the prom. I think that's because those events had yet to happen!