Talk:Bethany Young/@comment-99.123.61.225-20140903204156/@comment-85.180.117.194-20140907220401

That is why I believe Ali has a split personality: The rock scene looked for me, as if Ali hit herself! She slowly was rising her hand with a rock in her fist, while her mother was watching in shock. Then she hit herself in the back of her head. You can see afterwards, that the rock fell way to close to her feet, as if she openened her fist releasing it in midheight, arm height and she collapsed seconds later.

If a rock was tossed by A from a distance, it would not fall that way and would scatter further away, and Ali would be hit with a greater force, which would project her down almost diagonally and very hard, not that slow way, collapsing her knees etc.. And for A to stand so close to Ali, without her noticing and hitting her is impossible.