Talk:Turn of the Shoe/@comment-6402774-20130612173746

Uh oh.. I have a theory.

This is what I think happened:

Well nobody can deny Ali was cruel and mean, maybe she was pretending maybe not. I don't know how but I think Melissa figured out about the whole twin thing, as did Jenna. Anyway. So CeCe and Melissa, who met in Cape May, got tired of Ali and started a little game and began torturing her as A, maybe the real Alison was their leader. They recruited Jenna at some point. On the night of her death they were doing another A-game that horribly went wrong. I'm afraid to go into details, might sound too twisted :/. They stopped after the murder, because their goal was Alison after all.

After that Mona came along, taking their game to the next level, doing it to the liars. First they didn't care, but then they saw the liars were searching for clues and actually getting closer, so they interfeared. Melissa called Cece, she moved to town. And (evil) Red Coat was born. The other Red Coat is obviously Ali.

Remember the episode where that guy traced Ali's blocked messages to Melissa? Sure she might have sent some "leave my boyfriend alone" messages, but that guy traced particular messages, the A messages, to Melissa. He wasn't talking about the other messages.

I have no idea how Wilden is involved, but it seems like they all made a weird pact in Cape May :/

Remember how Ian said he was doing everything to protect Melissa? Well, I think, that on these videos there is proof of Melissa being A.