Talk:Fresh Meat/@comment-25755332-20150111114414/@comment-25584522-20150111121643

I replied in blog but I would like to comment here as well:

Amazing amzing amazing. ^_^

The thing is, for now we have to accept the flashback as they are, or else we wouldn't be able to craft theories and guess what is what.

Your theory flamed an internal debate I had with myself about one of the most mysterious flashbacks in the show, if not the most mysterious one of all: Jenna and Garrett's meeting with Alison the night she died.

Alison never metioned that flashback in season 4 finale. The producers had the audacity to say they wanted to show more important scenes from that night. But here is the thing - many flashbacks from that night were recapped again in that episode, like Byron's creepy dialog with Alison. So why didn't they show that one too?

I think there are three possiblities to why they left it out:

- Garrett lied to Spencer, which means that Alison told the truth, and she never saw them that night.

- Garrett told the truth to Spencer and Alison didn't mentioned it for whatever reasons that she had.

- Both Garrett and Alison told the truth. Alison never met them that night; Garrett and Jenna met up with a girl who was identical to Alison and pretended to be her. Which means the twin ("Courtney") exists, or existed - in case that Bethany was indeed Alison's twin.

Now all that left to decide is what the most plausible scenario  is.