Talk:Misery Loves Company/@comment-58.167.67.9-20130119065058/@comment-75.93.36.191-20130119094235

No I think the writers really want us to believe he is evil so that nobody will see the real plot twist coming. Remember in 3A they made Paige look SO GUILTY in the last couple episodes. I was convinced she was A and then out of no where it was Toby.

Right after his reveal I think everyone assumed he was doing it to protect Spencer so the writers had to push hard to get us to believe something different. I think they tend to lead us in the complete oppostie direction, upside down, and flat on our faces so that nobody knows what the hell is going on.

ANYWAYS, in my own opinion, I think Toby joined the A team during season 3. 'A' does a lot of messed up crap to Toby in season 2. Not to mention A framing him in season 1. If he has an "ax to grind" with anyone, it's A. I just think he has to be convincing enough as an evil A team member, for big A. Another possibility is that A is blackmailing him. I am pretty sure Toby has a few secrets.

Who knows. I am officially stumped after re-watching season 1 and 2. Nothing makes sense. But, one theory I can confidently support is that Toby is not doing this because he "wants to torture the girls". People that are convinced he has always been A and is evil should go back and watch season 2. and season 3x9 (or whatever episode Toby leaves to go investigate.)

blah. I could go on forever. I should probably quit while im ahead.

Oh and I think Spencer is on the A team.