Talk:Game On Charles/@comment-24784093-20150413214814/@comment-25984379-20150413225006

I have a theory you might like.

Bethany was the person who was peeping on the girls as they were dressing (the person Ali thought was Toby). Bethany had been escaping Radley at night in preparation to attack Ali (as in, following her to see where she goes, her routes for going home, her habits). When Ali realized someone was watching her, Bethany ran. She hid in the Cavanaugh's garage thinking Ali would never find her there, but she did. Bethany was burned on the face. After about a year recovering, Bethany and Charles had a plan to kill Ali.

All the girls were involved in burning Bethany, which explains his grudge against them all. To a certain extent, he may even have a grudge against Jenna or Toby (if Ali and Toby planned the Jenna Thing).

That was long I apologize XD