Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-168.13.154.2-20120829141337

Toby is on the A Team. Remember "The Jenna Thing." Alison and her friends were responsible for the fire that blinded Jenna, but Ali blackmailed Toby into taking the fall for the fire by threatening to release the video of him having sex with Jenna. Spencer, Aria, Hannah, and Emily knew that Toby was innocent and yet they sat back and watched him go to a detention center for a crime that they knew they committed. Besides, they had the entire town convinced that he was the person who killed Alison. I think that Toby joined the A Team for revenge.

I also think that Toby has been on the A Team the entire time. That would explain how A was able to be in multiple places at the same time. Remember the incident with Spencer and Ian at the church? Spencer was about to fall over the rail when "A" came up and pushed Ian over the ledge. Do we really think that Mona was strong enough to push Ian...nope it was Toby. Do you really think that Mona was strong enough to remove Ian's body from the church by herself...nope Toby was helping her from Day 1. It all makes sense.