Talk:Game Over, Charles/@comment-26862348-20150808194304

Omg I read this creepy theory that Bethany Young is actually Spencer's twin and that the real Spencer died that night! The Hastings family had put Bethany in Radley under a fake ID (age, name). Bethany and Charles became friends (that's why "Spencer" said that she felt like she had met Charles before + how she uncovered his name). They escaped together. Bethany killed the real Spencer that night and took her place. From that moment she believed that she was truly Spencer Hastings. Only Melissa, Peter and Jessica knew the truth. That's why Melissa is protecting "Spencer." Also Peter and Jessica had "an understanding" about "Spencer" in season 4. Also Jessica was always spying on Spencer because she knew she was Bethany. This could also explain Spencer's mental state troughout the seasons. She's slowly coming to realize that she's Bethany and Charles is trying to make her remember again.