Talk:Misery Loves Company/@comment-76.108.175.23-20130107003005/@comment-68.200.112.145-20130112135530

All of the girls end up keeping things to themselves. Two of the lies we know about - Spencer lying about Toby being A and Hanna lying about Lucas sneaking around Aria's basement.

The girls all act disloyal and they come clean to each other in Dead to Me, starting off with Spencer finally cracking and telling them about Toby. They all feel betrayed by each other and they stop trusting each other so much.

I don't think she lies to the girls out of a fear of looking stupid. I think she probably is in denial and let's herself be convinced that Toby is a double-agent. She should remind herself of Basic Instinct again. Toby injured his own arm so he could have an alibi, not because he wasn't A at that time.