Talk:The Silence of E. Lamb/@comment-69.181.200.235-20140719232956/@comment-5660329-20140720054211

^ I don't believe that about Toby. You say that he was A to find out secrets, yet he found out NOTHING aside from the fact that the leader was Red Coat/ a woman, something that we already knew about Big A. And we now know that red coat isn't even in charge! So technically, he found out nothing. And him being on the A team did nothing to protect her; she was in danger regardless. Let's not forget that Toby was most likely the one who: locked spencer in her shower, put a snake in her dressing room, hurt Hanna when she was waiting for the interview that didn't happen, drove Caleb's mom off the road, tried to run Lucas over, and possibly killed Garrett (idk why Melissa or Wilden would and I don't buy it), as well as letting his girlfriend think he was dead, and a few other things (I'm trying to think of them but I'm drawing a blank). And who knows if Mona was even telling the truth about when she recruited him; I still think he's been in it season 1. and I think Marlene previously stated that Toby was in the A team around the homecoming episode, before he and spencer even got close. Don't ask me to find the source because I don't remember where it was. But there are several hints that he's been part of it since season 1.