Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-79.115.88.141-20140101190034/@comment-14539762-20140101211917

That was a very confusing storyline :D Tbh, I'm not even that sure if it was planned by A to push Aria down. They got a message saying "Guess who doesn't make it to the end of the line - A" (or something similar). Garrett was the one dying, so the text could be about him. If A really did order Wilden and Melissa to kill Aria, why didn't they first kill her and then put her in the box? The did it with Garrett that night, so why not with Aria? I think that there is more of a story behind this.

We don't know what Marlene means when saying that Aria will be A's next target. It could mean that she really gets physically tortured, but it also could simply mean that Aria will be Spencer 2.0 and cry a lot and have a mental breakdown. The latter could easily be faked.

And it was never confirmed that Aria will commit suiced. It is just a rumour that some fans started.

I think you can't really tell "xyz is A, abc is not A for sure" right now. The producers are always saying that nothing is like it seems in Rosewood, that nothing is impossible in Rosewood and that you can't trust anyone. So you shouldn't rule out Aria (or anyone else) being A.