Talk:A's Messages/@comment-74.99.164.252-20120618170816/@comment-72.89.168.5-20120714172955

very elaborate theory but just letting you know, Vivian was not Ali's twin sister, Vivian is who Ali pretended to be when she wore the red coat and brown wig, ....Ali's twin is named Courtney in the books but there has not been any sign of her twin other than the story in the Halloween prequel (told by Ali) and the Hallucinations the girls have had where they thought they saw/talked to Ali ... could mean Ali isn't really dead, or that Courtney is real and did escape from Radley which could mean Mona may be able to escape ....and if Ali does have a twin sister Courtney, that would mean older brother, Jason, would definitely know about it so the question is why has Jason never mentioned it or maybe gone to visit Courtney just to check and make sure she's still under lock and key... Maybe his parents are up to something (we don't ever see them) and since it was revealed that Jason's real father is Peter Hatings, do you think he would know something about it or proabably not? Either way I don't trust any of them lol

I like how you said Jenna's story about Ali coming to visit her may be false to cover up something, didn't really think of that ... but maybe she did actually go there and try to scare Jenna but instead of scaring her, Ali just pissed her off and made her want to kill Ali...

I definitely think that Melissa is hiding something but they don't show enough footage of her to help give us clues... she faked the pregnancy atleast once she saw Spencer with Ian's phone that made her for some weird reason fake the pregnancy, and all we know is that she likes Toffee Frozen Yogurt and was the Black Swan but those clues don't help too much... the toffee helps us connect Melissa to Mona but it was originally Aria's ice cream so does that mean Aria's involved? I don't think so... and the Black Swan story was that Melissa was blackmailed to wear it and distract Jenna but that story could be a lie because I don't think anyone was supposed to know Jenna was there because when the camera showed her there she wasn't wearing her sunglasses even though most people thought she was blind.... people were also saying about how Aria's dress was in the Black Swan poster but I really can't see her being apart of Team A I just don't see any reason for it, there's no motive and actually Ali wasn't that mean to her, only about her dad cheating thing but that's not horrible enough to want to kill her....