Talk:A is for Answers/@comment-67.180.234.251-20140314013738/@comment-12103667-20140314145850

Tyler was a regular since season 3, so it's not the first time he is. And the reason why he is a regular and keegan isn't is because Caleb has more screen time than Toby. Toby (before season 4) only appears for like five minutes and then disappears. In season 4 he had more screen time, but he still shouldn't become a regular.