Talk:Now You See Me, Now You Don't/@comment-12339380-20130808151001/@comment-9100790-20130809161516

It's not copying the books, if you watch each epi you will realise that at the beginning of the episodes it says 'BASED ON THE BOOKS BY', so yeah.

At this point, if Alison is alive I wouldn't mind if they didn't go with the twin route. But at least go with one of the two. The writers have been hinting at BOTH theories for so long, aka since the start of this show. They can't just build up all this hype around two of the biggest theories and then just go "lol, no".

Also, they built SOME hype around Alison's killer but it's slowly dying down. If they do decide to have a killer then they'll probably go with the twin theory. The one who's alive is Red Coat, the Alison the girls knew (not sure if it's really her or Courtney) and the other is dead.