Talk:She's No Angel/@comment-26226778-20150624070727

What if Charles tortured everyone who was "present" at that night (Mrs. D, NAT club, Ali, the Liars, Byron, Jenna etc.) because they were involved in Bethany's murder?

Keegan (not sure) said that A's motives were romantic in some way. Perharps when Charles was in Radley he bonded with Bethany, maybe he fell in love with her and he wants revenge for her murder. He probably tortures the liars and Ali the most because she drugged them and they commited the crime but don't remember (it was a traumatic experience and they repressed their memories from that night).

Just a theory but it's quite possible since most of the people who were in Ali's backyard that night are already dead.