Talk:Oh, What Hard Luck Stories They All Hand Me/@comment-9290937-20150129145143/@comment-25937133-20150129152854

Well, logically, if Marlene decided A's identity in season 2, theoretically there should be no clues about A's identity in season 1, other than coincidental ones.

I'm pretty sure that the obviousness in every episode would be that it is someone's (probably Ali's) twin. There are pictures of twins all over Alison's room in the flashbacks, and tons of twin references all the time. What we thought was homage to the books, could actually be the "clues" Keegan is talking about. The only other character that would have clus pointing to them in many episodes since the beginning is Aria. Not saying she is A, but there are lots of clues pointing to something being off with her. I still think they are going the twin route, I don't care what the writers say.

Melissa would be the most obvious; which is why I'm pretty sure it's not her. Plus, she took a huge risk by confessing to burrying Bethany on tape. Spencer could have easily turned that in to the police and Melissa would likely be in jail (and there s solid video proof to stick her there). I don't think A would put themselves in that kind of position.

Jenna would be obvious too, except that she has almost died twice and was saved by the Liars twice. Again, not sure if A would put themselves in that position. Unless it was a really clever ruse...which actually Jenna is very capable of haha.

Also, just for perspective: Keegan also said that it's someone we would never suspect. Clearly he has never visited this wiki because we have suspected everyone from the Liars, to Wayne Fields, to Maya, to the random blonde lady at the Ravenswood cemetery. :P