Talk:Fresh Meat/@comment-26106484-20150115225317/@comment-25937133-20150116012013

I thought it was interesting too. I think it's probably just the writers though - if Ali gave an arguement as to why she wasn't A, it would decimate the Liars arguement that she is in seconds (mostly because the Liars have a lot of speculation and very few actual facts). If Ali verbally proved them wrong, they would look even dumber until 5x23 (I'm guessing) when they find out she is not A.

It is frustrating though, because I feel like most people in Ali's position would be laying out every possible arguement against being A to try and clear their name. She has been too quiet about it. I think there may be some A blackmail keeping quiet.

I think if Ali gave an actual logical arguement and explained some of her shady behavior the Liars would believe her. Look at Hanna in 5x15. Three sentences from Ali and you could already see Hanna starting to doubt her convictions.