Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-69.116.248.114-20120829024049

Toby has reasons to be A. He has just as much reasons as Mona. There were also some clues.

1) The girls weren't really nice to him until the end of season 1.

2) Ali blinded his sister

3) Ali threatened to expose a video of Jenna abusing him

4) Spencer tried to get Toby locked up because she thought he murdered Ali --

CLUES

1) the strange tattoo: 'free at last' I think it had to do with other things then Jenna

2) Toby left Spencer many times 'becasue she was keeping something' while it was obvious something was wrong it wasn't that obvious

3) Toby seemed to know a lot about Jenna, did he really hate her?

4) Toby got Dr.Sullivan at the exact right time, how could he know where she was unless he was the one blackmailing her?