Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-24004040-20131130213844/@comment-24004040-20131201103347

Yeah, but Alison STILL wouldn't go talk to the girls, because she is paranoid. Even if she thought (like your example) Hanna was A, but then got hit with the car, and Alisons theory was proven wrong, she still wouldn't go talk to the girls, because she would always have in mind, that Hanna still could be -A and set everything up (just like Mona send herself -A messages to make the liars think she was harrassed by -A too). Alison is really paranoid, especially after everything happened, so even if she had the slightes clue one of liars would be A, I doubt she would talk to them.

And come on, she wouldn't tell Emily "I thought I knew but I was wrong." If it was one of the Liars, the others still are Emily's best friend, and there is a high chance that Emily would believe the liars and not Alison. So Ali couldn't count on that.

And I meant with "unlogical" one of the liars is -A, not that it's not possible character wise, but just logical plot wise. Aria mostly (or nearly always) was there when something with -A happened and the way she reacted when Spencer said that maybe they should blame themseleves, come on. You can't compare your best friend murdering another person and you never suggesting it, with something so complex like -A. The whole set up of the -A game is so compex and confusing, Aria had to be sometimes at two locations at the same time and she is nearly 24 hours a day with the Liars, how should she do this if she is -A or Uber A? I mean, yes there is always a chance of -A employee's doing that, but people really think she is Uber A (I think Black Widow here, since she is endgame) and that is not possible since we already saw her when ALL the liars were together and it just doesn't make sense. The grls are together 24 hours a day. If your best friend murders another guy and you never suggested it, than what. You aren't with your best friend 24 hours like them and it's not something that concerns you (meaning YOU aren't being attacked by your friend too). That's a realy difference. That's what I meant with unlogical, not that there is a chance of one of your friends to do it, that's always a possibility, but just plotwise, it doesn't make sense.