Talk:A is for Answers/@comment-68.200.112.145-20140103100824

I think Alison does have a twin or Tabitha is in the show because the girl who was in the barn wasn’t Alison. Clearly these differences were intentional: Alison had earrings on, a necklace on, and the bracelet on her left wrist. Her hair was curly but thin and dirty blonde. Alison looked different when she arrived at Hanna’s house and Emily’s. She had her purple outfit on and the bracelet on her right wrist. She had her outfit for that night on while visiting Emily. She had no necklaces or earrings on, her hair was curly but thicker than the girl from the barn’s hair, her bracelet was on her right wrist and she had a ring on her left hand. Twin or not that girl wasn’t Alison and something’s going on because we saw a picture of the girl from the barn in the A lairs and she didn’t have a mask on – she looked exactly like Alison. At first I theorized and concluded maybe it was a mask and that had been CeCe and the 3x01 drugging of Emily happened to all of the girls, but the photo that was taken of the girl in the barn proves she didn’t have a mask on.

I haven’t read the novels. How closely does Tabitha resemble Alison? It’s just odd because I completely stopped believing in the twin theory, but then I looked at the clip from the upcoming episode – the finale, and it is proven that wasn’t just a mistake they made like the clips of Alison and Ian at the kissing rock changing. They did this on purpose as Alison was shown again with the bracelet on her left wrist. Maybe if the twin is gone this really is Tabitha and since we know CeCe was created so the twin could be removed this girl might be CeCe's friend from Radley (if she was ever locked up there, which wouldn't surprise me if she was).