Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-25584522-20141202072254/@comment-25584522-20141202095909

^ I really don't know. We know that Alison was the "good" Red Coat, CeCe was the "fake" one, and there was a third Red Coat, the "evil" one, and I think she was the one who dug up Alison's grave.

I also think there was ANOTHER Red Coat, whose role was exactly like CeCe - to confuse the liars and prevent them from exposing the "evil" Red Coat.

I'm almost positive that one of the evil Red Coats was Kate, Hanna's step sister. She was the one who rescued the liars and Mona from the fire at 3X24, but left Hanna behind. She was the one who burned a Hanna bobblehead at the end of 3X17. Kate was recruited right after she was kicked out from the school, back at season 2.

And despite what the producers claimed, I don't believe Mona was hallucinating at the end of season 2, when she said "I did everything you asked me to" to Red Coat. I believe she met CeCe - who was visiting her at the time for information regarding Alison's death. CeCe was the Red Coat who visited her during Season 2 ending.

The chances that I'm right are pretty low, though. Of course, there is a very good chance that the real, evil Red Coat incarnated herself as the Black Widow, but I still believe that neither are Uber-A.