Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-24004040-20131227192740

I'm currently watching Season 2 again and what I really don't get is that Ian really thought he killed Ali as he pushed her (as seen in the video), but later we see that the video was cut and Alison stood up again but Ian was there and SAW how she got up, so why did he still thought he killed her?

And why was Alison always out as to make herself appear like she died? Like when Garrett (is that written right? xD) fake hit her with that hockey stick and like I already set when she let herself fall down like being pushed to death. Why would she do that? It's like she set that up from beginning, but why?