Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-24004040-20131228104717/@comment-24004040-20131228223340

Yeah, there are a lot of storylines which aren't summing up with the rest now.

Like who did Ian push of the Bell Tower. Clearly it was a hooded figure (-A) but Mona said she didn't do it even though she was the only -A at that time. I know that it doesn't necessarily had to be -A who pushed Ian, but -A did take his body after all and pulled that suicide thing.

And pretty eyes doesn't fit now too. We all thought that Toby was pretty eyes (budding up with Mrs. Sullivan at the same place and seat he met Spencer later on) but now it's revealed he isn't which really just doesn't fit the rest.

I know the show hasn't finished yet and everything could be answered in a plausible way, but it's just not matching up.

I can understand that they wanted to make Alison appear as hallucinations, as the girl the liars remembered because otherwise it would appear like she was alive already in Season 1, but Alison spoke in those "hallicunations" like she was still alive, for example when she told Aria "Everywhere I go" or something like that when she asked if she sees -A. The girls talked to her as if she was really there (even though they didn't know at that point) so why not show how afraid she is?

Season 4B Alison appears to be constantly frightened and afraid of getting court. Tell that Season 1-3 Alison who walked around Rosewood and had time to talk to her old buddies.