Talk:Uber A/@comment-199.126.21.228-20140711025252

My theory is that Meredith is Big A/Black Widow. She was in the pilot and also seems to have the body of Black Widow. She is also similar in appearance to CeCe and Alison, and could possibly have been a third Red Coat? Mrs. Grunwald says that 'One of you has been touched by the one Alison fears the most', in 3x16, Aria is attacked/'touched' by Meredith. I think that Meredith being Big A ties in with the fact that Alison was involved with Byron's affair with Meredith, threatening to constantly expose the secret, etc and she wanted to shut Ali up. There was another theory I saw somewhere on here saying that Meredith might be Jason's twin sister, and if this is true, makes perfect sense that Mrs. D wanted to protect her, and she could've been the one that Mrs. D was writing the e-mail to ("I can't protect you anymore"), it's possible that Meredith is mentally unstable and she could've been the one to kill Mrs. D for not wanting to protect her anymore? Another big point in this theory is that Toby's mom was said to have been on a roof with a fragile/unstable blonde. It's no secret that Meredith was kind of crazy, she went crazy on Aria and was known to be on meds. This may also possibly relate to Bethany Young -- she was a Radley patient, and maybe Meredith has a past with Radley too, considering she might be insane (Mrs. D was also on the board for Radley - maybe to further protect and keep an eye on her possible daughter?). Toby's mom was also a patient at Radley. In 4x4 when Toby is meeting with one of his mom's past doctors, Dr. Louis Palmer, he tells Toby to tell his mom to "Stay away from that blonde girl, there's something wrong with the air around that one."

Meredith being Big A would be completely unexpected since she has not been mentioned for a while, which makes sense because PLL always throws its audience off track. It has a lot of holes and missing pieces, but this is my theory.