Talk:To Plea or Not to Plea/@comment-25132765-20150228144522

I found this theory about Bethany being A on Tumblr and wanted to share it with you:

-Bethany being A kinda seems unlikely but keep reading, it makes sense. Bethany could be someone we already know. We never saw her face, so she must be important. She could be someone's twin.

-Remember this A message Spencer got in 4x23: http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-UB4L_k48xwE/UyChp8kCsdI/AAAAAAAAP6M/jNqLq6UnDKQ/s1600/pic22lt.jpg If A is actually Bethany and Spencer hit her head with the shovel, this message is a huge clue.

-This is one of Bethany's drawings: http://media.tumblr.com/adfc0d6ee26f8e9b7422a6aa09223ae3/tumblr_inline_nh0f3w969o1t5a83j.png It looks like a blond with a burned face, and BW had a burned mask (Maybe her face really is burned, and that explains why she always wears masks)

-Another drawing: http://vignette4.wikia.nocookie.net/pretty-little-liars/images/f/fb/CADB_2.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20140725210626&path-prefix=fr I just wanted to point this out because the way she looks into mirror in the painting reminds me of this: http://vignette4.wikia.nocookie.net/prettylittleliars/images/f/f9/LiB.png/revision/latest?cb=20130612204153

-The night of The Jenna Thing, maybe another person was there and they also got burned, who I think is Bethany. That's how she got the burn on her face, and I think Jenna already knows that A is Bethany (they could be working together, or Bethany is taking revenge for Jenna?), as we saw her in 5x05 like this: http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/prettylittleliars/images/1/18/Screenshot_(684).png/revision/latest?cb=20140709073005

I would hate it if Bethany is just an irrelevant character and not the twin of somebody, but if she is someone we already know, this theory makes a lot of sense. ie If Bethany's twin is alive (and someone we met before), she would have enough motives to be A: Her twin sister and her friend -Jenna- got burned by the Liars, and Bethany was buried alive -I think the liars were involved in that one.