Talk:Bethany Young/@comment-25160183-20140710043903

I know it says Jason is 21, but it never says his birthday. So if he had his birthday late enough he would've been 17 the year Alison "died" (If his birthday was RIGHT before school). What if Bethany was his twin sister? It explains Mrs. D on the phone, and why Mrs. D would cover for her. Alison would have no clue, either. She could've sent Bethany to Radley because she didn't want Mr. D finding out about her affair. Bethany could've gone after Ali because of who Ali was. A very pretty, very popular girl. Bethany easily could've gotten jealous and tried to kill Ali. Mrs. D had to have known Ali was alive after she was burried alive, because the ground would look like someone dug their way out. Peter or Melissa or Mrs. D (she thought Ali was dead, but didn't want to turn in Bethany) could've killed Bethany to make sure nobody would find out about Ali being alive and Jason's twin, it makes sense why Peter and Melissa have a "secret" going on. Because if Bethany was around Rosewood, people would ask questions. Then Mrs. D could've killed Bethany because she was upset about Alison and wanted to get back at Bethany. When the police want to make sure it's Alison in the grave Holbrook (I think?) says, "Mrs. D, we're not so sure your daughter is in that grave." and Mrs. D says "Well I sure as hell am.", because she doesn't want anyone knowing she killed Bethany. Mrs. D and Peter also could've teamed up to kill Bethany, so nobody would know her. Then Mrs. D was going to blame it all on Peter so she wrote "I can't protect you anymore.", causing Peter to kill Mrs. D. Yes the Dental Records were forged, but maybe not as much as they think. Just a theory. Because if it was really the same person who tried to kill Alison, wouldn't they be hunting her down? A easily could've found Ali and killed her if they knew she wasn't really dead, because Ali stopped running after Hanna got hurt.