Talk:Season 4/@comment-81.242.99.15-20130617151914

I came up with this crazy theory: what if 17 years ago two baby girls were switched at birth? The one girl was born as Alison DiLaurentis but then got switched with another girl who was raised as the "Ali" we all know. The real Alison was raised by a horrible family so when she discovered the truth she came to Rosewood to reclaim what is hers. She became obsessed with the girl who she believed had stolen her life and she began to stalk her. The two girls had a confrontation one night which ended with "Ali" dying. Now, the real Alison DiLaurentis has taken on the persona of Red Coat and she wants her life back. I know this theory sounds really far fetched but it could explain why Red Coat is so obssesed with "Ali" and the girls + it is kind of based of the hole twin-storyline from the books where Ali's twin sister Courtney stole her sister's identity and was then killed by Ali out of revenge. Since the writers said they are not exploring the idea of twins, I think this could kin of an alternate version of that storyline but just where "Ali" is dead and the real Alison DiLaurentis is still alive and "A."