Talk:No One Here Can Love or Understand Me/@comment-69.181.200.235-20140816153905/@comment-5660329-20140816173739

No, Bethany is dead. She died when she was 17; once someone dies, they don't age anymore. Toby is 19, I believe and two years have passed since Alison went missing (and presumably when Bethany died), so there is a possibility that Toby and Bethany could be twins. Or maybe because the writers like doing things in "two" (ie. two red coats, two gas masks, two queen of hearts, etc), they could make Toby and Bethany twins/siblings and Mrs. D and Marion twins. It would explain why Mrs. D wanted Bethany to call her "Aunt Jessie".