Talk:The Melody Lingers On/@comment-16754824-20150312011226

I really feel like they're going in the "Toby is A" direction. The whole Charles Cavanaugh thing seems like it could apply. Charles could either be Toby's real name, or his middle name. That's also a possibility of why Troian Bellisario kept saying "not everyone should be with their first love", referencing to Spencer and Toby's relationship. I could see them revisiting the Toby plot, since there's so much unexplained from that time. That could also be why the writers are continuously damaging Spencer and Toby, and making her cheat on him, so Spoby shippers may feel less pain about Toby betraying her

The only damper on that plot line is Spencer and Toby's hinted romantic scene in 5x24. They're most likely going to be fixing their problems, according to the spoilers. I could see the writers giving them a loving, hot, romantic scene to work shippers up, and have people feel emotion towards Spoby, and then be crushed and shocked when Toby's actually the real A.