Talk:Spoby/@comment-69.130.249.81-20130205014258/@comment-26179634-20130206221702

It seems like he was only supposed to reveal himself to either Spencer or Emily. Those are the two girls that are the best at keeping secrets. Aria and Hanna would have blabbed to the other girls right away, but Emily and Spencer would have waited to see if there was a logical explanation for Toby doing what hes been doing. Thats just my theory based on the discussion that Toby and Emily had about the girls being brought closer after their ordeal with A. I think Big A was told about that conversation or was listening in and then ordered Toby to expose himself to Emily. Now that I think about it Emily was probably the one who was supposed to find out, which is maybe why Toby was so surprised by being called out by Spencer. Well my point is that someone was supposed to find out and because of the person being unmasked was Toby, the person who found out would keep quiet and that would drive a wedge between them and the other liars.