Talk:Taking This One to the Grave/@comment-25780807-20141129132244

Ali and Bethany are the same person. Ali has a personality disorder and they sent her to Radley under a fake name for privacy. Mrs. D was on the board and swore the staff to secrecy and took Ali out on trips trying to make her well again. Ali/Bethany killed Toby’s mom while at Radley. Mrs. D and Ali faked Ali’s death when A started threatening her. The girl in the grave is actually Sara Harvey. Toby is A. He suspects Ali or Mrs. D killed his mom and he hates the liars for letting him take the wrap for the Jenna thing. Spencer caught him a few seasons ago, but he played it off as “A forced me to do it” and we’ve all let it go since then. He killed Mrs. D for her role in his mom’s death. My theory :3