Talk:Through a Glass, Darkly/@comment-9290937-20150104192330

"A" has to be someone we already saw on the show and most likely someone who has been here since at least season 3 because Marlene said that she knew who was going to be "A" before she wrote unmAsked, before she unmasked Mona as Original A.

We could try with eliminating the four liars and their parents, except Ashley, she is kinda sketchy.Then, we are left with the love interests (Toby, Caleb, Paige, Ezra).We can eliminate Ezra and Toby because they were already accused of being "A".

Then, the other characters:

Jenna-a good character but that wouldn't shock me

Cece-I would hate it, she is the worst written character with so much potential, Marlene destroyed her

Alison-like in the books

Meredith-she hasn't appeared after 316 and we're on 514 right now

Sydney-doubt it, she was introduced in 503

Noel-he's not a chick and he wouldn't be a good "A"

Lucas -dunno, I want A to be female

Andrew-no, he appeared in like 4 episodes

Mike-just no

Melissa-she already done too many dark stuff, I would be disappointed if she ends up being "A"

Wren-he's very shady, could be A

So, A is either someone's twin or a member of Bethany's family.But, "A" has already appeared since we've seen BW in season 4 without a mask (according to Marlene)

Then, the answer lies in the list of characters.If I forgot someone, please mention it.