Talk:Alison's Attempted Killer/@comment-5660329-20130614190657

Okay, so I don't really understand how these people could have been legally cleared of being her killer. I mean, the reason for why they were cleared sound almost stupid (at least to me):

 Toby - " They later clear him because of him admitting to Emily that his tattoo, '901 Free at Last', was the day that he was free from his forced relationship with Jenna, rather than the day Ali was killed." How do we know that that's what his tattoo REALLY means? he could have just lied and said it was when he was free from Jenna. We've seen what Toby can do: trying to run someone over with a car, drugging someone, etc.. I mean, i assume Toby killed Garrett, so who's to say that he couldn't be Ali's killer?

Ian - " He is later cleared, as the girls are shown the rest of the video by A, which shows that Alison and Ian both left the Kissing Rock after the video ended." So he was cleared because he and Ali both left the Kissing Rock.. that's nice, but couldn't he have come back later and killed her? We've seen him when he was ready to kill Spencer "because he loves Melissa"; he could have killed Ali.

The Liars:  They each could have had a motive (see above!). Any of them could have killed her but kept quiet. I don't think Emily would have killed her though because when she saw Ali in S2 (hallucination?), Ali said "...that's why you're my favorite".. She wouldn't have said that if Em tried to kill her.