Talk:Surfing the Aftershocks/@comment-4053765-20140620220352/@comment-98.210.144.51-20140620221638

This show is really confusing. I'm okay not knowing the stuff about Jake's punching bag (for now anyways, I'll be pissed if they never address it). It's the hard to follow bigger things that bother me.

So Mona was A, but then someone stole the game from her? But didn't she say to someone what she first got to Radley in the S2 finale "I did what you wanted me to do." So doesn't that mean she was working for someone else the whole time? Also, Aria and Emily started getting messages from A before the four liars became friends again in the pilot, so Mona's motive doesn't even apply to the pilot when everything started.

Was Mona the same A that was torturing Ali before she disappeared? If not, how did she know about taking on A's persona? If she was, then how does this new A figure into everything? I mean, if you're going to all the trouble to torture people, why do it in someone else's style? Maybe the new A worships Mona and wants to continue her work?

Also, so did Ali see Mona in that vintage shop and figure out she was A or was that just a guess from Spencer (S2 finale)? If that's true and Mona was A, why would Ali let Mona help her after getting hit by the rock and leaving Mrs. Grundwald's car?