Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-25547603-20141110214725/@comment-5660329-20141111032346

^ im guessing that's yet another plot hole that will probably never be explained. I want to believe that Melissa is innocent in all of this and I think about her "protecting" Spencer, but then I think back to where a man and a woman (believed to be Wilden and Melissa) are trying to push Aria off the train but then the man says he can't. Melissa claims Wilden was blackmailing her; if that's true, then why wouldn't we hear the MAN say "get back here and help me push". I still believe that Melissa hates her sister for some reason (whether it's because she feels Spencer "stole" all the guys she liked and, to be fair, Spencer kind of did even though it wasn't intentional and the men Melissa chose showed interest or another reason entirely).. But one thing is for certain: if Melissa does in fact hate spencer, it's not because of sibling rivalry and wanting to "one up" each other. Idk why Melissa wanted to push her off.. I mean, Garrett was in there. Idk if she thought it was only Garrett and she was trying to push HIM off (which is odd, since I believe they were dating right before), but surely she must've heard Aria (and even if she didn't know it was Aria, it was clearly a woman) screaming.