Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-24004040-20131228104717/@comment-14539762-20131228214959

^ Well, the other girls nearly died in a fire. This is just as traumatic as being buried alive, I guess. Emily was almost sawn in half. She was rescued in the very last second. This is also as traimatic as being buried alive. And I don't think that A was that evil to Ali back then. Mona is a psycho bitch, but murder is something she isn't capable of...at least in the first season. She got more aggressive as time passed. At the beginning her games were rather "harmless". Therefore I don't think that A/Mona was really a huge threat to Ali before she went missing. Mona "just" wanted to scare Ali a bbitby sendong her soke scary notes, scaring her at Halloween etc. I'm not saying that Ali didn't have a reason to be scared, but she didn't have so fake ger death and go into hiding.

I agree with you on the rest though. I also find ot very strange how Ali changed within some EPISODES. When she visited the liars she was all confident, mysterious, secretive, all knowing, a bit mean... just like the old Ali we love. She wasn't scared a bit. And suddenly she is only crying when she is around the liars. If she really changed and was scared, why didn't she show it back then but suddenly now? It's more than unrealistic to change your personality withing some weeks or months.

I also don't see nice Ali integrating in Rosewood again. Rosewood is a small town. People wouldn't accept her. Just like Toby... all he did is to acccidently blind his sister (Well he didn't) and he had/has a very tough time in Rosewood (you saw it in season 1 and 2). What Ali did is far worse and if people find out what she did she would be the town's freak. She would have to move to another town.