Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-99.71.209.164-20140610205553/@comment-5660329-20140611201647

1. Yes, I do. 2. I think she's a good character;  we know Shana set the fire, but I think maybe Jenna helped pull the girls out. 3. Not counting Shana or Mrs. DiLaurentis? Um, idk.. I hope Ezra, but he won't die. 4. I think Melissa is lying and is against Spencer; she joined Mona's army and was in charge of the situation. There is no way Mona would have let her take charge if they hadn't met up plenty of times before. 5. Do not help the story:  Ezra, Aria (only when she's with Ezra) and Toby. That help the story: Ali, Mrs. DiLaurentis, Jason.

6. It wouldn't make sense; he's done so much for the girls to be A. 7.  It wouldn't make sense either; I love him with Hanna, but he's irrelevant. 8. Spencer is on the girls' side, and I don't believe Toby really loves her. I think he's still A. 9. I'd take the rose and invite him in for coffee. 10. I could see Ali being lesbian and have her be with Emily. 11. I think Hanna would react badly; I, on the other hand, would be very happy if he started dating either. Aria is better off with anyone other than Ezra and I don't like Spencer and Toby together.

12. I want to say Aria, just because she's already had sex with two guys. Hanna used protection when she was with Caleb. There was no chance for Emily to get pregnant when she was with Maya or Paige (i'm still confused as to whether their sex scene in shadow play was real/present time or not). I don't know about Spencer