Talk:Game Over, Charles/@comment-26096089-20150813102750/@comment-16931075-20150813110714

While it does make sense, it still leaves some problems. Most notably, the marion cavanaugh situation. How is it possible that ali saw her with tobi when she was arround 15 when it was revealed that marion died when charles was arround 12? As we know, Charles is alison's older brother so that doesn't make sense.

This could mean many things:

-Either she didn't die that day like we are told to believe

-Either it's a problem on the writers' part (That's probably the case IMO)

-Either, and this is far fetched (lol), she has a twin !!! Or, a very convincing lookalike.

I would really like to have that answered really.