Talk:Grave New World/@comment-17899646-20131012170911/@comment-91.37.83.254-20131012175813

Alison wasn't in a coffin, for beginners. She was pushed into that gazebo hole and than the murder tried to bury her alive, probably assuming she was already dead from that fall. Her hand reaching out of the ground is possible if the earth is really fresh (which she was) and she wasn't buried to deep. Mrs. Grunwald pulled her out, we don't know when, but Alison seemed to be really capable of holding her breath. Especially singers, dancers and swimmers are capabel of holding their breaths pretty long. Mrs. Grunwald already was on her way when Alison got pushed into that hole, so who knows, maybe it were only two minutes in between her fall and Mrs. Grunwald pulling her out.

This show is still fictional and especially with so much mystery not everything has to make 100 procent sense. If you had to produce such a show you wouldn't do better. There are some things I think of too far fetched too, but than I would question the whole show, since there are so many legal ways to find out who is -A from the beginning.

The only think not really making sense is that -A seems to see absolutey everything they do. Even the panties they are wearing seems to be to -A's knowing. And the fact someone else lies in Alis coffin and no one has seen that? Come on, in a murder there is ALWAYS a DNA test no matter if someone THINKS to identify the body, especially if after a year the body looks kinda .. bad.

I agree that some things aren't really logical and thought through, but Ali being pulled out of that gazebo is possible, only the things aftr that, not really.