Talk:Game Over, Charles/@comment-26096089-20150804105124

I'm not sure if I posted this somewhere else before (or if I forgot to press Post.. *blush) but I would like to hear your opinions on this theory: I think that on the night Alison disappeared, Mrs D planned on killing Bethany, possibly with Charles' or the Black Widow's help: So Mrs D hears that Bethany escaped from Radley; maybe she lets Charles out of Radley (or she makes a deal with A) to protect her should Bethany come looking for her. As Alison returns home after the sleepover, Mrs D thinks she is Bethany (hence the "mad" expression on her face). A sees Alison from behind, thinks she is Bethany and hits her. Or A planned on hitting Alison all along and pretended to work with Mrs D.

Also, on a slightly different topic: Why is it that A tried to kill Alison, later actually killed Bethany, but kidnapped Sara? Some people say that A's main motive is to kill Alison, others say that he/she actually wanted her as her "doll".