Talk:Love ShAck, Baby/@comment-108.16.110.121-20140117221748/@comment-14539762-20140118002910

-           ^  Emily was just as mean as Spencer at the beginning of 4x15. Spencer said „We know that Ali had journals, what’s so bad about this one?“, „Personal about Ali?“, „That’s not your call to make“, „Did you?“

Emily said „So, you thought that you’ve got to read it and we don’t?“, „And it took you till now to realize that?“ (after Hanna said that she made a mistake when not showing them the journal).

Spencer and Emily were equally mean, I don’t understand why everyone is just bashing on Spencer.

Yes, Aria stopped the fight… but this was kinda her duty since she started the fight.



   Hiding that Toby was A was a really dumb thing, I agree. This is the only reason to bash on her IMO. But she never hid that she was A. She did the opposite. She gave her friends clues that she joint the A-Team (sending Hanna a picture of herself, so that Malcom could indentify her as the one who „kidnapped“ him). She couldn’t go to the girl’s house and say „I’m A“ since she was being watched, so she only gave them clues.



-           So Emily is allowed to do Alison a favour (meeting her alone), but Spencer isn’t allowed to do Toby a favour (not telling that his mother might have been murdered and that A is „helping“ him finding out the truth)? „Alison wants to meet emily alone for some reason“. Toby also wanted Spencer not to tell her friends about A for some reason. Everyone thought his mom has commited suicide, but there is a possibility that she might have been murdered. He didn’t want anyone to know about his suspicion until he knows the whole truth. It wasn’t a easy situation for him neither (this emotional stress), so he only wanted his girlfriend know about it.