Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-14539762-20131230215446/@comment-16844114-20140101090452

Much of your theory makes sense, but I agree, that when Grunwald told  her version, it was Ali that she pulled and took to the hospital. It was her own personal flashback. Now, it could be possible that someone did try to hurt CeCe, Ali showed up just in time....then when Ali was attacked by ____________, CeCe didnt do anything to help her. Maybe CeCe has known all along who Ali's attacker is, an was a coward about it. Feeling guilty, she breaks up with Jason the next day and skips town bc she thinks Ali is dead. Then, somehow, she finds out Ali is alive....via Mona, Jason, Mrs D, whoever....or even Ali herself. This is where my biggest question comes into play....is CeCe working with or against Ali? There is evidence pointing either way. Also, the body that was pulled from the ground would have to be Ali...she was the one who could hold her breath for long periods of time, not CeCe. I know they had similar personalities and acted the same, but that isnt something I see CeCe practicing and perfecting. Ive always, how convienent tht Ali could hold her breath for so long, and then was burried. I mean, it almost seems like she planned that. But that's a total different theory I wont get into right now.