Talk:The Guilty Girl's Handbook/@comment-75.159.40.70-20130725165550/@comment-5660329-20130727140121

toby became A in the first few episodes of season 1; i believe he was already part of it by the homecoming episode when spencer and alex were dating.

^ there's actually an interview somewhere online where they say how long toby was A and when he joined. i still dont believe toby is telling the truth and he's been A for revenge but he fell in love with spencer so, in season 2 or 3, he decided to be a double agent (secretly, at least until the reveal). it wouldnt make sense for him to have joined in 3x08