Talk:Taking This One to the Grave/@comment-82.25.188.25-20140826115205/@comment-24407701-20140826121538

Melissa killed Bethany, but she didn't intend to. Someone hit Bethany with a shovel (we still don't know the identity of this person). Bethany was unconcious and Melissa thought she was Alison (who she also thought was hit by Spencer). Melissa thought Bethany was dead so she buried her to protect her sister. Bethany was buried alive and she died from this.