Talk:Game On, Charles/@comment-4947372-20150420205101/@comment-26131626-20150420210952

Sorry, but I didn't believed in this theory, because there was too little evidence for me. The clues for A are supposed to be there since s3, if not before, but the first hint to the transgender theory was basically the s5 christmas special. Two yellow dresses: they existed, yes, but where's the evidence that one of them was for Charles? Then Charles being jealous of Ali being a girl, so he broke her arm (Hello? We're supposed to feel sorry for him), or even worse: Charles being sent to Radley because he was an embarrasment for his family. That would be disgusting - being transgender doesn't equal mentally ill. The main plothole was the motive against the Liars. What is the motive? Charles is mad because they were born as girls and he wasn't? Jealousy? If this is true I will feel some pity, but not for Charles, but for Alison.