Talk:The Melody Lingers On/@comment-25350337-20150311063907

I had a strange idea. I can't believe I thought of this, so please excuse me if you find this disturbing.

We all know that Mrs D is what you would call '"uncontrollable when it comes to sexual relations" (you know the word lol). So this is what I'm thinking. What is Bethany's dad is Alison's dad's brother? So Bethany's father is Charles DiLauentis. That would explain why Mrs D asked Bethany to call her Aunt Jessie. No wonder Bethany got so pissed off and threw a bucket at her cuz Bethany's uncle's wife is sleeping with her father! Thus, she doesn't consider Mrs D as her aunt, that's why she called her a liar. This is the main background for the below possibilities.

Charles' wife found out and divorced Charles and gave Bethany (and maybe her twin) away to the Young family to be adopted. Then Bethany killed her twin and was sent to mental facility (not knowing who her biological parents are). Later, Mrs D found her and kept visiting her and asked Beth to call her aunt Jessie. But Bethany found out and hated Mrs D because she tore her family apart.

There is another possibility that Mrs D is Bethany's mother. (But honestly, I don't want Mrs D to be her mother) So, maybe Bethany got pissed that her own mother is denying her as a daughter and the shit that Mrs D commited with her father. Maybe after Bethany was born, Mrs D gave her away to the Young family to be adopted. Thus, Jason is connected to Bethany, Spencer and Alison! Jason is the link here.

This is why I think Bethany is A and hates Mrs D, either way, Mrs D tore her family apart.

Hope you liked my theory <3