Talk:Through a Glass, Darkly/@comment-25584522-20141229184858/@comment-25584522-20141229190536

^ I mean thw whole scene was a hint:

Aria and Mona have been playing with girls since (probably) Halloween 2008. Emily had an idea, and apparently Aria stole it, hence "It's not fair Aria, it was Emily's idea".

What was Emily's idea? did she have anything to do with Bethany's murder? I believe she does. Remember the confused memory that re-surfaced during her hypnosis session with Dr. Sullivan? Maybe it was the real memory, and Emily confused Bethany with Alison, and hit her with the shovel.