Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-93.186.31.97-20141024201104/@comment-50.107.48.176-20141025014310

There's still the fact that an A hoodie person attacked her at home alone in her house. Also if she was A and knew everything about everyone, there's no way she would have been careless enough to get caught in NY by Shana.

Also, I think the "too obvious" argument is a pretty solid one. We aren't finding out who A is until around the end of season 6. Why would they make her so obvious so early? When has anyone the show has tried to make obvious actually ended up being A? Pretty much everybody but Wilden (who was probably being blackmailed) had some semi-legitimate excuse for being on the A team.

Also, the only reason people thought Mona was obvious was because they had read the books and knew she was A. The only reason Mona might have been obvious to people who hadn't read the books was because she was basically the only non-parent character besides Ezra to never be suspected at that point. With Alison they are doing the opposite. They are going out of their way to make her look Shady.