Talk:Bloody Hell/@comment-16754824-20150221195658

I saw this theory on Twitter and it really made sense to me, although I'm not sure if Marlene is up to do this.

So, back when Hanna had that whole dentist situation, the visitor's log had the name "C. Cavanaugh" written on it. At first glance, everyone assumed it was Chris Cavanaugh, the guy from season 3 that didn't have any real relevance. But then, the supposed 525 reveal of "Charles" obviously makes no sense atm. The Twitter user believes that the C in C Cavanaugh could mean Charles Cavanaugh. Now, this could go two ways. Toby is Big A, and he has been lying about his name, or Toby has a twin named Charles. Someone has a twin. What if it's Toby?

The twin theory for Toby seems like something Marlene Would do, as making Toby be Charles would probably make her disappoint all the Spoby shippers. But with this in mind, I do sort of believe that it is Charles Cavanaugh, and is Toby's twin brother