Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-217.84.196.145-20141022022126/@comment-71.178.128.152-20141022025920

Personally I think going the book route with the "twin theory" actually would make sense in the show. Of course they've stated over and over that they won't be taking that route. Then again they said the same thing about Mona being A. It's not as though they can reasonably come out and say "Oh yeah we are following the books, guess you all know who A is now."

Not trying to be one of those people who insist on the Courtney/Alison theory; just saying that given how often Marlene lies (and that when it coms to A's identity, the writers have to lie for the integrity of the show) I'm not ruling it out.

Also, I never actually read the books, but I think there was a 3rd A after Ali that hasn't been revealed yet.

Haha and who even knows if it'll be real A they reveal. They could do what they did with Mona - she was "real A" but there is also someone else involved who takes over. They can always fake us out and reveal a legit A but then follow it up with "but there is a "bigger" A.