Talk:A DAngerous GAme/@comment-5550712-20130213025539/@comment-174.112.96.186-20130218062614

2. I think the "A" we meet in the pilot is Mona, but if your theory is true, it could apply to Wren as well. They just couldn't be referring to Toby since the first time we saw him was in a flashback in 1x02.

4. I believe that was Mona's file: she was was born the same year as the liars (Toby is a year or two older) and as far as we know Mona is the one Dr. Sullivan knew as "A"

Otherwise I agree with you completely. He may not have always been an "A", but Wren's been sketchy from the start. He hits on high school girls and feeds off their vulnerability (kissing Spencer every time her and Toby break up, kissing Hanna when Caleb dumps her). And he just happens to appear anytime something bad happens or someone gets hurt:

-he gets a job at the hospital around the same time they start to question what the murder weapon was

-he's there when Emily has an ulcer. He isn't her doctor, but tells Spencer he recognizes her name (I could be wrong, but she didn't mention any of her friends by name in their previous encounters, did she?). And he would have access to her drug test results

-he just happens to be Toby's doctor when he breaks his arm

-he's there when Toby and Jenna come back to town and are at her appointment, and it's like Emily's ulcer all over again-he's not her doctor, but he goes and introduces himself and asks Toby personal questions about Spencer

And then he ends up working at Radley after Mona's been sent there. And unless Mona timed it so he wouldn't see her, he would have had to know she was sneaking out (maybe even gave her an access card to do so) and that Toby was visiting her.

I'm surprised Spencer hasn't figured that out yet or even questioned it-that Wren would have known Toby was up to something and didn't tell Spencer.