Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-95.86.74.185-20141004182313

The more I think about it, the more I suspect the producers and the writers will -eventually- use the twins storyline. Yes, I know they denied it, but then again...they lied about other stuff that was supposed to happen in the show, so who knows?

If they want to, they can reveal that Bethany Young is actually Bethany/Courtney Dilaurentis, and she IS the same age as alison i.e. her twin; She was admitted to radley because she was mentally unstable; Her parents used fake identity to hide her, because they didn't want anyone to know about her, due to unknown reasons.

OR something even more sinister: Alison is Uber A and the Black widow (personally, when I first watched 4X1 I thought the BW was Alison, but now I don't). The story she told to the girls at season 4 ending was a lie,  as she never mentioned meeting up with Jenna or Garrett the night she "died"... Why didn't she mentioned them? Maybe because she never saw them that night? Maybe there was another sister that night- Courtney/Bethany- who pretended to be Alison in order to expose the anonimous person who was after the REAL Alison. It's possible that the secret twin saw Garrett and Jenna, and NOT Alison.

Maybe she is seeking revenge for her deceased sister, and that's why she took those pictures of aria that jason developed. If I remember correctly, Jason found the photos Ali took after she disappeared, but it doesn't mean she didn't gave it to him after her disapearance. Maybe Jason knew Alison was alive this whole time. Maybe he and Alison are working together to find out who killed their sister. Was it Aria? Was it Hanna? Was it Spencer? Or maybe Emily? Of course, this brings up so many questions. Why did the secret sister was out that night? Who threatened Alison?

Maybe Jenna was never blind at all? And if she is, is it safe to assume that someone was seeking revenge on her behalf? Toby, maybe? Or Sydney? Maybe Bethany/Courtney's murder was planned all along by Alison herself, who was trying to protect herself by all means, even by sacrificing her own twin sister? But then, who REALLY threatened her the summer she "died"? Aria? Mona? Meredith? Jenna? Melissa? CeCe?

 Or maybe there is another "Alison"?.... i.e. Vivian?