Talk:Season 5/@comment-86.180.111.140-20140417110635/@comment-93.221.81.114-20140426125517

Actually I don't. For me Toby's mother more has something to do with the history of Radley. We got to know that she was killed, that Wilden covered it and that Peter Hastings and Jessica DiLaurenits (especially her) wanted to close it and stop any investigation. I still firmly believe in the Ali has the twin, because it would make sense. Jessica doesn't want people to investigate in Radley because (if we go follow the books) Alison in Radley killed Toby's mum because she found things out she shouldn't (maybe even excatly that, that there were two Alison's and one was crazy) and Jessica wanted to cover it so no one would find out she has a crazy daughter.

That's why I think it's possible for her twin to try kill "Alison", because besides Jason there is no one she would protect and her mother didn't want her to go out that night. I don't think Jason and Alison could have any history as for Jason's twin to try kill her. Especially since CeCe wore the same clothes as Ali it seems like the focus lies more on Alison than Jason. A theory is that Alison got that yellow shirt from her mother (I think it's seen in the scene where she tries it on, there is a card from her mother saying it's her colour) and maybe Mrs. DiLaurentis got the same for CeCe as to lead Ali's attempted murder on a red herring. She wanted Alison to stay in so CeCe would be mistaken as her and killed instead of her own daughter.

Even though a lot think Alison doesn't have the twin because the producers confirmed it, I do, because the writers still follow the main important plots of the books, especially concerning the Night Alison died. And of course they wouldn't reveal such a plot hole but lie and distract people, obviously it works. I still believe in the Ali twin thing :)