Talk:Grave New World/@comment-5224716-20131011111823/@comment-93.221.99.227-20131011130642

Why shouldn't we? Why should Marlene make Mona lie about that and not about anything else? THERE IS NO POINT. Especially since nothing is build to expose Toby really as someone who has been on the Team for the beginning. Marlene didn't even hint something like that in the slightest, and she always give hints for everything, especially if it's A-Team member related. There is no reason for Mona to lie, she wasn't on the Team anymore and it's not like she likes Spencer and is all "Poor girl, better lie so she doesn't get the truth." That's not Mona's style. Marlene confirmed we would get honest answers. Starting with again a lie in between all the truths makes no sense, she said we would get the answer to the questions who queen of the hearts is, who killed ian (yet to come) and when toby joined. The following seasons are to reveal the mysterys from before, not creating hundred more. She would have hinted if what Mona said was a lie and she always says "We don't pull another Toby.". That means Toby did in fact join to protect the girls.

People who still don't want to believe that I'm really questioning. It may have been the plan to let him join from the beginning and they changed it when they saw how popular that theory of protecting the girls and spoby was and Marlene is a dear fan of them. But I think I read somewhere that it was always the plan to make him protect Spencer.

Really. There is nothing more. Stop to hang onto something like that when we are on totally new, more important mysterys. Toby's storyline is his mothers death who is probably more important than all think at the moment, and not if he was on the Team from beginning, because obviously nothing hints to that in Season 4a. And they are not suddenly introducing it in 4b when Keegan is not even really there and it focus lies on Ezra. He isn't even on the Team anymore.

Really. He joined in Season 3 when he got the jobs in bucks county. No matter how often someone called someone Pretty Eyes. I wouldn't even wonder if people think about that so often (since pretty eyes appeard in season 2) and Marlene just put it in season 2, to confuse people later on in order not to reveal Toby joined in S3.