Talk:Through a Glass, Darkly/@comment-25584522-20150104173052/@comment-25547603-20150104211317

^ I agree that he's been an asshole, really, but I don't think he's "A". It was his dumb and bad-written by Marlene way to protect her. I think he's good now and he wasn't lying when he seemed worried about Hanna, no one was watching him so why pretending that reaction?

Toby there with Hanna was just standing up for Jenna because she was in danger, if I remember correctly. Or maybe he had just broke up with Spencer, I'm not sure which episode is it. One of these two things anyway.

We don't know if it was "A" that attacked Hanna and then hid with the mask, or if there were two different people. Alison and CeCe were at the party and they met secretly, then they appeared in the ball room and the Liars followed them. But eventually they were actually Cindy and Mindy with masks and the same clothes as Ali and CeCe, so we don't know where did they go from that scene on. In the end we see Ali watching the Liars and their boyfriends having dinner