Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-5550712-20130127041011

Does anyone think maybe Toby could've been on "A" team since day one?

Exhibit A: When he and Spencer spent the night in that motel, everything was okay, sure, but then the next morning, he asked her if she had been up all night, and she said no; he could've just been asking her this to see if she had been awake when he snuck to Jenna's room and planted the "A" note. Then he tried to look innocent when he asked who "A" was.

Exhibit B: The person who knocked Ian off of one of the high levels in the church was definitely not a girl. You could tell by the body shape, so we know it's not Mona; however, it could've very well been Toby. He wouldn't have killed Spencer because he "loved" her, and he also needed her so he could continue tormenting the four liars with the "A" texts.

If you think about it, it sort of makes sense.

And I know this isn't exactly the right page for my theory, but:

A is Wren.

Either Ella or Melissa killed Ali; they both had a motive.

The person that will rise from the ashes will be Alison, duh. Sasha already announced that she will be in the final episode of season three.

And I think that the person who dies will probably be Toby, though I'm sad to say it because Toby is my all-time favorite character, but I do think he's been working with "A" team since day one.

If not Toby, then the person to die might be Jenna.

But we never know because the writers are always throwing us curve balls. When we think we know "A", we don't. We thought Mona was the big "A" at the end of season two--done. But she wasn't. We found that out in the pilot episode of season three. There's always something new to be confirmed and thought up. That's what I love about Pretty Little Liars.