Talk:Now You See Me, Now You Don't/@comment-14539762-20130828025447

Guys, I have a theory why A is torturing the girls.

Maybe A doesn't really hate the girls. He/she/it/they assume that Ali is alive and want to find her. And we know that everytime something bad happens to the girls (Hanna getting hit by a car, Aria getting drugged by Meredith, Emily almost dying in the barn, the girls almost dying in the fire, Emily almost dying in this episode, Emily actually almost dying every time), Ali showes up. So maybe A is torturing the girls to lure Ali.

What do you think?