Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-25547603-20141107020214

I was thinking about this... (yeah I bet the one who know me are saying - Oh no f*ck is saying one of his many theories lol)

We know that Shana was reading "The Scarlat Letter", in which a woman - who betrayed her man- had to wear a big A on her chest as a sign of guilty and betrayal... was she trying to find clues about A for Alison? I PLL books, Aria wakes up and prints an A on Meredith's chest, she's the one Byron betrays Ella with...

Now, who has been victim of adultery and is someone who would read a lot of books, including The Scarlat Letter? A teacher maybe? I know it's crazy but I would say... ellA.

Aria never got hurt by A.

Ella is an old-fashioned word that means "she/her" in my language, italian, did you know? (Now we use "lei") Anyway when they talk about A, it's always a SHE. "She's everywhere" "She is capable of things you have no idea"

SHE SHE SHE. Hints to ellA?

They already did this trick with Dr. Palmer "Air got too heavy for her [Marion Cavanaugh]" Air = Aria in italian. Aria is unknowingly related to something else that her mother knows?

We know A caused Byron and Ella separation in Season 1 and Zack and Ella separation in Season 4... Why A is so interested in her love life but not in Ashley's, for example? In 1x01 Ella said she was worried about Byron after Alison's disappearance...Why not worried for her children but for Byron? Did she know Alison blackmailed him?

Did she put Zack to the test by putting Hanna's number in his pocket? Maybe she wanted to see if he was loyal, and she already knew about the "betrayal" when Aria told her...

EllA has motive to hate Alison. Especially if it turns out Alison wasn't blackmailing Byron about Meredith but about herself.

Yeah. She had a pregnance scare. Didn't Alison look too much involved when trashed Byron's office? She wanted Aria to tell her mom in the same way she wanted Spencer to tell Melissa about the kiss with Ian.

Both times she said "Because it's the right thing to do". Well, we know she did that because she wanted Ian... What if she wanted Byron too? Her obsession with the book Lolita ( a 15 girl in love with a 50 college teacher) is curious...

EllA wants revenge?

(I still don't know why she would attack the other girls. Maybe is she related to Jenna somehow and wants to punish them for blinding her?)

This sounds crazy, I know, and there are certain things that I can't explain to myself yet... But it could make sense