Talk:The Bin of Sin/@comment-25584522-20150126182312

Okay, so I have a question about the photo that was uploaded here yesterday. Apparently there was this brunette girl standing in front of Red Coat. When Hanna was looking behind to see Red Coat, both of them (the brunette and RC) disappeared.

Now, it was suggested that it was Aria. As much as I would love that to happen, I can't really say it was her, though the brunette shared some similarities with Aria.

But let's assume for a second that it was Aria. Why would she be talking to Red Coat?

Another thing that struck me as odd, is the fact that during season 3B Red Coat focused more on Hanna and less about the rest of the Liars. The first clue is in episode 3X16 (the photo ^). The second one is in episode 3X17, during the infamous ending in which Red Coat was seen burning a Hanna's Bobblehead. The third one (and most important clue), is in episode 3X24 - when Hanna was left behind in the fire. It was confirmed by Alison that the others (and Mona?) were pulled out by someone else who "forgot" Hanna behind.

Those clues indicate that Red Coat holds a grudge against Hanna. But here is the interesting thing: Correct me if I'm wrong, but in season 3A Red Coat didn't show any particular interest in Hanna. Why? Because the Red Coat in season 3A was not the same one in 3B. But why there were two Red Coats in the first place? Because of The Halloween Train.

The Phantom who danced with Hanna was not Mona, it was the Red Coat who stalked Hanna during season 3B. And who is that Red Coat? Kate Randall, Hanna's step-sister, OR Hanna's twin. If we go on the realistic route, I'd say it was Kate.

So where who was the original Red Coat in Season 3A? Meredith, who surprisingly appeared in episode 3X02, applying for a teaching position, and disappeared in episode 3X16, the one when she drugged Aria and assulted Hanna and Emily, and the first episode to show that Red Coat in after Hanna.

Meredith was the one who commanded Wilden on the Halloween train, not Melissa. It couldn't be Melissa since she was afraid of him, hence why there were three Queens of Hearts on the train: Melissa, Wilden, and Meredith.

<3 ^_^