Talk:Through a Glass, Darkly/@comment-25584522-20141230094251

I just thought about something:

- Season 3 opened with Alison's corpse being stolen from her grave. The Halloween episode saw her body retrieved.

- That body was revealed to be Bethany's corpse, and not Alison's, since we know she's alive.

But what if the body that was stolen from Alison's grave was her actual twin (I know Marlene said there won't be an Alison's twin), and the body the A-Team gave back was a different one - Bethany's?

Which means that Bethany might have been somewhere else that night, or she was kidnapped and murdered later, around season 3.

'That also explains why there were 2 gifts in the piano and why Jessica made Ali lie: Alison's gift was under the Christmas Tree, while the other two were for the speculative twin, and the other one for Bethany. Alison was forced to lie about the two gifts and say there were only one, for her twin.'