Talk:Toby Cavanaugh/@comment-84.42.234.111-20130125220908/@comment-108.181.251.179-20130203052541

Toby is definently A, and an evil one as well. And that scaffolding incident, it very well coud have been a set up. A also forced Mona to do community service and risk going to jail. But we've seen how that turned out. The only possible way is that Mona and Toby regretted their actions a few times, and these messages were sent from the Main A to put them back into place.

But even if that happened, he is evil. When Spencer found out, and slapped Toby for it, you could see his face once he is slapped. You could see that evil, devient look on his face. When he asks Spencer how long she had known, he doesn't even show any kind of emotion. Toby hadn't done anything good for the liars in anyway. His reign as the second A was even more malicious then Mona's. All Mona did was send teasing texts, and blackmail the liars every now and then. And the blackmail wasn't even really that bad. Forcing Hanna to eat cupcakes for free, and geting lots of money for it? That's not even blackmail. I would accept free cupcakes anyday.

Toby on the other hand has been nothing but dangerous as A. Almost every messed up plot that A did was all done by Toby, probably. Killing Ian, Killing Garrett, trying to kill Aria, trying to kill Caleb's mom to scare Hanna, stealing Alison's dead body and sending parts to the liars, trying to run over Lucas with his car, and orchestrated trapping Spencer in that round thing. Everything that I have mentioned above (except the last) has all been associated with murder.