Talk:Season 3/@comment-66.233.62.156-20120831154120/@comment-74.136.162.185-20120902172620

They didn't do that, Alison did, and everyone knows that they were manipulated by Alison. If Toby hadn't taken the fall Alison would have told everyone about his relationship with Jenna.

And when he got back he started protecting the girls. Remember how he saved Emily?

I really can see him going either way, but I do believe there are reasons for him to not blame them.