Talk:A is for Answers/@comment-70.189.122.21-20140223202723

This is  theory. Melissa knew that Alison was dating Ian and using Spencer for popularity, so she killed Ali. Ian saw her kill Ali, so Ian needed someone to frame for the murder. When Melissa and Ian got back together, Ian decided he was going to frame Spencer. Melissa found out, so she made a deal with A (Andrew) that he would protect Spencer from Ian and Melissa would work for him. So at the bell tower, it was A (Andrew) who killed Ian because Melissa wanted to protect Spencer. It would also explain why Melissa said I've been protecting you.