Talk:Red Coat/@comment-108.181.251.179-20130204020440

I have multiple heories on the Big A:

Either both twins are alive, Alison is good and trying to help the liars via hallucinations while Courtney is the Big A. Ali could have faked her own death. She could have payed off the coroner not to reveal who the body really belongs to. This expalins why she was blackmailing people for money at the time of her death.

Or, Courtney was the original Big A, and on the night of the dissapearence, the liars tried to kill Alison and burried her alive, but failed. I think Ali then esacped (hence the scene of Ali's hand coming out of the gazebo). The liars don't remember because they were drunk, or maybe even drugged? I think Ali, who knew they had the intentions of killing her, wanted revenge on her friends. She killed Courtney, and without the A-Team members knowing, she switched places with Courtney and became the new Head A to get revenge on her friends.

Or, Courtney was the original Big A, and she tried to kill Alison for it. However, Alison killed Courtney in self defense. She was sent to Radely, being mistaken for Courtney. The truama that Alison recieved from A caused her to form a split personality: an evil version of Alison. So whenver this personality takes control of the body, Alison is evil and the Head A, but the A-Team members don't knwo that Courtney is really Ali. When the good Ali takes control of the body, she is helping the liars via hallucinations.

Courtney was the original Big A. In Radely, Courtney befriended Cece, who was also in Radely. When Ali found out that Courtney is A, Courtney tried to kill her for it, but Alison killed her in self defense. Alison escaped and is now in hiding. Furious, Cece took Courtney's place as the Big A and is avenging the death of her best friend.

Aria is A. I'm sorry but there are LOTS of clues.