Talk:Through a Glass, Darkly/@comment-85.180.119.187-20141211152652

New theory about Bethany being A(?):

As far as we know Alison wrote letters to Bethany and (maybe) visited her. Jessica did Bethany a lot of extra favors(Pony etc). Whatever happened, Ali ended up getting involved with Bethany, whom she told everything about the liars secrets etc. And eventually "poor" mentally ill (lovechild?) Bethany got killed.(by A, Alison, Cece, Noel...?)

But guys, Bethany mustn't be the innocent victim we all believe her to be. She could be a manipulative murderous bitch, too. She must have gotten in Radley for a good reason!!!

Bethany could be like A Hannibal Lector, although locked away, still being a puppet master. Maybe Bethany framed Jessica for Mrs Cavanaughs murder (which Bethany arranged somehow), getting her a pony and what not. (And Bethany could really be another half sister of Ali.)

Bethany could play manipulative games with Ali then, too. Making Ali believe they are sisters and Ali told her everything about the liars and etc. which lead to Bethany blackmailing Ali under the disguise of A. (Maybe she ordered her to bomb Jenna's garage?). They must have feared and hated each other.

On Labour day Weekend those A games should come to an end, Bethany's plan was to kill Alison (and take over her life?) but eventually being herself murderd by Cece, who she mistook for Ali?( Maybe Cece ploted out that plan to save Ali?)

Bethany may have died the night of Labour Day Weekend, but her A minions could carry on her plans and carry on her will from the grave. (Like Mona, who send the liars plans of Ali's house.) That's why Ali cannot figure out who A is, cause her main suspect Bethany is dead.

Bethany could also have had a crazy lover (Beach hottie or Black Widow, ...) who is out on revenge for her death and doing all the A games she told them to do.