Talk:I'm a Good Girl, I Am/@comment-26211734-20150311234803/@comment-16754824-20150312012318

That's sort of a stretch imo. The only thing that sort of sets your theory about Toby being the BH is that I think Alison would have warned Spencer about him. In 4x24, do you recall when Alison said "Toby's a really good guy. I can see why you fell for him" or something similar to that (lol idk for sure, but it was something about how he's good, and she's not surprised about her liking him). I think alison would have warned Spencer and stopped her from dating Toby, unless she was so drunk that night that she forgot who she slept with.