Talk:Fresh Meat/@comment-25584522-20150110182743

Can someone clarify something to me?

It is widely accepted by the fans that Uber-A, Black Widow, and the evil Red Coat are all the same person. My question is, is there any actual proof of that?

- Red Coat herself never sent texts or spoke to one of the Liars, and she was claimed by Mona to be in charge and capable of doing things way worse than what she did. But that was MonA, who's been known as a great liar.

- Red Coat re-appeared after her red coat was destroyed in the lodge fire with the Emily mask. Alison or CeCe seems unlikely to do that. We know Alison didn't do it, and CeCe was confirmed to be RC only on 4X12, when she confused A...I'm sorry, Aria.

- Red Coat did everything she could to keep herself in the dark, yet she comes on a daylight to Wilden's funeral and draws attention to herself. Why would she do that?

- MK said that BW is involved with the "Endgame", whatever that means. She never said BW is Uber-A.

I think it is more than plausible that they are all three different people.

Here is my theory: There were four Red Coats: Alison (good), CeCe (fake), and other two are the "evil" one and the "crazy" one (sorry, that's best name I can think of...XD). The "evil" one was the one to hold the Emily mask. The "crazy" one was the one whose red coat was destroyed at the lodge fire, thus reincarnating herself as the Black Widow. I think the purpose of two evil RC is like Alison and CeCe, but in a reversed way - to confuse the liars and preventing them from discovering who they are.

Either of them could be Uber-A, though I wouldn't be surprised if none of them are. Again, that theory is mere speculations... What do you think?