Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-95.86.70.230-20140920191608

I think the person who hit Alison with the rock is Bethany. We Know Melissa buried Bethany, thus killing her.

But the real question is, who hit Bethany with the shove l?

Was it one of the girls? Was it Ian? Garrett? CeCe AND Alison? Maybe it was Byron, who mistaken Bethany for Alison? What about Meredith, who claimed she was trying to prevent Byron from meeting up with Alison? Could she be there that night as well? Jenna? Toby? And what about Mona? Or Ezra?

Here is another theory:

The person who hit Bethany is Uber A, while thinking she was Alison. But why? What was the motive to kill Alison? Revenge? Keeping her quiet about the videos? Unrequited love? What if Emily's flashback at Dr. Sulivan's treatment (When she was hypnotized) was true? Could it be, that Emily thought Bethany was Alison, and hit her with the shovel, being fed up with Alison torments about  her sexual orientation? Is it possible that Emily is Uber A, and the Black widow is her minion? Is it possible that Emily dug up Alison/Bethany's corpes because some repressed memories surfaced up, and she wanted to know if she killed Alison? It also possible that Alison knows that, and that's why she kept Emily so close to her -  Remember "Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer"??