Talk:Game On Charles/@comment-25942694-20150503104217/@comment-5660329-20150503125808

Nico: you want me to tell you what happened? And just so you know, it may sound like I'm kidding with how bad it is, but I'm 100% serious. You can google it.

In the TAAHM finale, it was revealed that Charlie never died from being hit with a train. The thing that rose pushed in front of the train was a goat and that was what exploded into pieces from the impact. That was what rose had in the coffin, hence why in the season 9 (I believe) funeral held for Charlie, there was a closed coffin. Rose had kidnapped him and put him in a well, giving him his food by bucket (you know what I'm talking about? It's the rope and pulley system with the bucket).. He somehow managed to escape while rose was out and found his way back home. Keep in mind we never actually SEE Charlie's face: in the last couple minutes, we "see" a person wearing Charlie's clothes walk up the beach house and lift his hand to knock on the door.. A helicopter flying overhead is delivering a piano and drops it on Charlie killing him, causing him to turn to dust. It's silent for a minute but then the camera pans out and we see Chuck Lorre sitting in the director's chair saying "winning" and then he too "turns to dust"..
 * SPOILER*