Talk:Sequence of Events - Alison's Disappearance/@comment-86.0.213.59-20130323152555/@comment-93.221.84.32-20130403204902

That's excatly what I thought when I saw this scene. I'm pretty sure it was Spencer, since they live next door and I doubt that Spencer would just walk away when she heard something. And after hearing Ali say that with "knowing more about the night than they remember" I mmediatly thought about the books and that she probably did pull on her hand but forgot it.

Nonetheless, Ali's body STILL was buried alive, so she either let go of the hand and Ali (Or Courtney died) or she pulled her out and Ali buried Courtney alive after that (but that's not possible since Ali had to fake all the injuries she had and it would be just to comlicated)

I always thought about Spencer (and Aria!) as being the most suspicious ones out of the group.