Talk:Through a Glass, Darkly/@comment-174.237.4.255-20141211002950/@comment-85.180.119.187-20141211143558

"Cause Ali being A is the most obvious, unshocking, no brainier on the whole show. "A" needs to be someone who we wouldn't expect."

But how could you explain that "A" has so many insight into all the liars lives and lies and etc such knowledge about intimate things only Alison could have gathered because of her steady contact with them. Idk but that makes sense to me. Who else knew that much about nearly everything. (except Mona ;-))

My theory is, that A could either be Ali herself, or via A split persona like Dr Jekyll.

O.K. I hear those screams of the wiki...

Alison may or may not be A, but sure as hell, has created that A herself, that is after everybody now based on her knowledge. (Mona was just the first A, whose game got stolen by our A.)

As far as "A is someone who we wouldn't expect", my bet is, that the circle of suspects is "smaller" than we think it is. It will be someone who is somehow involved with Ali and who she trusts the most.

So A is one of Alison's bed buddies ("Beach Hottie") or trustees (Cece, Noel...) whom she told everything about the girls from her own perspective, creating A monster, which is blind of love for her, got fooled by her or misinterpreted sth or she broke up with them, and is out on revenge. Unleashing it on everybody in their way.