Talk:The Black Swan/@comment-86.144.254.30-20120505091317

im just gonna throw this out there, but Mellissa hasnt got the same mouth as the black swan. If you look at her mouth, its really pouty with tiny lips. Mellissas lips are bigger and fuller. Persides, if Mellissa's baby was fake, dont you think she'd have ditched it by now, and clearly we can see mellissa isnt a size 2.... lets be honest, shes like a size 8 or at least a 6 (size 4 to you) (im from england so size 8 to you thats like a size 6? A size 2 to me is a size 4...) It could be Jenna, she isnt listed, but she fits the qualities of the swan... afterall we know she can see!!! I dont think Ashley is the black swan, even though her mouth looks the same from the picture, with her really annoying pout. She doesnt have black hair, and I see no real reason why she'd be part of the A team. Its not the same as the book, claim the writers, therefore it wont be courtney/alison, even though they stuck with the mona idea.

If the black swan is the girl in picture 3, it cant be ashley, too young, or alison/courtney as her face is thinner, and do we really think that she's mellissa? seriously?

The idea about Aria makes logical sense, and A was confirmed not to be any of the girls. Therefore now A is Mona, it could be Aria. However, how would Aria become friends with Mona. When Mona became friends with Hanna, Aria was out of the country!! Persides, Mona is never really that kind to Aria, 'are you always that short'. Bare in mind that they had to work together, how would you work with someone who you didnt really know. I cant imagine Aria being all like 'hey i just met you, and this is crazy, but im on the A team, so join me maybe'... persides, getting her boyfriend fired and stuff is a bit sick...

Anyway comment your opinion!!!