Talk:Courtney DiLaurentis (Book Character)/@comment-174.252.225.75-20121225233511/@comment-83.8.139.225-20121226113328

I agree with you! To me it seems like Courtney was just a popular mean girl, living her normal life, she wasn't crazy enough like Alison. And she wasn't that bad if she was sympathetic towards Jenna (while Alison killed Jenna with cold blood). I wouldn't be surprised if the "real" Alison (the murderer) made up that story about her drowning by Courtney or/and even is the real insane twin who framed Courtney and made her being sent to a mental institute (we even don't know if the real switch between twins didn't actually happen already in Connecticut). Courtney (who really was Ali) wanted to regain her identity and made the next switch in Rosewood, while Ali (in reality insane Courtney) decided to get bloody revenge, still thinking she was the real Alison. Plus I don't believe that the luxurious spa-like Preserve would make Alison really so psychopatic. No, that madness was in her from the beginning.

Just a (crazy) theory..