Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-25755332-20141202013747/@comment-25755332-20141202033953

^^A is the good guy and using everyone just to figure out who Black Widow. A knows that Black Widow has to do with something bad that happened in Radley, perhaps it was A's relative. A is not targeting everyone with "evil" intentions. A is only using it to expose secrets that could lead to A discovering the identity of Black Widow. The Black Widow is inactive in Rosewood, she/he only appears to silence people who knows too much, Mona could be one of her victims. Everything else that happens is a side effect of A's exposed secrets. People turn against each other and kill to protect themselves, that has nothing to do with Black Widow and only indirectly with A.

We think that A is the bad guy. In this theory the actual bad guy is Black Widow. Black Widow did something in Radley, perhaps something to do with Marion, Jessica or Bethany, I don't know. A does know what happened, but doesn't know who did it. A is only responsible for turning Rosewood against each other, including indirectly responsible to some murders, because some secrets were exposed by A. But the actual killing part is none of A's business. A's only motive is exposing all the secrets so that he/she can find out who Black Widow is. In this theory we could actually feel sympathy for A. The only thing A has done is to be honest and people in the town are the ones covering up every mistake that has ever been made in the town, by murders and more lies.

In this theory there is no evil serial killer running around in Rosewood killing people, it's actually the people in the town that turned against each other to protect themselves, before their own lies would be discovered. Black Widow is only the bad guy in the Radley case and perhaps some of the victims in the town, all the other times it's the people from the town. A is only responsible for telling the truth and the truth hurts so much in some cases that people are willing to kill for them not to be exposed.