Talk:The Lady Killer/@comment-208.54.4.251-20120829160448/@comment-5271456-20120829180108

You couldn't be so wrong. Lol. You're right -A did in fact hurt Toby, but don't you see how that makes it perfect for everybody to not see Toby as a suspect?? Just because he got hurt. If you recall season 2 Mona started getting texts from A threatening her about the shoplifting. Once a character starts receiving texts from A the audience "A Suspect" lists shifts because you wouldn't think that they're A if they're being somehow threatened by A. Toby could've easily been A from season 1 but because he was labeled as a FREAK by Alison, producers probably thought that everyone was suspecting him just for being a weirdo. & that's true. when I first started watching this show I automatically thought "Mona is A.. Toby is A... Lucas is A.. Melissa is A..." and so on. Because they ALL HAVE MOTIVE. But they twisted it up and made him break his leg so people will stop thinking he's A. Then episodes later BAM! we find out he's a betrayer. They called it a BETRAYER not a friend helping friends by doing something fucked up. Lol.