Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-6957723-20140102180230/@comment-12829219-20140102220953

Thats pretty impossible becuase then technically they would all hate each other too after what each has been through.

Also Ali would know atleast 1 of them was 'A' after watching everything therefore she would not try to contact the girls, but she already has so it cant be them.

Additionally that means that all the main characters are sorta crazy and hateful which is not at all believable.

Furthemore Emily would never do that, i like her but she is too weak mentally  to go through something like that. Granted Paige was a little creepy but Emily still holds a flame for Ali, she would never do that.

Also imo its a pretty sh*t storyline. So we wait to find out who Uber 'A' is then we realise its pretty much everyone.

Also when it was revealed Toby was 'A', if he and Spencer are both 'A' then he would not have needed to hide it from Spencer. After all she definitively found out he was 'A' by herself (that kitchen scene when he was in the hoodie and she said looking for this?) therefore it would not have been a surprise to her. And you cant say she faked it because no-one else was there.