Talk:Welcome to the Dollhouse/@comment-26246094-20150419090627

The only reason we think it's Charles Dilaurentis is because of Mona's clues. What if the clues was Charles Dilaurentis, in the sense that Charles is linked with the Dilaurentis and not actually Charles Dilaurentis.

Maybe the Dilaurentis and the Youngs are actually related. Why would Jessica Dilaurentis insist on Bethany Young calling her Aunt Jessie? Nobody who's sane would keep insisting on such a thing, unless they were actually related.

Let's revisit the video we saw and piece it together:

- Charles is not Jason's twin or brother. Jessica says come kiss your baby sister and only one boy actually kissed her. There a chance, the baby is Charles sister and not Jason's. Also, this would mean Mrs. D is not Charles mother.

- The boys look like 4-5 years old in the video. Alison is 18 while Jason is 24 (8 years difference). They really don't look like they are 8 years old in the video. So the baby is definitively not Alison. Bethany is 2 years older than Alison, perfect age for the baby in the video.

This brings me back to Aunt Jessie. If Bethany is the baby in the video and Charles kissed her, then this means Bethany and Charles are sibblings. If Jessica is actually their aunt, then she might want to protect Charles for this very reason (same reason why Jessica would be on the board of Trustee at Radley, she was watching over them). This is why I think Charles might actually be Charles Young and not Charles Dilaurentis.