Talk:Now You See Me, Now You Don't/@comment-5224716-20130822145007/@comment-67.180.234.251-20130822175120

No it wasn't Toby, trust me. Alison said "you don't know him". Emily knew Toby. She wasn't exactly friends with him then, but she knew who he was for sure. It was probably someone they didn't know, such as Wilden or Garrett