Talk:Oh, What Hard Luck Stories They All Hand Me/@comment-25312059-20150201135620

There's part of me that thinks Bethany could possibly be 'A' but we didn't find even hear about her until 5x05, and in the Reddit AMA before season 5 began Marlene said that we had seen A before "in theory and in reality", so that makes me suspicious of whether they'd make a character they only introduced in season 5 'A', unless she is Alison's twin somehow. And I'd be pretty pissed off if Bethany was alive because the whole "who's in the box?" mystery would start again, and don't even begin to tell me that a third girl got buried that night because christ.