Talk:Taking This One to the Grave/@comment-109.30.236.85-20140828192937

Logic problems in episode 5x12 :

- They made it clear that Mona fought for her life until the end, and Holbrook stated that there was so much blood in the house that the victim was certainly dead. This means that the killer chased Mona all around the house and, given all the broken and thrashed furniture, it was very, very violent. Questions : Nobody heard anything in the neighborhood ? I've never murdered anyone (so far ;-), but how do you get a body, probably covered in blood, out of a house, in broad daylight, without anyone noticing ? And the killer did all this between Mona's phone call to Aria and the girls' arrival to Mona's house ? Really ?!

- So now, cops are allowed to declare someone's been murdered, on TV, before talking with the supposed victim's relatives, without a body, and mere hours after arriving on a crime scene ?! I hated Holbrook in this episode. Tanner, please come back !

- Spencer and Mona, former patients at Radley, a mental institution, walk in and walk out of the building at will, one of them displaying a very noticeable headset, without anyone noticing ?!

- Ah, The Montgomerys ! Weeks ago (season 3, yeah... I know) there was no way their daughter was dating one of her teachers, and now they invite him, in their house, to celebrate Thanksgiving ?!

- As far as I know, a person of interest is not a suspect. It's a person involved in a crime one way or another, but not necessarily guilty. They found Bethany Young buried behind Alison's house, the night Alison disappeared, they were wearing the same clothes, they thought Bethany's body was Alison's body for a long time, and suddenly Alison, whose very recent reappearance in Rosewood remains mysterious, to say the least, is not a person of interest any more ?! I really hated Holbrook in this episode.

Sorry if these points have already been discussed, but I really needed to write them down. I know watching this show requires quite a suspension of disbelief, but it really was hard to swallow with this finale !