Talk:The Lady Killer/@comment-66.233.62.156-20120829123149

It actually makes complete sense. I think Toby being on the A Team makes the most sense then any other crazy shit on this show. Think about it...

Ali made his life a living hell. He was blamed for Jenna and sent away, making him an outcast in the town and even his parents hated him. The girls thought JENNA hated them for that, they didn't think maybe Toby was the one who really did.

He was Spencer's original suspect then he mysteriously befriends Emily? He gains her trust and in turn, gains all the other girls trust.

Wasn't he the person Spencer ran into first when she came out of that fun house (I may be remembering his one wrong).

He fits the description of the person in the tower when Ian died. He could have easily lifted his body and got rid of it as well as pushed him over the edge.