Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-25420503-20140105233340/@comment-24004040-20140106130758

They didn't say Mona is not -A. Marlene only said it would end differently than in the books and it did, because Mona didn't die.

They did however lie about Toby's intentions.

And even though I love the CeCe has the twin theory it would not bring any further plot. The twin thing is the most important plot in the books and CeCe having it may explain the body in Ali's coffin, but nothing more. Because we already saw CeCe (or even her twin) being Red Coat, so she definitely isn't Uber A. If someone has the twin (for me only that is) that twin has to be Uber A. Otherwise the twin thing kinda would be pointless and not necessary.

I still believe it's Alison. I know the producers and Sasha denied it, but excalty that could be done as to not lead to Alison. Sasha could say "maybe someone else" as to let the people think of theories and don't even think that it's really going to happen with Ali, which obviously works because most people think other actors are getting the twin.

If another liar has a twin I would really question it. Alison is understandable. Her whole life was a mystery, she always wanted to hear the secrets from the liars, but never gave her own away. They practically knew nothing about her.

But we as viewers especially see the Liars and know how they live, know their secrets and if one had a twin I'm sure we would have already saw a hint or something along the lines.

But we as viewers know practically nothing about Alison. We know everything the Liars do. Nothing more, nothing less. Therefore the twin still would fit. If it was another liar I would really question how they hid that. Especially, if one Liar had a twin (they obviously had to know about that) I'm pretty sure they would have told when everything with -A started because If I had a twin that would be so ill-minded I would conclude on my own that it could be my twin that was harrassing me and my friends.

But it still could be anybody else. Still I hope it's Alison, I don't want that storyline to change, because it's the main point of the PLL books and the show still is based on it. I don't want it to end up like TVD where I question why it's even named TVD when it has absolutely NOTHING to do with the books. ;)