Talk:'A' is for A-l-i-v-e/@comment-9605291-20130602204610

My friend has this theory that Hanna is not Ashley Marin's real daughter, and this she is in fact Jessica DiLaurenti's daughter, and Alison's twin sister. At first I laughed at her and thought this theory was absurd, but now that I think about it, it actually kinda makes sense (KINDA, lol). Some clues:

1. The most obvious one: you can't deny that Hanna and Alison have their similarities when it comes into their appearance.

2. I read somewhere that Jessica has a soft spot for Hanna this season, and that that is why she gives Hanna the family bird. Maybe she feels bad for abandoning Hanna when she was born?

3. We all know Ashley Marin has a lot of secrets: this could be one of her many secrets.

-She was also very nervous with the whole blood test thing in episode 3x11. She obviously wanted to protect Hanna, but she could have also been worried that this blood test would prove Hanna is not biologically related to her.

4. Why did Ashley had that "ghost vision" the Halloween 3x13? She was haunted by Alison's twin. Maybe this "twin" is Hanna when she was little, and she has been for years haunted by the though of whether if she should tell or not Hanna about her real family, and her connection to Alison.

5. Episode 2x13: When Alison was telling that little boy at Hanna's house the twin story, it so happened Hanna was there. Coincidence? I think not. We all know in PLL there's no such thing as coincidence.

6. This could be the writer's version of going with the twin storyline.

7. Hanna is A's main target this season.

8. In episode 4x02 I read that Hanna will make an alarming discovery about her mom, and that this discovery will make us hate Ashley. She could find  out Ashley is not her real mom.

9. Ashley is the parent that has been targeted the most this whole series. Why would A wanna hurt her? If A is indeed Alison, she could be mad at her for taking away from her her twin sister.

10. Ashley could even be on the A team: It is possible that Alison discovered Ashley's secrets, and that Ali blackmailed her into doing whatever she asked her to do, or she would expose Ashley.

I repeat, I do not COMPLETELY agree with this theory, but I don't think It's as absurd as I used to think it was....