Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-9570279-20131110053134/@comment-68.174.245.138-20131110092933

I have been trying to do the math in my head and I would think, from what I took into account, it should be at least the ending of December 2011 or the beginning of January 2012. In 3x16 Misery Loves Company, it is Spencer and Toby's anniversary, which is November 5, which is believable since three episodes before, 3x13, it was Halloween (October 31). Then when Spencer found out that Toby was A (still November 5), it took her at least two weeks to tell the girls because when she finally tells Emily and Aria about Toby she says she's known "for a few weeks now". Let's say two weeks passed. It should now be mid-to-end of November, like the 19th, and I figure that Spencer was in Radley for at least a week, which would make it at least November 26. That same day or the day after was when Spencer was released from Radley and they went to the lodge which was in ep 3x24. Then in 4x01 it is the same night as the fire at the lodge in 3x24. So from the course of 4x01 to 4x13 I would say at least three weeks to a month has passed, which would make it the ending of December 2011 or beginning of January 2012.

The only thing that doesn't make sense is that in 3x14 when Hanna is trying to find who Aria might've stabbed on the Halloween train at school and notices Lucas limping, and she thinks it might be him who Aria stabbed, and Caleb replies to Hanna and says, "Hanna that was weeks ago", meaning that it was weeks after Halloween and that can't be since in 3x16, two episodes later, it is supposed to be November 5 for Spencer and Toby's anniversary. I hope this wasn't too long or too confusing to read. 😊