Talk:A's Messages/@comment-107.5.255.167-20120325201037/@comment-95.149.221.149-20120412203200

the person in the red coat wasn't A, A(mona) was just working for him/her. And the red coat Aria has isnt even Aria's, it was vivien's cause spencer just had it in the back of her car + aria wore it because she was cold. Anyway, i think that Ali is still alive. I think when A started texting her she found her look-a-like (like the twin in the books) and killed her, so it looked like ali was dead and A would stop tormenting her. Then Ali took vivien's place in life to aviod A.

either that or the person in the red coat is actually vivien and she's just getting the girls back for ali stealing her life. Basically Vivien plays the part of the twin in the books, but they changed it a bit so it wouldn't be exactly the same.