Talk:Now You See Me, Now You Don't/@comment-98.219.78.33-20130814224011/@comment-14539762-20130815114814

@BiohazardQ8: Hanna was on heavy medication. Maybe she saw in the drugged condition someone (Mona, her mom...) drink from the cup and her subconscious included this in her hallucination/dream (just that she saw Alision instead of Mona/her mom...). Emily was poisoned. So she might have dreamed this conversation. We don't know for sure if it was Ali saying "Two can only keep a secret if one of them is dead". This could be Emilys wishful thinking. Spencer was also on heavy medication. She could have hallucinated that she was talking to Ali and when she heared someone coming she put the bag under the couch. Same with Aria. Meredith was looking for the pages. Maybe she found the doll and put it on the table. Aria saw that in a drugged condition and included this scene into her hallucination... and just mistaked Meredith with Ali. Isn't it strange that Ali came for the pages and took it with her, but we later saw that Aria still has the pages and burns it?

It's a bit strange that 'Ali' disappears that fast, isn't it? After Ali left Arias room and closed the door, Aria immediately followed her. But Ali was gone... How can she disappear in less than 2 seconds? Same with Spencers 'visit' from Ali.

Alis first 'visit' was in season 1. The writers may have discussed back then if Ali should be revealed as alive or dead (in season 4), but they probably didn't make the decision. So they probably decided to let the liars see Alision only in a not sober condition. So they will still have both option: Ali is dead and the girls just hallucinated that they saw her or Ali is alive and those visits were real.