Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-25547603-20141120195335/@comment-25547603-20141120200602

^ I think something doesn't match about that night. If Mona was A back then and A was threatening her with messages like "Tonight's the night I kill you. -A", in 4x24 Alison would have just assumed that A = Mona, because Mona was revealed as the first A in 2x25 and Alison knows this. But Alison just said "I wanted to know who A - the person who told me that was gonna kill me - was but I couldn't find out".

I think Alison never got the texts about death that night. Yeah Mona "tortured" her, but not about killing her. Alison invented that. I think she drugged the girls because she had something to do that night maybe with CeCe and the thing they had to do was about Bethany. Someone attacked her that night and is A now. Alison doesn't know who that person is.