Talk:The Lady Killer/@comment-5263030-20120831170134

-I found a nice theory online!

Toby was approached to join the team last season, and he turned it down because he was in love with Spencer, and this resulted in the scaffolding incident (The Blond Leading The Blind). While he was in the hospital A made it a point to have Spencer break Toby's heart, which she did and it resulted to Toby into joining the team from hate and heartbreak (he really loves Spencer!) And Toby feels guilty in 3x12, even though he got back with Spencer in 2x25, which is when he found' Dr. Sullivan. Toby wants to get out, but the team would know that he would spill the secrets to the Liars'.
 * So here it is:

What do you think? Do you like this theory?