Talk:Taking This One to the Grave/@comment-5660329-20140811154301/@comment-25160183-20140812065452

The reason they say they wish they hadn't met Ali is because of A. If they hated Ali so much why did Spencer spend sleepless nights trying to find out about Board Shorts? Going to parties to find out about Ali, they could've Ravenswood. But they didn't. That just proves they care about Ali. Hanna says, "I have one friend who's missing, and other friends who are trying to find the first friend." FRIEND. Spencer also has pictures of her Ali in her room. They tried so hard bringing her home. They don't show hatred to her? They're PISSED at her. Spencer because she knows Ali is lying, and Hanna because of her own reasons. Hanna started getting pissed AFTER she dyed her hair. "Hanna, can you come with me for my physical?" "Yeah of course." Now she would've said hell no. When someone pointed out how much she looked like Ali she changed. She should be pissed at Mona not Ali. When they saw Ali for the first time they were SO happy. They don't hate Ali. They're upset with her. I get upset at my friends. That doesn't mean I don't hate them. My friend and I were in a huge fight for 2 months. We didn't hate each other. They need time. Sasha said in an interview they're happy, and pissed. I watched that interview. If Hanna really hated Ali she would've made sure she didn't stay with her. And they help Ali in 04x23. If my best friend and I were in a fight and she was kidnaped I would be bawling. And Hanna would've cut her off by now. Same with Spencer. They may do it, but they would've done it sooner. And they wouldn't help her come back, they wouldn't help her find out who A is, they would've let Shana blow off her face. They love Ali. They all do. They're pissed, yes. But they still care about her more than anything. And if anything happened to Ali, they'd be heartbroken. Just as heartbroken if it happened to another Liar. So stop saying they hate Alison. They're still her best friend.

And this is a very interesting theory that makes a lot of sense.