Talk:Welcome to the Dollhouse/@comment-4947372-20150324020458

I think the Liars are actually guilty for something on the night of Alison's disappearance. If you remember 3x01, Emily went missing and then the Liars called her and went looking for her. She was at "Alison's" grave.

What if the events of that night actually happened on the night of Ali's disappearance as well?

I think Emily's memory from 3x18 wasn't mixed up, it was just all true but in different aspects. She did attack someone that night and then ran back to the barn. Then Spencer comes by and that's when Melissa pops up and thinks that Spencer killed that girl. Melissa buried the girl and then left. After that, Emily wakes up Aria and Hanna and the two (like in 3x01) hide the evidence which is the shovel. Then the three Liars go back to the barn and end up falling back asleep due to the pills Ali gave them. By this time, Spencer comes back just when the other three wake up now forgetful of Emily attacking someone.