Talk:Garrett Reynolds/@comment-69.125.163.61-20120904011447

I know this is probably going to sound crazy, but what if the smile that garrett gave Emily was a genuine one (it just seemed creepy because he has been sort of suspicious)? I don't think he was the one that said "Emily I owe you one" because he was with mrs Hastings. what of he actually knows who killed Ali and took her body and he is only trying to help?