Talk:Caleb Rivers/@comment-72.27.133.121-20120829223558

I think Nate shot Caleb. Maybe he was not fully dead, saw the gun, aimed for Emily and shot Caleb unintentionally. I mean, the guy was dying, he wouldnt have perfect aim.

Why would Emily shoot Caleb? The guy came to save her life. Maybe the "guilty" look she was giving Hannah was for having little faith in the liars. Probably thinking this is all my fault. I think it was more of a sympathetic look because she knows how it fells to loose, or come close to loosing a lover. Plus, she just killed one guy. SURE WHY WONT SHE JUST SHOOT THE OTHER? I MEAN THE JUDGE WOULD JUST OVERLOOK THAT(sarcasm).

Why would Caleb shoot himself? I mean I get why you would be thinking that, (him telling Hannah I love you like that when he was drivig in the car) but it just dosent make sense. So there is a possibility but why?

Toby? I know you just found he was "A" and thats devastating, but come on, you cant pin everythin on "A".I mean who did everyone think killed Mya? Look how that turned out Scooby Doo. Beside, he and Mona were in a meeting about changing their plans and he had to drop her back at the mental hospital so he was busy. Toby is the good "A". He tried to save Emilys' life.

Paige(pigskin). Yeah I totally get that one I mean the girls a complete FREAK. I think she should be in the mental hospital instead of Mona. But it was not her because she was tied up. P.S. Emilys right the "A" team put the earing in her bag. They also put Myas' phone in her bag too.