Talk:Aria Montgomery/@comment-4646141-20120719111730/@comment-99.111.104.176-20120720095803

Im sure someone has already said this, but I think Aria is "A" because in the intro it says "two can keep a secret if one of them is dead." One of the "two" is Alison, who by all accounts everyone believes to be dead, and the other is Aria because she makes the Shhhhhh motion at the end of the intro; thus the secret is able to be kept because one of them (Alison) is "supposedly" dead. Also in the intro, look at the others girls body language towards Aria. They seem to not want to be around her, almost as if they know something just isn't right about her... Alison&Aria= --A & -A if you ask me.

P.S. When the girls go to the doll shop to try and locate the doll that Alison had, the kid there looks terrified when he looks out the window and sees Aria (Aria is also clearly shaken to see him as well). When he starts to describe the couple who came in, the old lady quickly quiets him up (why would she do this unless she knew "A" could hear what he was saying). From what we know, only the old lady, the kid, Hanna, Spencer, Emily, and Aria were there, so who out of the bunch is the most likely the be "A" ?(obviously Aria) Kids don't just make up stories for the fun of it and at that age, he has nothing to lie about. But notice, when the girls leave, only one of them quickly and harshly discredits his claim... Aria