Talk:Game On Charles/@comment-26244466-20150414034257/@comment-26131626-20150414110842

I don't think so. Charles is part of Ali's family, while Nick was her boyfriend. I still think the unseen Beach Hottie was the version if Nick. He is the only guy of Ali's past who the Liars never saw or talked too. In the books the Liars also didn't know Nicks real name or identity, until he was revealed as third A. They did know him in some way, but all under different fake names. In the books Courtney dated Nick secretly before her death, and in the show Ali dated beach hottie.