Talk:The Silence of E. Lamb/@comment-108.184.117.210-20140723221428

One thing I love about PLL is that there are basically no unnecessary characters in this show (well, maybe some of the parents). They all have a purpose. When Sydney first came into the picture, I thought she'd be an unnecessary character, but apparently she has a purpose & from what it looks like, it's going to be a big one. Like Shana, who ended up having a bigger purpose than we thought she would to the show.

Why is Spencer so against her dad wanting to sell the house? Yeah, she's right, it's their home, but it's not like they're going to be homeless. They can move & find a different home, one preferably outside of Rosewood. You would think any of the Liars would jump at the chance of leaving Rosewood. So I didn't understand Spencer's attachment to the house & not wanting it to be sold.

Melissa & Spencer's dad are keeping a secret. Melissa wants to tell, her dad does not. And it was a secret SHE reveal to her dad. Not something they were both in on from the beginning. Melissa had her chance to tell Spencer when they were alone, away from Peter who was no doubt going to try to keep Melissa quiet. I actually thought she was going to spill the beans. She didn't. Which leads me to believe that maybe her secret, although I'm not sure in what way, is discriminating to Peter.

Caleb... I'm not sure how I feel about Caleb anymore. He seems so sleazy now that I'm not sure if he could still be trusted or not. He changed a lot. He's acting like his old self from before he started dating Hanna when he was just spying on her for Mona. I'm not sure if this is a sign that he can no longer be trusted. With PLL, there is no such thing as being too paranoid or distrusting.

Also, the secrecy is starting to get really annoying. When Alison was at the doctor check-up with Hanna & they found that blade scar on her thigh, Hanna asked her who did it to her. Alison crypically says that once you know something, you can't unknow it & how she wishes she was blindfolded when that scar was made. Oh, c'mon! There is not a single person in that show who I would have been greatly shocked or surprised to find out they were the one who stabbed Alison. I wouldn't be surprised if it was one of the Liars. To me, that's just another unnecessary secret. Another question for the viewers that they really shouldn't need to have. Whoever did it, I'm positive it's not going to be that surprising. So what was the point of that?