Talk:Now You See Me, Now You Don't/@comment-109.154.239.191-20130821205356

Okay so here's my theory:

When Melissa said she had been protecting Spencer from the start, I think she meant from the night of Ali's murder. I think the night Ali was murdered, someone didn't just wanna kill her, they wanted to kill all the PLLs. So Melissa let Ali die because she hated her and made a deal with Ali's killer: I'll keep your secret if you don't kill my sister. But ever since they formed the A Team and tortured Spencer and her friends. So Melissa has been protecting the Liars from Ali's killer. However, I do not think Ali's killer is CeCe, I don't think she would be able to murder someone but I think she may have conspired with Ali's killer and helped form the A Team, which is why she was fighting with Melissa on that night and why she appears as Red Coat who also seems to be the leader of the A Team.