Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-24004040-20131130213844/@comment-14539762-20131130233348

^ Maybe she did suspect one of the liars at the beginning. I mean she disappeared and didn't try to get in touch with her friends for more than one year. Maybe she thought that one of them is her A, but then Hanna was attacked by A (the car accident) and she kinda dismissed the idea of one of the liars being A.

It's possible that Ali thought that idk Aria was her A (since her name starts with A), but then it was revealed that Mona was Ali's + the liar's first A. That's why she said "I thought I knew, but I was wrong". She thought it was Aria (or some other liar), but in fact it was Mona. And since Mona isn't A anymore (I guess), Alison doesn't know who is stalking her now.

Since Ali doesn't know who is stalking her, it's possible that it's one of the liars.

_____________________________________________________

I don't see why you think that the "Aria is A"-theory is stupid. Just watch some crime shows or read mystery books, mostly the comitter is someone that you never suspected and who is very close to the victim. And you end up thinking "OMG Why? She/He was your best friend/Sibling/whatever". Making the best friend the criminal is very shocking... and that's what authors and producers are going for.

And please don't mention "sense" and "PLL" in a sentence :D Mona and Hanna were best friends (better friends than Aria&Alison I guess), but still she was A. Plus Aria betrayed all of her boyfriends, so why is it so unbelievable that she would betray her friends as well?

A lot of people are convinced that Ezra is A. But this doesn't make sense either. Even if he was in a relationship with Ali, it doesn't explain why he want her dead and is ready to kill all of the liars in order to get her.

IMO the only reasonable motive for being A and doing all those things is revenge. And who has a reason to hate all the liars+Ali? Toby, Jenna, Mona, Lucas. No one else. Everyone else being A doesn't make sense.