Talk:Game Over, Charles/@comment-25984379-20150805214334/@comment-24004040-20150805220207

I actually think like this: Bethany and Charles met in Radley, fell in love and both escaped Radley on Labor Day. Somebody killed Bethany (well hit her head, since we know Melissa buried her), maybe accidentally and Charles believes it was Alison. He hit Alison out of rage and revenge because she took the only thing he had left and loved from him. Alison does know Bethany, but we never found out how? Isn't it funny that she talked to Bethany through letters but never knew about Charles even though they stayed both in Radley? There is something missing her. It could have been the plan of Alison to dress Bethany up as her so she finally could find out who -A is. But something went wrong. Charles hit Bethany, thinking she was Alison (we know from Kenneth he attacked her when she was younger.) and then projected his rage and anger on the REAL Alison (he just killed his own lover) and therefore hit her also. What I don't understand is that Charles as we know saw him, did not hate Alison. He liked having her at his birthday (the painting had even HER in it, not only Jason) and he shows himself to her. It is hard to believe he hates her so much, but I guess he DID hit her with that stone.

To sum up:

1) Somebody could have hit Bethany as a joke, or prank gone wrong. Maybe Alison wanted to prank Bethany knowing she would visit her on labor day and/or used her so she finally could find out who -A is. Something went wrong and she got hit

2) She could have been hit by Charles, because he thought she was Alison due to the clothes and projected his hate and guilt on Alison, believing she is at fault and therefore hitting her also.