Talk:Out, Damned Spot/@comment-26211734-20150211035452/@comment-5660329-20150211145951

^ tbh, I think she only does that now when she needs to. If she were to stop lying to make her story true, it would cause her to have to tell the truth about everything (the jenna thing, what happened in NY, the night she went missing, her lying about being kidnapped even though I believe she was for a time). Her telling the truth would cause all of the girls to go to jail. she herself said she would never betray her friends and she hasn't. She didn't tell the police that Aria killed shana and to the best of my knowledge didn't tell the police that Spencer came after her with a shovel and that she was on drugs the night ali went missing. She doesn't know who she can trust, which is understandable.

HandsomeLiar: normally I agree with your posts, but not this one. If ali really didn't have a heart, she wouldn't give a damn what happened to her friends and she'd turn them all in to the police. She hasn't. If she had no heart, she wouldn't have risked her own life multiple times to save her friends' lives. If she had no heart, she wouldn't have cried when she was looking at a picture of her friends.