Talk:Taking This One to the Grave/@comment-2152388-20140813121537

Melissa killed Bethany! I think she saw Spencer carrying that shovel and then also saw the unconsious Bethany Young and thought Spencer must have killed her! That's why she decided to burry her, not knowing she was still alive! She did it to protect her sister (as she many times have said she done), but she was actually the one who killed her without knowing! She later found out that Bethany died of suffocation and realised she actually killed her! If you look closely in the promo of 5x11 the person who carries the shovel wears jeans and red shoes, and we saw in 4x24 it was Spencer that she was wearing them! Also in this promo we see a person, wearing the clothes that match Melissa's from that night, burrying Bethany! So they're all make sense now! Melissa is Bethany's killer, even though unknowingly!