Talk:The Lady Killer/@comment-85.151.172.204-20120814212022

It can't be Toby, Ezra or Caleb because the halloween episode includes a Haleb, Spoby and a Ezria scene.

Also this episode is not a flashback, so if one of them is A then I would not think one of the liars would share a drink with him.

I might be wrong. I just read the page of the next episode and it may be false info.. Anyone else agrees?