Talk:I'm Your Puppet/@comment-66.170.138.98-20130312142000

Okay so here's my main thing - whenever I start thinking of the possibility that Ali could be behind all of this, I think back to "The First Secret." Someone clearly began threatening Ali first, sending her that voodoo doll and the notes and etc. Now, the twin theory could come into play here, but either way, I don't think the "Ali" the girls knew (whether it was really Ali or her twin Courtney) is Red Coat.

Toby, Mona and mainly everyone else around despised her, and I find it hard to believe that they would form a team and obey her. If "Ali" is still alive, I feel like it would only make sense for her to be trying to help the girls.