Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-14539762-20131026174955/@comment-24004040-20131026210720

I didn't mean us viewers, I mean the people in Rosewood. Besides the Liars, no one assumed Alison was alive, so no one would look into the coffin again.

I (especially because I am a fan of the twin theory), knew from the beginning on (mid season 1 to be truthful) that Alison was either alive herself or her twin, so that's why I waited and waited and always questioned myself "So, who's in the coffin if Ali is really alive?"

For me, that person in the coffin was important from the beginning. I hoped to see that storyline at least begin in Who's in the box, but it seems like that will happen way later :(