Talk:Charlotte DiLaurentis/@comment-26835433-20160324224334

Another quick ideas: What if Charlotte was lying about the whole Marrion/Bethany thing? Like, we saw that Bethany believed Mrs. D pushed Marrion that night (I think it was even confirmed that she saw that happen). So what if she actually saw MARY push Marrion off the roof?

Why would Charlotte lie? Becuase she was protecting her mother! I think it's 100% safe to assume Charlotte knew Mary was her mother and I doubt she chose Cece DRAKE out of random. So maybe she saw what her mother did and like Jessica did with Alison and Charlotte when they were younger, maybe Mary taught Charlotte how to lie?

It's not confirmed (I don't think) that Mary was in Radley with Charlotte, but what if she was and THIS is what really happened that night? It would explain why the flashback had so many plot holes (which made a lot of fans mad). Maybe that was a clue that she was lying?

I also believe that Mary could've been posing as Mrs. D often and was actually the one who was taking Bethany out of Radley all the time. Maybe Mary wasn't a patient at Radley, but becuase she posed as Jessica (who was on the Radley board), she was able to get into Radley late that night and kill Marrion?