Talk:The Bin of Sin/@comment-25547603-20150123162814

@Jarialover

Lucy gasped either because it was like she ruined the plot to some viewers in the studio who hadn't watched already, or because listening to "Ezra was A" still shocks people because it was a bad thing. Her gasp was for fun. When she said "He was A, old A" she was just referring to the times he was believed to be A, when we thought he was.

I do think the writers lie a lot. So I don't take for granted what they say.

Did they have to reveal Toby wasn't A before 3B began? "Yes, you'll see that he's not A and he's not evil at all" Of course they lied and said he was evil and he had reasons to be evil. It was said to keep the mystery about the plot!

Same about Ezra. They had to keep the secret and act like a big drama was going to happen, when they perfectly knew it wasn't going to happen. They can't spoil in interviews that they are just red herrings, so of course they have to lie all the time.

And honestly, PLL never had ratings problems, they know people will always watch, even if they complain about ships. How many people left the show because the plot was bad? You, and like - 400 other people? They do what they want, Marlene always said characters have their own truth and never change to please the fans. And I do believe her about this.

It could also be possible that they decided to make PLL last more and they were planned to be A, so they acted like they weren't A and one of them actually is. We don't know, we have to wait 'til the show ends. But I do think they never changed their mind to please the fans