Talk:Through a Glass, Darkly/@comment-79.112.232.134-20141223223507/@comment-85.180.120.96-20141223230915

My theory to that strange scene is, that Alison hit herself with the rock.

The way she colapses, the speed and the time and place when the rock hits the floor and when she falls is very intriguing. I think it happened that way: While she was watched by her mom, Ali took the rock from her left hand and hit herself with it. Then she was still a bit concious, let the rock slip out of her left hand and then collapsed finally to the right.

If she was hit from a rock by someone throwing it at her, she would be knocked down faster and more forcefully. The rock would fly a bit further away from the hit point, not falling slowly straight down. Again: the rock fell straight and slowly down! Even if she did not do it to herself, that still means, that her head was hit from a very close point. And I don't think she was hit from behind, too, cause Ali would have noticed or heared that person, standing right behind her and the scene shows us Ali from behind/ her feet, the camera angle and position suggests, that there is hardly any space for a person standing right behind her at that incident.

I believe she has a multiple personallity disorder, A, which overtook her body, trying "to kill" the real Alison part. Her mother witnessed how her daughter killed herself, unable to protect her child.

Again this is pll universe, so Ali could have told a lie, it could have been Tipi, the flashback scene might be filmed again and then with a diffrent outcome, Ali straight hair, curly hair, you know etc...