Talk:Alison's Attempted Killer/@comment-74.206.61.93-20140303235751/@comment-5660329-20140308023356

this is wrong in so many ways. for starters, Ali is alive, so no one killed her. second, let's pretend that it WAS emily who attempted to kill her:  why the heck would Ali say that Emily was her favorite? and i'm pretty sure Emily was more upset than mad about Ali not feeling the same way; and it's possible that Ali MAY have loved Emily like the latter loved her. the kiss in the barn was a sign; so was the diary entry about a "mermaid" (most likely about Emily, seeing as the other girls don't swim)