Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-25547603-20141123142440

About Mona being the first original A.

I know one of our theories is that someone knew Mona's game and used it that night to threaten Alison "Tonight's the night I kill you. -A". Of course that couldn't be Mona because Mona didn't want to kill her and when she found Alison with blood in her head was shocked and didn't know it.

Mona was in the lair and played with dolls in the flashback in 4x24, but the ultimate A has that dollhouse so I think that that means that it didn't belong to Mona.

There's something that doesn't match: the horseshoe when Ian dies. Mona didn't kill him, but it's Mona that stole the horseshoe from where Ian is found and uses it in change of Melissa's ring. So now I think that Mona is a minion and always knew about Big A.

Did Melissa eventually get her ring back? I don't remember