Talk:To Plea or Not to Plea/@comment-26083937-20150301190351

Here is my theory for Andrew being A:

What if Andrew is Bethany's brother, they both have blondish hair. And maybe Bethany and Mona were really good friends. Andrew and Mona probably knew that it was Bethany in the grave the whole time and not Alison. Mona and Andrew became friends and bonded over their loss. They felt that the liars were in some ways responsible for what happened to Bethany. To avenge her, Andrew and Mona came up with the A team. To figure out what secrets the liars had, Mona would act as Hanna's friend and Andrew would act as Spencer's. Eventually, they started to disagree on how they should torture the liars. Mona felt that the liars had enough pain and suffering and Andrew still wanted to be A. To kick Mona off the team, Andrew blackmailed her to reveal herself as A to the liars or else he would tell them himself. With Mona out of the picture, Andrew acted alone as Uber A.

What do you think?