Talk:Charlotte DiLaurentis/@comment-26835433-20160321230316

Quick theory (more like an idea, as my theory isn't really built yet):

What if Charlotte's father was Byron Montgomery's brother?

I'm not really sure if it was 100% confirmed, but maybe Mary wasn't crazy but had given Charlotte to her sister because Charlotte's father was unstable and in-and-out of phyciactric hospitals and it was too much for Mary at the time? Jessica and Mary seem to have grown up with certain issues (turning Jessica into a liar, enough for her to convice her young children to start lying) so maybe Mary had issues like Jessica, but with her daughter's murder and all the hate Charlotte got, Mary just wanted to evenge the daughter she always loved?

Maybe it's nothing, but they spent a LOT of time on Byron's brother having mental illnesses for them to just never pick it up again? Maybe they were trying to give Mike more of a plot and that's all it was, but I still feel like there's more to it...

Any thoughts? Like I said, it's just an idea right now aha