Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-185.34.110.1-20140731111856

Okay, I'm probably just taking this all too seriously but I think they've really messed up the timeline of this show. So if season 3 episode 13 took place on October 31st 2011, are we supposed to believe that every episodes from 3B through 5A took place over the space of under 2 months.

The only explanation would be if the Ice Ball takes place in January 2012 (which is also Winter), and all the Christmas stuff is just flashbacks. I don't know, but I hope this is what they're doing. If not, then Marlene King has really fucked up. I think it's just gotten to the stage where we should just sit back and not take stuff like the timeline so seriously. They've had references to the Katy Perry movie, Insidious: Chapter 2 and Frozen (all stuff that came out in 2012 and 2013) when they episodes were meant to take place in 2011.

I wonder does the show just take place in a reality where it just resets itself to take place in the year that it's being broadcast - so basically season 5 takes place in 2014, not 2011/2012. I need to stop typing now. What does anyone else think about this?