Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-25547603-20141030022948

Ok, I've realized this thing and maybe I'm wrong since the whole Marin's family/twins thing would make not sense.

Anyway. This was written from PLL's Peter, Melissa and Spencer for Troian's birthday.

Ok...I was thinking... Why Nolan's "IS" is capitalized? At first I didn't read it that way... But now... "That IS her name, right?"

What if it isn't her name? What if she is Melissa's twin? Torrey replied "So. Messed. Up." and Spencer didn't reply at that maybe in order to not make us suspect.

Then I remembered, 2x03.

Spencer wants to know who Melissa would choose between her and Ian. Also remember that this dialogue is very important since they talk about that again in Season 4 when Melissa said "Remember when you asked me who would I choose...?"

The dialogue in 2x03 was about Spencer bullied by Kendra Santoni when she was a kid; Kendra was a girl in her school, Melissa stood up to her and defended Spencer. After that Spencer says "Do you remember that??" And Melissa doesn't reply...and Spencer "Oh my god you don't?"

What if she doesn't remember that because she never lived that moment? What if she's the twin?