Talk:Noel Kahn/@comment-24871737-20140427154610/@comment-70.20.40.203-20140610054404

I'm not saying he is gay, I could see it going that way but I can see it going the other too. But your reasons for him not being gay make no sense.

1. Dating many girls means nothing at best, in fact it could mean that he is gay. When your trying to hide your sexuality dating a series of the oppisite sex helps to hide it.

2. What's in the books doesn't matter because as you point out the show and books are completely different.

3. As you said it can be and the fear of being rejected espically in sports is a motivating factor to stay closested. Also who said Alison was black mailing him? Most likely she trusts him because she knows everything about him etc.

4. What she said was "I know all of his secrets" which doesn't equal dark.

5. Them trusting each other and being friends in no way shape or form proves his sexuality one way or another. Also the books are completely different Spoiler Alison in the books is crazy and A which I highly doubt the show is going that route so like I said books means nothing.