Talk:'A' is for A-l-i-v-e/@comment-188.103.43.149-20130523164907/@comment-91.37.78.27-20130523204752

1) It is not confirmed that Toby was -A from season one on. You really should read well what you're reading. Keegan said, he knew that he would be -A since season 1: That means, Keegan Allen knew that Toby would be -A in future seasons, since maybe 1b aired.

2) The person didn't say "pretty eyes" but "Interesting eyes" and the Producers said, that they didn't have anyone in mind when they said that (interesting eyes), because it could mean anyone. Only PRETTY Eyes was confirmed to be Toby. and NO, it's not the same, because otherwise Marlene would have confirmed it or said anything about that to give us a hint.

3) That leaves us at Toby being on the A-Team on 2b, when Dr. Sullivan met with -A in that restaurant (which ironically is the same Toby later meets Spencer in 3x24, the same table) THAT was Toby. :)