Talk:Who's In The Box?/@comment-67.180.234.251-20131101235805

Lol I honestly don't think the writers have known who killed Ian and Alison since season 1. I think they're slowly trying to figure things out themselves so it makes sense, and that's often why things don't add up (I.e, Toby is "pretty eyes" and was A since 3x08, but pretty eyes was introduced in season 2). I think they just decided who Ian's killer is... They haven't know all along, and that's why this show is sometimes really sloppily put together