Talk:To Plea or Not to Plea/@comment-25312059-20150302223659

Ok so this is a theory for all the "Bethany is A" conspiracists

In 3x23 when Spencer is at Radley, she finds the map on the game Mona was obsessed with that leads her to the broken window where somebody could easily escape. It's implied that Mona drew the map, but what if it was Bethany who drew it? And that's how she escaped on the night she was supposedly murdered. Then when Mona was admitted to Radley, Red Coat visisted her an offered her a way out of Radley if she let her play the A game with her. If this Red Coat was Bethany, she would have known how to get in and out of Radley and she may have told Mona about that game which is why Mona was obsessed with it.

I doubt Bethany is alive but it's just a thought I had when I was rewatching some season 3 eps.