Talk:EscApe From New York/@comment-70.172.200.154-20140418172712/@comment-69.159.3.238-20140418190106

The Liars went to Philadelphia to meet up with Ali but instead found Noel. Noel then took them to New York between "Unbridled" and "A is for Answers". That's why when the girls are running from A, Emily says Noel has their phones. He left them in Spencer's car in Philly, which is where the police were. Hope that clears it up :)