Talk:A is for Answers/@comment-24686040-20140316152321/@comment-98.112.159.220-20140316213008

It would be very unrealistic if Maya has also faked her death, just like Ali. I get that it's a tv show but it would just be too far fetched. I mean, wow the teenagers in this town are so smart and have so many connections that they're able to effectively trick their families, the cops, and forensic experts into thinking it's them when really it's some other dead person. I just can't see it happening more than once. With Alison at least there's the excuse that the body had been dead for a year and buried in the ground without having been embalmed or otherwise preserved, which makes it believable that the identification could be flawed. But with Maya, they make it clear that she was killed the night before her body was found. In fact, she was killed just a couple hours after Garrett was arrested (for Ali's murder) in Spencer's house. So, Maya's face would've still been recognizable and her finger prints and DNA evidence would've still been intact. I do agree, however, that the fact that her funeral was not shown raises suspicion. But, again, as her body was not yet decayed, I think it can be assumed that Maya's parents and relatives who were at the funeral would've seen the body, as it would've been an open casket service. If it turns out that Maya is alive somehow, what do you think her motives are for faking her death and for being Big A?