Talk:Alison's Attempted Killer/@comment-5660329-20140722220255/@comment-50.32.254.168-20140724060928

I'm the person who wrote the comment, for the record.

Ezra: He knew it was Shana on the roof and he could have let Shana kill Alison if he'd really wanted her dead. Also, the whole point of his book was to find out who killed Alison, so why would he write a book with so many secrets in it and then lie about not being the one who attacked Alison.

Toby: Marlene stated in an interview that he was the only honest character in the first season and he told Emily that he didn't hurt Alison. I know Marlene is known to lie a lot, but the story matched exactly what happened in A is for Answers; Alison got into a car with some guy wearing his sweater, and Alison confirmed what Toby told Emily about what they talked about that night.

Paige: She should be on the list.

Mona: If Mona really wanted Alison dead, she could have killed her at the Lost Woods Resort.

Lucas: Same as Paige.