Talk:Through a Glass, Darkly/@comment-25547603-20141214001133

Everyone after 5x13 thinks that Bethany is a victim and a nice girl, but I think there's so much we don't know. The Bethany in Alison's letter is just so different from the girl who made those horrible paintings with Mrs D. as the devil and said "Everything she told me was a lie." I think the letter was written after the paintings (In the letter she said she just finished an art book, right?), so she was lying and wasn't really nice to Alison, she hated her and Mrs D.

Maybe Alison was really nice to her and wanted to meet her, while CeCe and Bethany had a plan to kill Alison... Who knows.

Melissa and Jason are 24, CeCe is 26, Bethany would be 19-20. So apparently Bethany isn't the twin of any of them, and Alison/Liars either because they are 17-18. But Jessica worked in Radley and could have faked Bethany's age.

Who's the one who could say that that wasn't Bethany's real age? No one, except Marion Cavanaugh that ops, died. I think that Marion - who worked for a peditrician - found out about Jessica's secret and realised it was a secret only when she was committed to Radley and met Bethany. Maybe she was killed because of this. But Bethany knew eveything and she painted all of it.

But what's this secret? Why showing us Mrs D in a black veil just like Black Widow? It's Alison's dream, agreed, but she dreamed the same black veil and I don't think that's a coincidence! Then why? And why Mrs D bought things to Bethany since she was a child?

Another strange fact: it seems like no one was looking for Bethany after that night, why? Two girls disappearing the same night, it would have been a great news. But no one ever talked about Bethany, when the girls look on the internet they just find news about Sara Harvey but no Bethany. Why?

I hope you have great theories. Can't wait to read them.



Who do you think is in here? (someone strong with a boy in his arms?)

->