Talk:Songs of Innocence/@comment-26140471-20150605002605/@comment-24048371-20150605051151

If this Charles guy really is A and Jason's twin brother and was the one who knocked Alison out than that could explain why Mrs. D didn't call the cops and buried Alison herself because she didn't want her son to go to jail. Despite how sick he probably is and tried to kill his own sister, he was still her little boy. She probably decided to hide him, but eventually he killed her when she found out Ali was alive. Maybe he didn't know she was alive either.

Another theory, Charles probably did something so naughty that his family sent him to Radley and Mr. Hastings knew about it. That is why he choked when Spencer and Toby were looking into the death of Toby's mother. Perhaps Charles killed her and his parents covered it up.

Then again... maybe not. Just when I think one thing, a monkey wrench is thrown into it.