Talk:Charlotte's Killer/@comment-26497373-20160718170802/@comment-4102239-20160718220750

We don't know that for sure. Remember, we don't know where either Caleb or Toby were the night that Charlotte was killed. If they did do it, then they had one motive: the Liars. I still believe that it could be Mr. D. Or Jason, or Jenna, or Noel, or Paige, or Sydney, or even Mike. His character in Teen Wolf was killed off so hopefully we'll get to see him. I, too, hope it wasn't Caleb or Toby. If it was it would be too upsetting. Not that it wouldn't make a great theory, I just don't see them as cold-blooded killers.