Talk:Game Over, Charles/@comment-26123313-20150819004947/@comment-26123313-20150819013549

Melissa said she had suspicion Ali was alive in 4x04, so Shana didn't tell her at that point. I don't think Jenna is against the liars per se, maybe just Ali. Honestly, I think Jenna and Shana were playing Melissa for information about the liars. But who knows, maybe we'll find out this winter.