Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-6659210-20141026151559

Okay, so I came up with this theory a few days ago. I think Bethany hit Alison because she was jealous of the life Ali had and wanted it so desperatly. Mrs. D buried Ali and I do believe that Mrs. Grunwald helped her get out. Now here's the crazy part (sort of). Where was Ian after the meet-up in Ali's room? We know Garrett and Jenna were talking and was confronted by Alison and we all know what happened. And we know Melissa was talking on the phone after the Bryon and Ali confrontation and was also seen talking to CeCe (was she on the phone too? I don't think she was talking to Ian) so that leaves Ian? I'm pretty sure he didn't stay in Alison's room, that would be creepy but hey he did create those videos so creepy is his middle name. So I think he took the time to think about what was happening after the kiss with Ali and the NAT club meeting, he decided to shut Ali up completely but found Bethany instead, thinking that it was Ali, and hit her. He fled the scene and that was when Melissa found and buried Bethany alive. Might I add, notice the ground that it was already dug up, so this all happened after Ali was buried alive and dug up and left an opening for Bethany to be buried.