Talk:How the 'A' Stole Christmas/@comment-25755332-20141202192857

Josicozy: ^I'm aware that there are plot holes, but I had this crazy idea and had to write it down and hear if anyone had some thoughts regarding the idea =)

Mrs D could have been killed by Black Widow, and when he/she sent the message to Ali just pretending to be A. Maybe the Black Widow was a imposter of A, and just "claimed" to be A. I mean we never really know who is sending the texts, they are always just signed with A. And anyone in town could in practice sign a message with A.

The main reason with the theory was to question if A actually is the bad guy or if she/he could be the good guy. And which events that are connected and which events that aren't connected to certain plots.

Somehow we think that everything that happens has to do with Ali's attempted murder. But what if some of the events just has to do with NAT, Ali was practically the one who dragged them in to her A mess in the first place. Radley is always present in some way, but we don't know that much about it yet. The liars mission is to figure out who A is. And the Black Widow only does things when necessary.

That could explain why some events and things don't make sense, because they aren't meant to. For example Garrett was probably killed because of the NAT-club's videos and that doesn't necessary have to do with Ali directly. Mona could have been killed by Black Widow and that doesn't have anything to do with A.

When we try to drag every event and connect them to Ali's attempted murder, exactly everything gets messy and nothing makes sense. But if we realize that there are more than one plot going on and try to unravel them into each plot, then everything could make more sense. For example now we believe that NAT has to do with what happened to Ali, but what if that is just a B-plot to make the story seem more complicated than it really is?