Original 3 were perfect
Ezra
Melissa
Wilden
Lucas
Noel
213 Votes in Poll
1,728
pages
ALL POSTS
Lucas Gottesman
Tagged Posts
Hanna and Wren
Hanna and Lucas
Holden and Aria
Spencer and Ezra
Jordan and Mellisa
Caleb and Aria
138 Votes in Poll
<p>Hi! I'm not upset with the finale, or saying that it should of ended differently. I just wanted to express something that's been running through my head recently, and maybe bounce some ideas off of a few other wiki members. I've always liked the idea of Lucas and Hanna being together. Seeing Lucas come back in 6B after rewatching the episodes brought a smile to my face, seeing the way he treated Hanna. He's always reminded me of myself, personally. (As I am a male). Lucas has ALWAYS been there for Hanna. He's always been such a genuine, loving guy with a HUGE heart. Granted, so has Caleb, and I won't deny that, but I just think the way Lucas looked up to Hanna was great, and I think that the stuff that Lucas did for Hanna in 6B and 7A was so cool. He came all the way back to fix the software after Aria's burn injury, and how he offered to invest in Hanna, and still talk to her after it went south. He's always been a good guy, and I wouldn't have minded seeing them as Endgame. My only conflict is that even though I can see Hanna with Lucas, I can't see Caleb with ANYBODY else, other than....wait, I just had a thought. I could really see Caleb with Mona in the end. Caleb had so much hatred for Mona due to the shit she put Hanna through, but honestly I could see them making up and forming some sort of relationship. It would be an interesting ending, and it would be a way for Mona to find love as her sane, intelligent self other than just a mystery French boyfriend. Just my opinion, was wondering what you guys think! I'd love to hear your guys' opinions! <3
</p>
(Edited by MoneybagsHastings)
<p>In this theory, Jenna has a big secret and knows about A.D too. Both of them are evil here ! (warning, it's very long)
</p><p>First of all, three importants facts:
</p><p>During the last 5 years, Toby found out Charlotte lied about Marion's death.
</p><p>Mary killed Marion. Charlotte protected Mary, but also wanted to be part of Jessica's family. She cared for both of the twins.
</p><p>Charlotte lied in 6x10. But flashbacks are shown in the perspective of people who told them, and for Charlotte these memories were true as she was deeply attached to Jessica and her children ! (more of this right after)
</p><p>
</p><p>Bethany = Charlotte, not because of a split personality case, just a fake name (it's maybe far fetched, but sometimes simples solutions are the best). Bethany's roomate Leslie (who obviously never met a girl named Charlotte) heard the name Charles for the first time the night of Ali's disappearance. What if, after transioning, Charles was called Charlotte only by Mrs D, while the other people at Radley knew her as Bethany Young. Charles was dead. Maybe they wanted an all new identity for her, and in some way changing her name to Charlotte wasn't enough. In Rosewood, Charlotte was Cece, in Radley, she was Bethany. After the night when a girl was buried alive, why no one signaled Bethany's disappearance from Radley ? Well, we learned that after this night Charlotte stayed in Radley thanks to Jessica and Detective Wilden; so if CC = Beth, there was no reason to signal her, and she probably stayed in isolation so Leslie never saw her again til she was released. </p><p>Both Mary and Charlotte were in Radley; Charlotte was the smartest, I believe she found out early about Mary Drake existence, Jessica's twin; and also knew, no matter what, that Mrs D was the one present in her life, the one who cared. Charlotte asked Jessica about it, so she confessed. From that moment, Mrs D would be only an aunt for Charlotte... (who else in Radley could call Jessica "aunt Jessie"? maybe a certain Bethany Young. Strange coïncidence, don't you think ?!). Charlotte knew the truth, but Jessica, Jason and Alison were still the ones she considered as her true family, so she freaked out when Mrs D told her now they only gonna be aunt and niece ! That's how she developed obsession toward all the DiLaurentis. An envy to be as close as possible to Jason and Ali. Marion Cavanaugh was perhaps the one who helped Mary to contact her daughter, but things went wrong, deadly. Maybe Mary was afraid of people who knew about Charlotte. </p><p>(Now the important part, AD and the killer chapters !) The name "Bethany Young" doesn't come from nowhere. Jessica cared for "her niece", she told her every knowledge she had on her twin. Mary had another son, Charlotte's brother. A boy separated from Charlotte by Jessica's lies (kind of), just like in Bethany's drawings. He was adopted by a family in another city, the Young. Both Jessica and Charlotte agreed about naming her with her brother's family name. But they never met, the Young never heard about Bethany, that's why we never saw them. But still we can imagine that the cops were in contact with them during the investigation, weren't they ? Well, with their legendary efficiency, it's easy for me to believe that someone tricked them, posing as Mr Young for example. </p><p>And who I think is the one who did it ? Charlotte's dad a.k.a. Peter Hastings. Peter knew Mary was the twin he slept with. He knew about her pregnancy and probably helped for the DiLaurentis' adoption of Charles (Jason is not Peter's, Charles was). Cheating was already huge, Veronica would have never accept a child from a crazy twin. Peter had to bury that secret... </p><p>A.D a.k.a. the Young's child a.k.a. someone we know with a different name in Rosewood a.k.a. Uber A was working with Mrs D, to be able to had news about Charlotte. I'm calling it, he's Jessica's killer. The one she couldn't protect anymore. The last Mrs D's secret, even Charlotte didn't know Jessica met A.D and told him the truth about her and Mary. When Jessica found that Alison was alive, she took a decision: No more secrets ! She wanted to reveal everything, introduced Charlotte, brought back Mary into their lives, exposing Peter (that's why he was so eager to ask her about their agreement), and exposing A.D existence by blowing his life. Back then, he wasn't ready to fully assume a sister and a mother who were in a mental institute. It was too much, too fast; he had to silence Jessica. A.D is Lucas. Mrs D made him a fake background life in Rosewood. The Young believed their son was in some private school. </p><p>The Dollhouse was built by Elliott and Mary, way before Charlotte thought about abducting the Liars there. A place where Mary could met Charlotte, thanks to Elliott, her doctor, who was able to secretly get Charlotte out of Radley. Elliott is Sara's kidnapper too. He took that blonde girl who had runaway from her home because of her resemblance with Ali. And it worked, Sara's presence in the future Dollhouse calmed down Charlotte after the event of that night. Sara and Charlotte developed a forced sister bond. Elliott was Varjak and it was his idea to use Sara as a Red Coat decoy. </p><p>In 6B, after Charlotte's release, Lucas was ready to kill her. He wanted to confront her the night of her death. They met quickly at the church, then he had second thoughts; that's when somebody else (another person who had a grudge against Charlotte) came here and roughly killed Charlotte. Lucas came back to make peace with his sister but found her dead. In despair, he staged her death in a way that could incriminate the Hastings (A.D knows about Charlotte's father and hates him). The biggest twist is that the killer witnessed Lucas and Charlotte's reunion cause the killer acted in A.D's back. The killer then knows about the Charlotte's brother existence and his will to keep this status a secret. With secrets messages/threats he/she blackmailed Lucas into exposing him if he try to get revenge, that is how Lucas became A.D, that's why he found and worked with Mary and Elliott, and started blackmailing the Liars. He is tied by the killer. Lucas truly wants the killer to be found by the girls. </p><p>Charlotte's killer is Jenna ! She is the puppetmaster behind the mess that started in 6B. She killed Charlotte because... revenge, remember Charlotte tried to kill Jenna in the first place. It was pure and evil payback ! And Toby covered for her. He told her about Marion's murder. Jenna is twisted enough to claim she killed Charlotte only for Toby. Amoji/A.D acted like a child or like someone who aren't totally free of his actions (lame messages/threats, lame emojis, lame actions like not being able to stop Caleb to hack his computer). </p><p>
</p><p>My theory is that Jenna will come back in 7A, but we will not found more information about the killer until 7B. For most of the season, A.D will appear as the only bad one, and Jenna as a normal Rosewood citizen. Who would suspect a "blind bitch" who seemed to have "<i>made peace</i>" with the Liars ? Jenna is a smart girl, she always had people to do her dirty work (Garrett, Shana, Nigel...) but she probably can do worst on her own. </p><p>I can see 7x20's revelations being the ultimate confrontation between Jenna and Alison, with both telling what they've been through because of each other since the First Secret; while elsewhere the Liars, with Mona's help, will confront Lucas !!! </p><p>Lucas is one Big Bad, he killed Jessica, and could kill again to protect his secrets. But, <i>all</i> of this is also <i>connected</i> to Jenna. </p><p><i>Noel's secret</i>: if Jenna and Noel come back in the show, I believe they will try to tie all the lose ends. Noel was scared of what Alison could reveal about him. It must have been a "life or death" situation/ level of importance. Noel dated Jenna. Was it really love ? Or out of guilt perhaps ??? How ashamed would Noel be if the secret concerned his ex-girlfriend's blindness !? Maybe he's the one behind the "Jenna Thing" as the person who gave the firecracker to Alison. </p><p><i>Melissa</i>: she was a manipulative, crazy, mean woman while she was "protecting Spencer". Could Jenna be spiteful enough to get revenge from her by blackmailing Melissa about the confession's tape, and in the same time get money with this ? If Toby knew for the tape, he could have inform Jenna. And killing Charlotte with a rod from Melissa's suicase would be like kill two birds with one stone ! </p><p><i>The girl in Alison's grave</i>: who she could be if Cece was Bethany ? Wren never was part of the A-game I think. Elliott paid him to secure the Cece Drake fake ID (remember the visitor pass) perhaps. Maybe he was in Rosewood only to investigate on the death of a relative one, a blonde girl who had nothing to do with Charlotte, Mary and all the Rosewood drama !? (It could be revealed in a movie, but) My unexpected plot is that Wren's sister is in the grave; Wren will come back this season to reveal that to Mona and Melissa, and get revenge from them ! </p><p>
</p><p>Sorry for this way too long post, I tried to connect all the characters ! </p>
</p><p>Bethany = Charlotte, not because of a split personality case, just a fake name (it's maybe far fetched, but sometimes simples solutions are the best). Bethany's roomate Leslie (who obviously never met a girl named Charlotte) heard the name Charles for the first time the night of Ali's disappearance. What if, after transioning, Charles was called Charlotte only by Mrs D, while the other people at Radley knew her as Bethany Young. Charles was dead. Maybe they wanted an all new identity for her, and in some way changing her name to Charlotte wasn't enough. In Rosewood, Charlotte was Cece, in Radley, she was Bethany. After the night when a girl was buried alive, why no one signaled Bethany's disappearance from Radley ? Well, we learned that after this night Charlotte stayed in Radley thanks to Jessica and Detective Wilden; so if CC = Beth, there was no reason to signal her, and she probably stayed in isolation so Leslie never saw her again til she was released. </p><p>Both Mary and Charlotte were in Radley; Charlotte was the smartest, I believe she found out early about Mary Drake existence, Jessica's twin; and also knew, no matter what, that Mrs D was the one present in her life, the one who cared. Charlotte asked Jessica about it, so she confessed. From that moment, Mrs D would be only an aunt for Charlotte... (who else in Radley could call Jessica "aunt Jessie"? maybe a certain Bethany Young. Strange coïncidence, don't you think ?!). Charlotte knew the truth, but Jessica, Jason and Alison were still the ones she considered as her true family, so she freaked out when Mrs D told her now they only gonna be aunt and niece ! That's how she developed obsession toward all the DiLaurentis. An envy to be as close as possible to Jason and Ali. Marion Cavanaugh was perhaps the one who helped Mary to contact her daughter, but things went wrong, deadly. Maybe Mary was afraid of people who knew about Charlotte. </p><p>(Now the important part, AD and the killer chapters !) The name "Bethany Young" doesn't come from nowhere. Jessica cared for "her niece", she told her every knowledge she had on her twin. Mary had another son, Charlotte's brother. A boy separated from Charlotte by Jessica's lies (kind of), just like in Bethany's drawings. He was adopted by a family in another city, the Young. Both Jessica and Charlotte agreed about naming her with her brother's family name. But they never met, the Young never heard about Bethany, that's why we never saw them. But still we can imagine that the cops were in contact with them during the investigation, weren't they ? Well, with their legendary efficiency, it's easy for me to believe that someone tricked them, posing as Mr Young for example. </p><p>And who I think is the one who did it ? Charlotte's dad a.k.a. Peter Hastings. Peter knew Mary was the twin he slept with. He knew about her pregnancy and probably helped for the DiLaurentis' adoption of Charles (Jason is not Peter's, Charles was). Cheating was already huge, Veronica would have never accept a child from a crazy twin. Peter had to bury that secret... </p><p>A.D a.k.a. the Young's child a.k.a. someone we know with a different name in Rosewood a.k.a. Uber A was working with Mrs D, to be able to had news about Charlotte. I'm calling it, he's Jessica's killer. The one she couldn't protect anymore. The last Mrs D's secret, even Charlotte didn't know Jessica met A.D and told him the truth about her and Mary. When Jessica found that Alison was alive, she took a decision: No more secrets ! She wanted to reveal everything, introduced Charlotte, brought back Mary into their lives, exposing Peter (that's why he was so eager to ask her about their agreement), and exposing A.D existence by blowing his life. Back then, he wasn't ready to fully assume a sister and a mother who were in a mental institute. It was too much, too fast; he had to silence Jessica. A.D is Lucas. Mrs D made him a fake background life in Rosewood. The Young believed their son was in some private school. </p><p>The Dollhouse was built by Elliott and Mary, way before Charlotte thought about abducting the Liars there. A place where Mary could met Charlotte, thanks to Elliott, her doctor, who was able to secretly get Charlotte out of Radley. Elliott is Sara's kidnapper too. He took that blonde girl who had runaway from her home because of her resemblance with Ali. And it worked, Sara's presence in the future Dollhouse calmed down Charlotte after the event of that night. Sara and Charlotte developed a forced sister bond. Elliott was Varjak and it was his idea to use Sara as a Red Coat decoy. </p><p>In 6B, after Charlotte's release, Lucas was ready to kill her. He wanted to confront her the night of her death. They met quickly at the church, then he had second thoughts; that's when somebody else (another person who had a grudge against Charlotte) came here and roughly killed Charlotte. Lucas came back to make peace with his sister but found her dead. In despair, he staged her death in a way that could incriminate the Hastings (A.D knows about Charlotte's father and hates him). The biggest twist is that the killer witnessed Lucas and Charlotte's reunion cause the killer acted in A.D's back. The killer then knows about the Charlotte's brother existence and his will to keep this status a secret. With secrets messages/threats he/she blackmailed Lucas into exposing him if he try to get revenge, that is how Lucas became A.D, that's why he found and worked with Mary and Elliott, and started blackmailing the Liars. He is tied by the killer. Lucas truly wants the killer to be found by the girls. </p><p>Charlotte's killer is Jenna ! She is the puppetmaster behind the mess that started in 6B. She killed Charlotte because... revenge, remember Charlotte tried to kill Jenna in the first place. It was pure and evil payback ! And Toby covered for her. He told her about Marion's murder. Jenna is twisted enough to claim she killed Charlotte only for Toby. Amoji/A.D acted like a child or like someone who aren't totally free of his actions (lame messages/threats, lame emojis, lame actions like not being able to stop Caleb to hack his computer). </p><p>
</p><p>My theory is that Jenna will come back in 7A, but we will not found more information about the killer until 7B. For most of the season, A.D will appear as the only bad one, and Jenna as a normal Rosewood citizen. Who would suspect a "blind bitch" who seemed to have "<i>made peace</i>" with the Liars ? Jenna is a smart girl, she always had people to do her dirty work (Garrett, Shana, Nigel...) but she probably can do worst on her own. </p><p>I can see 7x20's revelations being the ultimate confrontation between Jenna and Alison, with both telling what they've been through because of each other since the First Secret; while elsewhere the Liars, with Mona's help, will confront Lucas !!! </p><p>Lucas is one Big Bad, he killed Jessica, and could kill again to protect his secrets. But, <i>all</i> of this is also <i>connected</i> to Jenna. </p><p><i>Noel's secret</i>: if Jenna and Noel come back in the show, I believe they will try to tie all the lose ends. Noel was scared of what Alison could reveal about him. It must have been a "life or death" situation/ level of importance. Noel dated Jenna. Was it really love ? Or out of guilt perhaps ??? How ashamed would Noel be if the secret concerned his ex-girlfriend's blindness !? Maybe he's the one behind the "Jenna Thing" as the person who gave the firecracker to Alison. </p><p><i>Melissa</i>: she was a manipulative, crazy, mean woman while she was "protecting Spencer". Could Jenna be spiteful enough to get revenge from her by blackmailing Melissa about the confession's tape, and in the same time get money with this ? If Toby knew for the tape, he could have inform Jenna. And killing Charlotte with a rod from Melissa's suicase would be like kill two birds with one stone ! </p><p><i>The girl in Alison's grave</i>: who she could be if Cece was Bethany ? Wren never was part of the A-game I think. Elliott paid him to secure the Cece Drake fake ID (remember the visitor pass) perhaps. Maybe he was in Rosewood only to investigate on the death of a relative one, a blonde girl who had nothing to do with Charlotte, Mary and all the Rosewood drama !? (It could be revealed in a movie, but) My unexpected plot is that Wren's sister is in the grave; Wren will come back this season to reveal that to Mona and Melissa, and get revenge from them ! </p><p>
</p><p>Sorry for this way too long post, I tried to connect all the characters ! </p>
(Edited by NeedATeam)
<p>At the moment, i think Lucas killed Charlotte to protect Hanna, worried that Charlotte would become A again. It makes sense since upon being asked by Hanna if he was in Rosewood the night she was killed, he not only looked worried that Hanna had found him out but also he didn't even answer the question. He even immediately agreed to be Hanna's alibi since if the police ever suspected him of being the killer, he already has an alibi in place.
</p><p>If Lucas really is the killer we can assume that in Season 7 when they are given 24 hours to find Charlotte's killer, they turn over evidence of it being Lucas (either that or Lucas finds out what happened to Hanna and comes forward) but then A kills him and keeps Hanna hostage if they don't take care of the body, leaving them no choice but to burry his body where no one will ever find it. This is the mistake that Marlene talked about that A will use to fuel the endgame.
</p><p>Furthermore, it has been a five year time jump and they could have instantly brought back some main characters like Jenna, Jason, Wren, etc. but no, they bring back Lucas in the first few eps of 6B. Marlene wants to make sure people know that he is still around and maintains a connection to Rosewood.
</p><p>I am most likely to be 100% wrong but it is fun to theorise :)
</p>
(Edited by Wheatleyyy)
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> It’s about who are, and how connected are Big Bad and Charlotte’s killer ? I think at the end it will all be about family.</span></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px">Let’s begin with Charlotte, we first meet Cece in 3x07, while her first Big A’s action was to dig up «Alison’s grave» during That Night. In fact I have a problem with this story arc, like we never had a final word concerning Lucas, Noel, Holden or Jenna involvement. Even why Mona was there !? She knew Ali was still alive, and obviously never confirmed that to Charlotte. Did Mona used Red Coat to identify the girl in the grave ? Red Coat who was Charlotte (or Sara, if Charlotte needed a decoy at the cemetery) at the time of 3x01, but she said in 6x10 that she began to believe Ali could be alive when she saw a blonde girl in red coat looking at the girls (so does it mean that she saw Red Coat Ali during the summer before season 3, and then began to wear a red coat too ?) She kept the body long enough to test the DNA, body who will be identify as Bethany Young two seasons later (only 2 or 3 weeks in PLL timeline). Charlotte knew it wasn’t Alison, why bother to give the body back ? I’m almost sure I’m wrong (let’s be crazy, theories are made for that), but what if Charlotte put Bethany’s DNA there or just mess up with police’s analysis ?</span></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> We don’t know much about Bethany, except that she betrayed Charles, used to make drawings about Mrs D with a demon and a little boy with a demon too, and Jessica wanted to be called aunt Jessie by Bethany. </span></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px">Why aunt ? </span></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px">Is this « she had an affair with Mr Young » is really believable ? </span></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px">Maybe yes, if Bethany confused Jessica and her twin.</span></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> Right now (before 6x20), I think Mrs D had a twin sister, I just don’t know which one died in 4x24, but the one who is alive, is the new stalker. A mother who want to avenge her daughter. But it’s not the end.</span></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> I said it doesn’t matter which one is dead because Big Bad consider both Charlotte and Ali as her children. What is the link with Bethany ? Well, let say it straight, I believe Charles died at Radley due to his meds, and Charlotte was indeed a second personality of Bethany. (I told you it will be crazy). Mrs D cared to much about Bethany judging by the info we heard (since we still never saw Bethany’s adult face) if she was just a random girl who framed her son; my theory is that Bethany was Ali and Jason’s cousin (daughter of their mom’s twin). It’s the twin who had an affair with Mr Young, and somehow the twin asked Jessica to care for Bethany. She had split personality disorder, and the bond with Mrs D made her believe she was Charlotte DiLaurentis ! If Charles died and « Bethany became Charlotte » during Jessica’s grief, she could have let Bethany does it because it was a way for Mrs D to keep her son alive (ok this part is really really crazy). Look at Marion’s death flashback, clearly « Charlotte » had a false memory, a personality disorder could be a way to explain that.</span></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"></p>
<p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> And what about the killer ? Since the scene in Charlotte’s grave, I’m obsessed with the idea that maybe it wasn’t Big Bad who put flower there, but actually Charlotte’s killer. And remember, Charlotte had a rose in her hand when they found her body. And the killer seems to have tried to make it look like a suicide in a quickly and an improvised way. Like the murder was accidental or committed by someone who once cared for her. Who is my suspect ? Lucas Gottesman.</span></p>
<p>
</p><p>
</p> <p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> I’m a big fan of « Lucas is Big Bad » theory. With « Mrs D » return, I really can see a desperate mother looking for her child’s killer in Big Bad’s actions; it doesn’t mean Lucas can’t still be involved. The motive ?</span></p> <p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> Now this is my « crazy » theory last part. I thought Lucas could have been Charlotte’s secret lover. Since PLL beginning, Lucas is way too often and way too much involved in the A game. And as I said earlier, some of his involvement were never fully explained or developed. </span></p> <p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> BUT, the big final twist could be that Lucas was adopted, and is in fact the twin’s son aka Charlotte/Bethany’s brother !!! If the twin couldn’t raised Bethany, it’s logic she wouldn’t be able to raise an other child if she had one.</span></p> <p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> Maybe Lucas was the boy in Bethany’s drawings. Remember the Radley’s var from the episode The First Secret. Lucas could have heard about Bethany around this time, and since began to hate the DiLaurentis. He could also be the one who made Mona to begin the A game (since a huge part of the fandom believe that Mona wasn’t Original A or that there is an Uber A who controlled everything since the very beginning). Lucas could be the key to explain all the plot holes in the show.</span></p> <p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> I’m calling it, Lucas will be the HE going after Alison in season 7.</span></p>
</p><p>
</p> <p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> I’m a big fan of « Lucas is Big Bad » theory. With « Mrs D » return, I really can see a desperate mother looking for her child’s killer in Big Bad’s actions; it doesn’t mean Lucas can’t still be involved. The motive ?</span></p> <p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> Now this is my « crazy » theory last part. I thought Lucas could have been Charlotte’s secret lover. Since PLL beginning, Lucas is way too often and way too much involved in the A game. And as I said earlier, some of his involvement were never fully explained or developed. </span></p> <p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> BUT, the big final twist could be that Lucas was adopted, and is in fact the twin’s son aka Charlotte/Bethany’s brother !!! If the twin couldn’t raised Bethany, it’s logic she wouldn’t be able to raise an other child if she had one.</span></p> <p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> Maybe Lucas was the boy in Bethany’s drawings. Remember the Radley’s var from the episode The First Secret. Lucas could have heard about Bethany around this time, and since began to hate the DiLaurentis. He could also be the one who made Mona to begin the A game (since a huge part of the fandom believe that Mona wasn’t Original A or that there is an Uber A who controlled everything since the very beginning). Lucas could be the key to explain all the plot holes in the show.</span></p> <p style="margin-top:0px;margin-bottom:0px;font-size:14px;line-height:normal;font-family:'HelveticaNeue';"><span style="letter-spacing:0.0px"> I’m calling it, Lucas will be the HE going after Alison in season 7.</span></p>
(Edited by NeedATeam)
<p>This is a thread about Lucas being Uber A. I don't claim that I'm right and that I have figured it all out. I didn't. He is just my number 1 suspect. I appreciate supporting reasons as well as argumentation against Lucas being A. Questions are also welcome. :)
</p><p>(Maybe someone wants to open another topic about who else could be Uber A based on clues he/she found in this new season. ^^ )
</p><p>Here are my reasons why Lucas could be Uber A.
</p><p>1. Lucas has a lot of money now, like Big Bad seems to have.
</p><p>2. We saw Big Bad searching the internet for uniforms after Lucas returned. It was the first time that we saw the new villian in action.
</p><p>3. I saw a toy limousine in Lucas's appartement and Big Bad obviously enjoys his limousine. ^^
</p><p>4. I know it's a stretch, but the person with the mask and the uniforms doesn't seem to be very tall and Lucas isn't the biggest guy either. (However I don't rely much on the height of the new Big Bad.)
</p><p>5. The chauffeur reffered to the new Big Bad as "Sir". It is possible that Big Bad was wearing a mask and dressed up as a guy, but would someone else besides a lover leave red roses on the grave of a deceased?
</p><p>6. Lucas seemed far to willing to lie for Hanna and he even offered her to stay in his appartement. Maybe Lucas did so, because he hid camaras and microphones all over the place to see what the liars are up to.
</p><p>7. User NeedATeam mentioned and I quote: "And in Miss me x 100, Lucas invited Hanna to a party he made because his girlfriend was coming to town. Just at the same time, Cece came back in Rosewood (well maybe she never left, but it was time of Big A's return into the Liars' lives). Also, it was the 100th episode, I believe there was more important scene or information to share than "Lucas has a girlfriend" for such an episode. But yet, it's a detail the writers gave to us, and this woman never show up. "
</p><p>(Thank u for mentioning it. I personally think it could be a big hint that leads to Lucas being Uber A)
</p><p>8. Another clue that Lucas could be Uber A is that Uber A wore a female mask and dress in last nights episode (ep17). I also noticed the female wigs in Uber A's "lair". Lucas was called an hermaphrodite by Ali. Maybe he adverts to it by wearing female stuff.
</p><p>9.BIRTHDAYKAKE mentioned that Emily and Paige used to live in Palo Alto, where Lucas also has one of his three residences. She guessed, that maybe Lucas tipped Paige off that Emily is currently staying in Rosewood and that Rosewood High has a coaching job to offer. - Thnx!-
</p><p>10. I rewatched a scene between Hanna and Lucas, in which they are talking about Rosewood and the things they left behind. Lucas mentions that he bought some factories and mills in Rosewood and that the town gets some tax revenue from it. Hanna replies and I quote: "Local boy makes good." to what Lucas responds: "Yeah, a little of that. Maybe I'm giving this town a second chance."
Hanna further: "I know what you mean, when we finally got out of here, it was so fast that we didn't realize what we left behind." Lucas reacts with a little smile and casts down his eyes.
</p><p>There are 2 things I find odd about this scene. The first one is Lucas saying he wants to give Rosewood a second chance. Maybe a chance for Cece's murderer to come forward. And the second thing is Lucas's reaction about not realizing what they left behind. His respond makes me thing that he is well aware of the things he lost. Maybe his beloved one Cece? ^^
</p><p>For those of u who wants to rewatch the scene I'm talking about:
</p><p>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h_qtkVV_5sY
</p><p>Lucas motive for being Uber A could be, that Charlotte was indeed his girlfriend or maybe just a dear friend he could rely on. Unfortunately he doesn't know who killed Charlotte and he's trying to find it out by scaring the liars, who eventually will do the work for him.
</p><p>(My quess is that Dr. Rollins killed Charlotte. Maybe he had an affair with her, but Charlotte dumped him for some reason. And after she found out about the relationship between Ali and Dr. Rollins Charlotte met the doctor on the bell tower, they got into a big fight and he killed her in his rage. But this thread isn't about who killed Charlotte but why Lucas is Uber A or not. :P)
</p>
(Edited by administrators)
With Mona gone I feel like we will need a someone new to fill the void and sate our thirst for the cray cray. I feel like maybe it could be Lucas I mean I know it sounds out there but I think he could turn out to be a real closet lunatic like a Luke and Mark Grey from The Following level of crazy. I mean lets face it the crazy is what keeps the show going.
(Edited by MrAnonymous)
<p>I know this sounds weird but Lucas is like one of the best characters.....he practically carrys the show...you know what without him there would probably would be no show without him! GO LUCAS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
</p>
(Edited by A Fandom user)
<p>It's just a quick question but I haven't seen Lucas on PLL for a while now, does anyone know if he will come back or if he has left PLL for good?
</p>
(Edited by PrettyLittleTalker2)