All posts by BethanyMontgomeryYoung

<p>I have a sneaky suspicion that Jenna Marshall is Bethany Young and she killed Charlotte Dilaurentis.Firstly, Jenna and Charlotte became very close all of a sudden with Jenna stating that she was like a "Celebrity" to Charlotte, although Charlotte threatened to scratch her eyeballs out in season 3. I feel that Charlotte somehow found out that Jenna was in fact Bethany Young and wanted revenge or blaming Charlotte for killing Toby's mom.I think Jenna was occasionally admitted into Radley due to a mental illness, which only got worse after her accident. I also believe Charlotte Dilaurentis gave Ali the idea of throwing the firework into the Cavanaugh's shed, knowing Jenna would be there. (Charlotte pretended to be Toby and wanted to meet up). Anyways, Jenna ended up blind that night and was sent to Radley after a breakdown and for what happened to Toby! Throughout her stay in Radley and the Blind School,Jenna met a young student doctor named Wren Kingston (who did rotations in both hospitals). and they became close. Jenna told him everything the girls had done to her and he felt sorry for her. </p><p>That Night she broke out of Radley to get revenge on Ali and hurt her mum, hurting her mum would really kill Ali and Charlotte, who Jenna had already suspected had something to do with her accident. Although Jenna had her suspicions, Charlotte passed blame onto Ali,thinking she would be saf and that Jenna was too scared to harm her. She thought Ali's parents would protect  her. Jenna stole Charlotte's clothes and disguised herself in a blonde wig (allowing Kenneth and Radley to believe Charlotte killed her). Throughout the night, Jenna met up with Garret to get the video of her and Toby destroyed before Alison leaked it! Ali would suspect Jenna if anything happened after she threatened her in the Blind School! But Charlotte "killed" Alison, thinking she was Jenna! Then Jenna got away with her plan! Alison stopped and Charlotte suffered as well! Charlotte then wanted to get revenge on Jenna, and that's why Jenna was so scared of her! She knew if she wasn't protected by Shana, Wren or Melissa, Charlotte would kill her! When Jenna was released, she still wanted to get revenge on the girls. However, during the time jump after Charlotte was sent to Welby, Jenna went to visit her. Charlotte initally wanted to gloat about Charlotte being locked up for good, but then she felt bad for her and what the liars did. Charlotte hated Jenna, but saw their friendship as a way out of the hospital!Jenna then met Archer and got him into Welby through her old doctor friend, Wren Kingston. Jenna began to think Charlotte was using her and she began again to think she had something to do with her accident and she wanted Archer to investigate and see what really happened.Archer was originally a spy for Jenna, but he fell for Charlotte and this annoyed Jenna 'cause she was falling in love with him. Jenna eventually found out that it was Charlotte who got the girls to blind her. She then devised a plan to make Charlotte and Archer believe she could get out of Welby and when she was released, Jenna would get revenge! </p><p>Jenna also encouraged Archer to get with Alison to further develop her alibi if anything went wrong in her revenge plan. She wanted Charlotte to feel the hurt and pain she felt when she was blinded! She wanted to make Charlotte angry with Alison and give the police a reason to suspect Alison. Jenna rang Charlotte on the night of her murder and wanted to met up with her. Charlotte told her that they needed to end their friendship and it became clear to Jenna that Charlotte was using her. Jenna was livid and went to the Dilaurentis house to discover that Archer was there, but Charlotte and Alison weren't. When Jenna asked Archer to be with her, Archer told her that he didn't love her. That he wanted to be with Charlotte. He wanted to marry her. Jenna took a handful of Charlotte's flowers and left. Jenna met up with Charlotte at the church and offered her the flowers as a peace offering . Jenna then revealed tht she knew Charlotte was the one who was behind blinding her and she sent Archer in as a spy and Archer loved Jenna. This infuriated Charlotte and she attacked Jenna. They had a fight and when Charlotte turned her back -without thinking- Jenna snapped and stabbed Charlotte in the back of the neck with her stick. When lifeless Charlotte back onto Jenna, Jenna thought she was attacking her again, so she pushed her with brutal force! This knocked Charlotte through the window and to the ground! It's only when she felt the blood on her hands did Jenna know she killed Charlotte. Jenna never wanted to murder her, she just wanted to teach Charlotte a lesson and show her who's boss! Jenna then left town , but came back to pretend to search for answers, when she really needed protection and looked for forgiveness from Toby so he could protect her! Jenna is pretending to be on A.D's team  because she is scared and wants the suspicion off her! She is blaming the liars as a form of revenge and she wants them to suffer. Sara was looking for who killed Charlotte and when she was onto Jenna, she was going to tell A.D, but Jenna got Noel Kahn to kill Sara, so she wouldn't spill her secret.  </p><p>
</p><p>BTW! </p><p>When Spencer was accused of killing "Bethany", it was a part of Charlotte's plan to get her into jail. Charlotte paid off multiple people within Radley, UPenn and Rosewood P.D to infiltrate Bethany's records and get Spencer into the Dollhouse along with the other liars. Mona thought she killed Bethany that night  when in fact, it was Sara Harvey she hit and Melissa buried her. Sara then got out and Charlotte looked after her and helped her.Sara was eventually brainwashed into believing that she owed Charlotte and did her dirty work for her such as breaking into Hollis Medschool and stealing a cadavar(With the help of Wren Kingston), making everyone think Bethany was dead! Charlotte then used it to blackmail Mona and Melissa into her with the A-Game!  Jenna also used "Bethany's" death to get Mona to say she was the one who rang Charlotte the night she died. Jenna also blackmailed Melissa for money so she could pay Noel Kahn to work for her,protect her and to be her eyes and ears! </p>

<p>Okay, so I have a big problem with Jenna Marshall on PLL. She is one of these characters that fans either love her or hate her. I hate her. You see, Jenna Marshall isn't just you're ordinary spiteful evil; she is something much worse. In fact, I feel that she is even worse than Uber A.  </p><p>Firstly, she sexually abused Toby, her step brother. She bribed him into sleeping with her and manipulated him. For one, she has committed the most tedious crimes on the show. Yes, there has been murder, but when you die, that's it. The pain exceeds to exist.Whereas with sexual abuse survivors must deal with there pain for years and years. Just like Toby. It boils my blood everytime people call her the victim, when clearly she is the biggest villain on the show. </p><p>When did it come okay to express sympathy for an abuser? A rapist? Do we feel sorry for Bill Crosby? No, we hate Bill Crosby! Then why do we feel so sorry for Jenna! It's like people are rooting for her and it makes me sick!  </p><p>Yes, I know! The Liars blinded her! Hasn't she been through enough? Actually, no! Hasn't Toby been through enough before she molested him? He had just lost his mother and she had been replaced so quickly! He was so alone and all he wanted was peace and stability! Jenna Marshall ruined that for him in the worst way possible! Manipulating him and taking his fears for granted! This is not on! What the Liars did to Jenna was karma and they do not deserve to be punished for it.  </p><p>I feel like if Toby did it to Jenna, it would be a completely different story. That's always the case it this world and it makes me ill to think about it. Sexual abuse towards women is not justified, but towards men it is even worse. Men are seen as weak, emasculated, etc. by others. This is not fair! Not wonder Toby wanted to become a cop! He wanted to make a difference for people who didn't have a voice. People like him.  </p><p>I don't want to make this rant too long, so I am going to end with this; Jenna Marshall is the most villainous character on PLL for what she did. We always see hate for Ezra when he was with Aria, because she was younger! Well, did Ezra force Aria to do something she didn't want to do? No! Did he manipulate her or blackmail her into granting him sexual favors? No! Did Jenna do any of these things! YES! So, maybe we should focus our time into seeing her for what she really is; a sex offender! Let's not forget it! </p><p>PS If you have ever been abused in any way, just remember you have a voice. Use it to the best of your ability! Fight, fight, fight again for justice!  </p>

<p>So, I know what a lot of you guys are thinking. A.D is a guy! It was confirmed in the flash forward at the end of 6X10. Well, my good friend, not entirely! From what we have seen from the previews of season 7 and from what we know of season 6b, they "He" chasing Ali is, in fact, Dr. Elliot Rollins. He is manipulating and abusing Alison to make sure he controls the Carissimi Group. The Liars will eventually realise this and attempt to save Alison from Dr. Rollins and Mary, leading to some big climax. That flash forward was to trick us into thinking that Uber A  is a man when, in fact, it could be a woman. </p><p>Now after I have cleared that up, I want to delve into the origin of Maya St. Germain or A.D. Maya was born to Mary Drake and Eddie Lamb. Mary was admitted to Radley, where she met a young student nurse named Eddie. The pair fell in love and had a romantic relationship, which resulted in Mary getting pregnant. Mary and Eddie didn't want anyone to find out because Eddie could loose his job and they wouldn't be allowed to see each again, so she had her daughter Maya in secret. Maya was given to Eddie's sister (who couldn't have children) and this allowed him to keep an eye on his daughter as she grew up! With both of her children gone, Mary became bitter and her relationship with Eddie ended after they were caught by Charles, who  told Jessica, who was on the board. Jessica warned Eddie to stay away from her vulnerable sister or he would loose his job. Mary then became hateful towards Jessica. Her mental state allowed her to believe that Jessica was the reason behind her loosing her children, being locked up in Radley and she hated Jessica for having a perfect family with a perfect husband.(This later fueled Mary's revenge when she killed Jessica).  </p><p>However, a few years later, Maya and her adoptive parents moved to Rosewood in an attempt to tell her about her real family. The st. Germaines had hoped that when they confused about Maya being adopted and that her biological parents resided in Radley, that it would be easier for her to communicate with them.But Maya's drug habit had gotten in the way and her parents had to get her stable before she could find out about her past.  </p><p>When Charles transitioned into Charlotte, she began to search her family and she went to Eddie about "Maya". Charlotte blackmailed Eddie into telling her and she tracked her down and they had a close relationship. Charlotte told Maya all about her family and what happened between Eddie and Mary, which shocked Maya to her core. It also contributed to her relapse and sent her to True North. There, Maya met Landon, who stalked her and harrassed her. In an attempt to help her sister, Charlotte helped Maya fake her death live out a free life with her mother, Mary, who was also out of the country. Maya willingly did so, always accepting that she owed her sister.  </p><p>When Charlotte went to France, it was to see Mary and Maya. Mary had just killed Jessica and was having a psychotic episode and Maya needed help. Once again, Maya owed her sister.  </p><p>Charlotte and Wren were friends,so  she told Wren about Mary and Eddie and how he gave away Mary's baby! Wren was distraught over this and, due to issues with his own father, teased Eddie and threated him everytime he questioned Wren's illegal activities as a doctor. When Eddie seen Aria that day in Radley, he thought it was Mary coming back for him. He had always loved her and Maya, but he couldn't go to jail and loose his job. (Mary was a vulnerable patient, it could be seen as rape).  </p><p>When Charlotte was murdered, Maya knew it was the perfect opportunity to avenge her sister after everything she did for her. She is A.D (After Death) because it was Charlotte's game and she wants to bring her killer to justice. </p><p>I have a feeling that "Mary had a little lamb" comes into play here. Mary had a little lamb (Maya Lamb(Eddie's child)) who's fleece was white as snow (Maybe this refers to the wool cap in her bag that she ran away with (a gift from either Eddie or Mary))/ everywhere Mary went,the lamb would surely go (When Mary was at the Lostwood's Restort, so was Maya and she kidnapped Hanna)  </p><p>Also, the photo of Alison and Shanna was actually Ali and Maya, who visited Ali sometimes, but neither remember.  </p><p>"MAYA KNEW" was about Charlotte telling Maya about the diaries and what she and Alison did. Maya also visited Charlotte a couple of times when Mona was in Radley. Maya knew the -A game was starting again and wanted to help her sister, but wasn't revealed because Charlotte was protecting her again.  </p><p>"Lord help the mister who comes between me and my sister"- refers to Landon trying to kill Maya/ Wilden tracking Alison (who was her best friend)  </p> <hr><p>If you have any questions, just ask and I will try to respond to them as best I can!! :) </p>

<p>I have a theory, so just hear me out. What if Toby is Charlotte's brother and Mary's son. When Mary went to Radley, she had Toby and had to put him up for adoption. Jessica wouldn't take him because she already had Charlotte and Jason (Maybe even pregnant with Alison), so Toby was put up for adoption and was finally adopted by Marion Cavanaugh. Toby grew up, always thinking that Marion was his biological mother. Eventually, Marion ended up in Radley due to a mental illness, where she met Mary Drake. She and Mary became best friends, sharing secrets. Once Toby came to visit Marion and when Marion told Mary that she had adopted Toby from Radley, Mary clicked. She began to hate Marion and seeked revenge. It was Mary who pushed Marion off the roof, not Bethany. Charlotte wanted to protect her mother, who manipulated her into thinking that if Radley found out about what happened, Mary would be taken away. Mary convinced the board that it was Charlotte who killed Marion, all the while, pretending to be on Charlotte's side.  </p><p>It was when Toby joined the A-Team and began searching for answers about his mother that he found out about Mary. Mary began to tell Toby of how his mother stole him from her and Toby felt sorry for her.  Toby was always on the A-Team with Charlotte. There was always Charlotte, Toby and Sara. Toby was only a spy when he dated Spencer, but eventually fell for her which made the game harder.  </p><p>Maybe Toby stayed in Rosewood for the same reason as Alison; to look after Charlotte. When she was murdered, Toby decided , along with Mad Mary and Elliot to find out who did it.  </p><p>You're probably asking who kidnapped Hanna? That was Melissa. Melissa is being blackmailed by Toby and the A -Team to find out who killed Charlotte. Toby is using the "Bethany Thing" to get her to torment the liars. It eliminates Toby as a suspect as well as creates a sense of surprise if he is revealed to be Uber A. However, Toby is pulling all the strings. This is his game and he is the puppet master. </p><p>Toby was born Anthony Drake (A.D). A.D also stands for A After Death, which means that the A game will continue after Charlotte's death.  </p><p>Marlene King posted three emojis on instagram after the finale ; a pair of glasses, a notebook and a magnifying glass. I think the glasses represent Toby wearing a pair when he was with Spencer and the notebook and magnifying glass represent Mary's medical records and Spencer, Toby and Mona sleuthing through the Radley tunnels. </p><p>
</p><p>What do you guys think? Do you have anything to add to this theory? Who do you guys think is Uber A? </p>