All posts by Spenstolemyheart

I just think it shows that he was spying on Nolan and he thought if anybody found it they would thought he killed him. I think we can pretty much take him off the list of suspects now for killing Nolan, I don't really have a idea who it is now unless it is a secret Hotchkiss kid or maybe his dad isn't really dead. I thought for weeks now that it was gonna be Jeremy that did it he was about my only suspect so I guess a Hotchkiss family member is my guess now. 

I didnt really think of him being a Hotchkiss but I did think when we first found out who he was he might've killed Nolan to frame it on Ava to get back at her dad but I'm leaning more towards he just suppose to be her new love interest now. 

As soon as the Caitlyn/Jeremy scene came on the only think I thought of was Spencer and Andrew these writers dont like to come up with new things to write do they?

Cupcakes

Yeah the only thing I thought of when we found out it was Mason was we gonna have another Aria situation on the show. 

Yeah I dont think its her either after they mentioned her name she went all the way to the bottom of my suspect list but tbh she never was high anyway. 

I dont think Marlene thought it through all the way or she just didnt think we would notice. 

Great points about Jeremy I do think he's guilty of something but just dont really know what yet. I'm leaning towards he's the one that killed Nolan and for Mona's chess partner i keep thinking Taylor for some reason dont really have a lot of evidence to back it up but to me she's the most logical answer. 

I agree I think more then likely Taylor and Nolan knew about the secret child if it is one and thats my understanding to about it was because of Nolan's dad's death. 

Yeah I think Mason is a good choice to be a secret sibling we know Caitlyn and Nolan's families are connected somehow maybe just through politics but maybe more and we know Caitlyn's mom has cheated on her other mom so it wouldn't surprise me if that wasnt the first time it happened. We just dont know much of anything yet about Nolan's dad but we know with Marlene we dont usually get outstanding parents. 

Yeah I tried to pay close attention to how she acted when she first saw Taylor but its still to hard to tell if it supposed to been a clue or not. 

I dont really trust any flashbacks we see this early in the show I think its a good chance Nolan did tell Taylor who he was gonna meet that night and she just hasn't told Ali yet maybe she just wanted to make sure she can trust Ali completely before she told her everything. I'm thinking if she did know who was meeting Nolan (if it wasnt suppose to be Ali)that will be the next suspect after Mason and Dana that they look into. 

Yeah I agree I dont wanna see a twin of secret sibling again but I think we better get use to the idea because it seems like it coming. Please dont let Ali be the secret sibling I think that would be my biggest nightmare of the show. 

I dont have anything to add at all because I probably never played more then five games of chess in my life but this is interesting and I think you could be on to something but I got no idea what besides like you said this could be a hint to Mona's chess partner(maybe Taylor or Taylor's twin). Very well done that had to take a lot of research if you'll like me and have no idea what these terms means. This theory reminds me so much of Libby for some reason could be the Google research but like I said I think you're on to something. Great job!

Tbh if the show continues on for couple seasons I think I want the twin now instead of the big\last reveal like in PLL but like others have said I'll be happy with no twin at all but I can't see that happening with Marlene so if its coming let's get it out of the way now so we can focus on the clues for future seasons. 

I think if Taylor does have the twin then thats most likely who we're seeing now. 

I dont think we gonna have masks(Yet) but I do think its a good chance of a Hotchkiss twin. 

She's not anywhere near the top of my list but I do think just like you said this could be away to make us not even think of her as a suspect which make her more of a suspect for me(hope that makes sense). If I had to guess rn I dont think she's gonna be either person but I think she could be Mona's chess partner. NellyBell do you think the one we seen Nolan meet with was his killer or do you think he meet his killer later?

I think its a real good chance Taylor or Nolan has a secret twin(maybe not a secret the Hotchkiss kids seemed to know a lot what was going on. So maybe they knew of the twin but just didnt let anybody else know that they knew. That could be one of the reasons Taylor didn't trust Claire). 

I think its a decent chance of Taylor killing Nolan but she's not one of my top suspects. What's everybody guess on if the person we seen Nolan meeting is the one that really killed him? I think I'm leaning towards that wasnt really the one that killed him and he meet with the real killer later(another nod to the original show) and I agree please no masks and twins. 

I think we're gonna see a twin but dont have any idea who it will be but Nolan seems like a good choice ATM .