FANDOM


  • I think Bethany could be CeCe.I had many ideas about Bethany : - We never saw her face, no photo, no flash-back...- She appeared in the show lately but seems to be important though. Maybe we know her better than we think?- So Bethany may be alive, and be a character we know. If she is a stranger, why not show us her face? It seems to me the producers are hiding her identity from us!  I’ve read several theories about Bethany being Maya, Meredith, etc. As for me I think she could be CeCe. Let’s compare them : - Bethany has been to Radley and CeCe seems to also have some link with Radley (I remember she took Ali’s identity to go to Radley, but maybe there’s something else. Maybe she could have been a patient?)- Alison and Bethany knew each other. Alison and CeCe did too.- Bethany had kind of strange relations with Mrs D : Mrs D gave her a horse, but in the same time they seem to be really in bad terms (there are also Bethany’s drawings). Mrs D didn’t like CeCe, she didn’t like her friendship with Ali, but I have a feeling she tolerates her all the same, as if she could’t get rid of her so she accepts her presence.  We know Mrs D had an affair with Bethany’s father. She may then be Bethany’s mother (many clues make me think that). If Bethany=CeCe, CeCe is Mrs D’s daughter! I suppose Bethany/CeCe is the one who hit Alison the night she disappeared. Mrs D saw her do that, and thinks Ali is dead. She decides to hide everything from the police because Bethany/CeCe is also her daughter. She buries Ali and keeps saying to Bethany/CeCe « What have you done?! » and then helps her run away. Then Bethany disappears until it’s not dangerous anymore to come back, and reappears as CeCe Drake.  CeCe and Bethany aren't the same age, but if CeCe Drake is a fake ID, her age may be fake too.  If Alison and Bethany are both alive, the girl buried in the DiLaurentis’ backyard must be someone else. Probably Sara Harvey, the girl who went missing on the same day as Alison. Maybe she was killed there by chance, or maybe someone killed and buried her in order to make people believe it’s Ali’s body (MonA, or Ali herself, to protect her disappearance?!) This theory doesn’t explain why CeCe tried to kill Alison, or why they are know friends again, but I’ve never seen a PLL theory that explains everything xD PS: Sorry for my bad english, it’s not my mother tongue. Hope you can understand what I’ve written :-) 

      Loading editor
    • Great theory! Love it, and you're right, none theory explains everything. Your english is great, too :))

        Loading editor
    • I think that would be too expected, good theory, but extremely expected

        Loading editor
    • ^^^:eh not really as great a theory as that is. 1:Bethany is dead and in Ali's grave not only that but Cece has Blonde Hair Blue eyes,Bethany Had Blonde hair Unknown eye color. Plus Bethany's dad is Mr young and Bethany's mom is unknown.

      2:Jessica is the only one in the Dilaurentis family who had an affair with Peter Hastings that resulted in her having Jason and Kenneth being Jason's legal father instead of birth father while she was married to Kenneth and then she had an affair with mr young that probably resulted in Bethany iam pretty sure he doesn't about either affair because mr d is about as clueless as a clueless cop that mixed up Allison&Bethany for who was in Ali's grave when it comes to Jessica having 2 affairs along with one secret kid and one possible secret kid.

      3:Marlene king confirmed we get to learn what happened to Sara Harvey plus come on Bethany has Blonde hair Unknown eye color,Sara Harvey has blonde hair Hazel eyes,and Ali has blonde hair blue eyes.kind of seems more obvious the writers would only mix up Allison and Bethany for who's in Ali's grave and not Bethany and Sara because even Jessica&Melissa couldn't tell Bethany was not Allison when Bethany was getting burried alive by Melissa because Bethany was wearing Ali's yellow shirt and depending on Bethany's eye color I would think one of them would of noticed the eye color not being blue like Allison's. Because all both Melissa and Jessica notice is Ali's Yellow Shirt and automatically think it's Allison and Not Bethany so apparently Bethany& Allison must look like twins to both Melissa&Jessica because apparently all both of them notice is Ali's yellow shirt.

      4:so with getting to know what happened to Sara Harvey probably somewhere in the season 5 and with A being revealed in the season 5 finale it means there is still hope for Sara to be alive because the cops with Sara's disappearances never found Sara's body they only found her bike at the park there's still hope for her.

      5:Bethany=Cece wouldn't work Bethany's eye color Is unknown and plus all the pll fans think Bethany is dead and in Ali's grave that wouldn't work there's no way someone dragged Sara's body into Ali's grave to replace Bethany's corpse that is already confirmed as being Bethany's in the pilot. But I can't see Bethany being alive changing her name to cece.its too much of a excepted theory with Bethany=Cece

      6:It's possible mrs D Had another kid that is Bethany through the affair she had with mr young. But I don't think Bethany would equal cece.

      It's a great theory with Bethany=Cece but the writers would probably know that it is too much of an expected theory it's a very great one but it's too expected plus Bethany is like 17-18 while cece is like 23

        Loading editor
    • You say it's an expected theory, but really, I've not seen a lot of similar theories. Basically, I've read two or three theories about Bethany being CeCe, not more. So I don't think it'd be so expected as you say.

      To GirlMeetsWorldFan123 : you say Bethany is 17. That's not true. She was 17 when she disappeared, that is in 2009. She must now be older. I'm not sure in which year we're supposed to be in the show now, but assuming it's 2015, she must be approximatevely 22. 

      I know my theory is probably not true, but with PLL we never know what can happen :-) 

        Loading editor
    • GirlMeetsWorldFan123 wrote:
      ^^^:eh not really as great a theory as that is.

      1:Bethany is dead and in Ali's grave not only that but Cece has Blonde Hair Blue eyes,Bethany Had Blonde hair Unknown eye color. Plus Bethany's dad is Mr young and Bethany's mom is unknown.

      2:Jessica is the only one in the Dilaurentis family who had an affair with Peter Hastings that resulted in her having Jason and Kenneth being Jason's legal father instead of birth father while she was married to Kenneth and then she had an affair with mr young that probably resulted in Bethany iam pretty sure he doesn't about either affair because mr d is about as clueless as a clueless cop that mixed up Allison&Bethany for who was in Ali's grave when it comes to Jessica having 2 affairs along with one secret kid and one possible secret kid.

      3:Marlene king confirmed we get to learn what happened to Sara Harvey plus come on Bethany has Blonde hair Unknown eye color,Sara Harvey has blonde hair Hazel eyes,and Ali has blonde hair blue eyes.kind of seems more obvious the writers would only mix up Allison and Bethany for who's in Ali's grave and not Bethany and Sara because even Jessica&Melissa couldn't tell Bethany was not Allison when Bethany was getting burried alive by Melissa because Bethany was wearing Ali's yellow shirt and depending on Bethany's eye color I would think one of them would of noticed the eye color not being blue like Allison's. Because all both Melissa and Jessica notice is Ali's Yellow Shirt and automatically think it's Allison and Not Bethany so apparently Bethany& Allison must look like twins to both Melissa&Jessica because apparently all both of them notice is Ali's yellow shirt.

      4:so with getting to know what happened to Sara Harvey probably somewhere in the season 5 and with A being revealed in the season 5 finale it means there is still hope for Sara to be alive because the cops with Sara's disappearances never found Sara's body they only found her bike at the park there's still hope for her.

      5:Bethany=Cece wouldn't work Bethany's eye color Is unknown and plus all the pll fans think Bethany is dead and in Ali's grave that wouldn't work there's no way someone dragged Sara's body into Ali's grave to replace Bethany's corpse that is already confirmed as being Bethany's in the pilot. But I can't see Bethany being alive changing her name to cece.its too much of a excepted theory with Bethany=Cece

      6:It's possible mrs D Had another kid that is Bethany through the affair she had with mr young. But I don't think Bethany would equal cece.

      It's a great theory with Bethany=Cece but the writers would probably know that it is too much of an expected theory it's a very great one but it's too expected plus Bethany is like 17-18 while cece is like 23

      It was dark outside so I highly doubt that Melissa would have paid any attention to Bethany's eye color while she was burying her. Melissa saw Ali wearing the exact same outfit earlier that night, so why would she think any differently? If I thought my sister had murdered someone, the dead girl's eye color would have been the least of my worries. 

        Loading editor
    • It's hard enough to believe Melissa buried a girl she got mixed up with Ali. It must have been really dark and she never looked at her face. That's the only way I buy it.

      The question is did the person who killed Bethany (the one who struck her, I know Melissa technically "killed her") think it was Alison? Or did they kill Bethany on purpose? Was it personal to Bethany, or was she killed so a comparable body would be in that grave?

        Loading editor
    • This is a good theory! It totally makes sense because in the christmas episode, Mrs. D had bought only TWO of the same dresses that Ali found in the Piano. CeCe was wearing the same yellow top as Ali the night Ali dissapeared. If Bethany isn't CeCe and she was found wearing the same top...why would they all three have that same top if the producers made it a point to show Mrs. D only buying two dresses?

      If that makes any sense lol

        Loading editor
    • +Sierra MC:Yeah but there's A few problems with that theory Bethany is like 17-18 years old and Cece is 23-24 years old. Plus Bethany is dead. So unless the writers are lying about the age of bethany when she killed,Bethany and cece aren't even the same age. Plus also Bethany was Mistaken for Allison and jessica told Bethany to call her "Aunt Jessie" when Bethany was at Radley". Plus cece being Bethany is a great theory but it's also too much of an expected theory also. The writers wouldnt make cece and Bethany the same person. Plus as far as anyone knows Bethany at this point is 100% dead.

        Loading editor
    • +SierraMc:Don't get me wrong here I just said it's a great theory but it's also too expected. There's a lot of other things we would have to consider before Bethany and cece end up as the same person.but right now mostly things don't add up because Bethany is Dead and Cece is alive.Although I guess maybe it's possible either Cece or Allison have a twin sister named Bethany maybe,because I read somewhere that there is a character on the show that is suppose to represent Courtney from the book. I just believe the writters probably switched things up on the show to make it different then the book. But it's possible maybe Cece is like a half sister to Allison and Bethany but then again on the show anything is possible like Allison and Bethany being twins because Bethany gets mistaken by both jessica and Melissa as Allison the night Bethany dies. But again anything is possible but Bethany and cece being the same person is too expected plus cece is apart of the A Team And Bethany was Killed by A. But still anything is possible. But Bethany and Cece being the same person just does not add up mostly because there's a lot to consider with it. And if I can find the link back from where it said in some way courtney Is represented on the show I'd send it to you I just can't remember what the site was. There's too many sites on different stuff that it gets hard to keep track of it all. But there is a site that mentioned something about courtney that had to do with Allison's twin story i just think the writers switched things up a bit to make it different then the book so people would watch it more.

        Loading editor
    • Lady Morwen is right..Bethany was 17 when she "died". but that was 2009 so she would actually be older than 17/18 right now if she were alive... I wouldn't put it past the writers to make another fake death like with Alison. A creator said that someone else is alive that is thought to be dead other than Alison and Mona, so it could very well be Bethany. A is definetly capable of switching whatever they need to to get their way...whether it be medical records or something.

      As far as you saying she told her to call her aunt Jessie, yeah she could be her aunt and wanted to keep her away from Alison for obvious reasons, but still loved her because she was family. I think Bethany/CeCe is Marion Cavanaugh's daughter and Marion and Jessica are sisters. Thats why she was taking care of her. Thats why they exchanged looks when CeCe was being arrested...they definetly have some sort of history.

      Also Jason and CeCe dated and she told him she "had her reasons for dumping him and she'd rather not tell him why" . Maybe its because that would be incest

        Loading editor
    • Yeahhh, no I'm not saying she is her twin by any means lol

        Loading editor
    • +SierraMC:one of the writers did say we would learn what happened to Sara Harvey the other girl who was like 17 when she died the one who's body was never found after the bike Incident in the park who was last seen by one of her friends,the one with blonde hair and Hazel eyes.Because Marlene King confirmed on Twitter that we would get to find out what happened to Sara Harvey,so maybe it's Sara Harvey who is alive because for the cops never found Sara's body and Sara's Status says Unknown plus the last person to see Sara before she vanished was Avery. Plus if cops can't find a body there's no way to prove Sara is Physically Dead they can't do tests on the body to find out what happened to Sara,what kind of damage she got from her incident...I'd say sara Harvey still has a chance for surivial. Where as Bethany's body was found burried in the first epsoide of pretty little lairs when Maya's family was moving in and the Gazebo was getting put up.

        Loading editor
    • +SierraMc:Ik i was just clarifying because it would make sense for why Bethany got mistaken For Allison just like when Courtney was Mistaken for Allison by their parents in the books. It would explain why mrs couldn't tell Allison and Bethany appart in a yellow shirt that was Allison's shirt because Bethany has blonde hair and unknown Eye color,While Allison has blonde hair and Blue Eyes Ik its dark out when Bethany dies but still maybe Bethany's eye color could be Blue.Plus it would explain why The writers mixed up Allison and Bethany for who was in the grave.

        Loading editor
    • +SierraMc:Plus you would be right about jason and cece's relationship being incest because depending on who cece's mom and dad are that would techincally make jason and Cece half siblings through one of Jason's parents.

        Loading editor
    • Yeah...I just don't think we can ever rule anything out 100% on Pretty Little Liars lol

        Loading editor
    • +SierraMc:Ik right! A lot of people want Sara Harvey to be the one In the grave when one the writters would have to explain how Sara's body got all the way from the park to The grave.I believe Sara Harvey was found and taken to a hospital it would explain why the cops never found her body and just found her bike. Because without a body being found at the crime scene they can't even find out how she died. They can't do tests to see if anyone else's DNA is on her. You can't even say she's really 100% dead without the body as proof. I'd seriously say there's like a 50/50 chance on whether or not Sara Harvey is alive or dead. The cops only found the bike but not the body.its a lot like when the cops couldn't find Ian's body at the crime but then his body found somewhere else I just believe Sara's story ends with her in a hospital giving her a chance to be alive because Iam pretty sure if Sara was 100% dead they would of found her body along time ago.

        Loading editor
    • Another reason CeCe can't be Bethany is because CeCe once showed up at Radley pretending to be Alison. Bethany was probably there at the time. She couldn't pretend to be Ali, everyone there knew her. 

      Even the argument of CeCe being Bethany's twin doesn't work, for the same reason, and the age difference.

      I do think it is significant we haven't been shown Bethany's face yet. But I don't know if it's because her face will resemble someone else on the show, or because they don't want to cast someone yet.

        Loading editor
    • ^it would probably take a long time to cast the right person to play bethany which is why we haven't been shown her face yet. So right now as far as people know bethany is dead and in the grave.

        Loading editor
    • Lady Morwen wrote:
      I think Bethany could be CeCe.I had many ideas about Bethany : - We never saw her face, no photo, no flash-back...- She appeared in the show lately but seems to be important though. Maybe we know her better than we think?- So Bethany may be alive, and be a character we know. If she is a stranger, why not show us her face? It seems to me the producers are hiding her identity from us!  I’ve read several theories about Bethany being Maya, Meredith, etc. As for me I think she could be CeCe. Let’s compare them : - Bethany has been to Radley and CeCe seems to also have some link with Radley (I remember she took Ali’s identity to go to Radley, but maybe there’s something else. Maybe she could have been a patient?)- Alison and Bethany knew each other. Alison and CeCe did too.- Bethany had kind of strange relations with Mrs D : Mrs D gave her a horse, but in the same time they seem to be really in bad terms (there are also Bethany’s drawings). Mrs D didn’t like CeCe, she didn’t like her friendship with Ali, but I have a feeling she tolerates her all the same, as if she could’t get rid of her so she accepts her presence.  We know Mrs D had an affair with Bethany’s father. She may then be Bethany’s mother (many clues make me think that). If Bethany=CeCe, CeCe is Mrs D’s daughter! I suppose Bethany/CeCe is the one who hit Alison the night she disappeared. Mrs D saw her do that, and thinks Ali is dead. She decides to hide everything from the police because Bethany/CeCe is also her daughter. She buries Ali and keeps saying to Bethany/CeCe « What have you done?! » and then helps her run away. Then Bethany disappears until it’s not dangerous anymore to come back, and reappears as CeCe Drake.  CeCe and Bethany aren't the same age, but if CeCe Drake is a fake ID, her age may be fake too.  If Alison and Bethany are both alive, the girl buried in the DiLaurentis’ backyard must be someone else. Probably Sara Harvey, the girl who went missing on the same day as Alison. Maybe she was killed there by chance, or maybe someone killed and buried her in order to make people believe it’s Ali’s body (MonA, or Ali herself, to protect her disappearance?!) This theory doesn’t explain why CeCe tried to kill Alison, or why they are know friends again, but I’ve never seen a PLL theory that explains everything xD PS: Sorry for my bad english, it’s not my mother tongue. Hope you can understand what I’ve written :-) 

      That's what I call a premonition ! You were almost 100% right about Cece being related to Mrs D. You saw it clear !!! Now about the Bethany theory, I believe it could still be true too, since in PLL everything's possible. Every (not that much in fact) details we have on Bethany could be just fake. Never seen parents; 17 years when she died... I'd say to the writers prove it ! show us a real and concret flashback from Eddie Lamb, Leslie, Big Rhonda or whoever that shows Bethany's adult face !!! So far, the only situation where we saw both Charlotte and Bethany share a scene was Charlotte's flashback. So yes, it could seems crazy or silly, but I'll wait for better proof of Bethany's existence !

      My real issue with this theory would be: who's the girl in the grave if Cece = Beth and Sara is really Sara ? (maybe the show will end with the revelation that Bethany was a fake ID, and the mystery of the dead girl will be answer in a movie, haha !).

        Loading editor
    • Cece Drake is Bethany Young, daughter or Mary Drake. That would explain the explosion of Toby's house when her "death" is confirmed. Sara is Charles DiLaurentis (they are brothers). They kidnap this girl "Sara" and Charles took her image (for his transition). So the file Spencer discover last episode was of Mary Drake, and Cece Drake's real age is 25 now. In the video of a little Charles and Jason, the baby is not Alison but Bethany, that's why Mary Drake (not Jessica) said kiss your sister to Charles. 



      So apparently, Jessica destroyed Mary's family. And even started an affair with Bethany's father. 

        Loading editor
    • Pllbyjaz wrote:

      Cece Drake is Bethany Young, daughter or Mary Drake. That would explain the explosion of Toby's house when her "death" is confirmed. Sara is Charles DiLaurentis (they are brothers). They kidnap this girl "Sara" and Charles took her image (for his transition). So the file Spencer discover last episode was of Mary Drake, and Cece Drake's real age is 25 now. In the video of a little Charles and Jason, the baby is not Alison but Bethany, that's why Mary Drake (not Jessica) said kiss your sister to Charles. 



      So apparently, Jessica destroyed Mary's family. And even started an affair with Bethany's father. 

      By June of 2016, hadn't the reveal of Cece/Charlotte/Charles already been done? Why would you state as fact that poor dead Bethany - who allegedly killed Toby's Mom but that whole bit was some of the worst writing ever - and Cece were the same person? Why would that have anything to do with Toby's parents house being blown up? 

      You also think Sara is Charles. Huh? You think Sara used to be a boy and who did you think was her "brother"?

      I will say this - no way did that file just happen to be there. That was too silly! I think I heard AD say in hthe finale that "That file [it sounded like she said "fall"! The Closed Captioning even read "fall"] Charlotte found..." (Someone thought it was actual gold or somehing and wanted to steal it)  You mucked up a LOT but still came to a correct conclusion, if we believe Mary Drake's version of things, that Jessica "destroyed Mary's family".  And yes, she had one of her many affairs with Bethany's dad, but they are in no way related. The DiLaurentis family did pay for a few funerals for Bethany though, since  the ME in Rosewood was really sucky at his or her job! Oops!

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.