FANDOM


  • Screen Shot 2015-03-13 at 4.23.48 PM

    byron


    The name Byron means "barn and cows"Click Here for Proof


    Screen Shot 2015-03-13 at 4.29.55 PM

    cow

    Tumblr nfh2a9Tps01td6etoo1 1280

    barn






    This is a clip of 5x24 where ARIA and MIKE find a cow tongue inside a box. Why a cow tongue? Why this A message to them to stay quiet?

    Screen Shot 2015-03-19 at 9.37.48 PM




    Marlene instagrammed this picture, 4 months ago, with the caption: "It's A sign.Click Here To See Her Instagram Post


    Redcoat

    wrendrawing




    Second definition of cow as a verb. Hm.


    This is Wren's drawing. It is of a family infront of a barn. There is a father, mother, young girl, and little boy. The young girl and little boy seem to have the same age difference as Aria and Mike. So, you see, Byron, Ella, Aria and Mike. And several cows to their left and one on their right.



    Velkomnir means welcome in Icelandic.

    Screen Shot 2015-03-13 at 12.50.46 AM
    Listen to the voice at the beginning of the #bigAreveal preview say "velkomnir".
    Pretty Little Liars - Big A Reveal-0

    Pretty Little Liars - Big A Reveal-0

    Who spontaneously decided to move his family to Iceland for a year after Alison went missing?

    FullSizeRender-2

    byron

    Byron is big A.  Bethany Young is Byron's illegimate daughter. I am confident that Aria knew nothing about this. Alison discovered her mother (or aunt Marion) was having an affair with Byron. Jessica, not having the ideal mother-daugher relationship with Alison, tries to redeem herself by pursuing one with Bethany (her daughter OR possible niece). She attempts to have the bond with her that she never had with Alison. Alison catches on to this and discovers who Bethany really is. She threatens to make a call to Aria if Byron doesn't give her the money she needs. "You know how much it'll hurt Aria if you make that call." The writers made the audience believe the entire Alison/Byron beef was about Meredith. But Aria already knew about Meredith. And Byron knew that Aria knew, he saw them watching him kiss Meredith in the car. The affair with Meredith happened and was even resolved before that fatal night. Aria, Hanna, and Emily even had a conversation about the affair being over before then in episode 3x15. Meredith has always been a red herring when it comes to Byron's involvement with the disappearance of Alison. Byron knew he could not keep paying Alison to stay quiet. Ella was beginning to notice that it was not there, as he mentioned in 3x14. In episode 3x16, Meredith  tells Aria that Byron went to her place that night furious about Alison. She begged him not to go meet Alison but says he went anyway. So when he did, Alison warned him that it was his last chance to save himself, he agreed that it was (for a reason), saw Melissa come out the door on the phone, and eventually walked away (passed the shovel). Many of us believed that was the end of it. But moments after, I believe he returned. He had to put an end to it. And in his last opportunity to save himself and protect his family and Bethany, he picked up the shovel and hit who he thought was Alison. When he saw that it was infact Bethany, his own daughter, he absolutely lost his mind. He leaves and immediately begins looking for Alison. 

    Bethany is alison
    This is when Melissa discovers Bethany's body. 
    Alison42410

    alisonfinale

    Once Alison arrives on her lawn, Byron picks up a rock and slams it in the back of her head. Mrs. D runs out in horror and loses it. Byron tells her it is all Alison's fault. She knew about Bethany. He tried to scare her into staying quiet about it with threats and messages but she wouldn't listen. She wouldn't back down. He tells her he accidentally killed (or harmed) Bethany. Jessica is devastated. Byron then immediately forces her to bury Alison, maybe even by holding her at gunpoint. Alison awakened but could only see her mother burying her, which led her to falsely believe she was protecting the one who did it. What mother could do that? Seriously?
    IMG 5544

    MRS D

    She wasn't protecting someone else, she was being forced to bury Alison by A (Byron). Or else she would die as well. "I buried your Mom the way I watched her bury you." A was clearly present in that moment.

    FullSizeRender-4

    byron


    After that night, Byron decided to move his family to Iceland for a year! Why? To help Aria cope with losing Alison? To get away from Meredith? An affair he still hadn't been caught in by Ella or Mike?


    Weak motive. How about moving to Iceland because you accidentally murdered someone?

    IMG 5701


    VICTIMS:

    Tumblr inline n2royl5YB11rfzmq2

    Ian Thomas








    It wasn't until they returned from Iceland that the murders started taking place. And they weren't random. After faking his death at the bell tower, Ian Thomas escaped and was later killed. His killer made it look like a suicide and even left a suicide note (with handwriting similar to Byron's).


    FullSizeRender



    Byron's behavior at Ian's funeral was strange. While everyone was looking forward to the casket, Byron kept drifting his focus to the side. Guilty?




    Aria and Garrett

    Garrett Reynolds

    Garrett Reynolds told Spencer that he saw Byron in a heated exchange with Alison the night she disappeared. Spencer tells him she is gonna go get Aria so that he can tell her what he saw that night. As soon as she walks out, Garrett is killed. Right before he was gonna tell Aria the truth about her father. Aria later learns about it from Spencer, but I believe there was more that he saw. Remember in the flash back, he didn't walk away. He hid behind another tree to hear more. It was said by Melissa that Wilden was sent to the Halloween train to kill Garrett, that he was taking orders. Whoever was bossing him around must have been a powerful, older figure.

    Darren-wilden-dead

    Darren Wilden


    Det. Wilden was killed immediately after the lodge fire, which Melissa said he started. Red Coat pulled them out and saved them. Ali said when she got there, the rest of them were safe. She only helped Hanna. So if the lodge fire was A's plan than why did Red Coat pull them out? I believe Wilden tried to cross Big A and set the lodge on fire, putting Aria and the liars in serious danger. Big A (Byron) killed Wilden for almost setting Aria on fire.

    Pretty-little-liars-mrs-dilaurentis-blog

    Jessica DiLaurentis


    Byron poisoned Jessica DiLaurentis after she told him (through email) that she couldn't protect him anymore. She learned Alison was still alive from CeCe. And maybe Alison's reappearance gave Jessica the courage she needed to step forward and tell the truth about that night. And like every victim who knew too much, she was killed.


    HINTS:

    Letters


    The handwriting in Ian's suicide letter, A's letter to the liars, and Byron's letter is eerily similar. This could be just the same crew member doing the handwriting but they are very detailed about these things. Look at the T's, y's, and A's.

    Screen Shot 2015-03-20 at 5.04.01 PM







    IMG 5563

    bigAhints


    A fan asked for a hint as to who A was and Marlene, being very aware of how smart and observant fans can be, tweeted back "#bigA".

    HeybigA

    "Hey big A"

    Does this mean Aria is A? No. Remember that the fan asked for a hint, Marlene knew that tiny hint would mislead fans into believing what they already suspect, that Aria is A. But she is not, the writers just encourage suspicion. #bigA is a hint that someone connected to Aria is big A. The writers would never lead fans directly to A.


    EasternPenn


    In the ending episode 3x14, a random student walked out of Rosewood High with a textbook in hand that read "Eastern Pennsylvania". What city is located in there?



    FullSizeRender-19

    montgomery




    MONTGOMERY. Every hint that has lead PLL fans to believe Aria is A was just a distraction. By giving clues that lead to Aria, they are hinting it is someone close to her. Byron.





    IMG 5522


    A is always avoiding having to harm Aria.


    IMG 5523
    Example:

    The bottle stops on Aria.



    Nope..

    IMG 5524





    It is adjusted to stop at Spencer.


    During a flashback of Alison in Byron's office in episode 3x14, she tells him:

    "So you're a department chair now. You're a powerful man, Mr. Montgomery."

    Pretty Little Liars 314 She's Better Now! Alison & Byron Blackmail Scene!

    Pretty Little Liars 314 She's Better Now! Alison & Byron Blackmail Scene!

    In every scene together, the tension between Alison and Byron is dark and intense. Byron even goes as far as to aggresively grab her wrist and snatch her phone away when she threatens to make that call. Sure Ian and Melissa and every other A suspect was resentful towards Ali but they were very expressive about it. Byron, being an adult, had to restrain his feelings of anger towards her. You can feel it just looking at his reaction when she is in the room or even when her name is mentioned.


    TheGrunwald


    Notice how Mrs. Grunwald emphasises that ONE of the 3 liars has been touched by who Alison fears the most. Slightly hinting that A is connected to one of them. By Hanna not being present, it narrowed it down a little bit. I'm sure these girls have been touched by plenty of A suspects. But Byron has never had a real moment with Spencer, Emily, or Hanna. He has hugged and touched Aria throughout the entire show. We were made to believe this was Ezra she was talking about, but clearly, he isn't A. 

    BQEPB0QCAAAVN4L.jpg-large

    pigtunia


    In the pilot episode, which Byron was present, pigtunia makes it's first appearance. Ella mentions that Aria loves it so much because Byron gave it to her. The pig theme has appeared several times throughout the series. In the Season 4 finale, Ali was even holding it while the girls were asleep and she was checking to see if any of them were A.



    0034

    Aria and Ali trashes Byron's office, and Aria leaves him a message on the wall.


    When Aria and Alison trashed Byron's office, Aria wrote "WHO'S LEAVING WHO YOU PIG".





    In episode 3x15, Aria goes to visit Meredith after witnessing her father violently grab her burned arm in an argument. Aria says she has never seen him that angry before. Meredith tells Aria that she saw him rifling through papers and even through her purse. She says when he saw her, he seemed caught and defensive. She then goes into detail about that fatal night.

    Pretty Little Liars - Aria goes to see Meredith

    Pretty Little Liars - Aria goes to see Meredith

    After locking the liars in the basement, Meredith tells Byron at the 1:25 mark:

    "Aria knows everything. She knows about the blackmail, and she knows that you saw Alison that night, that you.." and stops. Then says: "She has proof, Byron. And her friends know too."

    Pretty Little Liars - Meredith and Byron talk about the liars

    Pretty Little Liars - Meredith and Byron talk about the liars

    I believe Meredith is Red Coat. She is who visited Mona at Radley and Mona told her she did everything she could. Meredith always wore an Alison mask to hide her identity from Mona. Also, Mona has always known that Byron was big A. She took orders from him. Which explains why he let Mike date her despite the fact that she tortured Aria and her friends. Watch this clip. Byron walks out of his office, and Mona is waiting infront of the door. It is made to seem as though he doesn't see her, but I believe he does. Mona then picks up a phone and says, "He's leaving. I'll call you back." Almost as though she's working for him.
    Pretty Little Liars 3x15 - A Ending Scene

    Pretty Little Liars 3x15 - A Ending Scene


    In episode 3x17, Byron and Aria have a talk. At the 1:14 mark, Byron begins to open up to Aria. Pay close attention to what he tells her and the emphasis that he puts on the fireplace. He says that when Aria was a child, him and Ella were always paranoid about them turning their backs and Aria getting burned the fireplace. He then says..

    "I knew that my one job on this earth was to make sure you didn't get hurt. And I haven't done a very good job, have I?" —Byron Montgomery.

    Pretty Little Liars 3x17 - Aria & Byron Talking

    Pretty Little Liars 3x17 - Aria & Byron Talking

    byron aria

    In this clip, pay attention to Byron's reaction to Aria's question at the :56 second mark.

    Pretty Little Liars 3x14 - Aria & Byron Talking About Alison

    Pretty Little Liars 3x14 - Aria & Byron Talking About Alison.

    Last one, Byron and Aria have an intense confrontation about who set up Meredith. Look at Byron's reaction to Aria's comment at 2:59 mark. 
    Pretty Little Liars - 3x14 - Emily her dad talk; Byron acuses Aria of hurting Meredith

    Pretty Little Liars - 3x14 - Emily her dad talk; Byron acuses Aria of hurting Meredith

    Knives

    Who else would be jealous/protective of Aria? Especially with someone as random as Jake. Byron put the knives in Jake's punching bag.


    Byron has made it obvious how much he disproves of Aria's love interests.

    Many have said they believe Alison and Byron had an affair, but that is too much for ABC Family. A 40+ year old man hooking up with a 15 year old? That's Lifetime.

    IMG 5555

    Keegan says: "You can go back to Season 3, or you can go back to Season 1, and watch and you might pick up on it. Not alot of people are gonna be concerned about who A is, it's about why A is. And it's so heartbreaking, tragically beautiful and sad and insane. It explains everything and people are going to be throttled by it because it's a bigger storyline than you can imagine." Notice how Keegan says, "Not alot of people are gonna be concerned about who A is, it's about why A is."

      Loading editor
    • I would like him being A I don't understand why people would hate if a parent was A it not like the parents on this show would win parent of the year one of them being A isn't a stretch.

        Loading editor
    • Interesting... 

        Loading editor
    • I've updated it! If you like, spread the word. Maybe we can figure it out before the finale.

        Loading editor
    • Redrice wrote:
      I would like him being A I don't understand why people would hate if a parent was A it not like the parents on this show would win parent of the year one of them being A isn't a stretch.

      It definitely is not. I don't see how that would not blow people's minds. The twin theories are so boring. I do believe Bethany's twin was CeCe. But I don't think any "twin" is A.

        Loading editor
    • Great and very interesting theory ! Those parents are full of secrets !!!

        Loading editor
    • NeedATeam wrote:
      Great and very interesting theory ! Those parents are full of secrets !!!

      Thank you! Yes, they are. Byron, Ella, Ashley, and Mr. Hastings have always been on my rAdar.

        Loading editor
    •  I love your therory. The only thing that bothers me is something Ms. Gurnwald said when she met Hannah at Mona's grave. She said each one hated the other because one feared the other. Then she said that Mona was cold and not having an easy passing due to betrayl and loss. Which kinda of made me think she was talking abot one of the girls. Why would she feel betrayed by Byron? I don't know you are probably right. I am so confused by this show!

        Loading editor
    • Heykgirl wrote:
       I love your therory. The only thing that bothers me is something Ms. Gurnwald said when she met Hannah at Mona's grave. She said each one hated the other because one feared the other. Then she said that Mona was cold and not having an easy passing due to betrayl and loss. Which kinda of made me think she was talking abot one of the girls. Why would she feel betrayed by Byron? I don't know you are probably right. I am so confused by this show!

      I don't think Byron himself killed Mona. Probably an A Team member working for him. And if she felt betrayed I think it was probably LucAs or JAson that killed her. I am 99% confident it was NOT one of the liars that killed her. You know?

        Loading editor
    • Very interesting theory, I enjoyed reading that but its not really possible. When A shoots Ezra he pulls off a mad athletic stunt between the buildings, I doubt Byron at his age can pull that off. In addition, the actor who plays Toby said something bout you can see it in every episode. Byron is rarely on PLL

        Loading editor
    • Also the last pic of the text from A is sent by Mona while they are in class. I cant believe i didnt know A was Mona initially. In episode 1 of season 1 she puts her phone away straight after sending that text

        Loading editor
    • It was Shana who shot Ezra. Btw, it's not because we saw someone under a black hoodie, that this person is A, I'm pretty sure, all the A's ending not always featured Big A ! I also believe Lucas could perfectly fit the betrAyed Mona has been victimed

        Loading editor
    • I like this theory. If you think about it, a lot of people are beginning to think Aria is A because of the clues pointing to her..the finale won't be as surprising that way. But they're probably only ponting to her because A is Byron. I don't think many people will connect those dots.

        Loading editor
    • NeedATeam wrote:
      It was Shana who shot Ezra. Btw, it's not because we saw someone under a black hoodie, that this person is A, I'm pretty sure, all the A's ending not always featured Big A ! I also believe Lucas could perfectly fit the betrAyed Mona has been victimed

      Marlene was quoted saying that she would not confirm that it was Shana who shot Ezra. She just said "that is what we're lead to believe isn't it?" I don't believe it was Shana. I understand that it could not have been Byron because he is old, but it very well could have one of his helpers.. whether JAson (who was in New York) or MAya (who I believe is probably still alive and working for A). I'm sure Lucas betrayed Mona but I do not think he is Big A.

        Loading editor
    • Fireflydawn wrote:
      I like this theory. If you think about it, a lot of people are beginning to think Aria is A because of the clues pointing to her..the finale won't be as surprising that way. But they're probably only ponting to her because A is Byron. I don't think many people will connect those dots.

      They don't! I truly believe it's because they're bored with the parents and want it to be a twin or one of the liars or one of the boyfriends. But I truly believe it is Byron.

        Loading editor
    • JAS91 wrote:
      Very interesting theory, I enjoyed reading that but its not really possible. When A shoots Ezra he pulls off a mad athletic stunt between the buildings, I doubt Byron at his age can pull that off. In addition, the actor who plays Toby said something bout you can see it in every episode. Byron is rarely on PLL

      I don't think Keegan (Toby) meant you can actually see their face in every episode. Because not even Toby, Ezra, Caleb, or Alison has been in every episode. I believe he meant you can see the CLUES in every episode, which you can. Very clearly.

        Loading editor
    • JAS91 wrote:
      Very interesting theory, I enjoyed reading that but its not really possible. When A shoots Ezra he pulls off a mad athletic stunt between the buildings, I doubt Byron at his age can pull that off. In addition, the actor who plays Toby said something bout you can see it in every episode. Byron is rarely on PLL

      Also Marlene said big A was in the pilot AND in the Season 3 premiere (3x01). Byron was in both.

        Loading editor
    • I totally agree. My theories have always been related to Byron cz they're the only ones that would make sense to me. And I recently saw this clue about Mona's killer's shoes and pants being similar to Byron's in a season 3 episode when aria gets locked in the basement by Meredith and Byron shows up. I believe the episode is called 'misery loves company' so check it and let me know what u all think.

        Loading editor
    • OMG he has to be A i dont want it to be Aria it could be wren. If anyone says it Toby,Ezra or Caleb i will lose it because i love them so much 


      PS does anyone know who charles dilaurentis is i need to know who he is 

        Loading editor
    • I don't think Byron is A but I don't think the thing between Ali, Meredith and Byron was as simple as what he told. 

        Loading editor
    • Oreo0madness wrote:
      I totally agree. My theories have always been related to Byron cz they're the only ones that would make sense to me. And I recently saw this clue about Mona's killer's shoes and pants being similar to Byron's in a season 3 episode when aria gets locked in the basement by Meredith and Byron shows up. I believe the episode is called 'misery loves company' so check it and let me know what u all think.

      Yes, I've seen that theory too! I'm not 100% sure it's him because of the blonde (wig).. and feminine body figure. 

        Loading editor
    • PaloRawrs wrote:
      I don't think Byron is A but I don't think the thing between Ali, Meredith and Byron was as simple as what he told. 

      That's fair.. yea maybe. I'm certain he is, though. If you think about it, Byron being A fills in ALOT of gaps. Once I fixated on him as big A, the rest started coming together. I could be wrong but I'm too certain to entertain that possibility!

        Loading editor
    • The clues keep coming! I found more! Tell me what you think.

        Loading editor
    • When I saw this theory, I shrugged it off and said "No." But, then I read it. This theory is really great. I think it is actually the most logical theory I have read in a while. However, I don't like it because I really want Aria turn out to be bad. :( So, I hope that this is wrong. But, if you are right then kudos to you!

        Loading editor
    • Spobyfan242 wrote:
      OMG he has to be A i dont want it to be Aria it could be wren. If anyone says it Toby,Ezra or Caleb i will lose it because i love them so much 


      PS does anyone know who charles dilaurentis is i need to know who he II kn

      I know if Toby is big A and A again I be very angry because it's going to mess up the whole show I know a lot of people don't like him but him being big A will retcon season 3 and I think that the best season.

        Loading editor
    • Webly wrote:
      When I saw this theory, I shrugged it off and said "No." But, then I read it. This theory is really great. I think it is actually the most logical theory I have read in a while. However, I don't like it because I really want Aria turn out to be bad. :( So, I hope that this is wrong. But, if you are right then kudos to you!

      Thanks! I actually wanted Maya to be A but I think BIG A is someone literally bigger (as in older) than the liars/Mona/NAT Club members. Like an adult. Because BIG A has so much money, power, and connections. I can't see it being anyone but one of the parents. I have this feeling the writers are gonna make the audience think Aria is A for awhile because they like to feed audiences' suspicions as long as it keeps them distracted from figuring out who the real big A is

        Loading editor
    • Redrice wrote:
      Spobyfan242 wrote:
      OMG he has to be A i dont want it to be Aria it could be wren. If anyone says it Toby,Ezra or Caleb i will lose it because i love them so much 


      PS does anyone know who charles dilaurentis is i need to know who he II kn

      I know if Toby is big A and A again I be very angry because it's going to mess up the whole show I know a lot of people don't like him but him being big A will retcon season 3 and I think that the best season.

      I do not think Toby is A at all. He is always made out to seem suspicious. #redherring

        Loading editor
    • Honestly surprised at how many fans would rather pick who they want to be A and attempt to justify it with far fetched, silly 'clues' than those who gather all the real evidence that we've been given and see who it is pointing to. Maybe I'm wrong, I initially wanted Maya to be A, but then I realized that Byron being A connects all the dots. Hoping more fans keep an open mind with this one!

        Loading editor
    • Surprisingly, I've been suspecting he's at least on the A-Team for sometime now, he has some good reasons to be.

        Loading editor
    • Y'all... Come on now.. It's getting obvious!

      Ariadollhouse
      5x25 family photo
        Loading editor
    • Thats an extremely great theory, and I understand why he would want to get rid of Alison or make her life miserable, but what motives does he have to torture the other girls?

        Loading editor
    • SierraMc: Yes! That's what I can't figure out. There has to be something we don't know yet..the Byron theory seems to make 100% sense though if you check out Marlene's and Chad's Twitter accounts the past few days.

        Loading editor
    • The post where Marlene says she loves farmers and Buckeyes..Chad Lowe is from Ohio, home of the Buckeyes!

        Loading editor
    • Yes I agree, of course he is going to hate Alison, but why the other girls?? Great theory though, it definetely made the most sense..

        Loading editor
    • omg look what Chad Lowe (Byron) posted on his instagram!
      Pllll
        Loading editor
    • Yes, that is what I was saying in my post a few minutes ago. Both his and Marlene's Twitter/Instagram's prove this theory. Especially when Marlene posted about the Buckeyes and farmers. Chad is from Ohio.

        Loading editor
    • There would be nothing heartbreaking about that story of Byron's if it's true.

        Loading editor
    • Bcmarjac wrote:
      There would be nothing heartbreaking about that story of Byron's if it's true.

      Are you serious? Nothing heartbreaking about a father accidentally killing his own daughter? Nothing heartbreaking about Aria finding out her father has been behind the "A" identity that harassed her/her friends for years? Nothing heartbreaking about finding out your father may have a split personality/mental illness? 

        Loading editor
    • SierraMc wrote:
      Thats an extremely great theory, and I understand why he would want to get rid of Alison or make her life miserable, but what motives does he have to torture the other girls?

      He said in one of the clips above "Aria, I know what you're friends are capable of."

      But I haven't connected those dots, yet. I DO remember him always being very hard on Aria and getting into it with her every season. He is very over-protective and judgemental of her decisions.

        Loading editor
    • Meaning he killed someone, hard to say that I'd feel sorry for him.  Based on what the cast set, you will 'feel sorry for A.'  I don't think I would if it plays out like that

        Loading editor
    • Bcmarjac wrote:
      Meaning he killed someone, hard to say that I'd feel sorry for him.  Based on what the cast set, you will 'feel sorry for A.'  I don't think I would if it plays out like that

      He ACCIDENTALLY killed her. I think they mean 'feel sorry' as in A has a serious mental illness. Or maybe his daughter was bullied/threatened/killed by someone else. But the former seems like a stronger motive for being A.

        Loading editor
    • Yeah I found some evidence too that he could be A. It seems like Marlene is dropping clues everywhere now..I'm almost sure it's him. http://pretty-little-liars.wikia.com/wiki/Thread:525704

      Also, remember it turned out that Meredith had a mental illness? Not quite sure how that directly links, but it seems significant..

        Loading editor
    • BigAtheory wrote:
      Bcmarjac wrote:
      Meaning he killed someone, hard to say that I'd feel sorry for him.  Based on what the cast set, you will 'feel sorry for A.'  I don't think I would if it plays out like that
      He ACCIDENTALLY killed her. I think they mean 'feel sorry' as in A has a serious mental illness. Or maybe his daughter was bullied/threatened/killed by someone else. But the former seems like a stronger motive for being A.

      If it plays out that way yeah for sure...just don't know if it would :)

        Loading editor
    • why would a 40 yr old Dad bother stalking, blackmailing, and threatening his daughter's friends, when it's only Alison he has a problem with ? don't he have anything better to do with his time ? or life.. :'>

        Loading editor
    • But what about Mike? Do you think he'd go as far as endangering, even trying to kill his own son? The weights, the crossbow... there are a couple of times now that Mike could have been killed. It's definitely an interesting theory, and the more I think about the evidence the more it makes sense to me, but I just can't wrap my head around that one fact; why would he work so hard to protect Aria, yet actually try to cause harm, even death to Mike??

      Thoughts?

        Loading editor
    • Goldie Lux wrote:
      why would a 40 yr old Dad bother stalking, blackmailing, and threatening his daughter's friends, when it's only Alison he has a problem with ? don't he have anything better to do with his time ? or life.. :'>

      Did you read the whole theory? If A, he would be HEAD A. Calling the orders. It is not only Alison he has a problem with, it is everyone that was there that night. Mrs. D, Ian, Garrett, etc. You gotta keep an open mind. We also have NOT been given A's motive for terrorizing the liars all these years.

        Loading editor
    • KittytheSheGeek wrote:
      But what about Mike? Do you think he'd go as far as endangering, even trying to kill his own son? The weights, the crossbow... there are a couple of times now that Mike could have been killed. It's definitely an interesting theory, and the more I think about the evidence the more it makes sense to me, but I just can't wrap my head around that one fact; why would he work so hard to protect Aria, yet actually try to cause harm, even death to Mike??

      Thoughts?

      That's whats tricky to me. Maybe because he sees his brother or himself in Mike. He has said that before. In a way, he's always favorited Aria over Mike. Sasha did say though that once A was revealed, we wouldn't be saying "oh that makes sense" but rather be very confused as to why A is A. At the same time, it is very obvious that A is insane/mentally ill. So not much of what he/she does is rational. It won't make any sense to us.

        Loading editor
    • Just random but I found this interesting.... the meaning of pig in dream symbolism:

      Shows self-reliance, independence and fearlessness in trials and tribulations. Are you too scattered in thoughts and actions? Do you need to stand up for your beliefs and opinions? Are you using your intuition throughout the day? Pig can teach power and respect in the balance of complacency and activity. Pig is resourceful and will teach the lessons to uncover what is needed.

        Loading editor
    • KittytheSheGeek wrote: But what about Mike? Do you think he'd go as far as endangering, even trying to kill his own son? The weights, the crossbow... there are a couple of times now that Mike could have been killed. It's definitely an interesting theory, and the more I think about the evidence the more it makes sense to me, but I just can't wrap my head around that one fact; why would he work so hard to protect Aria, yet actually try to cause harm, even death to Mike??

      Thoughts?

      Honestly I don't think it is a who has it out for Mike. I think Andrew is trying to kill Mike or send him a message to stop digging up information on Mona, because for whatever reason he was the one who killed her to help a set up the liars and Ali.

        Loading editor
    • im almost sure its WILLKOMEN

      and its german

      maya st.germain?

      or marlene king playing with her german heritage?

      I DONT KNOW BUT I REALLY LOVED THIS THEORY

        Loading editor
    • Byron is in my list of top three suspects. My suspects are Aria, Byron and Wren. A could be someone else, but those are the three I have my eye on.

      Wren has been suspicious to me since season one. He has access to, and probably does mind playing with body parts/bones etc. I think he is kind of a creep. At once point in the early seasons, it seemed like he was helping A. Remember the beginning on season 3 when A texted "Show me your boobs." Maybe he is a medical student, like he says and doesn't have time to be A. Or maybe he is lying about that. We know so little about him for sure, that it is easier to see him as A. But how he knows all the things that A knows and keeps tabs on everyone as A is a mystery to me. Remember in season one, when the girls block all unknown callers, he shows up at Specner's house saying he would have called but she blocked his number.

      Aria might be crazy. She had an A panic attack in the bathroom, then later she saw someone in a hoodie when no one else did. She wears a lot of skulls in her jewelry. I have read a lot of good theories to her motive, but don't know. One of the episodes this season is called something like the song goes on. An Aria is a type of song. I remember in a past episode her parents saying they wanted her to have a musical name. So, I do think A is connected to Aria, if not her. She does know the things that A knows, usually.

      Byron could be A. I do think he knew about Aria and Ezra before he let on. He might be insane like his brother. I don't understand how he could know all of the things A knows. He has a job and a lot of responsiblities.  I don't know how they are going to explain it all.

        Loading editor
    • Do you guys remember a szene when A broke into the Montgomery house? I don´t remember that we ever seen A with the black hoody there.

        Loading editor
    • Genevieve celeste wrote:
      Do you guys remember a szene when A broke into the Montgomery house? I don´t remember that we ever seen A with the black hoody there.


      Nope, i thought that.  Even when Aria said it was A that messed with Mikes weightlifting bench we never actually saw A do it.

        Loading editor
    • ABC family made it a rule that no parent on the show can be A so no its not Byron or any parent.

        Loading editor
    • Whiteangel19902003 wrote:
      ABC family made it a rule that no parent on the show can be A so no its not Byron or any parent.

      Where did you see this?

        Loading editor
    • Whiteangel19902003 wrote:
      ABC family made it a rule that no parent on the show can be A so no its not Byron or any parent.

      What? When did they say that? Neither Marlene nor any of the writers have ever confirmed this.

      Sasha Pieterse, who plays Alison, said in a recent article that Big A's identity was "dark, even for ABC Family".

      So I assume it's not a girl they bullied in preschool. Big A has murdered people.

      If they keep putting emphasis on the twist being "disturbing, twisted, and dark".. then it's probably someone older or profoundly mentally ill.

        Loading editor
    • It was awhile back but ABC family made it a stipulation that if they air PLL, no parent can be A. They dont want the image on their channel of an adult parent torturing teenagers.

        Loading editor
    • At this point since we also know there is only 1 A working since season 4 the only logical people it can be are Lucus, Wren, or Paige.

        Loading editor
    • The also said that we would feel bad for A after we hear their motive. I dont think anyone would feel bad for a parent torturng teens mentally ill or not.

        Loading editor
    • Whiteangel19902003 wrote:
      It was awhile back but ABC family made it a stipulation that if they air PLL, no parent can be A. They dont want the image on their channel of an adult parent torturing teenagers.

      You still haven't provided a link. I searched online and there is nothing. ABC Family would not narrow the list down like that.

        Loading editor
    • Whiteangel19902003 wrote:
      The also said that we would feel bad for A after we hear their motive. I dont think anyone would feel bad for a parent torturng teens mentally ill or not.

      I don't think you're understanding and probably just want to believe someone else is A which is fine. But A has a strong motive. Mentally ill or not. The motive has not been revealed yet and I think it's for a reason.

      You can't make the assumption that you wouldn't feel bad if you still haven't heard the motive. 

      The storyline is much bigger and deeper than "A torturing teens".

      There is tragedy and grief and mental illness and secrecy and power and blackmail.

        Loading editor
    • Whiteangel19902003 wrote:
      At this point since we also know there is only 1 A working since season 4 the only logical people it can be are Lucus, Wren, or Paige.

      I am confident enough to assure you that Lucas and Paige are not A. Neither is logical considering the 4 liars didn't bully them, Alison did. And neither is capable of murdering so many people. Wren, however, could be. But what motive does he have? Just speculation.

        Loading editor
    • BigAtheory wrote:
      Whiteangel19902003 wrote:
      At this point since we also know there is only 1 A working since season 4 the only logical people it can be are Lucus, Wren, or Paige.
      I am confident enough to assure you that Lucas and Paige are not A. Neither is logical considering the 4 liars didn't bully them, Alison did. And neither is capable of murdering so many people. Wren, however, could be. But what motive does he have? Just speculation.

      What if Wren was dating Bethany and blames them all for her death?

        Loading editor
    • Bcmarjac wrote:

      BigAtheory wrote:
      Whiteangel19902003 wrote:
      At this point since we also know there is only 1 A working since season 4 the only logical people it can be are Lucus, Wren, or Paige.
      I am confident enough to assure you that Lucas and Paige are not A. Neither is logical considering the 4 liars didn't bully them, Alison did. And neither is capable of murdering so many people. Wren, however, could be. But what motive does he have? Just speculation.

      What if Wren was dating Bethany and blames them all for her death?

      Ok.....call me over dramatic, but THAT...just gave me goosebumps. Wow. This would be amazing

        Loading editor
    • Thats just the thing you dont know that the murderer is A your just speculating. There may be a seperate person from A murdering people, we just all assume its A. And its just like you said we dont know the motive yet. Lucus or Paige or Wren could hate Ali and the liars for something completly different than being bullied.

        Loading editor
    • And yes maybe Wren did date bethany or was related to her, thats the thng we just dont know. Also Julian Morris plays mostly serial killers in movies so if Wren is revealed to be either A or the murderer he would be perfect to play that particular role

        Loading editor
    • Whiteangel19902003 wrote:
      And yes maybe Wren did date bethany or was related to her, thats the thng we just dont know. Also Julian Morris plays mostly serial killers in movies so if Wren is revealed to be either A or the murderer he would be perfect to play that particular role

      LOL nice :)

        Loading editor
    • Bcmarjac wrote:
      BigAtheory wrote:
      Whiteangel19902003 wrote:
      At this point since we also know there is only 1 A working since season 4 the only logical people it can be are Lucus, Wren, or Paige.
      I am confident enough to assure you that Lucas and Paige are not A. Neither is logical considering the 4 liars didn't bully them, Alison did. And neither is capable of murdering so many people. Wren, however, could be. But what motive does he have? Just speculation.
      What if Wren was dating Bethany and blames them all for her death?

      That's a good theory! I could see that happening.

        Loading editor
    • I want to know who tried to stab Aria in the eye with the knitting needle and who tried to shove her off the train? And what is Byron's motivation to torment the girls? I like it though!

        Loading editor
    • LCFisher wrote:
      I want to know who tried to stab Aria in the eye with the knitting needle and who tried to shove her off the train? And what is Byron's motivation to torment the girls? I like it though!

      Maybe Wilden?  If he blames them for Bethany Young's death that could be motive.

        Loading editor
    • I have only one thing to say.... 

      The family on the picture in the 5x25 promo isn't Aria's Family, because mother and daughter have blonde hair.....

      who are them?

        Loading editor
    • Bcmarjac wrote:
      LCFisher wrote:
      I want to know who tried to stab Aria in the eye with the knitting needle and who tried to shove her off the train? And what is Byron's motivation to torment the girls? I like it though!
      Maybe Wilden?  If he blames them for Bethany Young's death that could be motive.

      Why does Byron try to kill his daughter?

        Loading editor
    • I don't know that HE did.  If you're talking about Halloween train it could have been several people and I think Ali revealed it was Melissa or Wilden.

        Loading editor
    • BigAtheory wrote:
      Bcmarjac wrote:
      BigAtheory wrote:
      Whiteangel19902003 wrote:
      At this point since we also know there is only 1 A working since season 4 the only logical people it can be are Lucus, Wren, or Paige.
      I am confident enough to assure you that Lucas and Paige are not A. Neither is logical considering the 4 liars didn't bully them, Alison did. And neither is capable of murdering so many people. Wren, however, could be. But what motive does he have? Just speculation.
      What if Wren was dating Bethany and blames them all for her death?
      That's a good theory! I could see that happening.

      I think you're right.... but I don't remember, the Girls have never suspected tha Wren was A?

        Loading editor
    • I don´t think the girls ever suspected Wren.

      Did you guys noticed that "A" number one target ist Hanna (and her mother) and the less "A" harmed is Aria? Maybe that´s something important...or not :)

      ohh...and like I said before, I can´t remember "A" was ever in the black hoody in Arias house!

        Loading editor
    • Genevieve celeste wrote:
      I don´t think the girls ever suspected Wren.

      Did you guys noticed that "A" number one target ist Hanna (and her mother) and the less "A" harmed is Aria? Maybe that´s something important...or not :)

      ohh...and like I said before, I can´t remember "A" was ever in the black hoody in Arias house!

      I remember that A has black hood and gloves also when he tampered Mike's tool gym, so when he was in Aria's house. 

      And talking about who is the girl more hit by A, I would like to remember you that Aria was with spencer in the freezer in icecream farm and it'a only one of the examples.....

      (sorry for my English but I'm italian :D)

        Loading editor
    • I was so convinced either Wren or Maya was A in season 1 because of the huge amount of evidence against them...

      But I would feel so cheated if they were 'Big A', mainly because I'm expecting A to be someone who has a regular role in the show and the two haven't been in the show for agess. That's why I'm unconvinced they're Big A. They may be part of the team however.

        Loading editor
    • Fireflydawn wrote: I was so convinced either Wren or Maya was A in season 1 because of the huge amount of evidence against them...

      But I would feel so cheated if they were 'Big A', mainly because I'm expecting A to be someone who has a regular role in the show and the two haven't been in the show for agess. That's why I'm unconvinced they're Big A. They may be part of the team however.


      Thats a good point also.....thats where it gets interesting, though! Because who is actually a TRUE regular on the show other than the girls, Ezra, Caleb, Toby and Paige (up until the Christmas episode). I'd LOVE to see one of the regulars be A :)

        Loading editor
    • Fireflydawn wrote:
      I was so convinced either Wren or Maya was A in season 1 because of the huge amount of evidence against them...

      But I would feel so cheated if they were 'Big A', mainly because I'm expecting A to be someone who has a regular role in the show and the two haven't been in the show for agess. That's why I'm unconvinced they're Big A. They may be part of the team however.

      Exactly my thoughts. I'm expecting A to be someone who has literally appeared in every season. Not so much every episode but every season.. Since the pilot.

        Loading editor
    • SierraMc wrote:

      Fireflydawn wrote: I was so convinced either Wren or Maya was A in season 1 because of the huge amount of evidence against them...

      But I would feel so cheated if they were 'Big A', mainly because I'm expecting A to be someone who has a regular role in the show and the two haven't been in the show for agess. That's why I'm unconvinced they're Big A. They may be part of the team however.

      Thats a good point also.....thats where it gets interesting, though! Because who is actually a TRUE regular on the show other than the girls, Ezra, Caleb, Toby and Paige (up until the Christmas episode). I'd LOVE to see one of the regulars be A :)


      I would be so heartbroken if Caleb turned out to be A. That would be like a M Night Shyamalan twist o_O

      But I think Kendra is related to Maya somehow...and remember the mneumonic 'Maya Knew'? She could possibly be part of the team.

      As for Wren...The vodka, the massage he gave Spencer, someone spiking Emily's meds...he was always suspicious to me. It's just that he's not even there anymore -____-

        Loading editor
    • SierraMc wrote:

      Fireflydawn wrote: I was so convinced either Wren or Maya was A in season 1 because of the huge amount of evidence against them...

      But I would feel so cheated if they were 'Big A', mainly because I'm expecting A to be someone who has a regular role in the show and the two haven't been in the show for agess. That's why I'm unconvinced they're Big A. They may be part of the team however.

      Thats a good point also.....thats where it gets interesting, though! Because who is actually a TRUE regular on the show other than the girls, Ezra, Caleb, Toby and Paige (up until the Christmas episode). I'd LOVE to see one of the regulars be A :)

      Paige wasn't in the pilot episode. I would feel cheated if it were her or Caleb or anyone who was not in the pilot episode. Mainly because the pilot episode started this journey and FIRST asked the question of who A was.

        Loading editor
    • Probably Kendra is linked to Maya because Maya drugs her at the party before Thanksgiving!!

        Loading editor
    • I've updated the clips with new ones! Check it out.

        Loading editor
    • PLLdrugged wrote:
      I have only one thing to say.... 

      The family on the picture in the 5x25 promo isn't Aria's Family, because mother and daughter have blonde hair.....

      who are them?

      Doesn't mean it's Ella or Aria. What if it was Byron, Marion, Bethany, and Toby.. for example?

        Loading editor
    • BigAtheory wrote:

      PLLdrugged wrote:
      I have only one thing to say.... 

      The family on the picture in the 5x25 promo isn't Aria's Family, because mother and daughter have blonde hair.....

      who are them?

      Doesn't mean it's Ella or Aria. What if it was Byron, Marion, Bethany, and Toby.. for example?

      Or the women in the photo are Meredith and Bethany... O_O

        Loading editor
    • I really loved the addition from Meredith's big psychotic s3 episode and the idea that Byron let Mona date Mike. I remember feeling confused after what happened. If this turns out to be right, I feel kinda dumb because Byron is like one of the last people I would guess.

        Loading editor
    • Webly wrote: I really loved the addition from Meredith's big psychotic s3 episode and the idea that Byron let Mona date Mike. I remember feeling confused after what happened. If this turns out to be right, I feel kinda dumb because Byron is like one of the last people I would guess.

      I always thought he was shifty, but I never even considered him until I read this thread xD The more I look into it, the more on board I am.

        Loading editor
    • Webly wrote:
      I really loved the addition from Meredith's big psychotic s3 episode and the idea that Byron let Mona date Mike. I remember feeling confused after what happened. If this turns out to be right, I feel kinda dumb because Byron is like one of the last people I would guess.

      If he is infact A, they chose him because no one would expect him. You shouldn't feel dumb then because that was their goal.. to surprise us but also make us cry. lol

        Loading editor
    • KittytheSheGeek wrote:

      BigAtheory wrote:

      PLLdrugged wrote:
      I have only one thing to say.... 

      The family on the picture in the 5x25 promo isn't Aria's Family, because mother and daughter have blonde hair.....

      who are them?

      Doesn't mean it's Ella or Aria. What if it was Byron, Marion, Bethany, and Toby.. for example?
      Or the women in the photo are Meredith and Bethany... O_O

      Very true! Byron and Meredith were always on and off.

        Loading editor
    • You are just short of convincing me that its Byron. I feel like it def could be because you make some seriously good points. Theres just a few holes in the theory. Right now Aria is in jail and I'm not sure why Byron would do that to Aria when A's plan was to get them all arrested. The second thing is Mona did not know who Big A was because remember when she speaks to mike she tells mike her plan about pretending to be dead, framing Alison to gain A's trust and then exposing A... other than that your theory is solid

        Loading editor
    • JAS91 wrote:
      You are just short of convincing me that its Byron. I feel like it def could be because you make some seriously good points. Theres just a few holes in the theory. Right now Aria is in jail and I'm not sure why Byron would do that to Aria when A's plan was to get them all arrested. The second thing is Mona did not know who Big A was because remember when she speaks to mike she tells mike her plan about pretending to be dead, framing Alison to gain A's trust and then exposing A... other than that your theory is solid

      A's plan wasn't to get them all arrested just so they can go to jail. A's plan was to get them arrested so he could have them all in one car and then kidnap them and take them to the dollhouse. So I don't think Byron (if he were A) would be against Aria getting arrested if it meant he could bring her/the liars to the dollhouse and keep them there.

      As for Mona, that's true. She did say that. That's tricky. I still believe there's a reason Byron let Mike date Mona without even questioning her past with mental illness.

      He even says to Aria: "I understand that you and Mona have more than the usual amount of history." So he knew and still didn't care much.
      Pretty Little Liars 5x11 Byron and Aria talk about Mona

      Pretty Little Liars 5x11 Byron and Aria talk about Mona

        Loading editor
    • KittytheSheGeek wrote:

      BigAtheory wrote:

      PLLdrugged wrote:
      I have only one thing to say.... 

      The family on the picture in the 5x25 promo isn't Aria's Family, because mother and daughter have blonde hair.....

      who are them?

      Doesn't mean it's Ella or Aria. What if it was Byron, Marion, Bethany, and Toby.. for example?
      Or the women in the photo are Meredith and Bethany... O_O

      I think that it's not possible for Meredith to be Bethany's mom, because she's too young.....

        Loading editor
    • BigAtheory wrote:
      JAS91 wrote:
      You are just short of convincing me that its Byron. I feel like it def could be because you make some seriously good points. Theres just a few holes in the theory. Right now Aria is in jail and I'm not sure why Byron would do that to Aria when A's plan was to get them all arrested. The second thing is Mona did not know who Big A was because remember when she speaks to mike she tells mike her plan about pretending to be dead, framing Alison to gain A's trust and then exposing A... other than that your theory is solid
      A's plan wasn't to get them all arrested just so they can go to jail. A's plan was to get them arrested so he could have them all in one car and then kidnap them and take them to the dollhouse. So I don't think Byron (if he were A) would be against Aria getting arrested if it meant he could bring her/the liars to the dollhouse and keep them there.

      As for Mona, that's true. She did say that. That's tricky. I still believe there's a reason Byron let Mike date Mona without even questioning her past with mental illness.

      He even says to Aria: "I understand that you and Mona have more than the usual amount of history." So he knew and still didn't care much.
      Pretty Little Liars 5x11 Byron and Aria talk about Mona

      Pretty Little Liars 5x11 Byron and Aria talk about Mona

      Marlene said that we have to watch PLL from 3x01 to understand who A is..... I watch twice this episode and Ali appeared with the book Lolita in the hands..... Lolita's book talk about a teacher of Leterature which fall in love with a young girl, so Byron or Ezra could be Big A

        Loading editor
    • Oreo0madness
      Oreo0madness removed this reply because:
      I wanted to quote another comment
      14:58, March 22, 2015
      This reply has been removed
    • PLLdrugged wrote:

      BigAtheory wrote:
      JAS91 wrote:
      You are just short of convincing me that its Byron. I feel like it def could be because you make some seriously good points. Theres just a few holes in the theory. Right now Aria is in jail and I'm not sure why Byron would do that to Aria when A's plan was to get them all arrested. The second thing is Mona did not know who Big A was because remember when she speaks to mike she tells mike her plan about pretending to be dead, framing Alison to gain A's trust and then exposing A... other than that your theory is solid
      A's plan wasn't to get them all arrested just so they can go to jail. A's plan was to get them arrested so he could have them all in one car and then kidnap them and take them to the dollhouse. So I don't think Byron (if he were A) would be against Aria getting arrested if it meant he could bring her/the liars to the dollhouse and keep them there.

      As for Mona, that's true. She did say that. That's tricky. I still believe there's a reason Byron let Mike date Mona without even questioning her past with mental illness.

      He even says to Aria: "I understand that you and Mona have more than the usual amount of history." So he knew and still didn't care much.
      Pretty Little Liars 5x11 Byron and Aria talk about Mona

      Pretty Little Liars 5x11 Byron and Aria talk about Mona

      Marlene said that we have to watch PLL from 3x01 to understand who A is..... I watch twice this episode and Ali appeared with the book Lolita in the hands..... Lolita's book talk about a teacher of Leterature which fall in love with a young girl, so Byron or Ezra could be Big A

      It can't be Ezra because when Ali met him he was just a college student. It's also why I've always thought that 'hot for teacher' is about Byron. What do u guys think???

        Loading editor
    • Why would he ruin his own marriage? What was the purpose in sending the texts?

        Loading editor
    • Kylie.black426 wrote:
      Why would he ruin his own marriage?

      What was the purpose in sending the texts?

      That was Mona. Big A stole the game from Mona in Season 3.

        Loading editor
    • PLLdrugged wrote:
      BigAtheory wrote:
      JAS91 wrote:
      You are just short of convincing me that its Byron. I feel like it def could be because you make some seriously good points. Theres just a few holes in the theory. Right now Aria is in jail and I'm not sure why Byron would do that to Aria when A's plan was to get them all arrested. The second thing is Mona did not know who Big A was because remember when she speaks to mike she tells mike her plan about pretending to be dead, framing Alison to gain A's trust and then exposing A... other than that your theory is solid
      A's plan wasn't to get them all arrested just so they can go to jail. A's plan was to get them arrested so he could have them all in one car and then kidnap them and take them to the dollhouse. So I don't think Byron (if he were A) would be against Aria getting arrested if it meant he could bring her/the liars to the dollhouse and keep them there.

      As for Mona, that's true. She did say that. That's tricky. I still believe there's a reason Byron let Mike date Mona without even questioning her past with mental illness.

      He even says to Aria: "I understand that you and Mona have more than the usual amount of history." So he knew and still didn't care much.
      Pretty Little Liars 5x11 Byron and Aria talk about Mona

      Pretty Little Liars 5x11 Byron and Aria talk about Mona

      Marlene said that we have to watch PLL from 3x01 to understand who A is..... I watch twice this episode and Ali appeared with the book Lolita in the hands..... Lolita's book talk about a teacher of Leterature which fall in love with a young girl, so Byron or Ezra could be Big A

      I think a grown 40 year old man being in love with a 14 year old is too disturbing from ABC Family. Plus, Big A hates Alison. He/she always has. Even before that fatal night.

        Loading editor
    • Oreo0madness wrote:

      PLLdrugged wrote:

      BigAtheory wrote:
      JAS91 wrote:
      You are just short of convincing me that its Byron. I feel like it def could be because you make some seriously good points. Theres just a few holes in the theory. Right now Aria is in jail and I'm not sure why Byron would do that to Aria when A's plan was to get them all arrested. The second thing is Mona did not know who Big A was because remember when she speaks to mike she tells mike her plan about pretending to be dead, framing Alison to gain A's trust and then exposing A... other than that your theory is solid
      A's plan wasn't to get them all arrested just so they can go to jail. A's plan was to get them arrested so he could have them all in one car and then kidnap them and take them to the dollhouse. So I don't think Byron (if he were A) would be against Aria getting arrested if it meant he could bring her/the liars to the dollhouse and keep them there.

      As for Mona, that's true. She did say that. That's tricky. I still believe there's a reason Byron let Mike date Mona without even questioning her past with mental illness.

      He even says to Aria: "I understand that you and Mona have more than the usual amount of history." So he knew and still didn't care much.
      Pretty Little Liars 5x11 Byron and Aria talk about Mona

      Pretty Little Liars 5x11 Byron and Aria talk about Mona

      Marlene said that we have to watch PLL from 3x01 to understand who A is..... I watch twice this episode and Ali appeared with the book Lolita in the hands..... Lolita's book talk about a teacher of Leterature which fall in love with a young girl, so Byron or Ezra could be Big A

      It can't be Ezra because when Ali met him he was just a college student. It's also why I've always thought that 'hot for teacher' is about Byron. What do u guys think???

      I don't think it is. It could be. But the elements of pedophilia in it are too strong for ABC Family. And they've pushed the envelope plenty of times but that ones a little too disturbing.

        Loading editor
    • BigAtheory wrote:

      I don't think it is. It could be. But the elements of pedophilia in it are too strong for ABC Family. And they've pushed the envelope plenty of times but that ones a little too disturbing.

      They have already had a high school teacher having sex with a student 6 years younger than him (which yes is implied and not graphically shown). Same teacher, Ezra was pursuing/stalking another one of the liars, Alison, when she would of been like 15. Then you have the guys of NAT club: Jason, Ian, and Garrett taping young girls in their bedrooms even once they were out of high school and in their 20's.

      Oh and not to forget the episode 5x14 whose title is a reference to the "Through a Glass Darkly" originally titled "The Wallpaper" by Ingmar Bergman. About Karin who is trying to readjust to life with her family after being released from a mental institution. When she has sex with her brother Minus she realizes she is unable to live in two worlds and must choose between institutionalization and home life.

      I'm convinced the "deeper/darker backstory" Keegan references means that a parent or parents is involved in the development of A or they themselves are A.

        Loading editor
    • TheYellowBlouse wrote:
      BigAtheory wrote:

      I don't think it is. It could be. But the elements of pedophilia in it are too strong for ABC Family. And they've pushed the envelope plenty of times but that ones a little too disturbing.

      They have already had a high school teacher having sex with a student 6 years younger than him (which yes is implied and not graphically shown). Same teacher, Ezra was pursuing/stalking another one of the liars, Alison, when she would of been like 15. Then you have the guys of NAT club: Jason, Ian, and Garrett taping young girls in their bedrooms even once they were out of high school and in their 20's.

      Oh and not to forget the episode 5x14 whose title is a reference to the "Through a Glass Darkly" originally titled "The Wallpaper" by Ingmar Bergman. About Karin who is trying to readjust to life with her family after being released from a mental institution. When she has sex with her brother Minus she realizes she is unable to live in two worlds and must choose between institutionalization and home life.

      I'm convinced the "deeper/darker backstory" Keegan references means that a parent or parents is involved in the development of A or they themselves are A.

      6 years younger is different than 30 years younger. No denying that. Yea the NAT guys were creeps but they were also still young adults. Different than it being a man old enough to be Ali and the liars' father. There are people who still have a problem with Aria and Ezra's relationship.

        Loading editor
    • Let's face it, ABC Family stopped being a "family" channel when it started introducing shows like the Secret Life of the American Teenager. The plot twists and subject matter of that show was a first for ABC Family. I am not saying there is anything wrong with that because I watched every season of that show, but Byron being A and everything that goes along with that, is not a stretch for ABC Family.

        Loading editor
    • PLLdrugged wrote:

      KittytheSheGeek wrote:

      BigAtheory wrote:

      PLLdrugged wrote:
      I have only one thing to say.... 

      The family on the picture in the 5x25 promo isn't Aria's Family, because mother and daughter have blonde hair.....

      who are them?

      Doesn't mean it's Ella or Aria. What if it was Byron, Marion, Bethany, and Toby.. for example?
      Or the women in the photo are Meredith and Bethany... O_O

      I think that it's not possible for Meredith to be Bethany's mom, because she's too young.....

      I never said Meredith was Bethany's mom. If Byron really is Bethany's dad, and this theory is true, perhaps he really is in love with Meredith, and they are both in the photo because that is his ideal family. He wants the daughter he never got to raise, and he wants the woman he loves to be her mother. Step-mothers are a thing, you know.

        Loading editor
    • Mona having worked for Byron or knowing about him being A makes sense to me, because in the flashback of Aria and Alison seeing Byron and Meredith kissing in te car, Mona seems really eager to get Aria and Alison's attention, as if she was somehow trying to stop them from going that way and seeing them, It always seemed to me like that scene had more to show for than just Mona being rejected by them.

        Loading editor
    • Ktonn wrote:
      Let's face it, ABC Family stopped being a "family" channel when it started introducing shows like the Secret Life of the American Teenager. The plot twists and subject matter of that show was a first for ABC Family. I am not saying there is anything wrong with that because I watched every season of that show, but Byron being A and everything that goes along with that, is not a stretch for ABC Family.

      Agreed!

        Loading editor
    • KoreRiba wrote:
      Mona having worked for Byron or knowing about him being A makes sense to me, because in the flashback of Aria and Alison seeing Byron and Meredith kissing in te car, Mona seems really eager to get Aria and Alison's attention, as if she was somehow trying to stop them from going that way and seeing them, It always seemed to me like that scene had more to show for than just Mona being rejected by them.

      Wow I've never seen that scene that way! Great point. Mona was involved in the Aria/Alison/Byron/Meredith scene for a reason. Interesting!

        Loading editor
    • I believe the whole Montgomery family is involved (maybe not mike) before reading your theory I never looked much into this stuff but always thought Aria was involved somehow, and there are endless signs about Aria being A or connected to it. I think the twin story Alison tells is about Aria, I don't think Aria remembers all of it she might have a split personality or other similar disorder, her parents are trying to protect her and themselves. Its like the more you look the more you find.

      I can't wait to see what they reveal tonight!

      http://killerariaisa.tumblr.com/post/98849442184/parallels-between-the-montgomery-family-and-the

        Loading editor
    • KoreRiba wrote:
      I believe the whole Montgomery family is involved (maybe not mike) before reading your theory I never looked much into this stuff but always thought Aria was involved somehow, and there are endless signs about Aria being A or connected to it. I think the twin story Alison tells is about Aria, I don't think Aria remembers all of it she might have a split personality or other similar disorder, her parents are trying to protect her and themselves. Its like the more you look the more you find.

      I can't wait to see what they reveal tonight!

      http://killerariaisa.tumblr.com/post/98849442184/parallels-between-the-montgomery-family-and-the

      I think  that  this is too  much risky. .....all the 5 Girls  are innocent

        Loading editor
    • Maybe so, but I guess we are gonna have to wait and see! xD

        Loading editor
    • PLLdrugged wrote:
      KoreRiba wrote:
      I believe the whole Montgomery family is involved (maybe not mike) before reading your theory I never looked much into this stuff but always thought Aria was involved somehow, and there are endless signs about Aria being A or connected to it. I think the twin story Alison tells is about Aria, I don't think Aria remembers all of it she might have a split personality or other similar disorder, her parents are trying to protect her and themselves. Its like the more you look the more you find.

      I can't wait to see what they reveal tonight!

      http://killerariaisa.tumblr.com/post/98849442184/parallels-between-the-montgomery-family-and-the

      I think  that  this is too  much risky. .....all the 5 Girls  are innocent

      Agreed. I don't see how people can question why a parent would hurt their child but do not question why Aria would hurt/threaten herself? And the split personality card can be pulled on anyone. But Aria has been in the same room/building as A. It makes no absolutely no sense and can't be explained. Yet fans still 100% believe she is A and think everything Aria does is shady. Like "she eats that cupcake like she is A." lol

        Loading editor
    • LOL "she eats that cupcake like she is A."  that was freaking funny! I just think if she is involved she isn't doing it alone, and she has to apear as if shes being tormented just like the rest of them, I just think that there are a lot of hints about her. I admit some may be a little far fetched, but having one of the girls be involved would explain why A knows a lot of, sort of 'spur of the moment' decisions they make and stops them from getting ahead.

      And a show about lies not having one of the the main characters being the biggest liar just seems like a wasted oportunity. I don't want anyone specific to be A, or A related, Spencer is my favorite character and she is my second guess after Aria, I just want them not to waste a great plot and make A (and the A Team) be a really good reveal, and to make great twisted sense!

        Loading editor
    • KoreRiba wrote:
      LOL "she eats that cupcake like she is A."  that was freaking funny! I just think if she is involved she isn't doing it alone, and she has to apear as if shes being tormented just like the rest of them, I just think that there are a lot of hints about her. I admit some may be a little far fetched, but having one of the girls be involved would explain why A knows a lot of, sort of 'spur of the moment' decisions they make and stops them from getting ahead.

      And a show about lies not having one of the the main characters being the biggest liar just seems like a wasted oportunity. I don't want anyone specific to be A, or A related, Spencer is my favorite character and she is my second guess after Aria, I just want them not to waste a great plot and make A (and the A Team) be a really good reveal, and to make great twisted sense!

      But the show is also about friendship in the midst of all the lies. The liars have all caught each other in lies and confronted each other. I don't think it would be a waste if none of them were A. I think it would be a waste if Paige or Toby or some predictable character was A.

        Loading editor
    • You're right, but like I said I don't want it to be anyone specific I just want them not to waste it, regardless of who it ends up being. I just wish I was in America to watch it 'sooner', I'm gonna have to go hide myself to avoid any spoilers until I can watch it too.

        Loading editor
    • I guess it can't be Byron anymore.

        Loading editor
    • He can still be involved, we dont know enough to say he can't.

        Loading editor
    • Don't forget : There surely are Uber A and Big A. So everything is still possible. Although probably UberA=BV, so a girl...

        Loading editor
    • KoreRiba wrote:
      He can still be involved, we dont know enough to say he can't.

      Well yeah he COULD be involved, but what I was saying is that he can't be A. SPOILERS:

      It has been confirmed that Charles Dilientes(aka Jason's Twin) is A. Also we are assuming that Charles is around the same age as Melissa. This ruling out Byron obviously lol, he's like 40. 

      More and more signs leading to Wren, but who knows...........

        Loading editor
    • Let's say Byron isn't A... (although he could be) as PLL changes it's dang mind every season.. putting that aside.. WHO THE HELL IS CHARLES DILAURENTIS 

      I feel robbed of the last 5 years of my life. Had it been someone we actually KNEW I wouldn't be that mad because we KNEW them.

        Loading editor
    • So why did Melissa call? To tell her mother Wren was missing. Wren is Charles. Been saying this for months.

        Loading editor
    • well yeah it could be otherwise why would she call thats right....

        Loading editor
    • EzraisA wrote:
      So why did Melissa call? To tell her mother Wren was missing. Wren is Charles. Been saying this for months.

      So why does Charles have a british accent? And dark hair rather than blonde?

        Loading editor
    • because he is not jasons twinnnnnnnny

        Loading editor
    • they could be cousins or just family friends. not everyone in this show has to be related. I still believe Wren is A

        Loading editor
    • I don't think Marlene ever said twin. She said we'll see double. He doesn't even necessarily have to be Jason's brother. I still like my theory that Wren was Marion Cavanaughs son, who was Bethany's twin. Jessica and Marion could be sisters. because Marion was crazy Jessica could have forced her to give her twins up for adoption and Wren was adopted by a British couple. Or he could be faking. I'm beginning to doubt we will ever know.

        Loading editor
    • A lot of blonde children grow up to have dark hair. It's not uncommon.

        Loading editor
    • Or what if the twin is actually Wren's room mate, Colin. He's blond xD

        Loading editor
    • So, if Charles AKA Wren is Jason's twin, then he is dating his half sister and kissed his other half sister? Mr. Hastings is Jason's father.

        Loading editor
    • I really arrived to the conclusion that Andrew is A.

      His real name is Charles and he is Jessica and Mister Hasting's son (in reality Jason isn't Spencer step brother) gave in adoption to Campbell family.

      That's why Mrs DiLaurentis took Jason and Ali, and also Spencer's father took Spence and Melissa, to the Campbell's farm..... they wanted to control their son but they didn't want to be judge for their adultery.

        Loading editor
    • If Wren is Jason's older brother, then he could have Mr Di as his father, like Ali. Melissa and Spencer wouldn't be blood related to him.

        Loading editor
    • PLLdrugged wrote:
      I really arrived to the conclusion that Andrew is A.

      His real name is Charles and he is Jessica and Mister Hasting's son (in reality Jason isn't Spencer step brother) gave in adoption to Campbell family.

      That's why Mrs DiLaurentis took Jason and Ali, and also Spencer's father took Spence and Melissa, to the Campbell's farm..... they wanted to control their son but they didn't want to be judge for their adultery.

      I thought Andrew was the same age as the girls? 

        Loading editor
    • CoccinelleElena wrote:
      PLLdrugged wrote:
      I really arrived to the conclusion that Andrew is A.

      His real name is Charles and he is Jessica and Mister Hasting's son (in reality Jason isn't Spencer step brother) gave in adoption to Campbell family.

      That's why Mrs DiLaurentis took Jason and Ali, and also Spencer's father took Spence and Melissa, to the Campbell's farm..... they wanted to control their son but they didn't want to be judge for their adultery.

      I thought Andrew was the same age as the girls? 

      Maybe he lied on his age.......

        Loading editor
    • Or....

      maybe Big A could be a new carachter that we have never seen.....

      Let's try to read this interesting theorie in italian.......

      http://prettyitalia.altervista.org/benvenuto-charles-dilaurentis-commento-personale-alla-5x25/

        Loading editor
    • So is Marlene's tweet still revalent? She tweeted somthing along the lines that in the season 5 finale episode, We would see A without the hoodie.  Or are we not suppose to take that into account any more or what? A lot of people have been thinking Wren including me, but if her tweet is true then maybe not. Im confused as usual :( This show will be the death of me )

        Loading editor
    • Anyone know if Wren was present when Mrs Di was not and vice versa? Because I think if Jessica had already seen him, she would have warned Peter that her daughter has an affair with her half-brother. While if she has never seen him and he changed his name, it works.

        Loading editor
    • PLLdrugged wrote:
      CoccinelleElena wrote:
      PLLdrugged wrote:
      I really arrived to the conclusion that Andrew is A.

      His real name is Charles and he is Jessica and Mister Hasting's son (in reality Jason isn't Spencer step brother) gave in adoption to Campbell family.

      That's why Mrs DiLaurentis took Jason and Ali, and also Spencer's father took Spence and Melissa, to the Campbell's farm..... they wanted to control their son but they didn't want to be judge for their adultery.

      I thought Andrew was the same age as the girls? 
      Maybe he lied on his age.......

      I was also thinking about that, the only thing is that in this life stage, six years older is pretty much to fake. 

        Loading editor
    • PlsPLL wrote:
      So is Marlene's tweet still revalent? She tweeted somthing along the lines that in the season 5 finale episode, We would see A without the hoodie.  Or are we not suppose to take that into account any more or what? A lot of people have been thinking Wren including me, but if her tweet is true then maybe not. Im confused as usual :( This show will be the death of me )

      Marlene says - "Well we did see a face -- it's just the face of a child!".  Heres the link...

      http://www.tvguide.com/news/pretty-little-liars-marlene-king-big-a-reveal/


      I feel conned.

        Loading editor
    • Im going to be so disappointed if Andrew turns out to be A!

      The Farm was called Campbell's Farm which is Andrew's last name. How important is that clue to Andrew being Charles? King: As we get so close to the end of the story, there are no random clues or hints anymore.

        Loading editor
    • TheMartins08 wrote:
      PlsPLL wrote:
      So is Marlene's tweet still revalent? She tweeted somthing along the lines that in the season 5 finale episode, We would see A without the hoodie.  Or are we not suppose to take that into account any more or what? A lot of people have been thinking Wren including me, but if her tweet is true then maybe not. Im confused as usual :( This show will be the death of me )
      Marlene says - "Well we did see a face -- it's just the face of a child!".  Heres the link...

      http://www.tvguide.com/news/pretty-little-liars-marlene-king-big-a-reveal/


      I feel conned.

      Ah, I hate and love it at the same time. I'm so confused right now. 

        Loading editor
    • TheMartins08 wrote:
      Im going to be so disappointed if Andrew turns out to be A!

      The Farm was called Campbell's Farm which is Andrew's last name. How important is that clue to Andrew being Charles? King: As we get so close to the end of the story, there are no random clues or hints anymore.

      Oh no !! Do we know the age gap between Jason and the liars? I seemed to understand that Melissa was two years older than Spencer, right? Jason was the same age than Melissa, right?

        Loading editor
    • NanouSD wrote:
      TheMartins08 wrote:
      Im going to be so disappointed if Andrew turns out to be A!

      The Farm was called Campbell's Farm which is Andrew's last name. How important is that clue to Andrew being Charles? King: As we get so close to the end of the story, there are no random clues or hints anymore.

      Oh no !! Do we know the age gap between Jason and the liars? I seemed to understand that Melissa was two years older than Spencer, right? Jason was the same age than Melissa, right?

      Jason is 6 years older than Ali, and Ali is the same age as Spencer and Melissa is he same age as Jason... so the age gap between Jason and the liars is 6 years. Or am I wrong?

        Loading editor
    • Are you sure? I remember when Hanna was chosen as promo queen (when Melissa was in Black Swan?), girls were surprised to see Melissa so she explained "the last queen couldn't be there so they called me because I'm the penultimate". But I may have misunderstood... :/

      If you think Andrew is the twin, 6 years older it's still much to hide, no? Oo

        Loading editor
    • According Wikia you're right. 6 older.

        Loading editor
    • NanouSD wrote:
      Are you sure? I remember when Hanna was chosen as promo queen (when Melissa was in Black Swan?), girls were surprised to see Melissa so she explained "the last queen couldn't be there so they called me because I'm the penultimate". But I may have misunderstood... :/

      If you think Andrew is the twin, 6 years older it's still much to hide, no? Oo

      I do remember Melissa saying something like that though

        Loading editor
    • Ktonn wrote: So, if Charles AKA Wren is Jason's twin, then he is dating his half sister and kissed his other half sister? Mr. Hastings is Jason's father.

      It's possible that Wren doesn't know he's really a Hastings. Although that's kind of weak since A seems to know everything. But he could just be that twisted. Remember, insanity runs rampant in Rosewood.

        Loading editor
    • I'm just posting it here because this is the thread that made me join the wiki, sorry if its the wrong place.

      But guys idk if this is any clue about anything, but in the last episode, A greeted the girls in different languages, one of which was in Portuguese for "Good evening" (Boa tarde) and I remembered this guys Holden Strauss being related to Portugal

      http://pretty-little-liars.wikia.com/wiki/Holden_Strauss

      I guess its just a coecidence but since that character goes back to Aria's childhood he could also go back to Alison somehow? idk just putting it out there, they use other languages too like German and Spanish.

        Loading editor
    • PLLdrugged wrote:

      CoccinelleElena wrote:
      PLLdrugged wrote:
      I really arrived to the conclusion that Andrew is A.

      His real name is Charles and he is Jessica and Mister Hasting's son (in reality Jason isn't Spencer step brother) gave in adoption to Campbell family.

      That's why Mrs DiLaurentis took Jason and Ali, and also Spencer's father took Spence and Melissa, to the Campbell's farm..... they wanted to control their son but they didn't want to be judge for their adultery.

      I thought Andrew was the same age as the girls? 

      Maybe he lied on his age.......

      He couldn't have lied. He grew up next to Spencer. He's in school with them now. Besides, they showed Andrew yesterday listening to Veronica's call. I don't think he would have been in the episode if he was. He may be involved in some way, but I think he's just obsessed with the girls, mainly Aria. Just my opinion but I don't think he could fake that big of an age difference. Even if that second boy in the movie is younger than Jason, he's still at least three years older than Ali. Andrew is a diversion.

        Loading editor
    • EzraisA wrote:

      Ktonn wrote: So, if Charles AKA Wren is Jason's twin, then he is dating his half sister and kissed his other half sister? Mr. Hastings is Jason's father.

      It's possible that Wren doesn't know he's really a Hastings. Although that's kind of weak since A seems to know everything. But he could just be that twisted. Remember, insanity runs rampant in Rosewood.

      Haha A is perverse enough to do that !! That's why I asked if anyone noticed if Jessica and Wren have been at Rosewood at the same time? (since both do not stop making round trips)

      But I think If Wren is the twin, he know about Peter.

        Loading editor
    • Besides, they showed Andrew yesterday listening to Veronica's call. I don't think he would have been in the episode if he was. He may be involved in some way, but I think he's just obsessed with the girls, mainly Aria. Just my opinion but I don't think he could fake that big of an age difference. Even if that second boy in the movie is younger than Jason, he's still at least three years older than Ali. Andrew is a diversion.

      I got the feeling he might just be really desperate to help Aria (maybe in a stalker way), also his laptop background looked pretty harmless, even had homework or w.e. On the other hand, A and his minions always seemed to have super hack skills because they would always find out about their stuff, so maybe they are finaly showing us how they actualy do it? it could be just as simple as non suspicious people hanging at places listening to calls with bluetooth. idk 

        Loading editor
    • KoreRiba wrote:
      I'm just posting it here because this is the thread that made me join the wiki, sorry if its the wrong place.

      But guys idk if this is any clue about anything, but in the last episode, A greeted the girls in different languages, one of which was in Portuguese for "Good evening" (Boa tarde) and I remembered this guys Holden Strauss being related to Portugal

      http://pretty-little-liars.wikia.com/wiki/Holden_Strauss

      I guess its just a coecidence but since that character goes back to Aria's childhood he could also go back to Alison somehow? idk just putting it out there, they use other languages too like German and Spanish.

      For languages, there are several so don't steer you on one. Unless a character has traveled the world, I think it's just a wink to all the PLL's fans around the world and to tell us that A is someone cultured (what we already know).

        Loading editor
    • TheMartins08 wrote:
      PlsPLL wrote:
      So is Marlene's tweet still revalent? She tweeted somthing along the lines that in the season 5 finale episode, We would see A without the hoodie.  Or are we not suppose to take that into account any more or what? A lot of people have been thinking Wren including me, but if her tweet is true then maybe not. Im confused as usual :( This show will be the death of me )
      Marlene says - "Well we did see a face -- it's just the face of a child!".  Heres the link...

      http://www.tvguide.com/news/pretty-little-liars-marlene-king-big-a-reveal/


      I feel conned.

      Oh I see, we saw A but just as a child. Its quite genius if they meant to do it that way. So i guess that means its confirmed that Charles is A? right? And im not sure which A if there IS in fact two different A's, but im not going to get into that. It hurts my head just thinking about it(there being more A's to guess). 

        Loading editor
    • KoreRiba wrote: <div class="quote"

      On the other hand, A and his minions always seemed to have super hack skills.....
      

      </div>

      Right!? So at this point does any actually believe that A is working alone? I don't see how that's possible. There may not be an A team anymore, but he definitely, as you say, has Minions.

        Loading editor
    • The never confirm that the person in the dollhouse is Charles. Spencer askes, "Charles, is that you?" With no answer.

      As for the hoodie, A had a mask on and a tux for the prom, so yes, we saw A without the hoodie.

        Loading editor
    • @TheMartins08 thanks for the link :)

      Also when i was reading the interview, she said this:

      Is Alison and/or Jason aware of Charles?
      King: I can say that the Christmas episode, with the flashback of Alison and her mom, answers that question

      In that episode/flashback it was the whole " theres two dresses but we're going to pretend there was only one" thing.  So by Marlene answering the question the way she did shes saying the dress was for Charles? So is Charles a girl now? Also does that mean that Charles is one of the girl characters in the show( im not talking about the PLLs but like CeCe or Jenna or someone) since we apparently have seen there before? Or have we not? Because if thats the case then that means someone is really a guy. Oh damn! There's a big chance I'm wrong. But if I'm right................

      The rest is here btw if someone else wants to read it: http://www.tvguide.com/news/pretty-little-liars-marlene-king-big-a-reveal/

        Loading editor
    • EHI 

      I have another supposition!!! LOL I'm gettin crazy, take me to Radley

      So, if Andrew had said those things about Mona to Aria just because he is tired of commemorating someone who is still alive? Maybe he knows that Mona is alive so he investigates at Brew to unmask her and he goes to Mona's house to see if she come back!

      And Marlene show him only to let us think that he is -A ...........

      Maybe, in the next season, he will help the Girls to excape!!!!

        Loading editor
    • EzraisA wrote:
      The never confirm that the person in the dollhouse is Charles. Spencer askes, "Charles, is that you?" With no answer.

      As for the hoodie, A had a mask on and a tux for the prom, so yes, we saw A without the hoodie.

      Actually Marlene tweeted: "Actually you will see A without the hoodie or the mask. Gotcha! @5sausegirl_ #FinaleFever #MarchTwentyFour," 

      But I think TheMartins08 is right about Marlene referring to the child. 

        Loading editor
    • Byron can still be A.

      The tweet I see refers only to the hoodie: https://twitter.com/imarleneking/status/568159567210622976

      Therefore I agree with EzraisA: We've seen A in a tux with a mask on but not in the hoodie. Marlene didn't lie - we just hoped for too much.

      As far as BigATheory's observations are concerned, I think Byron is still an option (the most likely one, too, if you ask me). He is certainly not Jason's twin. But maybe the assumption that the short movie in the doll house shows Jason and his unknown brother is wrong to begin with. What if that scene depicts Jessica Dilaurentis, Alison, Jason - and Andrew? His parents seem to own the barn. So maybe the Dilaurentis family came there to pick apples and became friends with the Campbell family. As a matter of course their children play together and the person filming the scene is Charles. If this is indeed the case, Charles' age is still undetermined and he could very well be a grown-up, e.g. Byron or his mad brother he mentions in one episode. Byron might have a "Jekyll & Hyde" personality and be Byron Montgomery AND Charles Dilaurentis. Or his brother really exists and he got involved with the Dilaurentis clan somehow (marriage, adoption...).

        Loading editor
    • Sorry  but if A is simply Jason? 

        Loading editor
    • PLLdrugged wrote:
      Sorry  but if A is simply Jason? 

      I agree, this is also possible. And I think this behind-the-scenes picture of The Great Charlemagne wants to point us in this direction (Tumblr_mt49z6cdJ31rzt41jo1_500.jpg). I'm not so sure about this picture, though, as Charlemagne seems a lot older in the episode "Now you see me, now you don't" - if you trust IMDb, he was played by the actor Brian Dare then (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2924024/?ref_=ttfc_fc_cl_t19). The picture does not necessarily show the same man. I find it fishy that they show us this picture of Charlemagne's hair while disguising Charles as much as they did in the last season finale. My red herring alarm goes off.

      Besides, I have mainly two problems with the Jason = A theory:

      1) According to our current state of knowledge, Charles = A. If Jason is A, he would have to be Charles too. This is only plausible if he has a split personality or created an alias for himself at some point in his life. But wouldn't you choose something more distracting then instead of Dilaurentis when this is your actual family name?

      2) If Jason is A - what could his motive be for stealing the A game and torturing the liars, their families and Rosewood in general? I think A's motive comes from a "triangle" - a constellation of people where he (or she, we don't know for sure yet) was the odd one out. At least this seems to be what the doll house with the dummy family and the short movie hints at. He/she was forced out of the happy family picture at some point; maybe they admitted him/her to Radley (killing and locking someone up in a mental institution seem to be the most common ways to get rid of someone in Rosewood).

      This is why I think it can't be Jason. The reasons don't apply to Jason's twin, though, if he really exists (which is not my opinion, see posting above).

        Loading editor
    • I belive it could be Byron. Does Byron still like Meredith? Is Meredith the same age as Melissa and Ian? Did Byron recreate prom because he wanted to go to prom with Meredith but was too old? Meredith looks like an older Ali. Hence Byrons obsession with her 'your'e my favourite' in the last ep. Byron could easily have had an affair with Mr's D, and had a child called 'Charles'. Charles could be 1-2 years younger than Jason?.


      Also could Kenneth be A ? Maybe his name is Kenneth Charles Dilaurentis. He was in the pilot although uncredited. His name is 7 letters. He was in s3 ep called CRAZY. What if he killed bethany thinking it was Ali. (not sure why he would kill her) and Mrs D saw and wanted to protect her husband? When he found Ali was alive he went CRAZY and stole the A game from Mona. He was obssesed with Ali, because he resented what he thought he had done to her, but was still CRAZY and resented the four girls because of what he thought happend that night and it was their fault. Kenneth was the one filming the home video on the Campbell farm. Makes the most sense.

      The baby was Ali, and boy was Jason. the other boy could of been Jason's twin, and Kenneth did not like the fact his son was different (possibly gay, wanted to be a girl etc, or maybe found out Mrs D had an affair and either 

      a) killed him

      b) hid him or sent him to radley  etc 

      say the twin is called Charles, maybe Charles did go to Radley, but turned into the Bethany persona, and bethany was obsessed with Ali, dressing in her clothes so maybe Kenneth did mean to kill Bethany but he thought he accidently killed his fave child being Alison, and thats why when he found out Ali was alive the whole game changed. He made Mona dress like Ali because he was obsessed with his own daughter. He was a perfectionist. Jason was disowned because he knew he wasnt his son, (Charles/Bethany) was disowned because he was different. But Ali she was perfect.

      Who could have a house in the middle of nowhere to lock these girls up? Someone rich like Kenneth? his job is a bloddy Real Estate Agent. 

      Also the other kid might not even be Jasons twin, could just be Andrew its obviously his farm. Andrew Campbell at the Campbell farm. Spence knows Andrew from when they are little. All 3 families obvs go to that farm.  Andrew is deffinatley not A/Charles though.

      If Kenneth is Charles that home video meant a lot to him, maybe he found out thats where Mr's D was having an afair and when Kenneth first started going CRAZY, and having anger issues. 

      Marlene might just be leading us to think that there is twins. She does that a lot. Like when Toby was A but nope, Ezra was A but nope. Bet no one saw Kenneth as A coming, If anyone can help add to me theory please do so!!!

      Theory by Letesha

        Loading editor
    • I am not sure if this idea was mentionned before but I totally agree that Byron could still be Uber A. I believe Mr D and Byron had an affair from which Charles was born. I believe Charles is a pawn who is totally controlled by Byron. Making Big A Charles and Byron the Uber one which make them a team! 

      Marlene King said in a recent interview that in Season 7 the storyline of Big A will be history, which def means ther is someone else controlling Big A or else the series would end with season 6.

      Charles is def related to Aria since as it was mentioned a billion times before, she was always the least hurt by A.

      Cheers,

        Loading editor
    • If it is really true that Big A and Uber A are two different persons working together I second the theory that Byron and Jessica Dilaurentis had a son named Charles who carries out the mad plans of his father and was probably in Radley by the time Mona checked in. (Suddenly introducing the possibility of an even more complicated hierarchy of A, Big A and Uber A makes me wonder if the producers just make the whole story up as they go along. They are probably reading our theories, thinking: "Gosh, they are so close to the truth - let's mess everything up once again" because they are afraid they won't be able to fill two more seasons with mind-blowing plot twists and holes.)

        Loading editor
    • Aria 1
      Aria 23
      Aria 4

      I totally believe there is an hierarchy of A and very much related for Aria, in episode 24, we see Big A holding Aria's doll and placing her in jail with Alison. As if he's somehow trying to get the family all together in his twisted way.

      Now let's go to episode 25 that everyone is focusing on Mrs D video played at the end ignoring all other details like, Big A decided to place a pic of the mannequin family consisting of 2 kids (Aria and Mike perhaps) and parents, in Aria's room which is a freaking replicate of the same mannequin family he has in his own private secret room that Spencer found in the end! I very much doubt it is a coincidence and I truly believe Charles is Aria's half Brother as well as Alison's. and he ain't anybody's twin! Cheers

        Loading editor
    • A parent will never be A.

        Loading editor
    • I think at least one grown-up (older than 21) has to be involved - by now, A spent a whole lot of money on his/her plans, bought plane tickets, rented a house, set up the dollhouse, etc. This doesn't rule out Melissa, Jason and the like, I know, but the older and more settled a character is the more likely he/she can afford being A. If there is indeed a difference between Big A and Uber A (which would perfectly resolve some issues!) I can totally see a parent as Uber A - he or she never got his own hands dirty and never harmed anybody. The person was the master mind and financier but let others do the work.

      I'd like to add another aspect to the before mentioned observations: Not only isn't Aria harmed as much as the others - she also has a curious connection to Radley. When she starts to work there to get information about Bethany, Eddie Lamb seems to recall her face (5x7). By the end of the episode, Eddie is gone. We come to know later that this was his last day so he either quit voluntarily or someone harmed him and called the institution on his behalf, saying he wouldn't come anymore. Additionally, Aria seems disproportionately nervous when Eddie asks her if they've met before and insists on his feeling that they have the year before. Was she visiting her half brother and does she know about him?

        Loading editor
    • Mondrian wrote:
      Byron can still be A.

      The tweet I see refers only to the hoodie: https://twitter.com/imarleneking/status/568159567210622976

      Therefore I agree with EzraisA: We've seen A in a tux with a mask on but not in the hoodie. Marlene didn't lie - we just hoped for too much.

      She tweeted several things, here is the tweet I was referring to. https://twitter.com/imarleneking/status/568170312518340608 

        Loading editor
    • CoccinelleElena wrote:

      She tweeted several things, here is the tweet I was referring to. https://twitter.com/imarleneking/status/568170312518340608

      Thank you for looking it up! - This means that it's either one of the children in the movie or one of the other characters (e.g. Andrew) - or a lie.

        Loading editor
    • Mondrian wrote:
      CoccinelleElena wrote:

      She tweeted several things, here is the tweet I was referring to. https://twitter.com/imarleneking/status/568170312518340608

      Thank you for looking it up! - This means that it's either one of the children in the movie or one of the other characters (e.g. Andrew) - or a lie.

      I'm really scared that it's a lie... I don't know what to believe anymore. 

        Loading editor
    • Shes already said in an interview she was referring to the child in the video.  She has also said that Charles is big A but wont comment further on uber A, which would suggest it isnt Charles.

        Loading editor
    • Mondrian wrote: I think at least one grown-up (older than 21) has to be involved

      Don't forget that Charles is an adult! His senior prom was seven years ago.

        Loading editor
    • Mondrian wrote:
      I think at least one grown-up (older than 21) has to be involved - by now, A spent a whole lot of money on his/her plans, bought plane tickets, rented a house, set up the dollhouse, etc. This doesn't rule out Melissa, Jason and the like, I know, but the older and more settled a character is the more likely he/she can afford being A. If there is indeed a difference between Big A and Uber A (which would perfectly resolve some issues!) I can totally see a parent as Uber A - he or she never got his own hands dirty and never harmed anybody. The person was the master mind and financier but let others do the work.

      Here's the paragraph concerning big and Uber A from Entertainment Weekly's interview with Marlene: 

      This is Big “A” … but not Uber “A”: When asked about the Big “A” reveal, King clarified that “This is the person who stole the game from Mona.” However, when asked if there is also an Uber “A,” she said, “I’m not going to tell you just yet because that might ruin it down the line. I’m not going to comment on Uber ‘A.’” Translation: There could very well still be someone out there.

      I'd say Uber A is as real as Big A, but she talks as well about a 4 year time jump in the end of the summer episodes! It is very interesting to see how they will tie what happened before these 4 years to after them!! I mean it is a long period and it is very tricky to jump the storyline that far, it might just messes it up I feel.

        Loading editor
    • More clues that strengthen this theory is the ending of season 4, when A shot Ezra!

      Let's say Uber A is really Byron and Big A his minion is his son Charles from Mrs Dilaurentis. Byron as we all know really hates Alison for lots of reasons, While he really loves Aria very much, Charles was brainwashed by Byron to feel the same, and he was on a vendetta to kill Alison (Byron's order). We also know in season 4 how shaky was the relationship btw Ezra and Aria and how much the latter was hurtting bcz of him.

      What if Shauna was as well a minion working for them!

      Now by taking all these points into consideration, let us go back to the ending of season 4, when Ezra was shot on the rooftop:

      Now notice in the video how after all 5 girls made it to the rooftop and after Ezra found them, Shauna enters from the other door with only one goal in mind which is shooting Alison. But notice how she reacts when he sees Ezra (At this point, it is logical to believe Charles and Byron know about the pain and misery Ezra caused Aria to go thru, imagine the hate he will be feeling toward Ezra for hurting his beloved sister) She looks at Ezra and raises the gun slowely and aims it to Ezra's head,as if this was preplanned and she's going with her masters order (maybe Ezra was A's target after alison for what he did to Aria, but Shauna, following orders of course, thought she could deliver 2 birds with 1 stone). that if it was shauna and not charles :)

      Now in season 5 premiere, when Shauna went after the girls with a gun, she did it making sure Aria was out of danger leaving her with Ezra at the hospital. Some might think it is Aria's luck but was it? or was Uber A making sure Shauna gets on with her duty without having Aria in danger's way?

      And wasn't it weird that big A didn't bother going after Aria for killing Shauna!!?? As if Aria has some kind of immunity with him.

      The more I think about it the more sense the series is starting to make.

      Some might argue but he injured mike! Well he might be jealous of him because of his relation with Aria and his family, and what he did was fueled by jalousy!


      P.S: Although Ezra believed it was Shauna who shot him on the rooftop I still have doubt about it and believe it might be Charles instead.

        Loading editor
    • In the last episode it was impossible not to notice all the artwork in the girls fake bedrooms. So I remembered Hollis is an arts school...

      http://media-cdn.tripadvisor.com/media/photo-s/02/c5/90/97/warner-brothers-studios.jpg

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alea_iacta_est

      What if Ezra is also involved somehow?

      A few important scenes have happened at Hollis. http://pretty-little-liars.wikia.com/wiki/Hollis_College

      Also, in the lasted episode when Spencer is in that room in which she watched the film, notice how there is a plane hanging on the ceiling.

      http://pretty-little-a-team.tumblr.com/post/46102302324/jenna-at-the-park-planes-and-ezra

      What if Ezra is one of the people behind all this, and maybe Big A and Uber A have different plans and motives? maybe are even competing agains each other and this is why we have so many different pointers, because there are maybe two distinc motives behind it?

        Loading editor
    • there is a lot of logic in your theory especially byron had a mental brother !

      but why would he gave ali money when he knew that he is gonna kill her ?

      if ali knew about him then she knew he is A from the beginning then why she didn't tell the girls ? or at least protect her self from him ?

      why would he tortures his daughter friends ? maybe ali but why the others ?

      i think marline once said that we will feel sorry for A at the end ! I don't like bayron being A and i will not fell sorry for him !

      and we saw A body he is taller then bayron and stronger !

      altouthe good theory ! WELL DONE

        Loading editor
    • I love the whole Byron theory it was good until the season finale. Byron cannot be A I believe because Marlene said we saw A without the hoodie and mask, its just a childs face. Also she said we will feel sorry for A , your theory doesnt make anyone feel sorry for Byron he just sort of made his own bed to speak.

      From the video  A can be either the baby, or one of the two boys. We assume its one of the boys because of the Charles thing but what if it isnt what if its the baby. Could the baby really be Allison or maybe thats A and the boys are Jason and Andrew.

      Y does everytime Melissa wants to tell something its blocked out, I believe Melissa holds a huge piece to the puzzle. I mean we find out from her who buried the girl in the backyard and what happened that night.  Melissa was also filling in for the past prom Queen or something right could that be A or why A is like that.

      Also with the whole christmas episode that was supposedly a clue to Ali knowing the existance of A. How come there are only 2 presents that contains two dresses. Where is Jasons gift?? If that was Mrs. Dilaurentis hiding place for her gifts wouldnt she put all their gifts there? Maybe thats going too deep lol. 

        Loading editor
    • I'm pretty sure the 4 year time jump is season 7.

        Loading editor
    • I read where they said that the time jump is between 6A and 6B

        Loading editor
    • BigAtheory wrote:

      SierraMc wrote:
      <div class="quote

      Paige wasn't in the pilot episode. I would feel cheated if it were her or Caleb or anyone who was not in the pilot episode. Mainly because the pilot episode started this journey and FIRST asked the question of who A was.

      The A in the pilot was Mona. This A is supposedly in 3.1
        Loading editor
    • Byron can't be BIG A because in 3x18 A buys a bottle of whiskey and has to show his/her identity card in order to confirm that he/she is already 21.

        Loading editor
    • I think the background story might be true, even if Byron is not big A (maybe uber A?). Byron and Jessica had a baby together who might've been Bethany a.k.a. Rachel S. DiLaurentis. The two boys would have been Jason (Bethany's older brother), "?" and the baby girl would've been Bethany. She then got sent away due to whatever reasons (by "mistake"/for the wrong reasons?) and ended in Radley later on and accidentally got killed as you wrote (maybe Marion C. found out about Bethany's true identity before and got killed due to this). Maybe person "?" from her past took the name Charles -- being an anagram for Rachel S. -- and takes revenge on her fate. Regarding the prom scene: It might've been "Charles" prom and he would've taken Bethany there and thus Mona is forced to act as Alison who looks a lot like Bethany obviously and kind of is her "replacement". And the photography in Aria's room shows the "perfect" family, i.e. Bethany and maybe Jason, Byron and Jessica.

        Loading editor
    • Streifenzebra wrote:
      Byron can't be BIG A because in 3x18 A buys a bottle of whiskey and has to show his/her identity card in order to confirm that he/she is already 21.

      That was Toby. While he was working for Mona.

        Loading editor
    • @BigAtheory

      Monas voice doesn't say "velkomnir". It says "Willkommen" (with a strong accent). It's German for welcome.

        Loading editor
    • BigAtheory wrote:
      Streifenzebra wrote:
      Byron can't be BIG A because in 3x18 A buys a bottle of whiskey and has to show his/her identity card in order to confirm that he/she is already 21.
      That was Toby. While he was working for Mona.

      I thought this too but I was just watching the -A endings and this confused me because i thought it was Toby but the ending after they buy the whiskey is the ending where there are 4 bottles of whiskey with the girls faces on them, and it lands on Aria and a person turns it to be on Spencer, and the two people pour a drink and clink their glasses.

      If it was Mona and Toby why would Toby want something bad to happen to Spencer over Aria?

        Loading editor
    • TheMartins08 wrote:

      BigAtheory wrote:
      Streifenzebra wrote:
      Byron can't be BIG A because in 3x18 A buys a bottle of whiskey and has to show his/her identity card in order to confirm that he/she is already 21.
      That was Toby. While he was working for Mona.

      I thought this too but I was just watching the -A endings and this confused me because i thought it was Toby but the ending after they buy the whiskey is the ending where there are 4 bottles of whiskey with the girls faces on them, and it lands on Aria and a person turns it to be on Spencer, and the two people pour a drink and clink their glasses.

      If it was Mona and Toby why would Toby want something bad to happen to Spencer over Aria?

      And wasn't he just 18 or 19 back then. As far as I know you are not allowed to buy alcohol under the age of 21. Of course he could easily have faked his ID. And as we could see in that and some other episodes A likes candy. XD

        Loading editor
    • This is a really cool theory. Gave me a lot to think about. But I think it doesn't work.

      Jessica witnessed Ali getting knocked out. So Jessica witnessed Bethany hitting Ali and then Byron hitting Bethany like a half hour later?

        Loading editor
    • When the two little girls are in tHe kitchen the other girl can be bethany?

        Loading editor
    • I know not a lot of people are mentioning Scott Montgomery since he's barely talked about-- but does anyone think it's possible that Aria is Scott's and not Byron's?  He wouldn't have been mentioned for no reason and he has a history of mental instability and there have been theories that Scott is Wren's dad (since his dad had similar problems).

      It would explain why he was yelling at Alison the night she disappeared, since everyone assumes it was only about Meredith. It could either be about that or about the fact that Aria was Scott's and there was also another sibling...

      Also "Aria is the only girl who hasn't had a one-on-one scene with Toby or Wren".

        Loading editor
    •  If you also want to check out some amazing original work by some of the users here, there is a Male version of the Liars titled Handsome Little Liars which is on it's second season, but you can catch up on season one via binge readers guide I have provided . Then there's another original series titled Wicca_TV_Series_Wiki which has its own wiki and 2 episodes out. Lastly, there is my own original work titled:Inferno which is on its first season with three episodes aired. The first being titled: Down the Rabbit Hole , Followed byHighway to Hell and Born Under A Bad Sign being the latest. Hope you like all the suggestions and enjoy them! :) 

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.