FANDOM


  • So ...

    Here are a few things that I am sure on:

    1. Bethany hit Alison with the rock (I suspect that she saw ther her and Alison had on the same clothes and sensing that she was being tricked some how attacked her - like Mother, like Daughter was how Bethany put Alison).

    2, Uber A hit Bethany with the shovel mistaking her for Alison. (I've always had the suspicion that UberA has always been aware of Mona's little game and used it to ther advantage to minipulate the events leading upto the shovel incident).

    3. CeCe was there just like Bethany as a decoy on Alisons orders. After all she'd do anything for Alison (even pretend to be her and check herself in at Radley).

      Loading editor
    • 1. Do you remember when Jessica DiLaurentes got a call and afther the call Jessica told Alison not to go outside and she was afraid? I guess that Jessica got a call that Bethany escaped from Radley.

      2. Über A hit Bethany with a shovel and Melissa thought that it was Spencer so she buried Bethany.

      One of many questions is, is Bethany still alive? I think that three girls were buried that night. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yrG872T5aw So the murdered girl is Sarah Harvey?

      If it´s true that Bethany is still alive, I don´t think that she is Über A. Maybe he is helping Über A.I have a theorie that Toy might be A because of the Marion storyline. Bethany draw pictures of Jessica and Marion, so she knew both women. We know that there was a witness of Marions murder in Radley.(a blond girl, that could be Bethany) I don´t see the conection between Toby and Bethany, unless there were sublings. If Bethany killed Marion why would Toby help now Bethany?

      There is the twin-story, as far as we know, somebody has a twin and it´s not Alison. So who than? We know that Bethanys favorite color was yellow (it was in the letter that Bethany wrote to Alison) and the dresses were yellow, so I guess that the other dress was for Bethany, but Bethany is not Alisons twin. The other question is, why Bethany ended up in Radley? Did she have an other twin that we don´t know?

      I don´t see the conection between the Alison/Marion/Bethany story and the Varjak story either.

        Loading editor
    • I think Bethany did hit Ali but for some reason I think Jenna hit Bethany thinking she was Ali because I don't believe that Jenna was completely blind I think she could see colors and some shapes and she saw blond hair and a yellow top and hit her.

        Loading editor
    • I don´t see the conection between the Alison/Marion/Bethany story and the Varjak story either.


      I have the same issue - only that the Varjakstory caused Yellowdressstory/murderstory so A has to be involed in both  

      ( and maybe the NATclub knew something A also knew or knew about A ( and maybe just couldnt put the pieces together) so 2 of three NAT-members are killed -ONLY Jason is alive either because he cant remember THATNIGHT or something else or because hes Alis brother or is somehow involed or knows some weird things) 

        Loading editor
    • You know Redrice, I never even thought about the possibility of that!

        Loading editor
    • 1. Why did Jessica hide the dresses in the piano? She knew Ali would find them.

      2. Do you think Bethany killed Toby's mother?

      3. Why is always Tanner trying to blame the liars and their friends? For example...when Caleb showed her the photo he took of Mike being tied she indirectly blamed him for that.Do you think Tanner is trying to protect somebody?

      4. Do you think A it's really Charles DiLaurentis or a well known person?I heared some Ezra theories and..idk Ezra gives me goosebumps sometimes.

      5. What is wrong with Andrew? Is he trying to protect the girls or works for A?

        Loading editor
    • I really want it to be that Tanner is on A's payroll.

        Loading editor
    • Redrice wrote:
      I really want it to be that Tanner is on A's payroll.


      I know..right? She's weird and always lets Toby out of police business.And that isn't because he is Spencer's boyfriend.I think there is a several number of cops involved with this.Like Toby said: Most of the cops in Rosewood are corupted.

        Loading editor
    • Mrs. D bought the yellow shirt to Alison right? And said she wanted Ali to wear it that night because the other one was too revealing.  Did Ali even know that CeCe and Bethany had similar clothes on or that her life was threatened? Mrs. D also spoke very suspiciously on phone and obviously knew Ali was in danger. 

      She said (on phone)How could this happen? I don't understand. Then she bans Ali from going out and continues talking on the phone: You need to send somebody immediately, Is there any news, please hurry I'm very very worried

      I think that Charles had escaped Radley that night. If he had, Radley's staff would've called to his guardian/parent, Mrs. D. I'm not sure about the motive, maybe Charles hit Ali because Ali got so much attention by Mrs D and wasn't tossed to Radley and abandoned. Wasn't Mrs D. killed right after A saw Ali alive on the roof with the Liars?

        Loading editor
    • Applexsama wrote:
      1. Why did Jessica hide the dresses in the piano? She knew Ali would find them.

      2. Do you think Bethany killed Toby's mother?

      3. Why is always Tanner trying to blame the liars and their friends? For example...when Caleb showed her the photo he took of Mike being tied she indirectly blamed him for that.Do you think Tanner is trying to protect somebody?

      4. Do you think A it's really Charles DiLaurentis or a well known person?I heared some Ezra theories and..idk Ezra gives me goosebumps sometimes.

      5. What is wrong with Andrew? Is he trying to protect the girls or works for A?


      1. I really have no idea about this... I just can't figure out anything that would make any sense at all. 

      2. I think that Mrs. D killed Marion because she knew too much about Charles. Bethany just was in a wrong place at the wrong time and witnessed it. She knew the truth but couldn't tell because Mrs. D threatened to pin it on Bethany -who would believe crazy patient over a board memeber(or whatever Mrs. D was). Then Bethany was forced to live in a lie. That would make you hate someone as it is but I think that Bethany was close to Marion because they both were in Radley at that time. This would explain Bethany's drawings.Maybe Bethany wanted revenge and tried to kill Mrs. D's child, Ali, and wore the same outfit so no one would recognize her.

      Bethany drawings

      Marion falling






      3. I think it was weird that when the police found A's lair Tanner knew exactly what buttons to press to turn all of those screens on. But she seemed genuinely surprised when she saw Mona and the Liars trapped. This case is probably going to be her last.

      Dr Wren K

      That A on Wren's shoulder...

      4. To my mind Charles DiLaurentis is Wren, Jason's secret twin. There some evidence that points to his direction.. I also think that Ezra is suspicious too though! It has been proven that he knows how to stalk and use all kinds of machines. Also a rich family 

      would be a big help because A surely has spend a lot of money on this project.

      5. Maybe Andrew is double-agent or something! Definitely on the same side as Spencer and Mona because of e´what i read in this article: 

      We’ve taken three characters from the books who were the brainiacs — Spencer, Mona and Andrew — and we’ve made a really interesting, surprising trinity.

      (Not sure about that source though)

      OR maybe he is Bethany's brother! Hahah hadn't really given this a thought but that would be a shock indeed.

        Loading editor
    • Ellaadele wrote:
      Applexsama wrote:
      1. Why did Jessica hide the dresses in the piano? She knew Ali would find them.

      2. Do you think Bethany killed Toby's mother?

      3. Why is always Tanner trying to blame the liars and their friends? For example...when Caleb showed her the photo he took of Mike being tied she indirectly blamed him for that.Do you think Tanner is trying to protect somebody?

      4. Do you think A it's really Charles DiLaurentis or a well known person?I heared some Ezra theories and..idk Ezra gives me goosebumps sometimes.

      5. What is wrong with Andrew? Is he trying to protect the girls or works for A?

      1. I really have no idea about this... I just can't figure out anything that would make any sense at all. 

      2. I think that Mrs. D killed Marion because she knew too much about Charles. Bethany just was in a wrong place at the wrong time and witnessed it. She knew the truth but couldn't tell because Mrs. D threatened to pin it on Bethany -who would believe crazy patient over a board memeber(or whatever Mrs. D was). Then Bethany was forced to live in a lie. That would make you hate someone as it is but I think that Bethany was close to Marion because they both were in Radley at that time. This would explain Bethany's drawings.Maybe Bethany wanted revenge and tried to kill Mrs. D's child, Ali, and wore the same outfit so no one would recognize her.

      Bethany drawings

      Marion falling






      3. I think it was weird that when the police found A's lair Tanner knew exactly what buttons to press to turn all of those screens on. But she seemed genuinely surprised when she saw Mona and the Liars trapped. This case is probably going to be her last.

      Dr Wren K

      That A on Wren's shoulder...

      4. To my mind Charles DiLaurentis is Wren, Jason's secret twin. There some evidence that points to his direction.. I also think that Ezra is suspicious too though! It has been proven that he knows how to stalk and use all kinds of machines. Also a rich family 

      would be a big help because A surely has spend a lot of money on this project.

      5. Maybe Andrew is double-agent or something! Definitely on the same side as Spencer and Mona because of e´what i read in this article: 

      We’ve taken three characters from the books who were the brainiacs — Spencer, Mona and Andrew — and we’ve made a really interesting, surprising trinity.

      (Not sure about that source though)

      OR maybe he is Bethany's brother! Hahah hadn't really given this a thought but that would be a shock indeed.

      1. It didn't make sense for me at all...but i just found it weird..like jessica wanted to make alison lie.Maybe it was a pure coincidence =D


      Thank you for sharing your opinion with me! I'm really trying to figure some things out.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.