FANDOM


  • IMG 5137
    PEOPLE. THAT GIRL HAD TO BE SARA HARVEY!!!!!!! GIRL IS SHADY, AND THEY LOOK WAAAAYYYY TOO SIMILAR FOR IT TO BE A COINCIDENCE.

    DONE.

    What do u think?? :)
    IMG 51383
      Loading editor
    • totally agree

        Loading editor
    • I always thought it was Bethany

        Loading editor
    • It could have been either. It's been hinted many times that there are blonde twins - what if it's Sara and Beth that are twins?

        Loading editor
    • But wouldn't Sara have mentioned to Emily about Bethany?

        Loading editor
    • Everyone lies on PLL :) 

      I'm not even sure that Sara is who she says she is. But then I'm suspicious of everyone on this show!! 

        Loading editor
    • I think Sara is Charles???

        Loading editor
    • Possibly!! But I do wonder if she is just a pawn in the bigger game. I still feel like Wren is Charles...

      But I also can't help but think that Charles is also a pawn and being controlled by uber A.

        Loading editor
    • If the Black widow or "uber A" is the mastermind, I very much am in denial of that. not denying but in denial because it could be the truth. Because all the tragedies and heartbreak and insane-ness of the whole thing seems to lead back to Charles for me. With Uber A all I see is revenge. 

      Anyways about the post. Could be Sara Harvey. I feel if Sara is alive, Bethany is dead. and the opposite you know? There's a B in the box, the box isn't empty.

        Loading editor
    • BETHANY IS DEAD PEOPLE. COME ON. WE KNOW THIS.

        Loading editor
    • How do we know this?  The cops misidentified the body once.  A can switch medical records around.  

      Any character we've assumed is dead, is pretty much fair game to not be dead. We knew Mona was dead.  We saw a body.  Mona is alive and well and out of town to wherever her mother took her, last we heard from Hanna in this episode.  There goes the cardinal rule, "A character isn't dead unless we see a body."  We saw her body.

      With that rule broken, any past potentially dead character is fair game for the writers to play around with.

        Loading editor
    • Is it possible that Sara Harvey is actually who is dead and Bethany Young is who is claiming to be Sara Harvey now? It would make sense why she's not with her family and acting weird. No one in Rosewood knew either of them, so they wouldn't know the difference. And we never saw her mom - or the friends who came to Rosewood earlier in the show - so she's probably lying about something... maybe who she really is. 

        Loading editor
    • I keep saying Sara is actually Bethany. Just waiting to see if it's actually true ^

        Loading editor
    • The blond at the snake place had a bigger nose, like Spencer (I saw a blown up picture) 

        Loading editor
    • HannaIsBae90 wrote:
      I keep saying Sara is actually Bethany. Just waiting to see if it's actually true ^

      I think that makes a lot of sense. I mean, Bethany was in Radley for a long time apparently, so she is used to being in confined spaces. Sara went missing right around the time she would've gotten out/escaped/when Ali first disappeared. She could've been hiding out underground the entire time. Did we ever see Charles and "sara" at the same time? Could she be him? Or just working with him/not who we think she is. I don't remember. I still don't think she or Charles is A though. The only person who I can possibly imagine would have a legitimate reason to hate the liars so much is Toby/Jenna. They are the only ones who really had negative consequences to the liars actions... enough so they might seek out mega revenge over time. 

        Loading editor
    • Ashley marins mercedes wrote:
      HannaIsBae90 wrote:
      I keep saying Sara is actually Bethany. Just waiting to see if it's actually true ^
      I think that makes a lot of sense. I mean, Bethany was in Radley for a long time apparently, so she is used to being in confined spaces. Sara went missing right around the time she would've gotten out/escaped/when Ali first disappeared. She could've been hiding out underground the entire time. Did we ever see Charles and "sara" at the same time? Could she be him? Or just working with him/not who we think she is. I don't remember. I still don't think she or Charles is A though. The only person who I can possibly imagine would have a legitimate reason to hate the liars so much is Toby/Jenna. They are the only ones who really had negative consequences to the liars actions... enough so they might seek out mega revenge over time. 

      We know that most, if not all, of the NAT club turned out to be a part of the A team. Excluding (possibly??) Jason. He did cut them off in the midst of it all while Ian and Garrett continued. and Melissa wasn't confirmed of anything (well I am not saying she's in the clear) same for Jenna I guess. While its true that Jenna and Toby both have a strong reason to hate the Liars. The Jenna Thing? Alison's bullying? Words are easy to spill but feeling it was actually way worse. Ali isn't your typical.. Mean girl that's what I'd say. 

      There were three (or four , counting Cece) Yellow top Blonde girls on the Dilaurentis territory that night. We'll (or I'll) exclude Cece at this point. Anyways I believe 3 girls were buried that night and one of them is dead. Ali , Bethany , and Sara. 

      We know why Ali was in the property, Bethany was lured by Ali, Sara is a runaway who happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time who got caught up in this net, Cece is Melissa's accomplice for whatever she was doing. 

      Cece supposedly ran away or so, Bethany was buried by Melissa.. Possibly hit by Spencer or killed prior to her burial or buried alive, Sara was buried unknowingly.. Supposedly saved by Charles ( well the guy had his reasons lol) , Ali was hit by "Charles" and buried by her mother.. Later to be saved by Mrs.Grunwald. 

      Ali as you can see is very much breathing. Now, Sara or Bethany.. and we can see its Sara. There IS a B in the box, and the B stands for Bethany. Who , by seeing Sara alive. Could be confirmed-ish is dead. If indeed Sara is suspicious/guilty of something. She could have developed Stockholm syndrome while in captivity for the past 3 years or so. 

        Loading editor
    • Ashley marins mercedes wrote:

      HannaIsBae90 wrote:
      I keep saying Sara is actually Bethany. Just waiting to see if it's actually true ^

      I think that makes a lot of sense. I mean, Bethany was in Radley for a long time apparently, so she is used to being in confined spaces. Sara went missing right around the time she would've gotten out/escaped/when Ali first disappeared. She could've been hiding out underground the entire time. Did we ever see Charles and "sara" at the same time? Could she be him? Or just working with him/not who we think she is. I don't remember. I still don't think she or Charles is A though. The only person who I can possibly imagine would have a legitimate reason to hate the liars so much is Toby/Jenna. They are the only ones who really had negative consequences to the liars actions... enough so they might seek out mega revenge over time. 

      Agreed that Sara is up to no good. But look at the post I made about the name Charlie and read the responses. These people say stuff that makes a lot of sense

        Loading editor
    • Objection0ver wrote:

      Ashley marins mercedes wrote:
      HannaIsBae90 wrote:
      I keep saying Sara is actually Bethany. Just waiting to see if it's actually true ^
      I think that makes a lot of sense. I mean, Bethany was in Radley for a long time apparently, so she is used to being in confined spaces. Sara went missing right around the time she would've gotten out/escaped/when Ali first disappeared. She could've been hiding out underground the entire time. Did we ever see Charles and "sara" at the same time? Could she be him? Or just working with him/not who we think she is. I don't remember. I still don't think she or Charles is A though. The only person who I can possibly imagine would have a legitimate reason to hate the liars so much is Toby/Jenna. They are the only ones who really had negative consequences to the liars actions... enough so they might seek out mega revenge over time. 

      We know that most, if not all, of the NAT club turned out to be a part of the A team. Excluding (possibly??) Jason. He did cut them off in the midst of it all while Ian and Garrett continued. and Melissa wasn't confirmed of anything (well I am not saying she's in the clear) same for Jenna I guess. While its true that Jenna and Toby both have a strong reason to hate the Liars. The Jenna Thing? Alison's bullying? Words are easy to spill but feeling it was actually way worse. Ali isn't your typical.. Mean girl that's what I'd say. 

      There were three (or four , counting Cece) Yellow top Blonde girls on the Dilaurentis territory that night. We'll (or I'll) exclude Cece at this point. Anyways I believe 3 girls were buried that night and one of them is dead. Ali , Bethany , and Sara. 

      We know why Ali was in the property, Bethany was lured by Ali, Sara is a runaway who happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time who got caught up in this net, Cece is Melissa's accomplice for whatever she was doing. 

      Cece supposedly ran away or so, Bethany was buried by Melissa.. Possibly hit by Spencer or killed prior to her burial or buried alive, Sara was buried unknowingly.. Supposedly saved by Charles ( well the guy had his reasons lol) , Ali was hit by "Charles" and buried by her mother.. Later to be saved by Mrs.Grunwald. 

      Ali as you can see is very much breathing. Now, Sara or Bethany.. and we can see its Sara. There IS a B in the box, and the B stands for Bethany. Who , by seeing Sara alive. Could be confirmed-ish is dead. If indeed Sara is suspicious/guilty of something. She could have developed Stockholm syndrome while in captivity for the past 3 years or so. 

      Interesting that you mentioned 4 girls wearing yellow that night. I've read multiple theories that cece actually had a different design of a yellow shirt. Meanwhile, I still want to believe Sara is actually Bethany because it'll make more sense if she was on the A-team or helping because someone (not saying names) tried to kill her. Sara just randomly ran away and went to someone's back yard....who does that? Unless she was up to something.

        Loading editor
    • After reading a load of these theories, I'm convinced everyone born in Rosewood has a twin who is either mad, killed or sent away without anyone knowing!

        Loading editor
    • PllAddictCatherine wrote:
      I think Sara is Charles???


      Sara is the liars age and Charles would be like 25-26

        Loading editor
    • ok seriously they can't ALL hav been conveniently buried that night. i know this show has slightly gone to the dogs when it comes to realism, but COME ON. that can't be the case.

      i'd be really surprised if Marlene ended up making Sara be Bethany, and Sara being the one that really died, and everyone was fucking buried that night. like it'd be embarrassing at this point if THAT is where all of this is going. i'm pretty sure the Rosewood officials made sure to be 100% CERTAIN about who the dead body is this time. these people aren't COMPLETELY retarded...but they're still all pretty stupid.

      i think there's a reason Sara and Alison haven't actually met/had scenes together yet, or seen each other properly because Alison probably knows/would remember Sara and probably did some shit to her back in her bitchy days. now Sara could be CRAY.

      now don't get me wrong i'm not saying any of the above statements are impossible/incorrect, everyone's entitled to their own opinions/theories, but i just think that it's all so played out at this point. i mean with like 5 episodes to go, how many more storylines can Marlene repeat at this stage? not everyone can be dead but alive, and buried but not buried. i mean how many times can Marlene lie to us?

      i think Bethany is dead, Sara is SHADY, and to be honest at this point i don't even care that much anymore. i just want all of this to be over. i want to know WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON and WHO THE HELL IS BIG, FINAL, CHARLES, UBER, MEGA, PSYCHO, FAT, REAL, LEADER -A?!?!?!?!?!?!?! 

        Loading editor
    • ^ lol. agreed. But I think in the next 5 episodes we will find out who charles is... not A. I am imagining Charles lunging at them trying to explain he is not A or crazy and they kill him due to terror, then realize they shouldn't have because he isn't a bad guy. 

      There's still an entire season and a half for A to BS around. 

        Loading editor
    • There is no harm in ending this entire story in 6x10 and have the liars 4 years later after being  -A free getting a text after the jump in 6b with a brand new story having nothing to do with anything we`ve seen but something that happened during the 4 years we don`t see. No need to prolong and make the current story anymore confusing then it already is.

        Loading editor
    • I think that girl mustve been Sara

        Loading editor
    • HannaIsBae90 wrote: I keep saying Sara is actually Bethany. Just waiting to see if it's actually true ^

      If Sara is Bethany it could explain why it has been said that Black Veil is end game. But on the other hand: why would she go after the liars? She should go after Charles/CeCe. And, more importantly, why would CeCe work with Bethany?

        Loading editor
    • I was thinking the same thing! I hope it was Sara in the Reptile Pavillion

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.