FANDOM


  •  It’s about who are, and how connected are Big Bad and Charlotte’s killer ? I think at the end it will all be about family.

    Let’s begin with Charlotte, we first meet Cece in 3x07, while her first Big A’s action was to dig up «Alison’s grave» during That Night. In fact I have a problem with this story arc, like we never had a final word concerning Lucas, Noel, Holden or Jenna involvement. Even why Mona was there !? She knew Ali was still alive, and obviously never confirmed that to Charlotte. Did Mona used Red Coat to identify the girl in the grave ? Red Coat who was Charlotte (or Sara, if Charlotte needed a decoy at the cemetery) at the time of 3x01, but she said in 6x10 that she began to believe Ali could be alive when she saw a blonde girl in red coat looking at the girls (so does it mean that she saw Red Coat Ali during the summer before season 3, and then began to wear a red coat too ?) She kept the body long enough to test the DNA, body who will be identify as Bethany Young two seasons later (only 2 or 3 weeks in PLL timeline). Charlotte knew it wasn’t Alison, why bother to give the body back ? I’m almost sure I’m wrong (let’s be crazy, theories are made for that), but what if Charlotte put Bethany’s DNA there or just mess up with police’s analysis ?

     We don’t know much about Bethany, except that she betrayed Charles, used to make drawings about Mrs D with a demon and a little boy with a demon too, and Jessica wanted to be called aunt Jessie by Bethany.

    Why aunt ?

    Is this « she had an affair with Mr Young » is really believable ?

    Maybe yes, if Bethany confused Jessica and her twin.

     Right now (before 6x20), I think Mrs D had a twin sister, I just don’t know which one died in 4x24, but the one who is alive, is the new stalker. A mother who want to avenge her daughter. But it’s not the end.

     I said it doesn’t matter which one is dead because Big Bad consider both Charlotte and Ali as her children. What is the link with Bethany ? Well, let say it straight, I believe Charles died at Radley due to his meds, and Charlotte was indeed a second personality of Bethany. (I told you it will be crazy). Mrs D cared to much about Bethany judging by the info we heard (since we still never saw Bethany’s adult face) if she was just a random girl who framed her son; my theory is that Bethany was Ali and Jason’s cousin (daughter of their mom’s twin). It’s the twin who had an affair with Mr Young, and somehow the twin asked Jessica to care for Bethany. She had split personality disorder, and the bond with Mrs D made her believe she was Charlotte DiLaurentis ! If Charles died and « Bethany became Charlotte » during Jessica’s grief, she could have let Bethany does it because it was a way for Mrs D to keep her son alive (ok this part is really really crazy). Look at Marion’s death flashback, clearly « Charlotte » had a false memory, a personality disorder could be a way to explain that.

     And what about the killer ? Since the scene in Charlotte’s grave, I’m obsessed with the idea that maybe it wasn’t Big Bad who put flower there, but actually Charlotte’s killer. And remember, Charlotte had a rose in her hand when they found her body. And the killer seems to have tried to make it look like a suicide in a quickly and an improvised way. Like the murder was accidental or committed by someone who once cared for her. Who is my suspect ? Lucas Gottesman.



     I’m a big fan of « Lucas is Big Bad » theory. With « Mrs D » return, I really can see a desperate mother looking for her child’s killer in Big Bad’s actions; it doesn’t mean Lucas can’t still be involved. The motive ?

     Now this is my « crazy » theory last part. I thought Lucas could have been Charlotte’s secret lover. Since PLL beginning, Lucas is way too often and way too much involved in the A game. And as I said earlier, some of his involvement were never fully explained or developed.

     BUT, the big final twist could be that Lucas was adopted, and is in fact the twin’s son aka Charlotte/Bethany’s brother !!! If the twin couldn’t raised Bethany, it’s logic she wouldn’t be able to raise an other child if she had one.

     Maybe Lucas was the boy in Bethany’s drawings. Remember the Radley’s var from the episode The First Secret. Lucas could have heard about Bethany around this time, and since began to hate the DiLaurentis. He could also be the one who made Mona to begin the A game (since a huge part of the fandom believe that Mona wasn’t Original A or that there is an Uber A who controlled everything since the very beginning). Lucas could be the key to explain all the plot holes in the show.

     I’m calling it, Lucas will be the HE going after Alison in season 7.

      Loading editor
    • I find 6B was a liittle bored, but I'm exciting for this finale and the next 20 episodes !

        Loading editor
    • I think tonight's ep is going to be good :)

        Loading editor
    • Damn it, Mary Drake ! Now, I wanna know the whole story. But like everytime, the writers are gonna drag this til 7x20. I hope season 7 will be entertaining.

      And I'm pretty happy my theory still could be believable... All light on Lucas please. The twin's identy was predictable but the killer's identity or motive might schocked us !

        Loading editor
    • Also, I don't understand why Kenneth never confessed that Charles was adopted !?? We saw him so pissed and angry when he told Charles' story to Ali and Jason. I remember his first sentence to Jason "There is no Charles DiLaurentis in this family". He should have said the truth, especially when he learned Charles was alive and was A. Unless Jessica and Mary made some kind of arrangements in secret by their own... but no, no way. Kenneth had to know since the beginning.

        Loading editor
    • Charlotte obviously knew about Mary. She called herself Cece Drake ! I'm afraid Charlotte killed Jessica... or at least the flashback we saw was incomplete and after she escaped from the cop, Charlotte maybe saw Mary kill Jessica and help her real mom to bury Mrs D. And I still convinced there's a reason she was buried in Hastings' yard. Maybe Peter knew Mary, or helped for Charles' adoption.

      I'm convinced Hanna was kidnapped by Sara. I don't like Elliot... If I follow my theory above, I don't want (or need) to include him. Let say he's here for the money and Charlotte's heir. I believe Sara, Elliot and Mary were working together as the EmojA. But Sara is really concerned by avenging Charlotte only. I remember Mona and Sara's little chat in 6x19. Mona almost begged her to go easy on the girls. Perhaps Sara realised she had bad allies, and took Hanna to protect her. I saw like Hanna was dressed to prepare a staged death scene (she had flower in her hand just like Charlotte when she died). I think Sara will film "Hanna's death" and send the video to Mary and Eliott.

        Loading editor
    • NeedATeam wrote:
      Also, I don't understand why Kenneth never confessed that Charles was adopted !?? We saw him so pissed and angry when he told Charles' story to Ali and Jason. I remember his first sentence to Jason "There is no Charles DiLaurentis in this family". He should have said the truth, especially when he learned Charles was alive and was A. Unless Jessica and Mary made some kind of arrangements in secret by their own... but no, no way. Kenneth had to know since the beginning.

      Everything that happened to Alison is Kenneth's fault ! It's sad for Ali, and it's not the end, the HE is coming after her. Rosewood would be a safe place without the DiLaurentis lol.

      This is an issue that annoys me, we never had the chance to explore others families drama: Peter's secrets; Tom Marin's story; Scott Montgomery's whereabouts. It's Pretty Little Liars, not pretty little alison :( But there's no time to complain. I'm excited enough with Mary Drake next moves in season 7 !!!

        Loading editor
    • Why Keneth? I would say poor keneth, your wife has an affair with another man and then Jason is born and you have to take care of him and also take care of the child of your wife's crazy sister? I believe keneth is a saint and maybe he promised Jessica he would never reveal the secret that she had a twin sister. I feel sorry for Keneth.

        Loading editor
    • And why you think Keneth knew about A? Nobody knew about A except the girls.

        Loading editor
    • Did anyone else catch the part where they said that Charles was actually almost the very same age as Jason instead of being 18 months older?  I do not understand why the family would lie about that, and especially why Kenneth would lie about it.  Even if he did not want to tell them about the crazy aunt, he could have just said Charles was adopted.  I do feel sorry for Kenneth as well.  They made him out to be this really bad dad, and maybe the reason he wanted Charles to go to Radley is because he really thought he was trying to hurt Ali.  Especially when he knows the birth mother has issues.  

        Loading editor
    • PLLBarcelona wrote:
      Why Keneth? I would say poor keneth, your wife has an affair with another man and then Jason is born and you have to take care of him and also take care of the child of your wife's crazy sister? I believe keneth is a saint and maybe he promised Jessica he would never reveal the secret that she had a twin sister. I feel sorry for Keneth.

      Kenneth is a saint?? Yeah, his wife cheated on him and had a kid with someone else, but he locked his (adoptive) kid up in Radley and never visited her/him! Not once!!

        Loading editor
    • Cpate wrote:
      Did anyone else catch the part where they said that Charles was actually almost the very same age as Jason instead of being 18 months older?  I do not understand why the family would lie about that, and especially why Kenneth would lie about it.  Even if he did not want to tell them about the crazy aunt, he could have just said Charles was adopted.  I do feel sorry for Kenneth as well.  They made him out to be this really bad dad, and maybe the reason he wanted Charles to go to Radley is because he really thought he was trying to hurt Ali.  Especially when he knows the birth mother has issues.  

      Maybe they didn't want anyone to know that Charles was adopted because they didn't want anyone to find out about Jessica's crazy twin. And, since they were born so close together, they had to have said that one of them was older because you can't get pregnant that fast. 

        Loading editor
    •   Loading editor
    • SpencerHannaEmilyAria PLL wrote:
      PLLBarcelona wrote:
      Why Keneth? I would say poor keneth, your wife has an affair with another man and then Jason is born and you have to take care of him and also take care of the child of your wife's crazy sister? I believe keneth is a saint and maybe he promised Jessica he would never reveal the secret that she had a twin sister. I feel sorry for Keneth.
      Kenneth is a saint?? Yeah, his wife cheated on him and had a kid with someone else, but he locked his (adoptive) kid up in Radley and never visited her/him! Not once!!

      A saint might be an exaggeration but we don't know how long Charles was with them and he also said that wasn't the first time something like the Ali bathtub incident had happened. I think him being "the ultimate villain" or whatever Marlene called him with the Cece reveal might have also been an exagerration though. 

        Loading editor
    • NeedATeam wrote:
      Charlotte obviously knew about Mary. She called herself Cece Drake ! I'm afraid Charlotte killed Jessica... or at least the flashback we saw was incomplete and after she escaped from the cop, Charlotte maybe saw Mary kill Jessica and help her real mom to bury Mrs D. And I still convinced there's a reason she was buried in Hastings' yard. Maybe Peter knew Mary, or helped for Charles' adoption.

      I'm convinced Hanna was kidnapped by Sara. I don't like Elliot... If I follow my theory above, I don't want (or need) to include him. Let say he's here for the money and Charlotte's heir. I believe Sara, Elliot and Mary were working together as the EmojA. But Sara is really concerned by avenging Charlotte only. I remember Mona and Sara's little chat in 6x19. Mona almost begged her to go easy on the girls. Perhaps Sara realised she had bad allies, and took Hanna to protect her. I saw like Hanna was dressed to prepare a staged death scene (she had flower in her hand just like Charlotte when she died). I think Sara will film "Hanna's death" and send the video to Mary and Eliott.

      I'm convinced Sara gonna somehow help the girls, and Peter or Melissa will be more targeted by Mary next season. I'm calling it, it's gonna be Drake vs Hastings.

      There's still so many mysteries involving Melissa: the alliance with Jenna and Shana at the time of the fire lodge (when she said "bitches" speaking about Spencer and the girls !); the fact that she seems to have been the one who tried to kill Aria in the Halloween train; the blonde girl she talked to (Jason's flashback); her contribution into the "Mona's army"... So many more holes into the big picture.

        Loading editor
    • I don't know but I have a feeling that Alison is Mary Drake's daughter, or that Mary has a daughter that looks a lot like Ali. Maybe that person helped her get out of the mental hospital? Because Alison looks a lot like CeCe, and maybe she had a sister like Ali.

        Loading editor
    • IntotheShadows01 wrote:
      I don't know but I have a feeling that Alison is Mary Drake's daughter, or that Mary has a daughter that looks a lot like Ali. Maybe that person helped her get out of the mental hospital? Because Alison looks a lot like CeCe, and maybe she had a sister like Ali.

      That would be a lot like the books if then did that with Ali.

        Loading editor
    • NeedATeam wrote:
      NeedATeam wrote:

      I'm convinced Hanna was kidnapped by Sara. I don't like Elliot... If I follow my theory above, I don't want (or need) to include him. Let say he's here for the money and Charlotte's heir. I believe Sara, Elliott and Mary were working together as the EmojA. But Sara is really concerned by avenging Charlotte only. I remember Mona and Sara's little chat in 6x19. Mona almost begged her to go easy on the girls. Perhaps Sara realised she had bad allies, and took Hanna to protect her.

      I'm convinced Sara gonna somehow help the girls, and Peter or Melissa will be more targeted by Mary next season. I'm calling it, it's gonna be Drake vs Hastings.

      At least, according to the promo, Mary will come for Spencer, in a way or another... Bad news for the Hastings.

        Loading editor
    • Redrice wrote:

      IntotheShadows01 wrote:
      I don't know but I have a feeling that Alison is Mary Drake's daughter, or that Mary has a daughter that looks a lot like Ali. Maybe that person helped her get out of the mental hospital? Because Alison looks a lot like CeCe, and maybe she had a sister like Ali.

      That would be a lot like the books if then did that with Ali.

      True. This Ali-look-alike can sign Mary out of Radley as herself or as Alison and act as Ali D(A). This would also explain CeCe's closeness to Ali, as Ali reminds her of her sister, who she maybe thought to be dead. CeCe's sister saw this and became jealous of Ali and then targeted everyone.

        Loading editor
    • (Such as the liars)

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.