his dad remarried Jenna's mom a year after his mom died. So 13-15
In Charlotte's story Charlotte and Bethany were 12 and Charlotte was born 1988 so it must've happened in 2000 but we all know Bethany is 4 years younger than Charlotte and in 2x13 (2008 episode) Toby says it was 1 year since his mother died so it happened in 2007, not 2000.
agreed ^ 2007 should be the official date of death for marion
i Marion died at 45/36. DOB 1962 so DOD 2007 or 1998
o Toby DOB 1993
- 14 or 5
i Marion was in the flashback with Toby and Alison almost kissing. Marlene said that they WERE NOT teenagers.
o If she died in 2007, Alison and Toby were between 5 and 14
o If she died in 1998, Alison and Toby were less than 5 years old
o Charles would be 19 in 2007, making Charlottes story inconsistent because Charles “died” 3 years ago.
- So how could Charles be blamed for her murder?
I think Charlotte blamed the murder on Bethany because she was dead already for over 3 years and she couldn't confirm or deny it. Also Marion was dead so no one could deny her story except the doctor Palmer but he was already ill and Charlotte paid him (or something) to lie about it because he couldn't fight back (start of season 4)