FANDOM


  • Right so we know that Maya's 'body' was discovered but how do we know Maya is actually dead - she might of done an Ali on us...

         First of all the scenes where Alison's and Maya's 'bodies' were found are oddly similar: like how the same song is played, Emily's reactions are the same, at least one person sees an ambulance head down the road leading to Maya's or Alison's house and then the body's are both in body bags  - so how do we know Maya is actually dead? When Pam Fields spoke to Emily when they found Maya's' body she said 'They found a body and they think it's Maya's'  THINKS? It was never confirmed.

         Maya’s body being found: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UQ1ze8HLyNI

         Alison’s body being found:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jgsGtuLW2aA

       We also know that Nate/Lyndon James didn't actually confess to murdering Maya so there is no evidence that someone did actually kill her. We know that Maya wasn't afraid of Nate because when she talked about him she didn't seem afraid.

       We know that Maya knew that her life was in danger. She spoke about her stalker on several occasions - we know that wasn't Nate so could that stalker be 'A'? When Mona sung her riddles; 'Miss Aria, your a killer, not Ezra's wife' and 'No one to save Ali from evil' the first one tells us 'Maya knew' the second 'Not safe' Maya probably knew about -A/ the A team and maybe this is why she is in danger? Maya could of easily read Alison's diary's and looked at her belongings also when  Spencer sees a blonde figure in Maya's bedroom, could of she returned to collect her belongings? Maybe Maya saw her?  We also know that Maya worked in Lucky Leon's Cupcakes so maybe she saw 'A' come in and order 'Hefty Hanna' her cupcakes?



    I think Maya faked her death to protect Emily, like how Toby pretended not to be with Spencer to protect her.

      Loading editor
    • I have been saying that i think maya is still alive.  I totally agree with you!   everything about Maya was sketchy...she moved into Ali's old room, she befriended Emily, she knew Noel.  There is way more to the Maya story then we have been told.

        Loading editor
    • I've been thinking this the whole time hahahahahahaha

        Loading editor
    • I've always loved the 'Mary had a little (Eddie) lamb' theory that a lot of people have posted about since the twin reveal. That Mary had a secret relationship with Eddie Lamb while she was a patient at Radley, the product of which was Maya. This would obviously be more than breaking the rules of patient/doctor/nurse relations. When Wren is working there he sees Eddie spend a lot of time speaking to Spencer, he then asks him if 'they are going to have problem again'. Because Wren knows Mary, he knew of her and Eddies relationship and made that comment as a sort of bully tactic, implying that he'd be trying the same with Spencer as she was a patient too.

      This would totally fit into this theory! Although wildly unpopular and unlikely, I still think it's cool that things can be linked up in such a way, even if it wasn't on purpose.

        Loading editor
    • CCPLL wrote:
      I've always loved the 'Mary had a little (Eddie) lamb' theory that a lot of people have posted about since the twin reveal. That Mary had a secret relationship with Eddie Lamb while she was a patient at Radley, the product of which was Maya. This would obviously be more than breaking the rules of patient/doctor/nurse relations. When Wren is working there he sees Eddie spend a lot of time speaking to Spencer, he then asks him if 'they are going to have problem again'. Because Wren knows Mary, he knew of her and Eddies relationship and made that comment as a sort of bully tactic, implying that he'd be trying the same with Spencer as she was a patient too.

      This would totally fit into this theory! Although wildly unpopular and unlikely, I still think it's cool that things can be linked up in such a way, even if it wasn't on purpose.

      Definitely! It could happen as it's Pretty little liars!

        Loading editor
    • Emmamae wrote:

      CCPLL wrote:
      I've always loved the 'Mary had a little (Eddie) lamb' theory that a lot of people have posted about since the twin reveal. That Mary had a secret relationship with Eddie Lamb while she was a patient at Radley, the product of which was Maya. This would obviously be more than breaking the rules of patient/doctor/nurse relations. When Wren is working there he sees Eddie spend a lot of time speaking to Spencer, he then asks him if 'they are going to have problem again'. Because Wren knows Mary, he knew of her and Eddies relationship and made that comment as a sort of bully tactic, implying that he'd be trying the same with Spencer as she was a patient too.

      This would totally fit into this theory! Although wildly unpopular and unlikely, I still think it's cool that things can be linked up in such a way, even if it wasn't on purpose.

      Definitely! It could happen as it's Pretty little liars!

      Exactly! I think sensibly we know all of these theories sound crazy or really far fetched but I don't think anything can really be ruled out all together on this show.

        Loading editor
    • Can someone please explain how we know that Maya's stalker wasn't Nate, like this post says? I'm pretty sure it was him, that he killed her, and I'm really sick of "Maya is alive" stories! Seriously no offence to anyone, but Marlene even confirmed that Nate killed her, no? I can really remember that! He loved her, she didn't love him back, she wanted Emily instead so he was gonna take Paige from Emily to make her understand how it felt to lose someone cause of someone else. No matter what, I really hope she is dead and that there will be nothing more about her!

        Loading editor
    • Curly90 wrote:
      Can someone please explain how we know that Maya's stalker wasn't Nate, like this post says? I'm pretty sure it was him, that he killed her, and I'm really sick of "Maya is alive" stories! Seriously no offence to anyone, but Marlene even confirmed that Nate killed her, no? I can really remember that! He loved her, she didn't love him back, she wanted Emily instead so he was gonna take Paige from Emily to make her understand how it felt to lose someone cause of someone else. No matter what, I really hope she is dead and that there will be nothing more about her!

      1) Saying no offence doesn't make it not offencive. 2) Marlene even tweeted Maya was going to come back. 3) Nothing can be ruled out on this show.

        Loading editor
    • When did Marlene tweet that? Recently? I tend to agree with Curly that Maya is 1) DEAD 2) Not relevant to the current story line

      Why take offence to opinions? They are what they are. 

        Loading editor
    • MissyLA wrote:
      When did Marlene tweet that? Recently? I tend to agree with Curly that Maya is 1) DEAD 2) Not relevant to the current story line

      Why take offence to opinions? They are what they are. 

      -pllspoiler Maya is Alive
       1) I do not take offence to people's opinions, I just wanted to say that because I know from real life that 'no offence' does not make any difference.

      2) MAYA IS ALIVE (Look at Marlene King's tweet  - yes it was a while back but it still could happen!)

      3) It is Pretty Little Liars! Anything could happen!

        Loading editor
    • 1) Ok

      2) That tweet is from 3 years ago - totally has no relevance and was written before the A reveal.

      )
        Loading editor
    • Yes it was written before the 'A' reveal but still we haven't seen Maya - though who says Maya still make a comeback. [[1]]

        Loading editor
    • Haha thank you MissyLA!!! Emmamae - unless it offended YOU I don't see the point in that comment. That's why I wrote "no offence" - cause I knew some people might make a nasty comment about my opinion (like you) but you have to respect that we all have different opinions, so I really did mean NO OFFENCE when I wrote it! ;)

        Loading editor
    • People on this forum can take offence to anything I say if they want - because after all - I am only making comments about a fictional show on a forum.....not about anyone's family, friends, job, appearance etc...so....

        Loading editor
    • That tweet by Marlene was deleted right after and many people believe her to have been hacked or something. It is genuinely accepted in the fandom that that was not from Marlene. I will say, I wish we had gotten answers what exactly "MAYA KNEW" (Mona), but now it is too late. Maya will not be back. There is already Sabrina, Ali, and Paige coming back. Emily can't have another love ineterest on this show because of her dead lover returning!

        Loading editor
    • Little baby25
      Little baby25 removed this reply because:
      never mind
      21:26, August 16, 2016
      This reply has been removed
    • Curly90 wrote:
      Haha thank you MissyLA!!! Emmamae - unless it offended YOU I don't see the point in that comment. That's why I wrote "no offence" - cause I knew some people might make a nasty comment about my opinion (like you) but you have to respect that we all have different opinions, so I really did mean NO OFFENCE when I wrote it! ;)

      It didn't offened ME, it was just that I was bullied for quite a while and people said  'no offence' before saying somthing nasty - I said that no offence doesn't make anything not offencive.

        Loading editor
    • I'm very sorry to hear that, but that's really not what I meant... I just wanted to make my opinion clear (which is that I'm really sick of Maya theories) but I didn't want it to come across as offensive, cause that's not the intention here.

      I'm just kinda sick of reading; Maya is totally alive, she's the second kid, or Sabrina is A.D. and stuff like that. I know putting the pieces together are hard, but bringing up people that are so not relevant is pointless... If that's the case then let's also talk about how Shana and Wilden and Garrett and Ian might still be alive and have a roll in this! :P It's just taking it a bit too far for me!

        Loading editor
    • I told everyone there was more to the maya theories

        Loading editor
    • The only reason I would think maya is still alive is because when Emily and spencer went in Noel's house, Emily said she noticed a tattoo and that "Maya" Had the same one. A little off to mention her name right before 7A finale

        Loading editor
    • well noel knew maya and she stayed at his lodge. which could explain the box

        Loading editor
    • Everyone who went to Noels parties had this stamp on their hand, remember Holden had one too, not only Maya. So the sign on the box doesn't necessarily have to be connected to Maya. It could just be a Kahn-family sign or something lol. Maya is dead.. I do think that Maya knew something important ( Mona saying Maya know)

        Loading editor
    • yea but wasnt it also confirmed that Maya was hiding out at the cabin? probably hiding from nate lol

        Loading editor
    • If I remember correctly Nate was sending Maya text messages. Probably threathening text messages. So assuming Maya knew Noel because she went to one of his parties, she might've asked him to help her out because she was afraid of Nate and the cabin was a good hiding spot. When the liars started to suspect Noel, he sent that security tape video which shows Maya being taking by someone, probably Nate, since he killed her.

      Only thing I wanna know is. How the hell did Maya end up in Emily's backyard???

        Loading editor
    • ^ thats what i meant to say lol.

      as for how maya got in Emily's backyard.....maybe Nate knew of Emily and knew that it would devastate her?

        Loading editor
    • I think shes really dead but i DO wanna know what "Maya knew". Cuz That part has never been properly explained.

        Loading editor
    • If Maya is alive (and I don't think she is, but I'll play along) who's body was found?   Some random African American girl? 

        Loading editor
    • Fearless Diva said somewhere in the past that "Maya is Alive" tweet is Marlene Bullshitting 101.

      Maya has been dead for years since five seasons ago! Almost seven years in the PLL universe.

      Plus I don't mean to be mean when I post this:

      I can't deal with this one more time. She's dead!

      I can't deal with this again.

        Loading editor
    • ^^^Preach, some people won't let it go lmao.

        Loading editor
    • ^ I feel that way with all the theories of dead characters being alive. Everyone is just dead or they have a reallyreally bad forensics team lol

        Loading editor
    • ^ Probably. Next they'll say Ian's long lost twin is Uber A.

      @FearlessDiva On average, how many theories have you read that so-and-so is really still alive and is A?

        Loading editor
    • I read somewhere that detective Wilden is alive and Charlotte's twin looool. First of all Charles was born single and second of all Wilden is dead!

        Loading editor
    • ^^^ Theories upon theories just get crazier and crazier! Me thinketh that the PLL fandom is descending into madness.

        Loading editor
    • I don't think Maya is really alive. It's been WAY too long to bring her back up again, but I do think it's odd that her death is the only one that was never tied into "A" in some way and how the discovery of her body was oddly similar to the discovery of "Alison's" body.

      Also, it doesn't help the theories when they mention her name randomly out of the blue when there isn't a reason for it. All they had to mention was that the symbol was the same one people got when they attended Khan parties. Maya didn't need to be mentioned. So why do so?

      Maybe Noel really killed her and not Nate.....just a random thought.

        Loading editor
    • It was her stalker Nate. Case closed.

        Loading editor
    • MasterMystery wrote:
      It was her stalker Nate. Case closed.

      I hate this type of comment and outlook. I don't personally think Maya's alive either but to just say "case closed" is just obnoxious. Especially with this show that not only brings back "dead" characters but has gone back and changed what has already been written.

      If I don't want to talk about a particular topic, I stay out of it. It works out pretty well for me. You should try it sometime.

        Loading editor
    • MasterMystery wrote:
      It was her stalker Nate. Case closed.

      Perhaps your right. But as I said, it's odd that her death was the only one not tied to the "A" situation, when all other deaths have been connected is some way.

      Maya's name was mentioned in the most recent episode, when there was absolutley no need to do so. This is also the episode where they show that Noel helped Charlotte with the Dollhouse. Perhaps they mentioned Maya's name because it will be revealed that Noel killed her and not Nate. She had been staying at Noel's cabin when she was hiding from him. Add on the fact that she moved into Alison's house (which was still filled with clues/things Alison left behind). Also remember Mona's riddle? "Miss Aria, Your A Killer, Not Ezra's Wife" = MAYA KNEW

      There is high probability that perhaps she found something that could either reveal Alison was alive, or that Noel was helping torture the girls. This would tie her death to the rest of the story, answer the long time question of what "MAYA KNEW", but also not have her be randomly alive.

        Loading editor
    • ^this is most probable.   She is not alive, but her death is important. 

        Loading editor
    • Maybe Mona knew that Maya knew her stalker was dangerous?

        Loading editor
    • MasterMystery wrote:
      Maybe Mona knew that Maya knew her stalker was dangerous?

      That's entirely possible. Just seems odd that Maya's death is the only one that isn't somehow tied to the "A" situation. Also, out of all the things Mona told Aria and Hanna while in Radley, only two things were never investigated

      "Miss Aria, You're A Killer, Not Ezra's Wife" = MAYA KNEW

      "I Miss My Dolls" = I'M MD

      Now the I'M MD might not even be a real clue, or at least they didn't think it was one. They were not told that one directly, rather Mona said it to the hospital staff that came to return her to her room. We, as the audience, assume it's a clue because Mona knew they were hiding and could still hear her and she looked towards them when she said it. However, Aria and Hanna may not have realized she was still giving them clues with the staff around.

      However, Aria and Hanna were directly told the first one, yet chose to ignore it completely, not even mentioning it to Spencer or Emily.

      Question is, Why?

      These girls have quite the habit of jumping to conclusions over the smallest of clues. Strangely, they don't even remotely begin to assume there was more to Maya's death, despite Mona telling them that clue. Seems out of character for these girls not to at least think it's possible "A" had something to do with it, rather than ignoring it entirely. As if Mona never said anything.

      Just seems like there is more going on here than we're being told. (My above comment gets into that.)

        Loading editor
    • Maya Knew was pertaining to the fact that Maya knew who her killer was. That's that.

        Loading editor
    • Fearless Diva
      Fearless Diva removed this reply because:
      spam
      08:10, August 29, 2016
      This reply has been removed
    • so the first thing I would like to say is, I truely wish it were the case that Maya was still alive. There's a part of me that would be extremely happy, because they were my favorite pairing, and they really loved and cared for eachother. I was not a fan of Paige at all (she seemed to pushy, in a "i want things to go this specific way" sort of thing.) And the other relationships are just meh to me at best. But I know I shouldn't get my hopes up; as someone mentioned; it's been what? 6? 7 years PLL time? So that's probably very unlikely to happen.

      I do however, wanna know the meaning behind the previous discussions, with the "MAYA KNEW" part. Also, as someone mentioned before, also the "IM MD" one, although as the person mentioned, that might not actually be a clue, and was just her saying she missed her dolls so the doctors wouldn't suspect anything. Regardless, some clarification on the "MAYA KNEW" clue would be amazing. (As I agree with some other commenters, that it might not just be as simple as saying "she knew who her stalker/killer was." It could mean other things.)

        Loading editor
    • Maya knew was pertaining to the fact that Maya knew who her killer was. it Lyndon, the ex-boyfriend from True North. It's that simple. Marlene, I believe even clarified it. People need to move on. Maya has not been on since season 3A, which is over four sesons ago and 7-8 years in PLL time.  Mona saying I miss my dolls, was her way of talking to the girls, since she like Charlotte treated them as  such.

        Loading editor
    • Firstly, let me just say that if Maya comes back in 7B it doesn't mean she is still alive. She might be in flashbacks, or she might just be mentionned. Secondly, however, if she is alive, I don't see why anyone would be upset about that? She was a major piece to the puzzle from season 1 until now because she literally KNEW things the girls didn't. I really don't think she's alive because they would have brought her back by now, or something of the sort, but it's unfair to everyone on this website to shut down other people's theories. If you don't like it then don't comment? Or come up with something better? Saying you hate certain theories or that you find some of them unrealistic doesn't make you superior or smarter. It just means the only thing you can contribute is an unwanted opinion. No offence. 

      I understand that some people don't like certain theories, as do I, but being negative isn't necessary. 


      Moving on. 


      As for the actual original post, there is something fishy, in MY opinion, about Emily's relationship with Ali, Maya and Paige. They are very odd, and when I saw them onscreen I would feel extremly weird for different reasons. Especially when she's with Paige. The vibe that I get, is that the only person who loved her deeply and purely was Maya and that's the one person that was taken away from her. I personally don't think Ali's feelings are real, in my mind, Ali is still Ali and she wants Emily to be all about her even though she may not feel the same way back. Strangely, I get the same impression from Paige but it is projected entirely different. The fishy part that is bothering me about these three relationships is that Emily cannot tell the difference between someone actually loving her and someone using her. Which means that she is easily manipulated as we have seen on various occasions. All she has to do is like you and she will do anything for you. This inclines me to believe she is more involved with UBER A than we might think. 

        Loading editor
    • Slowbutsurely








      Idk if your directing it at me per se, but nevertheless, I am telling you not, I'm not bringing anyone down. It's just that we have pretty much heard all these theories a thousand times over.  People latest predictions are nothing new and are trying to make Maya into something she's not. All Maya knew was her killer. She wasn't even that important of a character when you look at appearences. Toby, Mona, Jenna and Caleb had more to do in those earlier seasons that Maya who was credited as main for the first two seasons. As for appearing in 7B.... even in in flashbacks is unlikely. Sure, she might get mentioned and they could use stock footage from previous scenes, but her storyline was wrapped up at the end of 3A.

        Loading editor
    • Maya was in more episodes than many characters like: Wren, CECE, Andrew, Sara, etc. Anything is plausible in this show.

      I couldn't care less who comes back and who doesn't but it's unfair to those who are trying to come up with theories to shut them down because a handful don't agree. 

        Loading editor
    • ^ Fearless Diva isn't being rude or unfair. She's just being real. Maya has never been mentioned since 3A, not even in 6x10. It's just that, even after all this damn time she actually turns out to be alive, how would that help anything or figure out whose A.D.

        Loading editor
    • <div class="floatleft">Gossip-girl-35</div>









      http://pretty-little-liars.wikia.com/wiki/Character_Appearances

      I'm not shutting anything down lmao. Simply stating the facts hun. Maya has been in 18 episodes as main and  then 4 more as part of the supporting cast for 3A. That puts her at 22. Andrew and Sara have not been relevant enough on the show to warrant more episodes. Wren will pretty much appear in most if not all of 7B, so that will put him at anywhere from 21-30 episodes by the end of the series run. He's been more important in terms of plot and storyline than Maya. Despite being a series regular, she wasn't used much. recurring characters appeared more than she did.  So in short, believe what you will, but just telling you know that all that  you have said or predicted has been said in the past by other users.

        Loading editor
    • Irrelevant to my point. You're dragging something on because you hate when people talk about the same theories over and over, so why are you STILL here? Lol.

        Loading editor
    • Maya is irrelevant now, @HannaDrake. Personally, I don't hate when people talk about the same theories (some irrelevant as Maya), but it should be exhausting. Why go dwell on the past that doesn't help anything or anyone RN?

        Loading editor
    • I agree, some things are repetitive, however I dislike seeing other people being put down when they are putting effort. And maybe that's not what was being done here, but it triggered me hence my reaction. 

        Loading editor
    • It's not what's being done here hun. Maybe you should control yourself more? As you have a right to your opinion, by someone posting a forum, it opends up to different viewpoint. The  forum asked if Maya was alive, I was simply answera this inane question with a dignified answer based on proof from the show. Your the one that took it too personal.

        Loading editor
    • ^ Sorry if you were talking to me I apologize. I didn't mean to come off as being rude or meaning to insult when responding to @HannaDrake.

        Loading editor
    • HannaDrake wrote:
      Maya was in more episodes than many characters like: Wren, CECE, Andrew, Sara, etc. Anything is plausible in this show.

      I couldn't care less who comes back and who doesn't but it's unfair to those who are trying to come up with theories to shut them down because a handful don't agree. 

      Wren will only be in a couple of episodes in 7b, so you are right in regards to him.

      Here is a link and quote from a PLL producer.

      He comes back in a very surprising way, in a way that I don’t think the character Wren was expecting to come back. Thus, his presence is a mystery to us. It’s really not going to be until the final episode of the series that an explanation for what he’s doing here is revealed, and it will be a whopper. It will not be what you see coming. He doesn’t really have a lot of screen time. We see him just once or twice in the second half of the season, and then we see him in a very surprising exchange in the final episode, which will be the moment that really causes people’s heads to explode in a positive way. He’s part of the ultimate final twist in the final episode. 3 days ago http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/live-feed/pretty-little-liars-final-season-924744

        Loading editor
    • Maya's death was confirmed but Marlene said there might be more to her story. You can read more here: http://www.bustle.com/articles/147247-maya-could-return-to-pretty-little-liars-according-to-i-marlene-kings-cryptic-tweet

        Loading editor
    • MasterMystery wrote:
      ^ Sorry if you were talking to me I apologize. I didn't mean to come off as being rude or meaning to insult when responding to @HannaDrake.

      No, I meant in response to Hanna Drake not you @Master Mystery.

      @MonaVanderDoll: Yeah but Marlene is like Alison, she lies more than she breathes lol. People should have learned by now to take what she says with a grain of salt. Pretty obvious she only said that to appease to crazy Emaya shippers who still can't let go. And last I heard, besides the finale, Wren is confirmed for at least 3 episodes of 7B. Moreover, it could end up being he appear in more than they are telling us. That's what happened with Brant in 7A.

        Loading editor
    • It wasn't Marlene that said Wren would only be in a few episodes but executive producer, Charlie Craig. As for Marlene and what she says, I do take it with a grain of salt. She did say on twitter that Mona was dead, when obviously she wasn't.

      What you said proves my point,  Marlene and other writers said Maya was dead. I believe she probably is. However, what people on this thread are doing is using Marlene's and other writer's words for the gospel truth in regards to Maya being dead, but then turning around and saying we can't trust Marlene or the words of other writers because they ended up doing the opposite of what they said like with Brant (not sure who that is) in 7A.

      However, the fact that she said it,  means it could happen, as you pointed out, we dont' know when she is telling the truth. There may be more to the story line. That's my point, to bring balance to this discussion because no one knows when they are pulling our leg, like with Mona.  As for Wren appearing more, that is speculation at best since we have what the Charlie Craig said will happen. We will have to wait and see if they aren't being truthful.

      No offense to anyone on this thread, I really mean that. I think it's important to really have fun with this and speculate without giving offense. I think what is happening is some of you are so annoyed with the Maya theories that you are not considering how you are coming across to the poster of the theory. It happens sometimes to all of us.

      You hate the theory, which is fine, we all have theories we are tired of seeing. When you put yourself out there though and people come off annoyed with something you wrote and use words like "inane" to describe someone's theory, or say "preach some people don't know how to let it go lmao",  that is not dismantling a theory but being personally offensive to the person that posted that theory.  Try to put yourself in someone else's shoes.

      Like HannaDrake says above, if you are annoyed with it, don't read it or atleast try to dismantle it kindly. No one on here has absolute proof of much of anything as both sides have pointed out, they have lied to us many times. This forum has enough room for many theories, so it's very easy to find a theory you like, if you don't like this one, without hurting someone. I'm done.

        Loading editor
    • OK, Brant Daugherty.

        Loading editor
    • @MonaVanderdoll Look, I agree with you about Marlene. Even Fearless Diva admits everything Marlene says we have to take with a grain of salt. I do not want to be mean, but the tweet Marlene sent saying "Maya is Alive" is BS. She probably had too much wine and decided to drunkenly browse through Twitter.

      I admit I myself is tired of the Maya theories. But looking at the past, especially Seasons 1 and 2 doesn't help. She hasn't been mentioned since the season premiere of 3A. Marlene or the other staff haven't mentioned her in years. Maya was just a love interest that added to the storyline. She died along with the first A mystery. Her time contributing to the storyline was up. To be honest, in death, she contributed a bit more in 3A. But any remnant of Maya died along with her killer in "The Lady Killer".

      Wren, on the other hand, will contribute more. I mean, like Archer, he was a suspicious English doctor whom everyone thought was A. But now that he's coming back he adds to the storyline (a big twist in the end!)

      I agree with Selena that, like Bethany, you have to let the Maya is Alive ideas go. You can argue or prove whatever you want, I won't stop you. But rationally, as confirmed by the show, there was still a body bag.

        Loading editor
    • @MasterMystery. I haven't mentioned anything about a tweet that Marlene may or may not have tweeted "Maya is Alive. Not sure why you brought that up. Did you read what I wrote? It's obvious that I'm not defending Maya is alive theories but the person's right to state that theory without feeling attacked. No you dont' have to agree with that theory and should disagree with it if you have proof to the contrary, but I have yet to see anyone here give concrete proof. Nothing more than conjecture and the words of writers that people believe or disbelieve depending on if it goes along with their theory.

      I personally believe she is more than likely dead and I've already read everyone's side on here and really dont' mind one way or the other. I'm not a Maya fan.

      I came on here to read a theory just to get a different perspective but was surprised to see some of what was written and wanted to point out that it doesn't really matter what you believe is happening one way or another, as long as we are considerate to the person themselves.

      Telling me that Wren will contribute more, is something I completely agree with. I believe there is more to Wren than to Maya. I read that same interview that you are quoting from. I'm really not sure why you are telling me to let it go when it's not even a theory of mine but a slim possibility in my mind, that quite frankly doesn't interest me that much cause I'm not a Maya fan as I pointed out.

      I'm not being mean either, but no, I don't have to let anything go, nor does the poster of this theory, that is what this forum is for and people acting annoyed and telling people "you have to let it go" is coming across as aggressive and rude to other people on here that are reading it.

      Is this a t.v. show? Isn't the whole point in it to have fun? If someone wants to believe it, why not just let them? It's not seriouis enough to warrant such responses. As for what you just said to me, I wasn't taking you as intentionally being rude. I don't think anyone on here tried to be intentionally rude or really realized that they were being rude.

        Loading editor
    • As for you saying there was a body bag with Maya, (keep in mind this is not my theory and am not defending it but just trying to point out something) well we have more than that with Mona. Mona was dead and we saw her dead face. Marlene said she was dead, Mrs. G said she was having a hard time passing and she was fully alive. You can't get more concrete proof then seeing cold dead eyes looking back at you from the trunk of a car and them giving Mrs. G that line, not to mention the cast and Marlene and who knows who else confirmed it. Yet Mona is alive. We never saw Maya's.In fact there is far less proof of Maya being dead.  My point is that you are arguing because that is what YOU want to believe and how YOU see it. And honestly I agree with your theory just not how you are going about it. This girl that posted this theory has reasons to believe her theory might be true, so let her. What is it hurting you,or me, or anyone else on here?

        Loading editor
    • BqZpW








      Oh my god....lol this is just too much. Clearly no matter what we say, we can't get through  you guy's heads. Again... Haven't been rude  and while I would read all of your responses, they are all things we have seen before. I'll cap it off with this though... That just as you said  this place to have fun and talk. That's what a forum is. All I've been trying to let you, Hanna Drake and whoever else might be know that based on the show's cannon, what's been said in interviews, cast gossip, etc. That Maya isn't coming back. Maya knew was nothing more than her knowing who her killer was. That's what it was. We've been considerate and respectful. Now is it really our fault that some people just can't let go that Maya is dead. It's  a tv show lmao.

        Loading editor
    • ^ THANK YOU!!!!!!!

      What part don&#039;t you understand that Maya is truly dead and has been?!

      What part don't you understand that Maya is dead?

        Loading editor
    • Maya is as alive as Jenna not being blind.

        Loading editor
    • Giphy (3)
        Loading editor
    • Selena omfg you're making me cry 😂😂😂

        Loading editor
    • Giphy (2)






      They don't call me the queen of gifs for nothing! :)

        Loading editor
    • You know what they say about the crazy ones - Captain Boomerang

      You know what they say about the crazy ones - Captain Boomerang

        Loading editor
    • ^^^ Such a hilarious movie!

        Loading editor
    • What was your favorite part?

        Loading editor
    • I didn't really have a favorite part but more like favorite characters. Harley of course,  Enchantress and  Diablo. Though, harley's scene at the prison and thereafter were hilarious

        Loading editor
    • Marlene is either BSing or drunk-tweeting again.

        Loading editor
    • What if Alison is A (read my theories) and since we found out Noel Khan was helping in the dollhouse and is the one who put blood on Spencer, Noel Khan was always ALISONS little minion! He helped her "disappear" for 2 years, he was the one who helped Alison sneak CeCe out as Vivian Darkbloom!! What if Alison killed Maya to keep her death looking REAL! Alison will go to extreme lengths to making her lies seem like the truth! Just like having NOEL KHAN break into Hannas house while she was staying there after she MANIPULATED Ashley to allow her to stay, and also let's not forget CYRUS! And she wouldn't have like Maya and Emily together because that was the one other girl Emily was head over heels for, sorry she never treated Paige like first priority like she did Alison or Maya!

        Loading editor
    • Marlene made a comment that by the end of the show they would explain the mythology of the show...mythology?? Then I ran across "slender man."

      Marlene said that Alison's middle name, Lauren, would be the biggest hint:

      Lauren is the main protagonist and playable character in Slender: The Arrival.

      Slender Man (a.k.a Slenderman) is a mythical creature often depicted as a tall, thin figure wearing a black suit and a blank face.

      He lures kids into the woods, and he has "proxies" that do all his work. Charlie Matheson was kidnapped by slenderman. I know it sounds far fetched, but google "slenderman."


      http://theslenderman.wikia.com/wiki/Proxy

      Ticci-Toby (real name: Tobias Erin "Toby" Rogers) is a fictional Proxy of the Slender Man from the creepypasta of the same name written by Kastoway. The story focuses on Toby's descent into madness and his first encounter with The Slender Man.
      

      http://slendermanconnection.wikia.com/wiki/Ticci-Toby

      Also, he has "proxies" that do all his work for him, which one of them is conveniently hacking, sound familiar?! He also stalks his victims for years. Andrew also made a comment about a tall black figure after a date with Aria one night. He give them the feeling of paranoia.

      It is suspected that Proxies do the actual, physical work for Slender Man, such as creating and manipulating objects, destroying and leaving evidence, creating videos and responding on Twitter (in ARGs), and influencing victims as needed.

      If you look up Charlie Matheson Jr. And click on images there's a missing persons flyer, similar to Alison's. It is said that this strange creature called "Slenderman" is the father of a child once died in a fire, and the flames had totally disfigured face.

      https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marble_Hornets

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.