FANDOM


  • Charlotte knew Mary Drake was her real mother. But, according to Jenna, she never met her. So what exactly did she knew about the Drake family ? Was she aware she had a younger sibling ? I believe she did. Also, I think she had to lie during the revelation in 6x10, but these lies had clues on them. Let me explain:

    In the episode, she used this lyric "Lord help the mister who comes between me and my sister". She knew Ali was only her cousin, but the whole Charles point was to win Ali's trust and being able to play the victim, so we can believe sister meant Alison and mister meant the Liars. But what if it was a hidden truth ? A teasing that once, a man (AD ?) came between Charlotte and Mary's second child. 

    Charlotte loved to play, she's not on the girls' side, but she cared about "her dolls". Twisted Charlotte could have let hints that this mister will soon hurt the Liars. If not a hint to the girls, at least one to the audience. Charlotte's story is weird, what was real or false ? but what she said is relevant. During the controversial Marion's murder flashback, Charles and Bethany dialogue about their escape of Radley "Nothing’s more believable than a really good lie. We just need to come up with a great story – something fabulous and devastating at the same time" Fake death sounds like something that could fit their plans. So maybe they did it. If the night Bethany escaped Radley, the plan was to mistake Alison for Bethany and somehow fake her death, Bethany would have been free of Radley for good. Proof, for two years no one seemed to care about her disappearance, till episode 5x05.

    Is it possible that Bethany was Charlotte's sister ? Charlotte escaped thanks to Jessica who faked Charles' death. What proof do we have that she really came back to Radley after Charles' funeral ? I mean, why would Wren had to make Cece's visitor pass if Charlotte was still there ? And with Noel's secret, we now know that Charlotte's time in UPenn was relevant. Charlotte never came back, she enjoyed life out of Radley until Noel pushed that girl.

    In the beginning of the show, the body found in the DiLaurentis' yard was identified as Alison because of the yellow top, the Alison's bracelet and also with the help of dental records. Someone switched Bethany and Alison dental records. Charlotte said she was A from season 3, so she didn't switch them. Mona hit a blonde girl before she helped Alison to disappear. Mona never buried Bethany, she didn't knew her, she hit her but she was still alive. Melissa buried Bethany but claimed she never saw her face. So who else knew the dead girl was Bethany and needed people to believe Ali was dead. Maybe the same person who gave Bethany the Alison bracelet ? That "famous mister" perhaps ?

    In Charlotte's version, crazy Bethany stole Charlotte's clothes. Ok, ok. And it's a pure coincidence that Alison received the yellow top that exact same day ? No way. Charlotte lied, or at the time she was clueless that someone else was involve. A.D. ! Jessica never wanted to buy the top for Ali, someone else let the tops for Ali and Bethany to wear them. Why ? I don't have a clue. In Mona's version, she wanted to scare Alison and later hit somebody she mistook for Ali = no mention of Ali's yellow top. In Charlotte's version, she just followed evil Bethany = again, no mention of Ali's yellow top. The two girls were identical that night for a reason we didn't find yet. Was it Uber A's plan ? If yes, that person needed to be aware of Mona's and Charlotte's intentions for that night. He's the ultimate puppetmaster, he tricked everybody else !

    Charlotte said it. Sara was only a decoy, just a decoy, Red Coat's decoy. She needed a decoy the night of the fire at the Lodge. In what other occasions did she use Sara ? None that I saw. Maybe, Sara wasn't Charlotte's Red Coat decoy. I believe there was three Red Coat: Ali, Charlotte, a mystery 3rd one and Sara (decoy of the 3rd ?). At the fire, Charlotte had black hoodie, Sara was the decoy and Alison had her hooded red coat, but firemen found a burned hoodless red coat after the fire. Who wore it ? Sara was a tool, the 3rd Red Coat was the real "friend and ally" and the one who managed to get prom tickets for Charlotte.

    Other proof that Uber A was there that night, we never found out who took the picture of Ali and Spencer encounter (picture found in 4x21). The one taken from the second floor of the DiLaurentis house where we saw Alison walking away from Spencer's shadow. They said (by Ezra's journal) Cece witnessed that feud and Jessica paid her to say nothing about it. Another piece of the Charlotte's story that, from now, fit no where.

      Loading editor
    • Two can keep a secret if one of them is dead " I think the song is an important clue as well and goes perfect with the theory Bethany was pretending to be dead

        Loading editor
    • I just wonder why someone would put that much effort in making it look like Alison was in that grave.. Same yellow top, same bracelet and swapping the dental records..

        Loading editor
    • Maybe someone who wanted to defend Radley and hide that Bethany ran away, or even had the chance to.

        Loading editor
    • Deeemster wrote:
      I just wonder why someone would put that much effort in making it look like Alison was in that grave.. Same yellow top, same bracelet and swapping the dental records..

      I have a feeling the bracelet and dental records will never be explained unfortunately. 

      As for the song, it is from White Christmas.  I never took it as a clue, just a way for CeCe to tell Ali "we're sisters."      But if it does contain clues, the next line is "and lord help the sister who comes between me and my man."    Also "When a certain gentleman arrived from Rome, she wore the dress and I stayed home."   

        Loading editor
    • Wonder who the mister is?

        Loading editor
    • archer?

      lord help alison who came between me and archer. when archer came from (not rome), she wore the wedding dress and i stayed home,

      thats what it looks like to me 

        Loading editor
    • Except Ali had not met Archer at that point. 

        Loading editor
    • NellyBell wrote: I never took it as a clue, just a way for CeCe to tell Ali "we're sisters."

      It's how I saw it first. And that song is probably nothing. I don't even know if "that mister" will be on the show. But in 6x10 we didn't know they're only cousins. Normally, Marlene has the complet Charlotte's story in her mind for years.

      We now know Charlotte had a sibling. How much Charlotte was sincere in 6x10, she claimed she did it for her sister. If the sibling is a girl, maybe Charlotte knew. Maybe Marlene made Charlotte talk about "her sister" because it was an hidden clue for future revelation...

      I don't know. Charlotte is the key, everything she said. Since we don't know what was truth, what was lie. Did she already meet Mary ? That's an important point, and yet we don't have a clue

        Loading editor
    • Well, if Ken and Jessica adopted Charles, than Charlotte was Ali's sister legally.

      But yes, the sister clue could be referring to the other kid.  I do think Charlotte knew about Mary and her other sibling.  That is one reason I think it could be Sara, and that is why they were working together.  Why else would Sara help Charlotte?  We were supposed to get more of her story but didn't.  Now that she is dead, it seems the only way we will get her back story is if she is part of the overall picture as Mary's other kid.

      But with that said, I also like the Spencer theory!

        Loading editor
    • I have wondered about those yellow tops many times. I like your idea that Bethany and Charlotte planned to fake Bethany's death. I wonder if there was a third person involved, someone who knew of the plan and deliberately gave Alison a matching top in order to throw a wrench in the plan (thus making Ali an unintended victim who ended up being the center of a years-long mystery completely by accident!) or because they would benefit from Alison's death and saw an opportunity to get rid of her. I also wonder, if it was just Bethany and Charlotte, if one of them double crossed the other. If the plan was to help free Bethany, then what about Charlotte? Would she have willingly stayed behind in Radley after being falsely accused of pushing Marion off the ledge? Why would she help Bethany after Bethany's damning lie?

        Loading editor
    • I don't know, but if what you are proposing is true, does that mean Mrs. Grunwald was involved? She is the one who "magically" showed up to pull Ali out.  Maybe she was supposed to rescue Bethany?

        Loading editor
    • The theory has been over and now we know the answer the other sibling is....... spencer. but in my head i still dont understand if jessica took mary's babies( cece and spencer) how did spencer got into veronica's hands??. I thought veronica was shocked to know that jessica had a secret child, like in season 6 episode 9, the liars mom reaction was like 'how can jessica and kenneth keep their child a secret' .I guess i have to wait for april 2017 to find out..!!

        Loading editor
    • NellyBell wrote: I don't know, but if what you are proposing is true, does that mean Mrs. Grunwald was involved? She is the one who "magically" showed up to pull Ali out.  Maybe she was supposed to rescue Bethany?

      That could be. Maybe she was informed of the plot in advance and was deliberate in looking for a grave. Maybe they are related somehow!

        Loading editor
    • maybe alison is who came between Charles and his sister...lol maybe this entire plot is to get rid of Alison. maybe just like jessica and mary, alison is really the twisted one and got charles put away. or maybe thats just how charles sees it. 

      btw im saying charles not charlotte or cece because there have been a lot of theories that CeCe might not be Charles and i kind think that would be a cool turn of events. Like A.D. is Charles and CeCe was just some girl he hired to pretend to be him. 

        Loading editor
    • 6east wrote:
      maybe alison is who came between Charles and his sister...lol maybe this entire plot is to get rid of Alison. maybe just like jessica and mary, alison is really the twisted one and got charles put away. or maybe thats just how charles sees it. 

      btw im saying charles not charlotte or cece because there have been a lot of theories that CeCe might not be Charles and i kind think that would be a cool turn of events. Like A.D. is Charles and CeCe was just some girl he hired to pretend to be him. 

      I'd hate that. They should leave Charlotte's story alone now instead of keep changing it and just focus on Mary's and her other child(ren).

        Loading editor
    • Did Wren was the man between Charlotte and Spencer ? Or was it Toby ?

        Loading editor
    • 6east wrote: archer?

      lord help alison who came between me and archer. when archer came from (not rome), she wore the wedding dress and i stayed home,

      thats what it looks like to me 

      Charolett knew the girls and Mona were watching her. What if it was a clue for Mona! So, Mona would know what charoletts next move was. Maybe Mona didn't want to get into Welby to find out what Charolett was going to say about her. What if she wanted to visit Charolett in Welby to continue the game just like Charolett did to her? They were playing the game together.

        Loading editor
    • IDK, maybe we're overthinking it.  Remember when we all went crazy with the "Walking after Midnight" song clue.  Who was walking? Where were they going?  etc etc.  Turns out the clue was Patsy Cline herself and the song "Crazy" for CeCe. 

      So maybe it was just about "I'm your sister"  (because adopted sisters are still sisters).  Or maybe it goes back to the movie White Christmas.  Remember the scene where Bing Crosby and Danny Kaye performed the song as a masquerede so the sisters could escape?  For those of you not familiar with the movie, the guys lip synced to the girl's record so the sheriff who was there to arrest the girls and was waiting backstage would hear the music and think the girls were there when they were escaping out the window.  In this case the clue would be about decoys I guess.

        Loading editor
    • There is also a fake engagement in the movie "White Christmas". All kinds of weather, we stick together, the same in the rain or sun. Two different faces, but in tight places we think and we act as one. Uh-huh!. That's the other part of the chorus to that song. Sound familiar. "We think and act as one". Maybe that's saying that Ali and Charolett were doing this together. I think what we are seeing is our thoughts about this song and movie were connected to what came later. I.e. A fake engagement and two sisters after the same man.

        Loading editor
    • ^ Ah, foreshadowing! I like it

        Loading editor
    • IHeartMysteries wrote:
      I have wondered about those yellow tops many times. I like your idea that Bethany and Charlotte planned to fake Bethany's death. I wonder if there was a third person involved, someone who knew of the plan and deliberately gave Alison a matching top in order to throw a wrench in the plan (thus making Ali an unintended victim who ended up being the center of a years-long mystery completely by accident!) or because they would benefit from Alison's death and saw an opportunity to get rid of her. I also wonder, if it was just Bethany and Charlotte, if one of them double crossed the other. If the plan was to help free Bethany, then what about Charlotte? Would she have willingly stayed behind in Radley after being falsely accused of pushing Marion off the ledge? Why would she help Bethany after Bethany's damning lie?

      Good point! I still think Bethany's story will pop up again. And the way she's been getting away with being "alive" is because she's assumed Sara Harvey's identity? Just a thought

        Loading editor
    • NellyBell wrote:
      IDK, maybe we're overthinking it.  Remember when we all went crazy with the "Walking after Midnight" song clue.  Who was walking? Where were they going?  etc etc.  Turns out the clue was Patsy Cline herself and the song "Crazy" for CeCe. 

      So maybe it was just about "I'm your sister"  (because adopted sisters are still sisters).  Or maybe it goes back to the movie White Christmas.  Remember the scene where Bing Crosby and Danny Kaye performed the song as a masquerede so the sisters could escape?  For those of you not familiar with the movie, the guys lip synced to the girl's record so the sheriff who was there to arrest the girls and was waiting backstage would hear the music and think the girls were there when they were escaping out the window.  In this case the clue would be about decoys I guess.

      Thank you for saying that adopted sisters are still sisters and not using the word "real sisters"


      Sincerely,

      Adoptee :)

        Loading editor
    • of course!!

        Loading editor
    • Sara was the third one and the third was a tool Ali and Cece was red coat I know how Ad is!

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.